DA - DSCA Tradeoff - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS
DA - DSCA Tradeoff - Michigan 7 2022 FMPS.docx
Indexed text preview
DA---Defense Security Cooperation Agency Tradeoff---FMPS Topicality T-DSCA---1NC A---Interpretation---the aff must go through the Defense Security Cooperation Agency---security cooperation is very broad, but so is the DSCA’s jurisdiction---prefer our evidence, it takes into account recent legal changes, has intent to define, and reconciles the DOD/DOS question ---not just descriptive of DOD security cooperation. It’s about security cooperation as a topic of interest within Congress generally, describes broader legislative authorities titled “security cooperation”, explicitly includes and accounts for DOS authority, explains the origins of the term “security cooperation” as being rooted in the creation of the Defense Security Cooperation Agency, and is descriptive of all security cooperation that takes place in a country as falling within the DSCA’s purview Colonel Luisa Santiago et al 19, Captain Harry Parent, Captain Reed Lorch, Major Deidre Baker, Lieutenant Colonel Timothy Litka, Colonel Luisa Santiago, U.S. Army Reserve Command staff judge advocate; Colonel Anthony Adolph, General Counsel (Staff Judge Advocate) - United States Forces Korea; and Colonel William Smoot, Chief, Criminal Law Division, U.S. Army OTJAG. FEATURE: No. 3 Fostering Enduring Partnerships: An Overview of Security Cooperation Offices Through the Lens of Iraq, 2019 Army Law. 49, Nexis //pipk Security cooperation (SC) is clearly a topic of current interest to Congress and the Defense community. In recent years, several changes to the regulatory and statutory guidance have taken place that include the publication of a RAND Report reviewing Title 10 authorities for security cooperation in 2016, 2 issuance of revisions to at least seven key joint references in 2017, 3 the publication of a Government Accountability Office (GAO) Report on Building Partner Capacity in March 2017, 4 the designation of a new chapter under Title 10--Chapter 16 Security Cooperation--and the push to professionalize and develop the security cooperation workforce under the newly formed Department of Defense Security Cooperation Workforce Development Program (SCWD) within the Fiscal Year (FY) 2017 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). 5 Provided through the lens of the largest current Security Cooperation Office (SCO)--the Office of Security Cooperation - Iraq (OSC-I)--this article is meant to serve as a primer for judge advocates facing assignment to an SCO, as well as judge advocates who may have an SCO in their geographic area. What Is Security Assistance, What Is Security Cooperation, and Who Does What? While the term "security assistance" (SA) has been in frequent use in the Department of Defense (DoD) since at least 1971, 6 the term "security cooperation" was first introduced by the Defense Reform Initiative in 1997. 7 The Defense Reform Initiative led to the Defense Security Assistance Agency (DSAA) being renamed the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA), effective 1 October 1998, 8 to reflect the enlarged mission and additional international programs DSCA would go on to administer. These programs are carried out by SCOs and DoD Regional Centers for Security Studies. 9 Explanation and definitions of SA and SC are provided herein, followed by more information on SCOs and DoD Centers for Security Studies. [*50] Security Assistance Security assistance primarily encompasses foreign military financing and sales, military education and training, peacekeeping, and counter-narcotics efforts. 10 Department of Defense Directive (DoDD) 5132.03, reissued on 29 December 2016, defines SA in conformity with the underlying U.S. Code provision, and specifies that SA is one element within the broader category of SC: Security Assistance. Group of programs authorized by the Foreign Assistance Act [(FAA)] of 1961 and the Arms Export Control Act [(AECA)] of 1976 or other related statutes by which the United States provides defense articles, military training, and other defense-related services by grant, loan, credit, or cash sales in furtherance of national policies and objectives. Security assistance is one element of security cooperation, which is funded and authorized by the Department of State and administered by the DSCA. This definition received additional minor modifications in the 23 May 2017, Joint Publication 3-20, Security Cooperation. 11 The only substantive modifications were adding "lease" to the methods of providing defense articles, changing that assistance is authorized "through" Department of State rather than "by" Department of State, and adding DoD as administering in conjunction with DSCA. 12 The most substantive update contained within both DoDD 5132.03 and Joint Publication 3-20 is the recognition that security assistance is one element of security cooperation. Security Cooperation While this term was the product of the 1997 Defense Reform Initiative, 13 and entered the DoD lexicon with the renaming of DSAA to DSCA in October 1998, 14 security cooperation remained ill-defined until 9 June 2004, when it was first formally defined within Joint Publication 1-02: All DoD interactions with foreign defense establishments to build defense relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests, develop allied and friendly military capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations, and provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to a host nation. 