EITC Counterplan - GDI 2023
EITC Counterplan - GDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
****EITC COUNTERPLAN: GDI23 Starter Set**** Notes and vocab vocab EITC – Earned Income Tax - a federal tax credit for working people with low and moderate incomes. It boosts the incomes of workers paid low wages while offsetting federal payroll and income taxes. Thirty states, plus the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico, have established their own EITCs to supplement the federal credit [CBPP]. During 2021, people without kids could qualify for the EITC at higher rates too –that’s expired. The amount of the EITC depends on a recipient’s income, marital status, and number of children. Child tax credit - Enacted in 1997 and expanded multiple times with bipartisan support since 2001, the Child Tax Credit helps families manage the cost of raising children. Under current law the credit is worth up to $2,000 per eligible child (under age 17 at the end of the tax year) [CBPP]. During 2021, the rate was increased but has expired. Income effect versus substitution effect – these concepts are related to microeconomic decisions by consumers. They are related to the comparison of EITC, FJG and BIG because, for example, larger EITC, workers can now cover their needs with fewer working hours than before and may cut back work effort. Or, the substitution effect, that benefits raising the value of jobs compared to other activities, so that more people choose to work, may result from EITC expansion [bc more workers could qualify and could work more under the expanded eligibility]. UBI and FJG would also impact income effect and substitution effect – so a comparison of each is important part of the internal links to the economy that would happen as a result of the CP versus the Aff. On the aff, multiple reasons why EITC is ineffective – including that it doesn’t incentivize more work – so you could argue this answers the jobs and innovation claims of the CP. Strategy/file organization Multiple variations of EITC CP – Multiple solvency options depending on what net benefit you would read and what internal links you are trying to solve. There’s solvency for: federal expansion EITC and child credit state +fed expansion EITC and child credit states expansion only The file separates these where needed – and you’ll see that there is also a section that’s more directly comparative to FJG and BIG. Make sure that you are reading the CP text that lines up with the solvency you are using – in other words, if you are arguing fed expansion only the you should not read cards that say the states are needed. Advantage Internal links – both preinstitute affs have internal links centering on poverty, inequality, innovation, jobs – the solvency evidence for all versions talk about why they solve those internals. 1ncs Generic 1nc – fed and states EITC/child credits Avoids economy DA and politics EITC solves - Federal and state EITC expansion reduces poverty, expands economy and addresses racial equity Waxman and Hinh, CBPP, 2023 [SAMANTHA WAXMAN AND IRIS HINH “States Can Enact or Expand Child Tax Credits and Earned Income Tax Credits to Build Equitable, Inclusive Communities and Economies” CBPP MARCH 3, 2023 https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/states-can-enact-or-expand-child-tax-credits-and-earned-income-tax accessed 6.13.23 GDI-TM] *figure omitted By reaching overlapping but different populations, each credit supports some families and individuals that the other doesn’t reach. State child tax credits are generally available to families with low or no earned income on their tax returns. These families may face high barriers to employment as well as high caregiving expenses, which the credits can help them meet. State EITCs are also available to families with children, but they also typically include people paid low wages without children in the home. Adults without children still face the same rising prices that make it hard to afford the basics; they may also be caretakers for people they cannot claim as a dependent on their tax return, such as non-custodial children. Figure 5 shows how Vermont’s child tax credit works (unlike most state EITCs, which are based directly on the design of the federal EITC, many state child tax credits have their own amounts and phaseouts). The full $1,000 amount is available to all families, whether or not they have earned income. Once a family’s income reaches $125,000, the credit amount begins to decrease, fully phasing out at $175,000. Families receive the credit for each child claimed on their tax return. Figure 6 shows how the federal EITC works for a single-parent family with one child earning the federal minimum wage in 2022 (about $15,000 a year for full-time, year-round work). Most state EITCs share a similar structure. For every dollar the parent earns, they get 34 cents in EITC benefits from the federal EITC. The value of the credit continues rising at that rate until their earnings reach $10,980. At that point, the parent receives the maximum benefit of $3,733. Once their earnings exceed $20,130 the credit shrinks by about 16 cents for each additional dollar of earnings until reaching zero at about $43,500. Although the EITC parameters are adjusted for inflation each year, the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 included a permanent provision that erodes the credit’s value over time by changing the measure used for inflation indexing from the Consumer Price Index to the “chained” Consumer Price Index, which usually increases at a slower rate. A projection at the time it was enacted found that families will receive a credit that is about $100 to $300 smaller in 2027 as a result, depending in part on family size and earnings.