Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 GDI Evidence

Inflation and Economy Updates - GDI 2023

Inflation and Economy Updates - GDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Economy & Inflation Updates
AFF – Economy Uniqueness
Economic Decline Inevitable
Economic disorder inevitable – multiple indicators prove the risk is high
Lachmond, American Enterprise Institute senior fellow, 7-10-23
[Desmond, 7-10-23, American Enterprise Institute, “Brace for 1930s-Style Economic Disorder—Especially If Interest Rates Keep Climbing,” https://www.aei.org/op-eds/brace-for-1930s-style-economic-disorder-especially-if-interest-rates-keep-climbing/, Accessed 7-15-2023, ah]
The world is soon headed for a period of serious economic disorder, warns Ray Dalio, founder of the world’s largest hedge fund, Bridgewater.
And (to paraphrase what a 1970s brokerage-firm commercial used to say about E.F. Hutton) when Dalio speaks, people need to listen.
Especially with his alarming warning backed up by historical experience and by current trends.
The essence of Dalio’s message: Economic disorder looms as a result of the combination of three factors all too reminiscent of the economically turbulent 1930s.
The first: The world has never been indebted before as it is today.
The second: Populism driven by income inequality has become the order of the day in all too many countries, including most importantly the United States.
Finally: Rivalry between major world powers like China, Russia and the United States has echoes of the world geopolitical tensions experienced in the first half of the 20th century with the rise of Germany as an economic powerhouse.
Anyone who thinks that the world does not have a major debt problem hasn’t been paying attention.
According to the Institute for International Finance, world debt at the end of 2022 hit a record $300 trillion, or some 350% of world GDP.
That is around 50 percentage points of GDP higher than it was on the eve of the 2008-2009 Great Economic Recession.
Meanwhile, per the Bank for International Settlements, if interest rates were to reach the levels of the mid-1990s, the debt-service burden for developed economies would be the highest in history.
Unfortunately, there is every prospect that interest rates in the developed countries will reach or surpass their mid-1990s level.
Over the past year, both the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank have raised interest rates to combat inflation at the fastest pace since the early 1980s.
At the same time, both Fed Chairman Jerome Powell and ECB President Christine Lagarde are warning that interest rates might need to be raised further in light of inflation’s current stickiness.
They have also warned that interest rates will stay high for longer than the market currently expects.
The one sector for which high interest rates could be particularly problematical is the real commercial-property space.
Already struggling with low occupancy rates in a post-COVID world, the last thing this sector needs is high interest rates.
This is especially the case at a time when it has $500 billion a year in debt to roll over in the next three years.
This could add renewed stress to the US regional banks: Commercial property represents 28% of their balance sheets.
The political calendar suggests that debt problems could coincide with increased domestic political strife, especially in the United States.
Polls indicate that the nation has never been as politically polarized as it is today in the post-war period.
They also suggest a divisive Donald Trump very likely could be the Republican Party’s nominee in the 2024 presidential election.
As if the debt and domestic political problems were not a sufficient challenge for the global economy, there’s the real prospect that the world’s already difficult geopolitical environment could take a turn for the worse.
This would be particularly the case were China’s President Xi Jinping to take a page out of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s playbook and embark on a Taiwanese military adventure to divert attention from a struggling domestic economy.
It hardly helps that Taiwan supplies around half of our electronic chips and an even higher proportion of the more sophisticated of these chips.
All of this suggests the Fed and the ECB could be playing with fire in their single-minded quest to defeat inflation with ever higher interest rates.
Recession Inevitable
Non-Unique – Aggressive Fed policy makes recession inevitable.
Lachman, American Enterprise Institute Senior Fellow, 7-7-23
[Desmond, 7-7-23, American Enterprise Institute, “The Federal Reserve Keeps Fighting the Last War,” https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-federal-reserve-keeps-fighting-the-last-war/, accessed 7/15/23,CC]
Yet despite these deflationary forces, and despite the likelihood that the full effect of the past year’s tightening is still to be fully felt by the economy, the Fed shows every sign of maintaining its hawkish monetary policy stance. Indeed, in his most recent Congressional testimony, Mr. Powell was at pains to tell Congress that the Fed’s job of reducing inflation was far from done and that two more interest rate hikes were likely in the rest of the year.
