Aff - Digital Cyclops Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ
Aff - Digital Cyclops Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 BEJJ.docx
Indexed text preview
Digital Cyclops 2AC – AT: Capitalism K WRONG – It’s no longer just capitalism! It’s something worse! Wark 19 [Mckenzie Wark, 2019, “Capitalism is Dead: Is this something worse?”, <<Professor of Media & Cultural Studies @ The New School>>, Verso]\\pairie A reminder of the thought experiment that threads through these chapters: What if this was no longer capitalism, but something worse? Could we approach this now by describing relations of exploitation and domination in the present, starting with the emerging features, and work back and out and up from that? This chapter plays mostly with the sociological imagination. 1 This is the ability to conceptualize the problem synchronically, as if we could slice through the social formation of the present and look at its anatomy, rather than diachronically, in terms of patterns of development through time (a topic discussed in Chapter 5, a historical fantasia). Since the sociology we are playing with is vulgar Marxist, our imagination might be drawn initially to some features of the forces of production. It is still the case that extracting useful organic and inorganic matter from the earth is the basis of social existence. And it is still the case that applying vast amounts of energy in the form of fossil fuels and labor to that base matter is still how the endless array of commodities around us come into existence. But both of those processes seem these days to be subordinated to a third form of relation. At the smallest and largest scales, so much of primary production and secondary manufacturing seems to be controlled by rapid flows, extensive archives and complex algorithms whose concrete existence is in a tertiary form—that of information. The forces of production that instrumentalize information extend all the way into the production process, whether in the form of industrial robotics or the detailed and constant surveillance of living labor. They extend all the way out to global networks of measurement, command, and control that work in real time. These networks of information subsume not only inorganic and organic matter and energy in their web but also the human as “user,” who becomes a producer of information even when not working. The value of information can be extracted even from free labor. The relations of production seem to evolve to enclose these forces in rather novel extensions of the private property form. Wittgenstein’s contribution to communism was his robust proof of the proposition that there is no private language, but in our time, privatized languages are everywhere. 2 And not just languages: Images, codes, algorithms, even genes can become private property, and in turn private property shapes what we imagine the limits and possibilities of this information to be. Information is a relation between novelty and repetition, noise and order. 3 Novelty is extracted from a class whose efforts are hardly described by the category of labor, for the simple reason that while labor repeats an action whose form is given in advance, the whole point of these actions is to produce unique instances of such forms in the first place. Alongside the worker is the figure of the hacker, producer not of repeated content but of novel form, and form which more often than not ends up being someone else’s property. One has to ask whether the ruling class presiding over this mode of production is still adequately described as capitalist. 4 It seems no longer necessary to directly own the means of production. A remarkable amount of the valuation of the leading companies of our time consists not of tangible assets, but rather of information. A company is its brands, its patents, its trademarks, its reputation, its logistics, and perhaps above all its distinctive practices of evaluating information itself. Some like to talk as if one could just add an adjective or two to capitalism and describe all this, but we have already rejected that option as uninteresting poetry. Maybe it’s not the same old familiar endless essence of capitalism cloaked in new appearances. For instance, call it finance capitalism if you like, but perhaps the rise of finance is really just a symptom. Yann Moulier Boutang invites us to see finance as something other than speculative or fictive excess. 5 It has to do with the whole problemof exchange value in an age where the forces of production are extensively and intensively controlled by information: nobody knows what anything is worth. Financialization is a perverse socializing of the problem of the uncertainty of information about value. 