Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 Northwestern Affirmative

UBI Aff Neg - Northwestern 2023

UBI Aff Neg - Northwestern 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Aff – UBI
1AC
1AC---Plan
Plan: The United States federal government should fiscally redistribute via Universal Basic Income.
1AC---Automation Advantage
Automation is accelerating---Universal Basic Income is essential to prevent mass labor displacement
Court Ash-Dale 23, investigative journalist at Queen’s College Journal The Observer, 1/29/23, “Automation and UBI: Charting a Path to a New Future,” https://theobserver-qiaa.org/automation-and-ubi-charting-a-path-to-a-new-future
Recent advances in artificial intelligence are disrupting the future of work in ways that have inspired us to consider alternative economic models. The emergence of cheap, lightning-fast labour will permanently change the job market, and perhaps the future of work.
In late 2022, artificial intelligence pioneer OpenAI unveiled ChatGPT, a free online program that answers prompts and questions by generating human-like text — for example, the title of this article. It is a smaller replica of GPT-3, a machine-learning model that can theoretically carry out many tasks of white-collar careers.
“When robots automate our fast-food restaurants, workers will be incentivized to get better educated for a white-collar career,” said Dr. Robin Boadway, an economics professor at Queen’s University, in an interview with the Observer.
The mass automation of minimum-wage work threatens the livelihood of millions of undereducated and unskilled workers who, according to Boadway, will probably see a growing market as we shift to green energy.
One Stanford study predicted the project would employ 28 million long-term, full-time workers worldwide, plus up to 100 million more in production and construction.
“Jobs are going to be greener and more digital, requiring degrees in engineering, IT, data, and business management,” Boadway said.
Computers can already do most of those tasks alone. Online programs can write code, paralegal, and make marketing content in seconds. Humans are a tentative means of productivity.
Yet, the automation of the job market may be a blessing in disguise.
The jobs that can be automated are usually ones we don’t like. The nature of work today is often unfulfilling, under-compensated, and unrewarding. It’s ironic to live in the most prosperous age of human history and to be so unhappy. So why are we doing this to ourselves? What if we could automate our ‘bullshit jobs’ while guaranteeing a modest standard of living for all?
“I think ultimately, we will have to have some kind of universal basic income [UBI],” Elon Musk said at the 17th World Government Summit, describing a policy proposal that gives every citizen a monthly allowance to afford a modest standard of living. “I don’t think we’re going to have a choice.”
Below its fanatic exterior, a universal basic income may be our greatest asset in the Age of Automation.
“I’m unaware of any UBI experiment, but we fund several basic income programs today,” Boadway explained, who co-authored a proposal for a Canada-wide basic income. “They are tax-funded allowances that help make ends meet.”
Basic incomes are income supplements traditionally reduced depending on how much recipients make from working, encouraging workers to find work. In the scenario of a UBI, every citizen could be eligible for a guaranteed income.
“In this economy, no such policy can exist,” according to Boadway. This suggests only radical changes to the way basic incomes are funded can make it a reality.
For one example, with big businesses feasibly and completely automatable, the accumulated wealth of highly profitable businesses can be redistributed among every citizen. The remaining positions at industry giants would be reserved for talented workers.
A guaranteed income will allow us to let our hobbies and interests guide us to live more productive and satisfying lives. Free to do as we please, we may return to an age of revolutionary inventors, philosophers, and pioneers.
The UBI tends to divide the room despite how much society and the concept of work will be transformed. Skeptics argue that state-funded laziness would disincentivize workers to contribute meaningfully to the economy or society. However, several basic income experiments have found recipients tend to use the increased income to get better educated, improve their careers and start businesses. The rise of unearned income does not mean the end of work but would grow the economy and the middle class.
It is impossible to predict every side-effect of a society where work is optional. Still, believers of the UBI agree it possesses the solutions to several of society’s most significant challenges. Basic incomes have been proven to be one of the best strategies for reducing poverty, income inequality, demand for public services, and crime. Despite the high costs of paying for every citizen’s living costs, fewer tax dollars would be spent on these thought-to-be unsolvable problems.
