AT - Afropessism K - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW
AT - Afropessism K - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW.docx
Indexed text preview
AT: Afropess Framework Change in the debate space can only emerge from collective movements that are centered around intersectionality and relationships. Afro-pess works against movements to change the space – its nihilistic and individualized approach forecloses the possibility for change. Thuli Gamedze and Asher Gamedze 19, MA in Education, Gender, and International Development from Michaelis, member of iQhiya(art collective); MA in African studies from University of Cape Town, 1-1-2019, "Anxiety, Afropessimism, and the University Shutdown," South Atlantic Quarterly, 118 (1), pp. 215-225, https://doi.org/10.1215/00382876-7281732, kav gamEdze: Just to clarify, “shutdown,” as we refer to it, was (or is) a tactic used by Black students at South African universities that emerged mainly during #feesmustfall in October 2015 and has been used since then in 2016 and 2017. The plan was to stop the university from operating and make it impossible for it to continue with business as usual. Arrest its academic program, hold it ransom, and pressure the management to agree to certain demands that were part of a much larger call for decolonization, which I suppose is what we are dealing with in this collection of texts. The end of outsourced labor and the call for free education have been the main material demands that somewhat unify the national shutdown periods, but the nature of the campaign and the broader demands depended a lot on students’ educational and political processes at the various campuses. gamedZe: Of course “shutdown” is not a new revolutionary strategy; it has been used all over the world in different ways in different spaces. In our context we might see it as an extension, transplantation, and a micro-referencing of the anti-apartheid strategy of “ungovernability” that proliferated in the townships in 1980s South Africa. After 1994 there have been instances of Black students adopting a similar strategy, but until “mustfall,” the notion of shutdown had not taken on a “national” character. In recent years, different campuses adopted different strategic approaches to shutting down. Some movements embarked on a live shut-down, moving class by class, rendering lectures and tutorials that were in operation impossible, triggering fire alarms, and mobilizing other students as they went. Others embarked on more preventative shutdowns, attempting to make it impossible for university to even begin, by barricading campus entrances with bins, bodies, and burning tires. These barricades and protest lines, the frontiers of “shutdown,” were met with extreme physical violence from the state police and hired private security forces. This violence— unimaginative masculinist aggression—provoked a response from students, which generally took on the mirrored form of masculinist resistance. Or at least, this was the newsworthy narrative, because, as disturbing as it is, we know that mainstream media has an unending masochistic capacity to absorb images of Black people being brutalized. The image of the violated black body has strong ties to the politics of the Afropessimist. We feel that through the cycle of protest and violent repression, which continually produces and reproduces black people as “socially dead,” Afropessimism has fed deeply into the ways we think about protest. gamEdze: I want to get a bit deeper into what you’re saying here, because I think it’s really important to consider the complex and somewhat contradictory role of Afropessimism in student movements. I’m interested in how these politics have been instrumentalized in the service of “shutdown” protests, as well as the ways that the ideology which informs political strategy plays into and is given life in the internal world of the movement. Before I get into the Afropessimism thing, though, let me set it up with an initial statement or belief that I hold. We are all externally vulnerable to the violence of capital-driven time-space, and so it is the politics through which we live that can potentially offer us healing or, on the other hand, can exacerbate the problem. A therapist once explained to me that anxiety and anger are place-holder emotions, and what she meant is that in order to explore the causes of our anxiety and anger and potentially soothe them, we must seek a place that is more internal, and perhaps less easy to understand and manage. This internal place is often one of deep sadness, and fear can render us reluctant to explore it. Thus anxiety and anger function to express our incapacity to manage the depth of ourselves in a given situation—they are ways the body defends and manages circumstances that hurt and can possibly damage us. Sadness, on the other hand, is a kind of giving up of the body to its own incapability to be okay—an abandonment of reactive behaviors to violent parameters, and an acceptance of a boundless present of despair. It is raw and difficult, but the experience of pain or sadness is often what allows us to come to terms with pervasive dissonances between our own spirit and the ways we are vulnerable to, and complicit in, the mismanagement of people in the world. My interest is in how our politics can contribute to, hinder, or interact with our emotional life, and how this has played out in the bits and pieces of the shutdown processes we know about. gamedZe: That’s really interesting, thinking about the notion of a “place-holder politics” and their emotional corollaries. I wonder if it’s useful here to get into Afropessimism, or at least how we saw, understood, and experienced it within student movement spaces? gamEdze: For sure, go ahead. gamedZe: As I see it, briefly, Afropessimism is one political lens, set of ideas, or a vocabulary that has found significant traction in certain student movement spaces. This traction has brought with it a particularly nihilistic approach to protest. It could be interesting to think through this tendency toward protest along with some of the ideas you have set up. gamEdze: Yes, so Afropessimism defines itself through understanding the world’s fundamental structure as “antiblack,” and thus sees black people as perpetually negated or “socially dead” and so absent from any conception of humanity. gamedZe: Uh huh. And it seems to flatten out and homogenize Black people, reducing and owning the interpretation of Black peoples’ experiences by subordinating them to one supposedly absolute and totalizing logic. gamEdze: It goes further by articulating that the maintenance of antiblackness is crucial in sustaining the psychic