2AC – AT: Settler Colonialism K Perm do both – it definitely solves – indigenous movements like Idle No More focus on rejecting the will to technology Kroker 14 [Arthur Kroker, 2014, “Exits to the Posthuman Future,” <<Professor of Political Science @ the University of Victoria and Director of Pacific Centre for Technology & Culture>>, Polity Press]\\pairie Technologies of abandonment: lost dreams of the sustainable “global village” Insurgencies of the periphery: Idle No More, a courageous Indigenous political protest of global significance, takes place in the bitter cold of a Canadian winter.1 Inspired by a hunger strike by an Indigenous woman, Chief Theresa Spence, an Attawapiskat tribal leader, from a community on the shores of James Bay, Idle No More is resistance by the abandoned. Not quiet resistance, but Indigenous collectivities in solidarity, spontaneously organizing as dancing flash mobs moving to the inspiring rhythms of Indigenous drummers in shopping malls, outdoor city squares, blockading busy highways and barricading railway tracks. Day after day, the hunger strike by Chief Spence continues with one simple, but basic, demand: to meet with the Canadian government to negotiate nation-to-nation exploitative land-use policies affecting all the energy sectors that are quickly destroying the land and its Indigenous inhabitants. The government’s official response is the silence of cynical indifference, perhaps based on the political calculation that defeating Indigenous protest will facilitate exploitation of the land. In this case, the themes rise beyond simple politics to the level of Thinking the Future 185 eschatology. As long as Indigenous responsibility for the land and its inhabitants exists, the earth will continue to exist. Disappear Indigenous protest, and the land and its (dissenting) inhabitants may well disappear as well. When McLuhan once said that, in the electronic world, any periphery can quickly become the center of politics, he probably didn’t have in mind a hunger strike undertaken by a single Indigenous woman in a teepee on a small island on the Ottawa River across from the parliament buildings of Canada. Truly one of those insurgencies of the periphery in which great eschatological themes – the future of the land, the very survival of Indigenous peoples, the possible reconciliation of humans with earth, sky, water, and air – achieve such powerful clarity that suddenly the center of politics, Canadian at first, but swiftly by extension any form of politics steered by massive energy projects, gravitates around the profound ethical issues raised by an Indigenous tribal leader who says “no.” With Idle No More, we are present at the first of the clashes of cosmology that will increasingly dominate the politics and culture of the twenty-first century – a cosmological collision between the system of politics, economy, and information associated with the ruling will to technology and the more profound vision of sustainability emerging from this insurgency of the periphery. If official power can respond only with the silence of indifference, perhaps that is because the masters of the technological universe – political and energy elites – recognize that no mediation is possible in this clash of cosmology, that in the courageous body politics of an Indigenous tribal leader willing to wager her claims to a broader sense of justice on the scales of life and death, that everything is at stake, that there can be no easy reconciliation between these competing life visions because what is really involved here is less a local political protest than a fundamental turning point in the direction of cosmology – technologies of abandonment represented in all their destructive intensity by mass energy projects versus enduring dreams of earth, land, and people mediated by social community and personal responsibility as a common dwelling place. Seemingly everything, today, is environment to the will to technology, not only the natural environment but human nature as well with all that entails for the future of human subjectivity. Transcendental in spirit and driven by a double dialectic of augmentation and incorporation, the will to technology has evolved to a point well in excess of what Nietzsche described as the “will to power” and Heidegger the “will to will.” Perhaps sensing the appearance of an epochal change, that moment when the will to technology began to turn back on itself, the philosopher Hannah Arendt captured the essence of contemporary 186 Crash times when she noted in her last book, Life of the Mind, that the future will be fully enveloped by the metaphysics of the “not-will” – a time of abandonment of all that is not necessary for the self-preservation of the will to technology. In Arendt’s prophetic vision, the historical primacy of conditions for the self-preservation of technique will inevitably result in the nihilism of “not-being,” that moment in which everything that is valued is measured only in its relationship to the self-preservation of the will to technology and, subsequently, everything that is not a condition of self-preservation is abandoned, effectively left behind as surplus remainder. Idle No More, this insurgency of the periphery, this declaration on behalf of a deeper conception of a sustainable environment that