Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Counterplan

AT - Cap K - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW

AT - Cap K - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AT: CAP
Cap Good
Peace
Cap sustains peace – economic cost, resource drain, and market checks and balances dissuade conflict
Friedman, 10 --- Uri Friedman is the managing editor at the Atlantic Council and a contributing writer at The Atlantic. He was previously a staff writer and the Global editor at The Atlantic, and the deputy managing editor at Foreign Policy magazine. (Uri Friedman, "Capitalism's Most Overlooked Benefit: Peace", 12-17-2010, Atlantic, https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2010/12/capitalism-s-most-overlooked-benefit-peace/339363/)//EG
In discussing capitalism's attributes, argues J.T. Young at The American Spectator, we too often forget about peace: Virtually all conflicts of the last century have been initiated by fettered market, authoritarian states. Often the world's armed conflicts have been between two such regimes. Contrastingly, military conflicts have almost never pitted two capitalist, democratic nations against one another. Socialist, communist, fascist, or simply non-ideological dictator-governed nations have almost always been the world's aggressors. When capitalist democracies are drawn into armed conflict, it is almost always against such economically-fettered nations. To prove his point, Young, who's worked in the federal government and on Capitol Hill, points to the Korean Peninsula: "In South Korea, a capitalist market, open society, and democracy exist. In North Korea, a closed market, closed society, and totalitarian regime exist. You also have a stark distinction between peace and war." For capitalist countries, Young says, war is a terrible economic investment, since resources are deployed for unproductive rather than productive ends. War only becomes an option when the long-term costs of an enemy's continued aggression outweigh the short-term costs of resisting it. The economic calculation for non-capitalist nations is reversed, he continues. Since, by definition, their economies are not allocating resources optimally, conflict is actually the best economic investment. Young adds that free markets are also likely to create free political systems whose checks and balances make it difficult for the government to go to war or remain at war for a protracted period of time, whereas the opposite is true in societies with "fettered markets." After citing the economists Milton Friedman and Frederick Hayek to support his claims, Young concludes: "capitalism is frequently credited with only the most prosaic of goals and ends in society. In fact, it is really the protector of society's most sublime goals."
AT: Ukraine proves cap X= peace
Ukraine proves high economic impacts of war limit combat capabilities and doom countries – sends a signal
Alden, 4/11 --- Edward Alden is a senior fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, a visiting professor at Western Washington University, and the author of, "Failure to Adjust: How Americans Got Left Behind in the Global Economy.”(Edward Alden, "Perspective", 4-11-2022, Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2022/04/11/russia-china-peace-capitalism/)//EG
Despite these dispiriting developments, though, it is too soon to declare that the heirs of Kant have failed. Russian arms have proved deficient in Ukraine, but the power of money has never been more on display. Sanctions against Russia have cut off access to hundreds of billions of dollars of its central bank reserves, crashing the value of the ruble (it has recovered only because of capital controls that make the currency all but worthless outside Russia). Russia’s manufacturing industries, from steel to cars, have ground to a halt since the flows of Western parts and technology have ceased and foreign markets have been blocked. Its citizens have lost access to most Western goods and services — companies including McDonald’s, H&M, Visa and Mastercard have left. Thousands of Russians have already fled the country in what is looking like a massive brain drain of the nation’s best and brightest. The Institute of International Finance forecasts that Russia’s economy will contract nearly 18 percent by the end of 2023, wiping out the last 15 years of economic growth. China, which only months ago declared its friendship with Russia to be “without limits,” is watching closely. While it appears to have adhered to Western sanctions against Russia, capital has nonetheless been flowing out of China. Investors, seeing massive losses in Russia, are recalculating the risks they face in authoritarian countries. If China were hit with similar sanctions, it would have many more economic weapons to fight back than Russia does. China’s economy is more diversified; its trade with the ASEAN nations is now larger than with either the United States or Europe. It has invested heavily in developing countries through its Belt and Road Initiative, and those countries might be reluctant to enforce Western sanctions. And China has a near monopoly in some critical sectors, such as the processing of rare-earth metals, a vital component of many consumer products including electric and hybrid vehicles, and for military applications such as jet engines and satellites. But China still relies on the West for the most advanced technologies, especially semiconductor equipment and fabrication capabilities. In an economic conflict, its vulnerabilities exceed its strengths. Russia’s military