K - Fem IR Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW
K - Fem IR Supplement - Michigan 7 2022 CPWW.docx
Indexed text preview
Fem IR updates Neg Uq Feminist scholars have been collecting data and working to over throw the current system Anne Runyan, 2019 (Runyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Interview – Anne Sisson Runyan” E-International Relations. March 8, 2019. https://www.e-ir.info/2019/03/08/interview-anne-sisson-runyan/ /// MF) How has the way you understand the world changed over time, and what (or who) prompted the most significant shifts in your thinking? I have lived long enough and through enough epistemological shifts that have chipped away at modernist understandings of the world to be wary of progress narratives. That it appears the world is being revisited by the ghosts of overt patriarchy, racism, and fascism and even the ghosts of nuclearism just when it seemed that all kinds of human rights, gender equality, humanitarian, and environmental protection norms were being secured at the international level is, on one level, dizzying, but on another level, not surprising. It is not as if feminist scholars have not been steadily documenting largely unabated levels of violence, impoverishment, and disposability experienced by women and feminized/racialized others throughout the world, but particularly in the Global South, which belies simplistic “success” stories. It is also not as if feminists have not been tracking the feminization of men’s labour and the self- and other- destruction associated with this. And it is not as if feminists have not also been repeatedly raising concerns about the enclosures and depoliticizations of feminism as it moves through the halls of power within the (neo)liberal order that can undermine it as an oppositional force and thus vulnerabilize it to assaults, particularly from the religious and nationalist right that have been going on for some time. Knowing all of this, in recent work I have been doing with Marysia Zalewski we ask why the (re)emergence of what we shorthand as “Trump-time” has been met with such incredulity. We work with the spectral to consider how ghosts of virulent masculinity and constrained and constraining femininity are always with and haunting us, but also how other, more oppositional spirits are always present as well. In earlier work together (e.g.,Taking Feminist Violence Seriously in International Relations), we raise the spectre of feminist violence, which seems to be an oxymoron given the normalized association between women and peace and the normative association between feminism and nonviolence. This brings to the fore the continued excesses of feminist thought to do epistemic violence to bounded and secured knowledge and attempts to bind and secure feminism and even render it “post” or dead. Even if liberal feminism was somewhat successful, it coopted the true issue Marysia Zalewski, 2018 (Zalewshi, author and professor of International Relations at Cardiff University. “Feminist Approaches to International Relations Theory in the Post-Cold War Period” part of The Age of Perplexity: Rethinking the World We Knew https://www.bbvaopenmind.com/en/articles/feminist-approaches-to-international-relations-theory-in-the-post-cold-war-period/ /// MF) How has liberal feminism fared in global politics? There are many women political leaders now, still a minority if perhaps a decreasing one. Women serve in large numbers in militaries around the world and the bans on women serving in close combat are disappearing almost daily.5 Gender as a concept has been mainstreamed in the thinking and practice of many national governments and international organisations. The United Nations is a key actor here, not least since the ground-breaking Security Council Resolution 1325 introduced in 2000 which was the first formal and legal document from the Security Council that required parties in a conflict to prevent violations of women’s rights, to support women’s participation in peace negotiations and in post-conflict reconstruction, and to protect women and girls from sexual and gender-based violence.6 The two most recent relevant Resolutions include SCR 2106&SCR 2122 both in 2013.7 In many ways the success of liberal feminism seems clear. Though for many feminist international relations scholars, this success is dubious. It is the case that the majority of feminist scholars welcome inclusive practices for women, rather the troubling issue relates to the tacit acceptance of conventional (oftentimes articulated as ‘malestream’) political and theoretical agendas and practices. Plus, the acceptance of the standard of ‘human’, which is, by historical default, most often elite, white and male. As a corollary, liberal feminist work tends to support the invisibility and lesser worth of women’s traditional lives, behaviours and work, be default ignoring the imbalances and biases and discriminations this wreaks upon many women globally. In the current geo-political order, liberal feminism has, many argue, been co-opted in the service of neo-liberal agendas and practices. I will return to this point. UN actions are too narrow and don’t really create any real change Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Security, pg. 105 /// MF) Perhaps most problematic for disrupting the gendered division of violence is that gender and especially sexual violence is repeatedly reduced to violence against women in the WPS agenda, upholding the “sex essentialism” that renders the idea that women can be perpetrators, including rapists, unimaginable (Sjoberg 2016) and misrepresenting much wartime rape as organized, and thus controllable by international policy and punishments, rather than seeing it as part of the disorganization of war itself which is not placed under indictment (Baaz and Stern 2013). Indeed, as sexual violence and contraction of HIV/AIDS in war have become securitized, the agenda is simply to “protect women” from these in wartime (not in peacetime), increasing the power of already powerful states to punish others while regulating rather than actually addressing the inequalities and injustices that enable these violences (Jansson 2017). Ultimately, the WPS agenda reproduces very narrow constructions of gender and gender violence that do not disturb and, in fact, reinforce the international order that is productive of gender harms (Shepherd 2008). Previous shifts are not enough, we need a