Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2022 Michigan Negative

Framework - Neg TVAs - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS

Framework - Neg TVAs - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Antiblackness
LAWs consolidate anti-blackness through algorithms that perpetuate violence on black people AND forced experimentation on black women for the sake of scientific advancement BOTH of which are potential advantages
Ramsay-Jones 19 (Hayley Ramsay-Jones, Soka Gakkai International, member of the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, October 17, 2019, “Racism and Fully Autonomous Weapons,” UN Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, workshop on the impact of new information technologies on racial equality, https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/Documents/Issues/Racism/SR/Call/campaigntostopkillerrobots.pdf) nihara
Introduction
The rise of artificial intelligence is largely due to an increase in power, memory and speed of computers, and the availability of large quantities of data about many aspects of our lives.i Through the commercial application of big-data, we are increasingly being sorted into different classifications and stereotypes. In its most benign form, this stereotyping is being used to sell us products via targeted advertising, however, in its most egregious application, we see the weaponization of new information technologies utilize similar classifications based on biased algorithms, to which the consequences for certain communities could be deadly. In this paper I focus on fully autonomous weapons that are currently being developed for military and law enforcement purposes; and their potential threat to the human rights of marginalized communities, in particular persons of color intersectionally ii . This paper will also consider the systemic nature of racism and how racism would be reinforced and perpetuated by fully autonomous weapons.
Racism in Artificial Intelligence
Fully autonomous weapons can select and attack targets without meaningful human control, they operate based on algorithms and data analysis programming. In essence, this means that machines would have the power to make life-and-death decisions over human beings.
The trend towards more autonomy in weaponry without adequate human oversight is alarming especially when we know that digital technologies are not racially neutral. Moreover, when it comes to artificial intelligence (AI) there is an increasing body of evidence that shows that racism operates at every level of the design process and continues to emerge in the production, implementation, distribution and regulation. In this regard AI not only embodies the values and beliefs of the society or individuals that produce them but acts to amplify these biases and the power disparities.iii
One example of racism manifesting in AI is the under-representation problem in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) fields, which in itself is a manifestation of structural racism and patriarchy in western society. Technologies in the west are mostly developed by white males, and thus perform better for this group. A 2010 studyiv by researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) and the University of Texas, found that algorithms designed and tested in East Asia are better at recognizing East Asians, while those designed in Western countries are more accurate at detecting Caucasians. Similarly, sound detecting devices perform better at detecting male, Anglo-American voices and accents, as opposed to female voices, and non-Anglo-American accents.
Research by Joy Buolamwini,v reveals that race, skin tone and gender are significant when it comes to facial recognition. Buolamwini demonstrates that facial recognition software recognizes male faces far more accurately than female faces, especially when these faces are white. For darker-skinned people however the error rates were over 19%, and unsurprisingly the systems performed especially badly when presented with the intersection between race and gender, evidenced by a 34.4% error margin when recognizing dark-skinned women.
Despite the concerning error rates in these systems, commercially we already see adaptations of faulty facial recognition systems being rolled out in a variety of ways from soap dispensers to self-driving cars. The issue here is what happens if law enforcement and national security become reliant on a system that can recognize white males with just 1% error rate yet fails to recognize dark-skinned women more than one-third of the time?
These types of applications of new information technology fail people of color intersectionally at a disturbing rate. The fact that these systems are commercially available reveals a blatant disregard for people of color, it also positions "whiteness"vi as the norm, the standard for objectivity and reason. These applications of new information technology including their weaponization favors whiteness at the expense of all others, it is not merely a disempowerment but an empowerment. In real terms, racism bolsters white people's life chances. vii
As we all grew up in a white-dominated world it is not surprising that the vast majority of white people operate within, benefit from and reproduce a system that they barely notice. This is a long-held reality and it is a fundamental problem that we now see infiltrate technology.
Historical or latent bias in data is another issue, this is created by frequency of occurrence, for example in 2016 an MBA student named Rosaliaviii discovered that googling "unprofessional hairstyles for work" yielded images of mainly black women with afro-Caribbean hair, conversely when she searched "professional hair" images of mostly coiffed white women emerged, similar google search results are still seen today. This is due to machine learning – algorithms; it collects the most frequently submitted entries and therefore reflects statistically popular racists sentiments. These learnt biases are further strengthened, thus racism continues to be reinforced.
A more perilous example of this is in data-driven, predictive policing that uses crime statistics to identify "high crime" areas and then subjects these areas to higher and often more aggressive levels of policing. Crime happens everywhere, however when an area is over-policed such as communities of color that results in more people of color being arrested and flagged as "persons of interest" thus the cycle continues. In 2017, Amnesty International launched a report called "trapped in the Matrix",ix the report highlighted racially discriminatory practices by the UK police force and their use of a database called the "Gangs Matrix" which inputs data on "suspected" gang members in London. As of October 2017, there were 3,806 people on the Matrix, 87% of those are from black, Asian and minority ethnic backgrounds and 78% are black, a disproportionate number given that the police's own figures show that only 27% of those responsible for serious youth violence are black.