losses give diplomacy a fighting chance The West’s economic embrace of China and Russia, of course, was not all about peace. Businesses have profited handsomely. Former German chancellor Gerhard Schröder became board chairman of the Russian oil giant Rosneft, and he used his close relationship with Putin to champion the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline project, which Germany halted just before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. U.S. companies lobbied furiously to bring China into the WTO, lured by cheap labor and the huge Chinese consumer market. It is easy to see how Putin would miscalculate, believing corporate interests to be so strong in the West that governments would be dissuaded from truly damaging sanctions. But those profits are exactly the point. Economic interdependence breeds peace only if the costs of breaking those ties are high enough — and just as important, if all sides recognize that the costs are high enough. If the West can remain united on sanctions in response to the invasion of Ukraine — a big if as energy prices soar and inflation hurts consumers — Russia will pay high and sustained costs. That cooperation is already being tested as pressure is growing in Europe to cut off gas and oil imports from Russia in the wake of the Bucha massacre, which Germany fears would throw its economy into recession. But a demonstration of unity may discourage Xi from following Putin’s example. We can do more to help Ukraine without provoking World War III To prevent wavering, the United States and its allies should be working to ensure that economic vulnerabilities are as one-sided as possible. The Biden administration is properly seeking to bring home production in strategic industries such as semiconductors and electric-vehicle batteries, while denying the most advanced U.S. technologies to China and Russia. It is cooperating with Europe to find alternatives to Russian oil and gas as quickly as possible. The administration should also put aside its affinity for narrow “Buy American” approaches and pursue “friendshoring” — working with allies to build up critical supply chains and limit Chinese and Russian economic leverage. And it should work with partners to minimize the harm from sanctions in the developing world. The Kantian ideal has certainly been damaged; the line between economic interdependence and peace is at best a crooked one. But the power of money has also been reinforced by the robust Western response. Demonstrating the high economic price that countries will face for choosing war remains one of the best ways of sustaining peace
Environment
Yale and CoC study shows Capitalist countries have higher scores in environmental performance
Zitelmann, 21 --- Zitelmann studied history and political science, graduating with a doctorate “summa cum laude” in 1986. In 2016, Zitelmann was awarded his second doctorate, this time in sociology. (Rainer Zitelmann, "Capitalism is good, not bad, for the environment", 8/21/21, Washington Examiner, https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/opinion/capitalism-is-good-not-bad-for-the-environment)//EG
Every year, the Heritage Foundation ranks countries around the world on their economic freedom. It's a kind of capitalism index. But analysis shows that the most economically "free" countries also register the highest scores on Yale University’s EPI environmental index, averaging 76.1, while "mostly free" countries averaged 70.2. These two groups have a significant lead over the "moderately free" countries, which received much lower ratings (59.6 points) for their environmental performance. The countries rated by the Heritage Foundation as either "mostly unfree" or "repressed" received by far the worst Environmental Performance Index scores (46.7 and 50.3, respectively). Researchers at Yale University found that there is not only a correlation between the Heritage Foundation’s index and their own EPI but also between the EPI and the "Ease of Doing Business Index." That latter index is published each year as part of the World Bank’s "Doing Business Report" and is generally regarded as the world’s most comprehensive and reliable gauge of the ease of doing business. In 2016, researchers published a study in the journal Sustainability that included an evaluation of the correlation between the EPI and the "Open Market Index" compiled by the International Chamber of Commerce. The OMI measures a country’s openness to free trade and is thus an important indicator of economic freedom. The researchers found a high degree of overlap between the OMI index and the EPI:19 of the OMI’s 27 highest-scoring countries also appear in the top 27 of the EPI. The survey covered a total of 75 countries, including all G20 and European Union members. Together, these countries account for more than 90% of international trade and investment. The researchers found evidence for their "hypothesis that countries with an open economy score higher in environmental performance." There are two real-world observations that also disprove the argument that stronger economic growth automatically leads to greater environmental pollution. First, in noncapitalist countries, environmental degradation has been a far more serious problem than in capitalist countries. Second, the correlation between economic growth and increasing resource consumption is becoming ever weaker in the age of dematerialization. Put simply, these studies point in the same direction: Capitalism is not the problem. It is the solution — both economically and environmentally.