The moral of the story is that the Fed keeps making the same policy mistakes. To wit, it follows a backward-looking data dependent policy and it pays too little regard to the long and variable lags with which monetary policy operates. Last year those policy mistakes gave us a bout of high inflation. Over the next year, those same mistakes are likely to give us an economic recession.
Recession inevitable – interest rates are only one factor
Redman, Bitcoin.com News Lead, 7-13-23
[Jamie, 7-13-23, Bitcoin.com, “Experts Warn of Impending Recession in the US as Survey Reveals 59% Chance by July 2024,” BITCOIN.COM, https://news.bitcoin.com/experts-warn-of-impending-recession-in-the-us-as-survey-reveals-59-chance-by-july-2024/, accessed 7-15-23, MO]
According to economists surveyed by Bankrate, the probability of a recession occurring in the U.S. is significant. The survey, published on July 12, 2023, reveals that Bankrate’s experts estimate a 59% chance of a recession taking place by July 2024. Bankrate states that the expert forecasts “suggest a downturn is more probable than not.”
“Illustrating those odds even more, most respondents (78 percent) indicated that the percentage chance of a recession was greater than 1-in-2, while 28 percent said the odds were 70 percent or higher,” Bankrate’s Sarah Foster writes.
Bankrate’s most recent poll is not the sole survey indicating experts’ belief in an impending recession in the United States. ITR Economics forecasts a macroeconomic recession commencing in late 2023 and extending throughout 2024. HSBC Asset Management predicts a downturn for the U.S. in the fourth quarter of 2023, followed by a “year of contraction and a European recession in 2024”
The Bankrate survey underscores numerous factors that contribute to the prediction of an impending recession. These factors include a substantial increase in interest rates, strict monetary policy, bank failures, inverted bond yields, and other vulnerabilities in the global economy.
“Given the aggressive tightening by the Fed, the most likely outcome is a recession,” stated Abbey Omodunbi, senior economist at PNC Financial Services, in an interview with Bankrate.
Alongside Bankrate’s poll, Statista’s projections reveal a forecasted probability of 70.85% that the United States will experience another economic recession by May 2024. Scott Anderson, the chief economist and executive vice president at Bank of the West, believes that a downturn is probable this year.
Labor market weakening now – Employers are shortening hours, which is a sign of future layoffs and potential for recession
Bhattarai, The Washington Post economics correspondent, 7-11-23
[Abha, 7-11-23, The Washington Post, “Businesses are cutting workers’ hours in a warning sign for the economy”, https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/07/11/part-time-jobs-economy/, Accessed 7-15-23, ED]
Businesses are starting to cut workers’ hours, forcing hundreds of thousands of people into part-time roles, in what could be an early warning sign for the economy.
The number of people who worked part time, but want to work full time, rose by 452,000 in June, the biggest jump in more than three years, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. In all, 4.2 million people were employed part time for economic reasons beyond their control, a 12 percent increase from the month before.
Economists warn against making too much of a single data point, but say the latest spike in involuntary part-time work could be a harbinger of layoffs to come, especially when combined with other signs of slowing in the job market.
“Looking at this indicator — along with two straight months of decline in Black employment — gives me a bit of pause,” said Michele Evermore, senior fellow at the Century Foundation and former deputy director at the Labor Department. “I don’t mean to be Chicken Little here, but this does tend to be a leading indicator that things are starting to slow down.”
Employers add 209,000 jobs in June, a slow but steady gain
In interviews with nearly a dozen people whose employers recently shortened their hours, all said it was the result of slowing sales. Most worked in service jobs — fast-food joints, grocery stores, hair salons — where schedules can be easily redrawn to keep up with demand. But in at least two instances, office workers said drops in revenue had forced their employers to shorten workers’ hours across the board.
“As a company we aren’t doing as well as we were this time last year,” said Liv Roach, who works at a sustainability nonprofit in New York where most full-time employees were recently downgraded to part time. “Our nonprofit’s income is dependent on larger companies, and they’re starting to pull back. People keep saying recession fears are being assuaged, but no, recession fears are still very much here.”
Economists have been bracing for a recession for well over a year. While the U.S. economy shrank during the first half of 2022 — which typically indicates a recession — it has notched healthy growth since then.