15 That broad definition has continued to take shape, with 10 U.S.C. Ch. 16 § 301 currently defining security cooperation programs and activities of the DoD as meaning any program, activity (including an exercise), or interaction of the DoD with the security establishment of a foreign country to achieve a purpose as follows: build and develop allied and friendly security capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations; to provide the armed forces with access to the foreign country during peacetime or a contingency operation; to build relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests. 16 Department of Defense Directive 5132.03, reissued on 29 December 2016, includes a definition of SC in conformity with the underlying U.S. Code provision, and, like the current definition for SA, specifies that SA is included within SC: Security Cooperation. All DoD interactions with foreign defense establishments to build defense relationships that promote specific U.S. security interests, develop allied and partner nation military and security capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations, and provide U.S. forces with peacetime and contingency access to allied and partner nations. This also includes DoD-administered security assistance programs. This definition received an additional minor modification in the 23 May 2017, Joint Publication 3-20, Security Cooperation, replacing the word "defense" relationships with "security" relationships. Defense Security Assistance Agency, Security Cooperation Offices, and Regional Centers for Security Studies The DSCA's mission is to lead the Security Cooperation Community (SCC) in developing and executing innovative security cooperation solutions that support mutual U.S. and partner interests. 17 This mission is executed through SCOs, which bring together DoD security cooperation and DoS security assistance efforts, as well as DoD Regional Centers for Security Studies which act as venues for international discussion and course work teaching security cooperation. While DSCA falls under the DoD and is thus a Title 10 entity, it draws its authorities to establish and operate SCOs from Title 22 under the DoS, a structure which indicates Congress's desire that DoD and DoS synchronize security cooperation efforts. Security Cooperation Offices are authorized by section 515 of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961. 18 Through that provision, Congress authorized the President to assign members of the Armed Forces of the United States to a foreign country to carry out the President's duties under the FAA and AECA to perform one or more of seven enumerated functions: (1) equipment and services case management; (2) training management; (3) program monitoring; (4) evaluation and planning of the host government's military capabilities and requirements; (5) administrative support; (6) promoting rationalization, standardization, interoperability, and other defense cooperation measures; and (7) liaison functions exclusive of advisory and training assistance. Notably, advisory and training assistance is limited under 22 U.S.C. § 2321i(b): Advisory and training assistance conducted by military personnel assigned under this section shall be kept to an absolute minimum. It is the sense of the Congress that advising and training assistance in countries to which military personnel are assigned under this section shall be provided primarily by other personnel who are not assigned under this section and who are detailed for limited periods to perform specific tasks. Security Cooperation Organization is defined in DoDI 5132.13 as: All DoD elements located in a foreign country with assigned responsibilities for carrying out security cooperation/assistance [*51] management functions. It includes military assistance advisory groups, military missions and groups, offices of defense and military cooperation, liaison groups, and defense attaché personnel designated to perform security cooperation/assistance functions. 19 Security Cooperation Offices go by different names, with different mission sets, in different countries. Examples, in addition to the Office of Security Cooperation - Iraq, are the United States Military Training Mission (USMTM) in Saudi Arabia; 20 the Office of Military Cooperation - Egypt; 21 Office of Defense Cooperation - India; 22 and Office of Defense Representative - Pakistan. 