full transition to overcome the mistakes of the past Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender and Global Governance, pg 53/// MF) These points suggest how this shift in analysis, in turn, shifted strategies: from “adding women” to formal power structures to valorizing feminine traits in order to redefi ne politics from “power-over” to “power-to” (also known as “power-with” or enabling power) and change the standards of political behavior in favor of interdependence and cooperation. Still, this left intact a lingering and limiting referent to “women” that did not de-homogenize the category to recognize power diff erentials among women and the power some women hold over some men. It also left intact the association of embodied women with feminine values, which, on the one hand, led to essentialist assumptions about women as cure-alls for social (and global) ills and, on the other hand, positioned certain embodied men (largely non-Western, non-white, and/or lower class) as the villains of the piece. In the process, attention is defl ected from the complicity of both women and men—particularly those with the most power and privilege—in contributing to global ills. It also misrepresents feminist politics as exclusively about women rather than about resisting gender and gendered hierarchies and the ills they cause globally. This is not to say that raising the status of women and other subjugated people—in politics and other facets of life—is not necessary to increase formal representation and better equalize voice, but to note that it is insuffi cient if there is no attendant ideological shift away from politics as power-over to politics that enables resistance to and transformation of global politics-as-usual, which the power of gender sustains. Link AI reinforces gendered hierarchies and ideas Sophia Ahn and Amelia Costigan, 2019 (Sophia, MPA in policy analysis, BA in political science and international studies, women’s rights advocate and research fellow of the Catalyst Information Center. Amelia, senior director at the Catalyst Information Center. “How AI Reinforces Gender Stereotypes (Trend Brief)” Catalyst. December 5, 2019. https://www.catalyst.org/research/ai-gender-stereotypes/ /// MF) AI is What We Design It to Be Artificial intelligence (AI) has been heralded as a tool that can enhance human capacities and improve services,1 influence the future of work,2 create jobs,3 and serve as an equalizer by reducing bias in decisions by making predictions with algorithms based on data.4 Yet AI, ultimately, is what humans design it to be, learn, and do. This means that AI, by definition, is not neutral. Rather, it reflects the biases held by those who build it, reinforcing stereotypes based on those biases.5 Stereotypes are widely held, oversimplified generalizations about a group of people.6 This sort of “shorthand” categorization is based on the assumption that all members of a particular group are the same. Whether explicitly or implicitly, when stereotypes influence our perceptions and decision-making, members of stereotyped groups can be disadvantaged, and damage can be done.7 Women Take Care and Men Take Charge Gendered stereotypes result in sexism and can create structural barriers that perpetuate workplace gender inequality.8 One example of a gendered stereotype is that women are more nurturing than men.9 Over time, the societally pervasive stereotype that “women take care, men take charge” can embed itself in organizational cultures and norms, and—whether at home or in the workplace—women are viewed as more likely to be caretakers, which often negatively impacts women’s careers.10 As we interact with AI in our daily lives, AI has the power to unintentionally reinforce gendered stereotypes.11 Catalyst research finds that women leaders perceived as nurturing or emotional are liked but not considered competent. This “double bind” can lead to women’s occupational segregation and lack of advancement opportunities.12 A study on human-robot interactions found that AI reinforced the double bind dilemma. Participants rated robots that were assigned an explicit gender—either stereotypically male personality traits (confident and assertive) or stereotypically female personality traits (agreeable and warm). Participants rated the male-identified robot as more trustworthy, reliable, and competent than the female robot; the female robot was rated as more likeable.13 While users do not necessarily prefer robots of a certain gender, they do prefer robots whose “occupations” and “personalities” match stereotypical gender roles.14 For example, people respond better to healthcare service robots identified as female and security service robots identified as male.15 Digital voice assistants, such as Siri and Alexa, are often designed with female names and gendered voices. Their role is to perform tasks that have traditionally been assigned to women, such as scheduling appointments and setting reminders.16 Designing these assistants consistently with a female voice can reinforce traditional gender roles17 and may even lead to biased hiring of women in service or assistant-type jobs.18 Additionally, how we speak to our digital assistants can influence societal norms. Abusive, insulting, or sexual language can normalize the way we speak to each other and particularly to women, while the tolerant or passive responses by feminized digital assistants to this language can reinforce stereotypes of the compliant and forgiving woman.19 AI Reinforces Gendered Roles and Occupations Word embedding is an example of how machine learning can reinforce gender stereotypes. AI identifies words close to each other and uses them as a frame of reference. Recently Apple’s iOS automatically offered an emoji of a businessman when users typed in the word “CEO.” When AI finds words like “CEO” near the word “man” multiple times, it learns this association and links these words going forward.20 Princeton University found that AI’s word associations can reinforce stereotypes on everything from what internet search results we receive to hiring decisions we make. Princeton researchers measured AI’s word associations and found gender stereotypes in the word choices.21 The word “nurse,” for instance, was highly associated with the words “women” and “nurturing.” Meanwhile, the word “doctor” was more often associated with “men.” AI learns these contextual associations through the data provided to it