A surprisingly strong job market and continued spending have kept the economy afloat, even as the Federal Reserve aggressively raises interest rates to slow the economy and control inflation.
More than a year into the Fed’s campaign, which has caused borrowing costs to rise at the fastest rate on record, there are growing signs that the economy is softening: The housing market is in decline. Manufacturing is on the downswing. And job openings are waning.
“In recent months it’s become more difficult for unemployed workers to find jobs, and even once they do, to find enough hours,” said Julia Pollak, chief economist at ZipRecruiter. “This is mostly the labor market returning to a more normal, sustainable pace. But that’s down from a situation that was much more favorable to workers, so going back to normal means that some workers are going to be losing out.”
The first people to lose out, she added, are often the most vulnerable: those in hourly, low-wage jobs, Black and Latino workers, and immigrants.
In East Lansing, Mich., Lawrence Hart-Howlett recently took on a second gig after his $14.42-an-hour job at a Michigan State University cafeteria got slashed from five days a week to two days for the summer.
But a week into his new position as a dishwasher at a fast-food chain, his hours were cut by 20 percent. This week, he found out they’ve been whittled down again: To 15 hours a week instead of the original 24.
“I had to pick up this job to help cover for my first one, and now what am I supposed to do?” said Hart-Howlett, 37. “Honestly, it’s kind of upset me. I’m not sure I’ll be able to cover next month’s rent.”
Economists use a variety of tea leaves, including joblessness and bond yields, to determine the odds of a recession. Some say an increase in part-time work could signal a coming downturn, even before unemployment ticks up. Joshua Mask, an economics professor at Temple University, says in every recession since 1980, a marked increase in involuntary part-time work has predicted a downturn in the coming months.
“It’s a curious pattern that seems to hold up going back to the 1980s, and it’s potentially another leading indicator we could be using to detect recessions,” Mask said. “I don’t think of [part-time work] as being a predictor, but I do think it’s picking up on the early stages of a trend.”
Stimulus and delayed action on monetary policy have set us up for a recession
Lachman, Global macroeconomy Senior Fellow, 7-13-23
[Desmond, 7-13-23, American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research, “America Is Facing a Recession: Should We Blame Joe Biden?,” https://www.aei.org/america/is/facing/a/reccesion, accessed 7-15-23, DG]
John F. Kennedy was fond of repeating the wise old saying that success has a hundred fathers but failure is an orphan. If ever there was an area where this adage has applicability, it has to be in the field of economic policy.
Today’s welcomely benign inflation numbers will offer a clear example of how economic success has a hundred fathers. We can be sure that President Biden will claim that the sharp reduction in headline inflation from a multi-decade high of 9 percent last June to today’s 3 percent has been the result of Bidenomics in general and the Inflation Reduction Act in particular. He will see today’s numbers as a gift to his re-election bid. Those numbers will bolster Mr. Biden’s hopes that he can get a skeptical American public to start believing in the supposed wonders of Bidenomics.
Not to be outdone, Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell is sure to claim that inflation’s welcome decline has been the result of the Fed’s brilliant monetary policy tightening under his watch. He will intimate that a soft economic landing might be in sight thanks to the Fed’s bold monetary policy management. After all, did the Fed not raise interest rates over the past year by 5 percentage points or at the fastest pace since the early 1980s? Also, did not the Fed shift from an aggressive policy of flooding the market with liquidity through its bond buying activities in 2020-2021 to one of withdrawing $95 billion a month in liquidity over the past year by not rolling over its bond holdings as they mature?
By contrast, last year’s inflation surge, which caught our economic policy makers totally flatfooted, was an orphan. Rather than assuming any responsibility for one of the largest economic policy failures in decades, both Mr. Biden and Mr. Powell were quick to find reasons for inflation’s surge that notably excluded their own egregious policy mistakes. These reasons included the Covid pandemic with its associated global supply chain disruptions and Russia’s Ukraine invasion, which drove the price of food and oil through the stratosphere.