“It gives [everyone] the opportunity to invest in their lives, or in their business,” wrote Rutger Bregman, a historian and best-selling author of Utopia of Realists. “The true business of people should be to go back to school and think about whatever it was they were doing before somebody told them they had to earn a living.”
How advanced economies react to an AI revolution will define the livelihood of tomorrow’s workforce. A universal basic income, which could effectively make work optional, may be a necessary feature of our digital future.
Studies and trends prove---only UBI can solve
J Scull 22, International Relations professor in China, 12/21/22, “Universal Basic Income: A Solution to AI and Unemployment,” https://soapboxie.com/economy/Universal-Basic-Income-A-Solution-to-AI-and-Unemployment
Could artificial intelligence and robots trigger mass unemployment and the collapse of the economy?
The answer is yes, and no. Yes, they will most likely cause unemployment. An Oxford University study points to a probable 47% of the world’s jobs to be lost due to automation from robots or artificial intelligence within the next 20 years. No, the economy need not collapse if certain precautions are taken and the proper social programs are put in place.
Whether we like it or not, robots and AI are here to stay. In several restaurants in China, from Harbin to Hefei to Yancheng, robot waiters and waitresses are serving customers. Naulo, a new restaurant in Kathmandu, Nepal, uses only locally manufactured robots to serve customers. In Tokyo, Japan, four-foot tall robot waiters controlled by people with disabilities from their own homes serve customers. They receive videos over the internet which they use to guide the robots, in the interim earning about $9.00 an hour.
Some of these robots cost as little as $13,000 per copy, however, that price is expected to drop as technology improves and production increases. Each copy is expected to last for at least five years. Of course, this is only the beginning. Companies worldwide are joining the race to develop more agile and smarter robots, as well as artifacts with artificial intelligence and even artificial consciousness.
Some of these robots cost as little as $13,000 per copy, but that price is expected to drop as technology improves and production increases. Each copy is expected to last for at least five years. Of course, this is only the beginning. Companies worldwide are joining the race to develop more agile and smarter robots, as well as artifacts with artificial intelligence and even artificial consciousness.
High Risk and Low Risk Jobs
Initially, jobs at risk will be those that can be easily replaced by what is known as weak or narrow artificial intelligence. These are artifacts that can perform routine, predictable, or pre-programmed tasks such as an automated phone recording, factory robotics, burger-flipping, stocking shelves and filling prescriptions at a pharmacy.
Many of these artifacts do not necessarily have to be a robot. They could just be a software that could become automated to perform repetitive tasks such as filling out reports even write basic news briefings.
Eventually, as the more advanced artificial intelligence systems or strong AI become available, more complex jobs currently performed by humans will be replaced. These are artifacts that possess consciousness, sentience, and some semblance of a mind. These machines will be able to apply intelligence to any problem, rather than the narrowly defined job the weak AIs are able to do.
Some of the jobs strong AI or intelligent robots could replace are tellers, loan officers, insurance appraisers, brokerage clerks, data entry workers, library technicians, telemarketers, cargo and freight agents.
It is possible some of the jobs that could be more secure at least initially are librarians, lawyers, physicians, surgeons, dentists, nurses, supervisors of repair technicians, occupational therapists, police supervisors, and school teachers. (PC Magazine, "20 Jobs Likely to Be Replaced by Robots and 20 That Are Safe," Evan Dashevsky, June 30, 2014)
However, widespread robot and AI replacement of human labor will happen, perhaps surpassing the 47% level estimated by the Oxford University study. The substitution will happen slowly at first, speeding up as the technology improves, prices for these machines drop, and the return on investment of owning any number of these artifacts increases.
The chart below shows the four categories where robots and AI will replace human labor. (Wired, Kevin Kelly, Dec 24, 2012)
How Robot Replacement of Humans Will Happen
The implications of robots and artificial intelligence displacing close to 50% of the world’s jobs currently performed by humans could be quite dire for the global economy.