by programmers who are predominantly white and male. It’s possible that gender bias could occur if an AI recruiting system begins to use these word associations to accept nurse candidates with female names at a higher rate. 22 Even AI translation services reveal gender-occupation stereotypes when translating languages without gender-specific pronouns, such as Chinese and Turkish. In this example, researchers found that AI also assumed “nurse,” “nanny,” and “teacher” all to be women.23 Machines taught by photo-based image-recognition software also quickly learn gender bias. In a recent study at the University of Virginia, images that depict activities such as cooking, shopping, and washing were more likely to be linked to women while images of shooting or coaching were more likely linked to men. Researchers further tested the data sets and discovered that the AI not only reflected the unconscious stereotypes of its creators but actually amplified them.24 Where Do We Go from Here? AI Industry Diversification: As of 2018, women comprise only 22% of AI professionals globally.25 The lack of gender diversity in the AI field hinders the industry’s ability to catch gender bias and stereotyping during AI machine learning and database design.26 An important first step to begin to mitigate the impact of AI-reinforced bias and stereotypes is for the AI industry to increase representation of women and other underrepresented groups in its workforce. Business Policies, Procedures, and Practices: The number of businesses using AI increased by 60% between 2017 and 2018, but “only half of businesses across the [United States] and Eope have policies and procedures in place to identify and address ethical considerations—either in the initial design of AI applications or in their behavior after the system is launched.”27 While providing clear benefits, AI is not a technological utopia. It is important for organizations to develop policies and procedures to address ethical concerns that arise from the application of AI in their business models. It is equally important that businesses identify and utilize tools to review for unwanted bias in their data sets and machine-learning models.28 AT: binaries Binaries are simply constructed – the k observes the social constructions around the ideas of gender, it doesn’t reinforce the ideas of binaries Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Introduction, pgs 6-7 /// MF) Finally, the specifi c meanings and values conferred on masculinity and femininity have also changed over time as well as across cultures. For example, Western ideals of “manliness” have undergone historical shifts: from the early Greeks through the feudal period, the emphasis of idealized masculinity was on military heroism and political prowess through male bonding and risk-taking; whereas more modern meanings of masculinity have stressed “competitive individualism, reason, self-control or self-denial, combining respectability as breadwinner and head of household with calculative rationality in public life” (Hooper 1998: 33). This does not mean, however, that older meanings have gone away, as unbridled military toughness and financial risk-taking can come once again to the fore in times of war and economic restructuring. Moreover, not all cultures have associated such conceptions of masculinity with leadership qualities: “queen mothers” in Ghana and “clan mothers” in many Native American societies have been accorded power and leadership roles in these matrilineal contexts on the basis of the feminine quality of regeneration of the people and the land (Okojo 1994: 286; Guerrero 1997: 215). Furthermore, there is some play in gender roles even within patrilineal or patriarchal cultures, given that men are not exclusively leaders and warriors and women are not exclusively in charge of maintaining the home and caring for children. Cultures also vary in the play allowed to the display of non-conforming gender behavior, such as that not associated with a person’s assigned sex; sometimes even “third genders” are revered. Polities also vary in terms of acceptance of and resources available to people who choose to change their assigned sex. Due to the variation in meanings attached to femininity and masculinity, we know that expressions of gender are not “fi xed” or predetermined; the particulars of gender are always shaped by context. Because models of appropriate gender behavior are diverse, we know that femininity and masculinity are not timeless or separable from the contexts in which they are embodied, acted out, and observed. This illustrates how gender rests not on biological sex differences but on interpretations or constructions of behavior that are culturally specific, that shift as contexts change, and that typically have little to do with biological differences, which themselves are not fixed as some bodies are born neither “male” nor “female” and gender and sex assignments can be altered. In short, there are multiple genders and gender orderings, but gender is always raced, classed, sexualized, and nationalized, just as race, class, sexuality, and nationality are always gendered. Hence, gender analysis must avoid stereotyping (or reducing people to unfounded caricatures), essentializing (or assuming “natural” and unchanging characteristics), and singling out any one identity as descriptive of a whole person. Instead, gender analysis must adopt intersectional analyses to make sense of our multiple, crosscutting, and differentially valorized identities. However, these variations still rest on concepts of gender differences and do not necessarily disrupt the power of gender as an oppositional dichotomy and as a relation of inequality. A gendered lens is a prereq to solving the existing dichotomies – only the alt solves Anne Ruyan, 2018 (Ruyan, professor in the School of Public and International Affairs, faculty affiliate of Women’s, Gender and Sexuality Studies at the University of Cincinnati and has a PhD in International Relations. “Global Power Politics” Gender(ed) Lenses on Global Politics, pgs 39-40/// MF) This is what is meant by mutually reinforcing: the dichotomy of gender gains its natural-ness by being grounded in the assumption of essentialized sex diff erence; gendered orderings are normalized by being reproduced throughout social life; dichotomies gain their taken-for-granted and even desirable s
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.