23 . While each of these organizations carries a different name, they all perform an SA mission involving Foreign Military Sales and International Military Education and Training, and all play a role in security cooperation efforts such as training exercises. B---Violation---we’ll concede a genuine we meet or this will be the 2NR C---Standards Limits---Security cooperation is vague and broad. Requiring the aff go through the DSCA is the only limit on the topic Ground---there’s no core ground with link uniqueness against security cooperation broadly. DSCA is the only core disad. Smart plan wordings mean CP’s that PIC out of the DSCA lose to perms which means it’s only a question of disad ground. Yes DSCA---2NC The aff must go through DSCA. It’s the only limit on the topic and is normal means for all security cooperation. Anthony V. Lenze 17, Major, Judge Advocate, United States Army. Presently assigned as Associate Professor, Contract and Fiscal Law Department, The Judge Advocate General's Legal Center and School, United States Army, Charlottesville, Virginia. ARTICLE: TRADITIONAL COMBATANT COMMANDER ACTIVITIES: ACKNOWLEDGING AND ANALYZING COMBATANT COMMANDERS' AUTHORITY TO INTERACT WITH FOREIGN MILITARIES, 225 Mil. L. Rev. 641. Nexis //pipk Security cooperation is now a term that encompasses "any program, activity (including an exercise), or interaction of the [DoD] with the security establishment of a foreign country to achieve a [strategic] purpose . . . [.]" 85 [85 10 U.S.C. § 301(7) (2017). Congress articulates three purposes for security cooperation: "to build and develop allied and friendly security capabilities for self-defense and multinational operations; to provide the armed forces with access to the foreign country during peacetime or a contingency operation; to build relationships that promote specific United States security interests. Id.] The DoD assigns such strategic importance to security cooperation that, with the help of Congress, it created the Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) to direct and guide the execution of all DoD security cooperation programs. 86 [86 U.S. GOV'T ACCOUNTABILITY OFF., GAO-13-84, SECURITY ASSISTANCE: DOD'S ONGOING REFORMS ADDRESS SOME CHALLENGES, BUT ADDITIONAL INFORMATION IS NEEDED TO FURTHER ENHANCE PROGRAM MANAGEMENT 4 (2012) (The "[Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA)] oversees program administration for both traditional programs and newer [building partner capacity] programs. [The] DSCA establishes security assistance procedures and systems, provides training, and guides the activities of implementing agencies."). ] The DSCA helps administer security cooperation, now a multi-billion dollar industry within the annual Defense appropriation. 87 With all the money and strategic brainpower pouring into security cooperation, newcomers to the field may presume fully-vetted, standardized terms and definitions. However, this could not be further [*656] from reality. Members of the DoD frequently mischaracterize security cooperation or outright disagree with respect to its doctrinal definition. 88 For example, the 2010 National Security Strategy (NSS) used the term security cooperation to include rebuilding damaged infrastructure and establishing conditions necessary to end military operations in Afghanistan. 89 With the exception of combat operations, it would seem that almost any military action could fit under the 2010 NSS's version of security cooperation. 90 Nevertheless, if security cooperation is in fact an evolving term in the DoD, making sense of the authorities under which the military executes security cooperation events is even more troublesome. 91 This is especially true when authorities are based upon a set of specific terms. Hence, with doctrine lagging behind and accompanied by undefined terminology, no authority in the realm of security cooperation is more ambiguous than the authority for military-to-military contacts. 92 With ambiguity surrounding military-to-military contacts, planners and lawyers should defer to commanders to decide the best way to employ these strategic interaction events. The fate of 10 U.S.C. § 168 and its ultimate repeal is illustrative of this point. Overview---2NC Security cooperation must go through the Defense Security Cooperation Agency. Setting a predictable requirement for one component of the aff mechanism is key to neg ground. Our arg isn’t that they can only fiat the DSCA, just that they must include the DSCA. Our interpretation has an intent to define, has jurisdictional expertise, and traces the history of the term to explain why there’s so much confusion---it resolves DOD/DOS confusion because the DSCA operates under both---the term “security cooperation” didn’t exist until the DSCA was created in 1998---recent legal changes mean there is a lot of confusion around the term but it’s very broad, which a. means the scope of possible actions the aff can do is very large, which makes being neg hard, but b. also means the scope of actions that fall within the DSCA’s jurisdiction is large and includes the af Disad DSCA Disad---1NC The Defense Security Cooperation Agency is stream-lining