Yale’s EPI index proves capitalist countries have the best environmental performance
Zitelmann, 20 --- Contributor to Forbes (Rainer Zitelmann, "‘System Change Not Climate Change’: Capitalism And Environmental Destruction", 7-13-2020, Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/rainerzitelmann/2020/07/13/system-change-not-climate-change-capitalism-and-environmental-destruction/?sh=413d7ba16d72)//EG
But isn’t there a price for this growth: environment devastation? Of course, nobody would deny that industrialization causes environmental problems. But the assertion that growth automatically leads to ever accelerating environmental degradation is simply false. Yale University’s Environmental Performance Index (EPI) uses 16 indicators to rank countries on environmental health, air quality, water, biodiversity, natural resources and pollution. These indicators have been selected to reflect both the current baseline and the dynamics of national ecosystems. One of the Index’s most striking findings is that there is a strong correlation between a state’s wealth and its environmental performance. Most developed capitalist countries achieve high environmental standards. Those countries with the worst EPI scores, such as Ethiopia, Mali, Mauritania, Chad and Niger, are all poor. They have both low investment capacity for infrastructure, including water and sanitation, and tend to have weak environmental regulatory authorities. Contrary to prevailing perceptions, industrial development and technological advances have contributed significantly to relieving the burden on the environment. Both Indur Goklany in his book The Improving State of the World and Steven Pinker in chapter ten (“The Environment”) of his book Enlightenment Now demonstrate that we are not only living longer, healthier lives in unprecedented prosperity, but we are also doing so on a comparatively clean planet. Researchers have confirmed that economic freedom—in other words, more capitalism—leads to higher, not lower, environmental quality. Every year, the Heritage Foundation compiles its Index of Economic Freedom, which analyzes individual levels of economic freedom, and thus capitalism, in countries around the world. The Heritage Foundation’s researchers also measure the correlation between each country’s environmental performance and its economic freedom. The results couldn’t be clearer: the world’s most economically free countries achieve the highest environmental performance rankings with an average score of 76.1, followed by the countries that are “mostly free,” which score an average of 69.5. In stark contrast, the economically “repressed” and “mostly unfree” countries all score less than 50 for environmental performance.