Amnesty stated that some police officers in the UK have been acting like they are in the "Wild West", making false assumptions about people based on their race, gender, age and socioeconomic status. As a result, individuals on the Matrix database are subject to chronic over-policing. With black people six times more likely to be stopped and searched than white people, and ten times more likely to be convicted of drug-related offenses. This system not only interferes with their right to privacy, Amnesty claims that the police often share the Matrix with other local agencies such as job centers, housing associations, social services, schools and colleges. In several cases, this has led to devastating impacts on people's social and economic lives because they are listed as "nominal" gang members, a label which is deliberately vague and stigmatizing.
The nature of systemic racism means that it is embedded in all areas of society, the effects of this type of oppression doesn't easily dissipate. Through the continual criminalization and stigmatization of people of color, systemic racism operates by creating winners and losers regardless of what people actually do. This is also the way that it redistributes opportunities and resources based on nothing other than privilege.
Given that the UK, as well as five other countriesx are developing fully autonomous weapons to target, injure and kill based on data-inputs and pre-programmed algorithms, we can see how long-standing inherent biases, pose an ethical and human rights threat. Where some groups of people will be vastly more vulnerable than others, fully autonomous weapons would not only act to further entrench already existing inequalities but could exacerbate them and lead to deadly consequences.
Legalities
As AI technology advances, the question of who will be held accountable for human rights abuses is becoming increasingly urgent. Machine learning and AI, effect a range of human rights including privacy, freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, the right to non-discrimination and equality, the right to life and the right to human dignity.
Holding those responsible for the unlawful killings of people of color by law enforcement and the military is already a huge challenge in many countries, however, this issue would be further impaired if the unlawful killing was committed by a fully autonomous weapon. Who would be held responsible: the programmer, manufacturer, commanding officer, or the machine itself? Lethal force by these weapons would make it even easier for people of color to be at the mercy of unlawful killings and far more difficult to obtain justice for victims of color and their families.
Conclusion
According to Reni Eddo-Lodge racism perpetuates partly through malice, carelessness and ignorance, it acts to quietly assist some, while hindering others.xi It is within this framework that we must grapple with race and the weaponization of new information technologies. In this regard, we should ask ourselves who controls these technologies and what do they think they know about the people they are "classifying"? What are the politics of these relationships and the deeply-rooted systemic forms of discrimination? Who benefits from these technologies and how?
There is a long history of people of color being experimented on for the sake of scientific advances from which they have suffered greatly but do not benefit. An example of this is from James Marion Sims, known as the father of gynecology for reducing maternal death rates in the US, in the 19th century. He conducted his research by performing painful and grotesque experiments on enslaved black women. "All of the early important reproductive health advances were devised by perfecting experiments on black women,".xii Today, the maternal death rate for black women in the US is three times higher than it is for white women.
Thus, when it comes to new information technology, facial recognition systems, algorithms and automated and interactive machine decision-making, communities of color are often both deprived of their benefits and subjected to their consequences. This paradox where science is inflicted on communities of color rather than aided by it must be addressed.
We must be vigilant against deeply rooted social problems taking root in the technical infrastructure that we create. We must work towards a zero policy on racism in technology, and not weaponize racism in technology. If racism and killer robots are allowed to co-exists these weapons will be used discriminately against people of color and other marginalized groups.
For these and many other ethical, moral, human rights, legal and humanitarian reasons the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, numerous governments, regional groups, tech workers, experts, scholars and the UN Secretary-General are all calling for a legally binding instrument to prohibit fully autonomous weapons. xiii
We call on the Special Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance to condemn fully autonomous weapons and the human rights threat they pose to people of color; and to support a prohibition treaty that will preserve meaningful human control over the use of force and prohibit fully autonomous weapons. xiv
Bronze Knight
Building stacks through cooperating with NATO allows for open sourcing that provides better public benefits.
New America, ND, "The Digital Government Mapping Project," https://www.newamerica.org/digital-impact-governance-initiative/reports/digital-government-mapping-project/10-principles-for-building-a-digital-government-stack/
1. Modularity
While a handful of countries have built impressive, tightly integrated digital stacks, these outliers are the exception rather than the rule. Both technically and politically, it is usually easier and less expensive to create smaller solutions that can be easily reconfigured and optimized as circumstances change. Just like a set of Legos, modular platforms can be reassembled to address needs and opportunities that may not have been anticipated when they were first created.
UK Notify demonstrates these benefits. After the solution was initially deployed in the UK, it was adapted to meet new challenges by the Australian Digital Transformation Agency, the U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs, and the Canadian Digital Service. Along the way, the system developed new capabilities. For example, Canadian engineers added French language support to the original tool. Doing so not only fulfilled a national mandate to make the software available in French and English, but also provided new functionality that the UK and French-speaking communities might be able to draw on in the future. The flexibility of modular solutions is a huge advantage at a time when technology and public needs are both evolving rapidly.