Inequality between the top 1% of earners and the other 99% of the less financially secure may widen as robots and AI take over jobs. Competition by a growing population of unemployed for fewer jobs could be socially and politically destabilizing.
Universal Basic Income
An ever-increasing number of experts, political, and industry leaders are beginning to see a day when people’s usefulness in society and their ability to earn money will be greatly diminished or perhaps vanish entirely.
When this time comes, society needs to implement a system of income distribution that will more adequately meet the needs of the vast majority of people. A universal basic income (UBI) could provide the means to make sure wealth continues its normal circular flow between service companies, producers and consumers.
Society’s Only Solution?
UBI could be the solution to a largely idle population with no means to purchase food, clothing, and maintain a roof over their heads. Such a program of income distribution could be coupled with a program reminiscent of the New Deal where some of those receiving government funds could be put to work in the repair and rebuilding of decaying infrastructure.
In spite of how the funds are distributed or the minimum requirements for those receiving funds, UBI would allow for those displaced by robots or AI to return to school in order to receive necessary personal retooling.
These recipients of public funds could start small businesses that provide goods or services to local populations, even purchase their own robots that would help them in bringing in additional funds. The uses for a basic guaranteed income are limitless.
Unchecked automation triggers durable populist scapegoating and aggression
Kevin Drum 17, politics blogger for Mother Jones, 10/31/17, “Progressive Politics Can Probably Survive 4 Years of Trump. It Might Not Be Able to Survive 8.,” http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2017/10/eight-years-of-trump/#
Six weeks of semi-vacation from Donald Trump was nice, but jumping back into the cesspool is…bracing. Unlike a lot of people, though, I don’t have Trump fatigue. I’m not sure exactly what I do have, but it’s bigger than Trump. It’s more like a slow but steady rise in my unease about the future of my country. Is Trump going to turn out to be a blip, with the ship righted and returning to course in 2020? Or is Trump a harbinger of things to come?
I used to be pretty sure it was the former, but I’m less sure now. The ability of Trump to tweet out his version of alternate reality and have it accepted without question by his base is increasingly scary. It’s obvious that he doesn’t care if all the rest of us know it’s nonsense. It’s not meant for us. And no matter how crazy it gets, Fox News is willing to amplify it; congressonal Republicans are willing to ignore it; and his true-believer core laps it up. If that core is enough to power Trump to a reelection win in 2020, we’re in serious trouble even if he doesn’t start a nuclear war or destroy the rule of law.
The reason has to do with one of my other hobbyhorses: artificial intelligence. Economic anxiety among the working class was an important, but still small, part of last year’s election, but it’s likely to start growing in the mid-2020s thanks to the first glimmerings of the AI revolution. And 20th-century history is pretty clear that it’s misguided to ask whether Trump’s victory was really spurred by economic anxiety or racial anxiety. They’re a package deal. The response to widespread job losses nearly always includes a big dose of scapegoating: Jews, Ukranians, Poles, Mexicans, blacks, Catholics, you name it.
What this means is simple: If we can dump Trump in 2020 and prick the fever, we at least have a chance of dealing in a reasonable way with our forthcoming era of mass unemployment. If Trump makes it to 2024, I’d say all bets are off. A future of toxic, right-wing, nationalist-inflected populism becomes our most likely future. This means that 2018 and 2020 are, perhaps, going to be our most consequential elections since at least 1980. Maybe since 1932.
I wish I were able to be a little uplifting about all this, but I think this is just the bare truth. Progressive politics can probably survive four years of Trump. But given the march of technology, I’m not sure it will survive eight.