now to get weapons to Ukraine but they’re on the brink of being over-stretched by new demands from NATO and the rest of the world. Now is the critical time to lock-in security relationships but reliability is key. Joe Gould 6/30, "Senior Pentagon reporter for Defense News, covering the intersection of national security policy, politics and the defense industry." https://www.defensenews.com/pentagon/2022/06/30/european-arms-demand-grows-as-russia-fallout-deepens/ //pipk The changed security environment in Europe will mean increased demand from its allies for integrated missile defenses, early warning systems, air-to-air missiles and intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance platforms, a senior U.S. defense official said Thursday. The assessment comes as rattled European countries are committing to boost their militaries in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. U.S. government officials, while racing to send weapons to Ukraine, are also working to backfill allies who have sent arms to Ukraine or are keen to strengthen their conventional defenses. “Globally, that demand is increasing, and I do think we will continue to explore with our partners how they want to look at that,” Jed Royal, the deputy director of the Defense Security Cooperation Agency, said during a call with reporters. He said needs vary by country. While the State Department has primary responsibility for approving arms exports, the DSCA, a Pentagon agency central to foreign military sales, has taken a key role in U.S. and allied efforts to send and replace billions of dollars worth of weapons both from existing military supplies and through new procurements. “DSCA wants to make sure we are not only thinking in terms of backfilling the United States but certainly backfill[ing] for allies and partners as they continue to support Ukraine as well,” Royal said. “I spend a lot of time with our allies and partners and ... the demand is certainly coming in a really significant way.” Potentially driving demand, NATO announced this week it plans to increase the size of its rapid reaction force from 40,000 to 300,000 troops by next year. Forces would be based in their home countries but deploy further east, where the alliance would stockpile equipment and ammunition. Beyond air defenses, the focus of Europe’s defense investments should shift toward networks, strike weapons and munitions, logistics and base construction, Capital Alpha Partners Managing Director Byron Callan said in a note to investors Thursday. “Open questions remain about how the Russian threat is assessed in 2025-30, how U.S. commitments to NATO are weighed depending on the 2024 [U.S. presidential] election outcome, and views on the needs and capacity of the European defense industrial base,” Callan said. With an eye on the health of Europe’s defense industry, the European Union has sought to incentivize deals among its members. Earlier this month, EU officials were expected to meet with member nation delegates to craft ground rules for a €500 million (U.S. $523 million) fund meant to promote quick purchases of bloc-made military equipment. The U.S. has been working with more than 50 countries to see what weapons they can send to Ukraine. Though the initial focus has been on Russian-made weapons Ukrainian forces were familiar with, Ukraine has received more advanced weapons and the training to go with them as the war’s continued. DSCA has been part of the Pentagon’s internal efforts to find and fix defense industrial base constraints exposed by the Ukraine effort, and it’s put new focus on acquiring nonstandard systems for allies. That has included the AeroVironment Switchblade 300 loitering munition for Ukraine, Royal said. “We found that there’s a lot of systems that are not standard systems that the U.S. acquires for itself that are nonetheless very valuable and worthwhile to our partners,” Royal said. “So we’re looking at those non-program-of-record systems and making sure that we are using our program offices to prioritize those requirements for allies and partners just as we would for more standard acquisition systems.” Beyond Europe, India and other importers of weapons from Russia, the world’s No. 2 arms vendor, have had to rethink those arrangements as widespread sanctions cripple [hurt] Russia’s ability to make and export defense equipment. Without mentioning any specific countries, Royal echoed other U.S. officials who have said the west, if not the U.S., might eat into Russia’s market share. “We need to be able to demonstrate the reliability of the Western industrial base, the U.S. industrial base, a friendly industrial base, in order to be able to make sure that allies and partners globally can find an alternative to Russian systems in the future,” he said. “That’s very much part of our thinking as well.” Security cooperation resources are limited. Plan trades off Gregory Dykeman 7, Colonel in the U.S. Army, Chief of Effects Assessment and Targeting in the
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.