[11] The American Rescue Plan, enacted in March 2021, expanded the federal Child Tax Credit and EITC for the 2021 tax year. (See Figure 4 for state-by-state data on Child Tax Credit recipients under the Rescue Plan.) It made the maximum value of the child tax credit available to children in families with low or no earnings, raised the maximum credit from $2,000 to $3,000 per child and $3,600 for children under age 6, extended the credit to 17-year-olds, and provided for advance payment of part of the credit. It also increased the EITC for low-paid working adults who are not raising children at home from about $540 to $1,500, increased the income limit for these individuals, and expanded the age range to include younger adults aged 19-24 (excluding students under 24 who are attending school at least part time), as well as people aged 65 and over. It also extended a federal supplement to help Puerto Rico expand its local EITC.[12] Benefits from these credits extend far beyond the dollars that a family receives. By helping families keep up basic spending, the credits help them build economic security, improve longer-term health and well-being, and boost state and local economies. They are especially important when high prices for basic needs hit low-paid workers the hardest, as they did when inflation started rising in early 2021 and peaked in mid-2022 before starting to come down. They: Reduce poverty, especially in communities of color. Child tax credits and EITCs are helpful to households with children struggling on low wages and to those living below the poverty line. Overall child poverty in the U.S. is much higher than in any of the world’s 18 other similarly wealthy nations: 20 percent of U.S. children live in families with incomes below half of the national median,[13] compared to between 3 and 15 percent in those 18 others. But child poverty is higher still for Latino, Black, and American Indian and Alaska Native children in the U.S. than for white children. Children in some Asian ethnicity groups also face higher child poverty rates than white children, despite low overall poverty rates among all Asian and Pacific Islander children. For example in 2020, 24 percent of Hmong and 25 percent of Bangladeshi children lived in poverty compared with 11 percent of Asian and Pacific Islander children overall. Child tax credits and EITCs both reduce poverty and improve racial equity. The temporarily expanded federal Child Tax Credit, when combined with other pandemic relief measures, drove the child poverty rate to a record low of 5.2 percent in 2021.[14] The Rescue Plan’s expanded credit reduced hardship for children of all races and ethnicities — with the greatest reduction in child poverty rates for Black, Latino, and American Indian and Alaska Native children — and narrowed the differences in poverty rates between them in 2021. (See Figure 7.) A 50-state analysis estimates that a state child tax credit of $2,000 or less (with a 20 percent boost for children under age 6) that’s available to families regardless of earnings would reduce the child poverty rate by at least 25 percent in almost all states.[15] Meanwhile, state and federal EITCs serve a larger number of white households than any other racial or ethnic group (due in part to population size) but they reach a larger proportion of people of color relative to their population size. And the EITC has an outsized impact in reducing poverty rates for households of color. Due to historical and ongoing racial discrimination, many people of color are overrepresented in work with low wages and face obstacles to building economic security, leading to families struggling to afford the basics and respond to financial emergencies.[16] The EITC helps shrink these disadvantages by lifting low pay. The average state EITC benefit for households headed by a person of color was $120 higher than for white, non-Hispanic households, a recent study found, and state EITCs lift a larger share of people of color and Hispanic populations above the poverty line.[17] Help children and families thrive. The income from tax credits like the EITC and Child Tax Credit help children from birth throughout their lives. For instance, research links children in families receiving such income to having better childhood nutrition, as well as higher school enrollment, test scores, high school graduation rates, rates of college entry, and earnings into young adulthood.