health of white people. In other words, the binary created through the construction of blackness versus whiteness is the logic through which white people are able to recognize themselves as human, and through which black people, too, see white peo¬ple as human, and negate themselves. While Afropessimism can be useful in identifying systems of power—for instance, the mutual relationship of the racist construct of “black people as criminals” with the legal system and the capitalist prison-industrial complex—it falls short itself by asserting that there exists no other state for the black body except perpetual death, so con-sistently caving in on itself. gamedZe: So, in that, it fails on many levels to make sense of the nuanced ways in which people, despite their supposed nonexistence, exist in and navigate through the world. How does Afropessimism understand its social death in relation to queerness or disability—forms of otherness that also generate gratuitous violence, exclusion, and oppression? But also, this particular transplantation of the American thing (the origin of the school of thought) to the continent is pretty wack. Even as the Black radical tradition has largely been formulated and theorized in and from America, and even as it often falls prey to American exceptionalisms in its quest for forms of Black universalism, I think it holds radical potential for us on the continent. As many theorists and thinkers of the Black radical tradition have shown, African cultural practices have formed the basis of Black revolt across time and space. I see Afropessimism as a departure from that tradition’s dynamic foundations in African culture. Afropessimism, through its fixation on natal alienation, tends to ignore the living connections to the continent, seeming to take the severance of African people from the continent through the middle passage as utter and complete. It therefore seems to understand Black people not as cultural subjects who brought entire cosmological worlds and practices with them but as hopeless, utterly dislocated beings only existing as the sum total of their position in white supremacy. While I think that this can be challenged even in a diasporic context, this contradiction is even more pronounced here on the continent, because although many of us are alienated from African cultural practices and contexts, those traditions persist and are more or less proximate whether or not one is immersed in them. gamEdze: In this way, it can be difficult to move with the Afropessimist, whose American-specific engagement with a particular history defines the functioning of antiblackness, seen as a mechanism that forms the foundational reality of every scenario of oppression. Afropessimism’s refusal to engage its own internal world, to abandon its reactive and defensive nature, leads me to imagine it as a “placeholder politics,” similar to the ways that anxiety and anger hold and protect us from entering the place existing beyond them. This is not to offer a clean critique on Afropessimism but to situate it as a politics that perhaps exists as external to something more effective in exploring and acknowledging the internal— the power and the pain. Afropessimism finds no way to its own sadness. gamedZe: The idea of “holding” the “place” is quite a nice one. And interesting to think about how, in relation to the continent, it is perhaps the anxiety or the anger of Afropessimism that holds the place that prevents or protects the descent into the deep sadness. Perhaps this is what Fred Moten (2003: 94), through Amiri Baraka, might refer to as “the tragic,” which “is always in relation to a quite particular and material loss,” in this case being “the impossibility of a return to an African, the impossibility of an arrival at an American, home.” The sadness of the tragic is too great. gamEdze: Heavy ... Let’s move back, or forward to the student movement, where we have seen Afropessimism function in a number of different ways. Because of the diverse and chaotic mixture of political ideologies under the “mustfall” umbrella, Afropessimism, like other politics, has been a collaborator, mixing sometimes productively, but often aggressively, with other political schools in the space, such as Black feminism, Marxism, and Charterism. No one ever decided that “mustfall” would adhere to a single way of navigating, and thus we could find ourselves having to hold a number of contradictions, jumping between politics as we navigated the trauma of the external, and the ways we chose to deal with emotions of the internal. In this way, sometimes the reactive nature, the anxiety and anger of the placeholder politic of Afropessimism, functioned to hold the outsides, as different political ideas played out on the inside of the shutdown. I know that this thought experiment seems far neater than the muddiness of any reality of shutdown and occupation could possibly be. But we are using it because as far as we both critique Afropessimism, the way it has catalyzed in the mix of mustfall politics seems to have opened it up to something beyond its own imagination. On the outside, Afropessimism leads to a style of protest, to a style of retaliation, to a mode of policing, to a steering away of movements from initial strategy, to individualized acts of embodied resistance to the law. gamedZe: On the barricades, forced into the form of protest that the state and security is prepared and equipped for—violent confrontation—there is no possibility of Afropessimism evolving into anything else because we run into the militarized trap set for us, with no possible escape. gamEdze: On the inside, in the temporary “safety” offered by a successful shutdown, is the place where we can create. gamedZe: That kinda comes back to what I think of as a classic revolutionary dialectic, of reaction and creation. It raises the question: was it necessary to react in that way in order to create? Did we have to adopt this nihilistic politics and dangerous bodily mode of protest to shut down the space such that we can then explore other possibilities? gamEdze: This is such a fundamental question, and I personally don’t necessarily think so. Afropessimism to a large extent really upset the growth of Black feminist thought, at least in the shutdowns I have been involved in. Instead of providing an entry point into various political schools, black feminism—particularly intersectionality—seemed optional, forming just one of several political collaborators within the shutdown space. This approach was often read by Afropessimism and even black consciousness as an aggressor, or a “distracting” force within the movement. But intersectionality makes collective work possible. Audre