In Mr. Biden’s view, his overly expansive budget policy had nothing to do with inflation’s surge. Never mind that in March 2021, at a time when the economy was already well on its way to recovery, Mr. Biden got Congress to pass the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan. That stimulus came on top of $3 trillion in bipartisan Covid relief stimulus the previous year. This meant that in the two years 2020 and 2021, the US economy received a budget stimulus in the staggering amount of some $5 trillion or more than 20 percent of GDP. Little wonder that former Treasury Secretary Larry Summers characterized this as “the least responsible” budget policy in the last forty years and correctly anticipated that the economy would overheat.
For his part, Mr. Powell keeps insisting that inflation’s surge had nothing to do with the Fed’s ultra-loose monetary policy. Never mind that at a time when the economy was well on its way to recovery from the Covid-induced recession and was receiving its largest peacetime budget stimulus on record, the Fed chose to keep interest rates at their zero-lower bound till March 2022. Never mind too that the Fed kept flooding the market with liquidity through its Quantitative Easing policy and allowed the broad money supply to balloon by a staggering 40 percent over a two-year period.
Even though the economy is now slowing and even though the recent contraction in the broad money supply has often been the harbinger of a recession, the jury is still out whether the economy will soon experience a hard economic landing. However, of one thing we can be sure. Neither Mr. Biden nor Mr. Powell will assume any responsibility for the overheated economy and the inflation surge last year that all too likely has set us up for an economic recession.
Employment Recession Incoming
An employment recession is incoming.
Tokic, University of Texas Rio Grande Valley Finance Professor, 7-7-23
[Damir, 7-7-23, Seeking Alpha "A Full Employment Recession," https://seekingalpha.com/article/4615740-full-employment-recession-nightmare-scenario, Accessed 7/15/23, S.A.M]
A Full Employment Recession
A full employment recession might seem like a paradox, but the truth is that this is becoming a baseline scenario for some of the top Wall Street players. In fact, last year in 2022 when the US GDP had two negative quarters of growth, The Wall Street Journal questioned whether that was a full employment recession. The 2022 "recession" was due to inventory adjustment, but the current situation closely resembles an actual full employment recession - and that's a nightmare scenario for stocks.
BlackRock, the world's largest asset manager, actually thinks that the US economy could possibly be in a full employment recession. Here's a LinkedIn post from Wei Li, Global Chief Investment Strategist at BlackRock, about three weeks ago, when she stated that the US economy is in a recession, based on the real GDI data:
And here is the Wei Li LinkedIn post from last week, when she specifically states that the "labor shortage" could create an unusual situation of Full Employment Recession.
Note, Wei Li points to the fact that the GDP data is still pointing to a strong US economy, while the GDI data is pointing to a recession, and calls this a "statistical discrepancy."
Nevertheless, the Fed is also concerned about the same thing - the GDP/GDI statistical discrepancy. Here's the quote from the most recent Fed minutes from June 14 FOMC meeting:
In their discussion of economic activity, several participants pointed out that recent GDP readings had been stronger than expected earlier in the year, while gross domestic income (GDI) readings had been weak. Of those who noted the discrepancy between GDP and GDI, most suggested that economic momentum may not be as strong as indicated by the GDP readings. In discussing that possibility, a couple of these participants also cited the recent subdued growth in aggregate hours worked.
AFF – Inflation Answers
Uniqueness Answers
Inflation High Now
Inflation high now - multiple indicators prove.
Kramer, Mott Capital founder and Seeking Alpha analyst, 7/12/23
[Michael, 07/12/2023, Seeking Alpha, “The Inflation Battle Is Far From Over, Now The Hard Part Begins”, https://seekingalpha.com/article/4616668-the-inflation-battle-is-far-from-over-now-the-hard-part-begins, accessed 07/15/2023, RT]
Core services for June were up 6.1% on a y/y basis, and goods were still up 1.3%. Both are still much higher than the historical average from 2000 until the beginning of 2020, when services averaged 2.8%, and goods averaged around 0%.
Overall, the core CPI of 4.8% was the lowest reading since the fall of 2021 and, indeed, has fallen quite a bit from its high of 6.6% in September. But again, it has been a slow long road, and disinflation isn't the same as deflation. Disinflation means prices are rising slower; deflation means prices are falling. Core CPI still needs to lose another 2.8 percentage points from here to get back to levels it was before the pandemic began.
The CPI non-seasonally adjusted rose by 0.3% in June and was in line with data in May. When looking at the trend of the non

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.