speaks to issues of individuals, community, and nature, is a rebellion against this formulation of the will to technology. This is offense – it means the alternative’s knowledge production is wedded to technical development narratives. Castro-Gómez 7 [Santiago Castro-Gómez, 04-03-2007, “The Missing Chapter of Empire: Postmodern reorganization of coloniality and post-Fordist capitalism,” <<Santiago is a Colombian philosopher & professor at the Pontificia Universidad Javeriana>>, Cultural Studies Vol. 21, Nos. 2&3 March/May 2007, T&F Online]\\pairie The centrality of knowledge in the global economy and in imperialistic politics of development is made more evident when we examine the subject of the environment. Beginning with the Conference in Rio already mentioned, the environment becomes the backbone of sustainable development. It was at the conference where this Conference that The Agreement on Biological Diversity was signed, obligating signatory nations to protect their genetic resources given that now genetic resources were considered part of the ‘common heritage of mankind’. The United Nations’ interest in the conservation and management if this ‘heritage’ is clear: genetic resources have economic value and mean benefits for those businesses that work with the latest technologies in the areas of biotechnology and genetic engineering. In this way, the handling of information and abstract languages what H/N call ‘immaterial production’ is placed at the center of the capitalist, postmodern business. In effect, the identification, alteration and transference of genetic material by way of knowledge have economic applications in the fields of agriculture and health. In the agricultural sector, biotechnology works by incrementing the production of food by means of the production of transgenic plants that are most resistant to plagues and insects, and less vulnerable to chemical fumigation. In 1999, 90 percent of the soya beans produced in Argentina and 33 percent of the corn produced in the United States originate from transgenic crops, and that percentage is even higher for products like cotton, tomatoes, tobacco, sugar cane, asparagus, strawberries, papaya, kiwi, barley, cucumber and zucchini. The biotechnological transformation of agriculture is a profitable business for the food industry and is controlled by a handful of businesses specialized in biotechnical research. The same occurs in the health sector. The pharmaceutical industry is concentrated in the production of medicines with a biological basis that are used in the treatment of illnesses like cancer, hemophilia, and hepatitis B, not to mention the growing production of generic medication and pharmaceutical drugs. It is estimated that the market for medication derived from pant extracts or biological products generates profits that hover around four hundred thousand million dollars annually, earnings that are concentrated in the hands of a small number of multinational businesses that monopolize ground-breaking research.14 Therefore, the subject of biodiversity places us at the forefront of a strategic sector of the global economy that will certainly redefine the geopolitics of the twenty-first century because access to genetic information will determine the difference between success and economic failure. Multinational corporations are interested in genetic resources that can be altered and manipulated by expert knowledge. Interestingly enough the greatest diversity is found in countries located in the South, the underdeveloped countries. For this reason, these businesses have initiated a real ‘lobbying’ campaign to obtain patents for these resources, appealing to intellectual property rights (CDI). Before the Uruguayan round of the GATT15 in 1993, no transnational legislation existed that pertained to intellectual property rights. Multinational businesses like Bristol Myers, DuPont, Johnson & Johnson, Merck and Pfizer, with vested interests in the biodiversity business, pressured for the introduction of the TRIP16 accord into the negotiations. This agreement permits the monopolistic control of the planet’s genetic resources by businesses. Intellectual Property is a juridical concept with a transnational scope. It is protected by the United Nations through the OMPI (World Intellectual Property Organization), which protects and regulates the ‘creations and innovations of the human intellect’, such as artistic and scientific works.17 According to this norm, when immaterial products involve some type of technological innovation that has commercial application, they can be patented by their authors and used as if they were private property.18 A patent is defined as the concession that the State grants to an inventor so he can commercially exploit his product in an exclusive way, for a certain amount of time. In the case of biodiversity and genetic resources, multinational corporations that work with the latest technologies can legitimately claim that any genetic alteration of the flora and fauna implies an