AT: Structural violence
Capitalism sustains life by reducing hunger and poverty – Socialism doesn’t Zitelmann, 20 --- Contributor to Forbes (Rainer Zitelmann, "‘System Change Not Climate Change’: Capitalism And Environmental Destruction", 7-13-2020, Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/rainerzitelmann/2020/07/13/system-change-not-climate-change-capitalism-and-environmental-destruction/?sh=413d7ba16d72)//EG
As one argument would have it, capitalism is responsible for the destruction of the environment because capitalism is based on growth. And yes, capitalism has led to tremendous economic growth. But without this growth, an ever-expanding world population would not have been able to provide even the most basic necessities. After all, in 1800, there were just one billion people on the planet; today there are more than seven billion. Economic Growth Helps To Combat Hunger And Poverty It is all the more astonishing that, despite this rapid population growth, the world has not been overcome by rampant poverty. Looking back to 1800, most people in the world were extremely poor—average incomes were the same as they are in the poorest countries in Africa today and more than 90% of the global population was living in extreme poverty. The development of capitalism and economic growth reduced the proportion of extremely poor people in the world to less than 10%—despite the sevenfold increase in the global population during this same period. So growth is not a bad thing in and of itself. In fact, growth has led to a reduction in hunger and poverty. Life expectancy at birth has increased more than twice as much in the last century as in the previous 200,000 years. The probability of a child born today reaching retirement age is higher than the probability of previous generations ever celebrating their fifth birthdays. In 1900, the average life expectancy worldwide was 31 years; today it stands at 71 years. Of the roughly 8,000 generations of Homo sapiens since our species emerged approximately 200,000 years ago, only the last four have experienced massive declines in mortality rates. In the last 140 years there have been 106 major famines, each of which has cost more than 100,000 lives. The death toll has been particularly high in socialist countries such as the Soviet Union, China, Cambodia, Ethiopia and North Korea, killing tens of millions of people through the forced transfer of private means of production to public economies and the weaponization of hunger. On its own, the biggest socialist experiment in history, Mao’s Great Leap Forward in the late 1950s killed more than 45 million Chinese. The number of deaths due to major famines fell to 1.4 million per year in the 1990s—not least as a result of the collapse of socialist systems worldwide and China increasingly embracing capitalism. In the first two decades of the 21st century approximately 600,000 people perished of hunger. That is equivalent to roughly 2% of the death toll from the early 20th century—despite the fact that the global population is four times larger today than it was back then.
Feminism
Capitalist tech developments enabled women to join the labor force and opportunities for income allows investment in education – socialism counters this Stefano, 19 --- Executive VP & Chief Strategy Officer at Commonwealth Foundation and Fellow at Independent Women’s Forum. (Jennifer Stefano, Opinion Contributor, "Feminists should thank God for capitalism", 4-25-2019, Hill, https://thehill.com/opinion/civil-rights/440477-feminists-should-thank-god-for-capitalism/)//EG
When it comes to feminism, “t’s the economy, stupid.” Pantsuits didn’t liberate women; washing machines did — and we have American capitalism to thank for that. So, why are so many self-styled feminists trying to tear down capitalism? Take, for example, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.), popularly known as AOC. She calls herself a feminist, even fronting as a suffragette at national events. But her socialist Green New Deal won’t make American women more independent. As a feminist myself, I know it will create a whole new category of “kept” women — this time dependent upon government instead of a man. {mosads}Big government is a sugar daddy by another name. Expanding it will set women back 100 years. AOC’s “new deal” would stifle the very thing that got us this far. We’ll never achieve equal opportunity and prosperity for women until we finally accept that women have what it takes to make it in the free market — where jobs aren’t guaranteed. Instead we need to guarantee that all women are free to utilize their skills and talents to help each other, and themselves, without government interference. Over the past 200 years, the free market has driven unprecedented technological advances that benefited women — a fact highlighted in the famous “kitchen debate” between then-Vice President Richard Nixon and Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev. In 1959, the United States opened an exhibit in Moscow to display the innovations our country was producing. It featured labor-saving devices for the home that more than 450 American companies built explicitly for women, and which — as Nixon crowed to Khrushchev — nearly any American could afford. That exchange was about more than one-upping the Russians. Those appliances were transformative, enabling our grandmothers and mothers to leave behind scrub boards, hand wringers and coal ovens and enter the labor force en masse. Now, U.S. women are free to outwork men in the business world. Professor Ann E. Cudd, a founding member of the Society for Analytical Feminism and the provost and senior vice chancellor at the University of Pittsburgh, adds women’s education to the laundry list of capitalism’s benefits. “By providing an opportunity for an income independent of their male relatives, [capitalism] provides women with the ability to advocate for their education or to directly invest in their own and their daughters’ education,” she writes in her book, “Capitalism, For and Against: A Feminist Debate.” If you look at female accomplishments — from high school and college graduation rates to income growth — we are crushing it. Automation, information technology and other outgrowths of capitalism are allowing women to compete and win in traditionally male-dominated fields. Clearly, America’

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.