[18] EITCs and child tax credits also may play a particularly important role in helping children of color do better in school and access postsecondary education. Families of color, particularly Black and Latino households, were more likely to use the Rescue Plan’s expanded Child Tax Credit payments for their children’s long-term educational outcomes, such as saving for college and covering K-12 tutoring costs.[19] Evidence also suggests that additional income from tax credits can support families in meeting the full range of their children’s needs in the short and long term. Studies have found that more generous state EITCs are associated with improved birth outcomes, and states with EITCs that provide the full credit filers are eligible for regardless of tax owed had improved women’s health and healthier birth weights.[20] Even temporary aid to families with low incomes can reduce short-term stresses (which can have long-term consequences), such as hardship events like eviction, food insecurity, or loss of transportation.[21] During the initial monthly payments of the temporarily expanded federal Child Tax Credit in 2021, the number of adults living with children and reporting that their household didn’t have enough to eat fell significantly.[22] Individuals with higher incomes can also more easily afford healthy recreational activities, quality housing, and other opportunities that contribute to their overall well-being. Boost local economies. Child tax credits and EITCs help families who earn low wages keep up basic spending. This has been particularly important given increases in energy and food prices in the last two years arising from supply chain issues and the war in Ukraine, leading to many families experiencing hardship and causing some local businesses to struggle. Families typically spend their EITCs partially on bigger purchases such as a car repair or a security deposit on an apartment, and partially on routine bills and expenses.[23] The most common way people used the monthly payments of the temporarily expanded federal Child Tax Credit was for food, utilities, clothing, rent or mortgage, and education-related costs such as school supplies, books, tuition, afterschool programs, and transportation to school.[24] When families can keep up basic spending, this in turn helps their local and state economies. Versus FJG Avoids economy DA and politics EITC comparatively better for economy and work incentives than FJG – prefer the CP Pethokoukis, Senior Fellow AEI, 2018 [James “Thinking About (much) Better Pro-work Ideas Than a Cartoonish Federal Jobs Guarantee” AEI May 01, 2018https://www.aei.org/economics/thinking-about-much-better-pro-work-ideas-than-a-cartoonish-federal-jobs-guarantee/ accessed 6.15.23 prejcp-TM] The idea of a federal jobs guarantee, perhaps last seen in the enjoyable 1993 film “Dave,” is the hot-take economic policy on the left at the moment. (Sorry, universal basic income, your 15 minutes appear to be up.) Now there are many, many problems with a federal jobs guarantee. In a recent blog post, economist Timothy Taylor highlights lots of them, at least regarding the undercooked Bernie Sanders version. There’s a government managerial problem, a jobs-skills mismatch problem, a geographical mismatch problem, a worker displacement problem, a worker discipline and incentive problem, a “what happens to existing anti-poverty programs” problem, and, of course, a budgetary problem. Lots of problems. You really can’t hand-wave these away. Taylor also includes some commentary by Mother Jones’ Kevin Drum, which really shows why the jobs guarantee fails the sniff test. Drum: Since this is just a proposal, let’s also suppose that Bernie is proposing universal health care and a minimum wage of $15, which we know he supports. In that case, everyone with a job would be just as well off keeping it. However, there would still be millions who don’t have a job and want one, and more millions who might not like their jobs and would prefer a government job that’s a little cushier. How many is that? Maybe 5 million? 10 million? And probably more like 15-20 million during a recession. That’s still pretty damn close to insane. It’s about 3-10 percent of the labor force effectively nationalized forever by the federal government, which makes it roughly comparable to the emergency labor force employed for a few years by the WPA during the depths of the Depression. This is why even our lefty comrades in social democratic Europe don’t guarantee jobs for everyone. It would cost a fortune; it would massively disrupt the private labor market; it would almost certainly tank productivity; and it’s unlikely in the extreme that the millions of workers in this program could ever be made fully competent at their jobs. That’s what we in the commentary business call a reality check. But of course government should not be indifferent to encouraging