inventive activity of the intellect that has a direct application in the agricultural or pharmaceutical industries, and therefore they are rightfully protected by patents. By claiming that genetically modified biological material is no longer a product of nature but of human intellect, the multinationals claim the right to patent and declare as their own the economic benefits from the commercialization of these products. Legitimated in this way by a supranational juridical regime, the intellectual assets administered by multinational corporations are converted into the key sector for the creation of wealth in postmodern capitalism. But it is precisely here where the ‘postcolonial face’ of Empire is revealed. I am talking about the ways in which new representations of development reinforce the modern/colonial hierarchies in a postmodern register, establishing a difference between the valid knowledge of some, and the non-knowledge or doxa of the others. One example of this is the way in which global agendas of sustainable development approach the subject of ‘traditional knowledge’. Multinational corporations are aware that by association with biodiversity and genetic resources, traditional knowledge and its ‘officials’ acquire a fabulous economic potential and represent numerous opportunities for commercialization. It is no wonder that in 2001 the OMPI created a ‘intergovernmental committee for the protection of intellectual property, genetic resources, traditional knowledge and folklore’, and that in 2003 UNESCO declared that ‘ ... communities, in particular indigenous communities, play an important role in the production, safeguarding, maintenance and recreation of the intangible cultural heritage, thus helping to enrich cultural diversity and human creativity’.19 The ‘safeguarding’ of traditional knowledge, now transformed into the ‘guarantors of sustainable development’, does not come for free. What is sought is to put a whole series of knowledges used for hundreds of years, by hundreds of communities world-wide at the disposal of multinationals specialized in research on genetic resources. These knowledges become susceptible to appropriation by multinational corporations through patents. Naturally, this requires a change in the representations of the other. What does this change consist of? We know that in the modern paradigm of development, non-occidental systems were seen as the enemies of progress. It was assumed that industrialization created the conditions to leave behind a type of knowledge based in myths and superstitions, replacing it with the technical-scientific knowledge of modernity. It was also believed that personal traits like passivity, lack of discipline and indolence, associated perhaps to defects of race, depended rather on the ‘absence of modernity’. The absence of modernity could be overcome in the same way that the State resolves structural problems like illiteracy and poverty. In this way, the modern paradigm of development was also a colonial paradigm. ‘Other’ knowledges had to be disciplined or excluded. However, and as H/N see it, postmodern capitalism is presented as a machine of segmentary inclusions, not of exclusions. Non-occidental knowledge is welcomed by the global agendas of Empire because it is useful to the capitalist project of biodiversity. The tolerance of cultural diversity has become a ‘politically correct’ value in Empire, but only in the sense that diversity is useful for the reproduction of capital. The indigenous person, for example, is no longer seen as someone pertaining to the social, economic and cognitive past of humanity, but as the ‘guardian of biodiversity’ (Ulloa, 2004). Once considered obstacles to a nation’s economic development, the indigenous are now seen as indispensable to the sustainable development of the world. Traditional knowledge is elevated to the category of ‘the intangible heritage of humanity’. Arturo Escobar formulates it in this way: 2AC – AT: Feminist Cyborg K Perm do both – the post/transhumanist reading of her work is wrong and gets coopted by the same cybernetic systems we are describing – Haraway agrees! Haraway & Gane 06 [Dona Haraway & Nicholas Gane, 12-01-2006, “When We have Never Been Human, What Is to Be Done?: Interview with Donna Haraway,”, <<Donna is a Professor in the History of Consciousness Department & Feminist Studies Department at the University of California>>, Theory, Culture & Society]\\pairie NG: One thing I find fascinating about the ‘Manifesto’ is its complex mix of feminism and cybernetics. It is stated, for example, that ‘Human beings, like any other component or subsystem, must be localized in a system architecture whose basic modes of operation are probabilistic’ (Haraway, 1991a: 212). This is a radical extension of Claude Shannon and Warren Weaver’s famous Mathematical Theory of Communication (1949), in which information is defined in statistical terms. In an interview conducted in 1999 you said that you were f
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.