2. Open Source
Most of the work performed by governments is similar regardless of whether it is in New York, New Delhi, or Freetown. Almost all governments have to provide public benefits and services, collect taxes, maintain registries, and carry out a pretty well-defined set of other responsibilities that could be streamlined using technology. As the example above illustrates, governments are slowly waking up to the opportunity to develop and share open source solutions to power the public sector rather than building duplicative solutions of varying quality. Along with modular design, open source development can help governments cooperate to develop best-in-class solutions, adapt them to meet their own needs, and quickly scale them across borders to benefit other communities at minimal extra cost.
One of the benefits of open source development is that it allows civil society to examine the systems governments implement and point out design flaws, security risks, and threats to privacy and civil rights. A contact tracing app deployed in India was found to have numerous security bugs and led public authorities to open source the code for additional review by the global security community. Since then, hundreds of security flaws have been identified and fixed thanks to the power of crowdsourced engineering talent made possible by open source. DIGI’s Building and Reusing Open Source Tools in Government report provides a guide for how open source solutions can foster innovation in the public sector.
Fem IR
The United States federal government should increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization by integrating embodied data in the area of artificial intelligence in military logistics projects.
Vulnerability and corporeal practices are deployed within practices of power and within fixed lines---The TVA Solves
Väyrynen, 2019. Tarja Väyrynen is a professor of Peace and Conflict Research and a director of Tampere Peace Research Institute (TAPRI). Her research interests include conflict resolution and peacebuilding, feminist theory and post-colonial theory. “Mundane peace and the politics of vulnerability: a nonsolid feminist research agenda,” Peacebuilding, 7:2, 146-159, //barn
Choreographies do not happen in a vacuum: they are enacted in the corporeal practices people deploy in the everyday to form and maintain movement within practices of power. For the actors, then, choreographies are always partially pre-given, already planned and presented as fixed lines to be followed – yet the interactional resources of bodies can be used to remould the situation, as my vignettes demonstrate. Looking closer at these everyday techniques of interaction reveals that choreographies are in fact open to surprises and even disturbances, and tend to produce extraordinary acts out of the ordinary.57
Because the everyday is made and remade thorough the changing positions and relations of bodies, choreographies are always situationally enacted in events. As such, choreography allows, in my view, the study of embodied micro-practices of peace. In short, the immediacy of the everyday and its encounters, as well as their relevance for peace, calls for the analysis of events and their corporeal choreographies where acknowledgement and recognition emerge. This ‘corporeal turn’ in peace thinking points research towards events and processes that are marked by their mundaneness and ordinariness – their everydayness – as well as towards embodied data collected from multiple sources.
The United States federal government should substantially increase its security cooperation with the North Atlantic Treaty Organization by *covertly* subjecting all new cybersecurity standards to a gender impact assessment
Millar et al 21 Dr. Katharine Millar (Assistant Professor of International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) and holds a doctoral degree from the University of Oxford, United Kingdom. Her research interests lie in the relationship between gender, sexuality, politics and violence. Her current research examines gender and cybersecurity; gender, race, militarism, and contemporary populism(s)) et al, 2021, " Gender approaches to cybersecurity: design, defence and response," United Nations Institution for Disarmament Research, https://s3.eu-west-2.amazonaws.com/igc-production/5VmjuiWvoa7oVEK1Y2ErHT4HxYMu2lUJ.pdf
3.3 Recommendations » International standards organizations, in cooperation with national standards bodies, should identify, and collect data on, the areas where cybersecurity standards have gender effects. » Based on data collection and analysis, current cybersecurity standards should be revised in a gender-sensitive and gender-responsive manner. » All proposed new cybersecurity standards should be subject to a gender impact assessment to ensure gender sensitivity and gender responsiveness. Practitioners should be given gender and cybersecurity training to support them in conducting these assessments. 25 GENDER APPROACHES TO CYBERSECURITY » International standards organizations and national standards bodies should ensure that all working groups developing cybersecurity standards have gender and intersectional equality experts. » International standards organizations and national standards bodies should ensure diverse gender representation in cybersecurity standardmaking processes, in stakeholder consultations and within standards organizations.
Imperialism
Solves the AFF. Historical Bans have decreased imperial military power.
Garcia, 12 [Denise Garcia is an Assistant Professor of Political Science and International Relations at Northeastern University, 2012, accessed on 7-18-2022, Cornell International Affairs Review, "Banning Evil: Cluster Munitions and the Successful Formation of a Global Prohibition Regime", http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/1244/banning-evil-cluster-munitions-and-the-successful-formation-of-a-global-prohibition-regime]/ISEE
Cluster munitions constitute a substantial part of the military arsenals of all major powers. Their development, procurement and stockpile are a central hard component of national security. Yet, in less than two years, cluster munitio

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.