work. This from my AEI colleague Michael Strain in a piece for Bloomberg: The right place to start is with policies to help individuals become more successful workers. One example is the federal earned-income tax credit, which uses taxpayer dollars to subsidize the earnings of low-income, working households. By increasing the financial rewards of working, previous EITC expansions have pulled people into the workforce. Or take work-based learning programs, like apprenticeships, which can be successful by combining skill-building with formal instruction in order to increase workers’ productivity and wages. Versus BIG Avoids economy DA and politics EITC expansion to universal tax credit for individuals to maximum of 10k provides support and reduces poverty – and if automation claims of the aff are correct, could convert to UBI Capps, 2019 [Kriston, “Is This the Universal Basic Income That Americans Will Buy?” Bloomberg News May 30 2019 https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-05-30/the-case-for-a-universal-earned-income-tax-credit accessed 6.15.23 prejcp-tm] As it’s currently construed, the Earned Income Tax Credit supports working low-income households with children. It’s a substantial enough subsidy that these households plan their annual spending around it. Anyone who has ever eagerly anticipated a tax refund understands this, although for some working families the credit can amount to as much as 40 percent of annual household income. Yet the Earned Income Tax Credit is only progressive-ish at best, since it provides little to no help for working households without children or for middle-class families. Burman’s paper calls for replacing the Earned Income Tax Credit with a Universal Earned Income Tax Credit, which would “provide meaningful assistance for low- and middle-income workers whether or not they have children living with them.” This universal tax credit “would not directly penalize two-earner couples,” he writes. The fixes are straightforward, albeit ambitious: The universal tax credit would be based on individual income, not household income, so dual-income households would benefit. Family makeup would no longer be a factor, so childless workers would earn more from the credit, too. The universal credit would apply to 100 percent of earnings up to a maximum $10,000, extending its reach into the lower middle class. Burman also tacks on changes to the the Child Tax Credit, making it fully refundable, which would be a huge boost for very low-income parents. Further, Burman proposes a way to pay for the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit: a new value-added tax of 11 percent. If nobody works at all, thanks to the robots, then the Universal Earned Income Tax Credit could easily be converted to a traditional UBI program. That pay-for element distinguishes the Tax Policy Center concept from Senator Cory Booker’s Rise Credit, Senator Kamala Harris’s LIFT the Middle Class Act, Senator Sherrod Brown’s Working Families Tax Relief Act, or the Economic Security Project’s Cost of Living Refund—all of which are otherwise fairly same-same. Any eventual effort to improve or expand the tax refund as part of the social safety net is bound to draw from some or all these drafts. The idea is to accomplish through the tax code what might be impossible through legislation, given the current partisan gridlock. Solvency – Expansion EITC – General Expand EITC – federal only Federal EITC Expansion – solves income inequality EITC expansion to childless workers and larger age group boost economy and address income inequality – COVID temporary expansion proves Weiss, 2022 [Laura, “Earned income credit backers aim to keep expansion on the radar” RollCall December 13, 2022https://rollcall.com/2022/12/13/earned-income-credit-backers-aim-to-keep-expansion-on-the-radar/ accessed 6.14.23 preJCP-TM] Outside groups are urging Congress to bolster a key tax benefit for low-income workers in a year-end legislative package after a previous expansion lapsed. Organizations including anti-poverty advocates, civil rights groups, seniors group AARP and business representatives are calling on lawmakers to boost earned income tax credits for workers without children at home, arguing it’s a critical program for low-wage workers and would boost the economy amid lagging workforce participation. Under Democrats’ pandemic relief law, the maximum dollar value increased for the earned income tax credit for workers without dependent children who live with them a majority of the year, the benefit phased in faster, and the benefit became available at higher income thresholds. Democrats also made the benefit available to most qualifying workers age 19 or older, scrapping age limits. The roughly $12 billion, one-year expansion lapsed after 2021, reverting to a smaller credit and shrinking the pool of those who qualify to workers age 25 to 65. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a think tank that has lobbied in
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.