Lorde, much in keeping with intersectionality, is insistent on conscientizing difference, so that it escapes its usual trap of exploitation by the status quo. This approach to making activism is a depthy internal process of instrumentalizing and weaponizing one’s pain and power toward collective struggle (Audre Lorde 2012). It is in direct conflict with Afropessimism, which begins and ends through the arrest of blackness in singular form: a circular anxious reasoning that cannot explore its particularities and intersections, and so finds its imagination short-circuited by the binary understanding of power only through white supremacy. If Afropessimism went to therapy, it might find, beneath its repeated anxious mantra of social death, a network of connected histories that have created layers and layers of power and oppression. This painful conscientization is the beginning of a process of shaping tools that can be used to transcend the defensive limitations of placeholder politics and can, rather, soothe the internal while launching a fiery attack on the oppressor. Lorde’s tool was poetry. And ours right now is this. gamedZe: I’m thinking now of some of Toni Morrison’s work and how one gets a real sense from her stories, that, despite the horror, violence, and the trauma of racism, Black people have, and have always had, stories outside white terrorism. Not that the terror is ever fully absent, but she makes a political decision in her writing to center Black people rather than white supremacy, opening up different creative and political potentialities. Although one of her starting points might be a critique of racism, it is not her endpoint. And I think what we are interested in thinking about in relation to shutdown is the possibilities that open up when the campus is claimed and the spaces, under new management, have not yet been purposed. When you occupy a house successfully, what do you do in the house? If we are able to arrest the university, what kinds of potentialities emerge? gamEdze: And further, to extend your question, if a particular mode of protest that is exclusionary is used in “shutting down” or securing the space, does this mean that the inevitable political landscape within that space is limited to this political tendency? Considering that the act of barricading requires a certain kind of bodily intervention which is often masculinist and exclusionary, can an Afropessimistic-led shutdown secure and open the space for an intersectional collectivity and loving place of study? gamEdze: The connection is that a masculinist, exclusionary, body-based rupturing of space will easily lead to an exclusionary group consciousness that occupies spaces using the same guiding principles it did to secure that space, unless tasks are explicitly divided using an intersectional approach to plan for the people involved. It is well documented, although poorly publicized, that “mustfall” in most instances failed to challenge institutionalized ableism and built-in inaccessibility at South African universities, as much as it did racism, classism, and patriarchy. gamedZe: Where the work happened well, it seemed to temporarily allow for a reconfiguring of relationships and roles insisted on by the university. For instance, the mobilization, organizing, and study that happened around the “OutsourcingMustFall” opened up new ways of relating between “workers” and “students.” These relationships were shifted, through organizing together and resisting white institutional order, from the rigid and distinct categories of the university, to being resituated within the framework of the Black family. In certain instances Black students spoke about workers as “our mothers and fathers” and workers related to students as “our children.” This was a radical departure from the way that the institution was intentionally curated, where to be a student means to have gained access to a world of more privilege than that rewarded for physical labor (for a further discussion, see Motimele, in this issue). Following on from the Black family, what I think shutdown allowed for in its most generative expression was the possibility of a different way of being together. And interestingly, it was the possibility of a different way of being together and being at the university. The university was what was being shut down. Its normative mode of functioning was arrested. So in certain senses it was about not being at the university, because the university represents a space of not-being-together, or at least only being together in particular ways that are shaped and governed by notions of difference and hierarchy—ways that operate to preclude or prohibit collectivity.2 In that sense shutdown ruptured the university, using it as a site for anticapitalist experiments with/in time and space. Some might say that that rupture forms a prefigurative moment—a prophetic enactment of a utopian future that is still, yet, or perhaps to come. Perhaps shutdown forms opposition to the obstacles blocking us from our true social nature? Shutdown and the space of occupation didn’t, in any definitive or over-bearing way, stop the university being what it is. Even when these spaces were alive, while they might have been able to arrest and repurpose certain functions or buildings, they were only pockets or time-space capsules casting fleeting shadows on the hegemon’s place in the sun. But what we know to be true is that spaces of study and planning have always, at every historical moment, been casting shadow. gamEdze: Yes, and I think that this is important, too, with our conversation around Afropessimism, which seems to assume that validity only exists in the hegemonic, where the nuances, characters, and textures of everyday social moments are seen to hold no radical value in resistance politics. Can Afropessimism make sense of the reality that no matter how you look at it, we are here, we are working, and we are of value to one another?! gamedZe: Since its conception of the world seems so thoroughly and hopelessly centered on whiteness, Afropessimism seems unable to value the spaces between us as Black people and what we are able to create together. These collective spaces are only considered important within a “prefigurative frame,” as if they are enactments of the future we imagine in the present. Afropessimism seems to imply that the only possible way for it to value Black life would be following an absolute rupture, the moment of the end of the world, in other words, supposedly the cataclysmic end of whiteness. Afterward, everything is assumed to be different. gamEdze: Yes. The potential for imagination in Afr
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.