Causes global war---the US is a model
Kaitlyn Read 19, intelligence analyst, The Center for Global Affairs, New York University, “Is Populism a Threat to Security?,” Global Affairs Review, 5-15-2019, https://gareviewnyu.com/2019/05/15/is-populism-a-threat-to-security/
US Example
While populist movements have emerged throughout Europe, the US provides the quintessential example of a populist movement gaining sufficient power to not only threaten human and state security, but also the liberal world order. The election of President Trump in 2016 exemplifies the significance of successful securitization by a populist leader. President Trump’s populist platform established two homogeneous groups, the socially disadvantaged “common people” versus the “elite,” and he aligned himself with the “common people” (Inglehart and Norris 13). President Trump’s rhetoric during his campaign capitalized on the economic and cultural vulnerabilities felt by many of the less educated in the US who believed that the globalized world’s increasingly progressive outlook did not align with their cultural beliefs and that their economic standings were suffering because of it (Inglehart and Norris 16).
President Trump’s securitization of these cultural and economic vulnerabilities framed Mexican immigrants as the existential threat to these citizens. President Trump’s audience is the Republican Party because the rejection of progressive values is already embedded in the Republican base (Inglehart and Norris 31). Consequently, within the Republican Party, President Trump’s referent object is the less-educated Republican. The functional actor used by President Trump changes, depending on the circumstances, but it is usually the US military or Congress, as these groups have the ability to transform President Trump’s beliefs into actions.
During his presidential campaign, President Trump frequently securitized Mexican migrants by associating them with the loss of jobs, criminal activities, and the diminishment of American values. In a study analyzing 73 speeches given by Trump during his 2016 campaign for the presidency, it was recorded that Trump mentioned immigrants 364 times, with negative comments vastly outnumbering positive remarks, and that he mentioned jobs 1036 times (Lamont 12). Not only was Trump aware that his audience felt occupationally vulnerable, but he was able to utilize this by making immigrants, primarily Mexican immigrants, the principal threat to this vulnerability and by casting himself as the only solution to eliminating this sense of vulnerability.
Furthermore, in 2015, Trump said, “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bring those problems. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists” (LoBianco 2). This quote epitomizes Trump’s securitization strategy and his continual reinforcement of it. Trump associated Mexican immigrants with drugs, crime, and rape – three matters generally agreed as unwanted in society. Thus, Trump was able to label Mexican immigrants as threatening not only to his audience’s occupational vulnerability, but also to their way of life. As a result of this successful securitization, Trump garnered enough support to win the 2016 presidential election.
Since elected, Trump has continued to securitize Mexican immigrants in order to achieve his policy goals. For instance, Trump tweeted, “Building a great Border Wall, with drugs (poison) and enemy combatants pouring into our Country, is all about National Defense. Build WALL through M!” (“Trump Immigration” 1).This tweet evidences Trump’s continuing securitization of Mexican immigrants. Due to his securitization efforts, Trump is able to appease his audience by pursuing the named threat and to garner support for his immigration policy objective of building a wall between the US and Mexico. The only difference between Trump’s securitization of this issue before and after the election is that after the election, Trump has had the de facto power to attempt to enforce his policy objectives.
President Trump’s continuing securitization of Mexican immigrants as an existential threat has also garnered significant domestic support for building a border wall and for terminating the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which defers deportation for immigrant children. Trump’s securitization of Mexican immigrants has also damaged diplomatic relations between Mexico and the US (“Trump Slams Mexico” 1). While the wall remains at issue, a US Court blocked the termination of DACA (“Judge Orders Trump” 1). Meanwhile, Mexico’s relations with the US remain impaired.
Concluding Threat Assessments of Populism
Populism poses a threat to both state security and human security because the illiberal acts it engenders can erode interstate relations and oppress citizens. For example, the frequent securitization of migrants by populist leaders can result in the implementation of policies restricting immigration. Since this securitization involves antagonistic rhetoric, the migrants’ home state could respond negatively, inciting conflict and threatening state security. Regarding human security, these same policies could also increase deportations of those who left dangerous situations in their home countries. Securitization can be based on class, race, gender, or religion and if successful, can threaten both state and human security as a result of the populist rhetoric and the resulting illiberal policies.
While the illiberal results of populism are a given, the capacity of populism to harm state and human security varies depending on the resources and unchecked power held by the populist leader. That is, “if populists have to share power with non-populists, the effects tend to be small”(Mudde 3), as non-populists p

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.