Monetary Policy CP - GDI 2023
Monetary Policy CP - GDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Monetary Policy CP 1NC Shell The United States federal government should substantially increase monetary redistribution <in the area of the plan>. Monetary policy solves for inflation, lowers unemployment, minimizes economic inequality, and works more efficiently than the fiscal policy Tax Policy Center 20 (May 2020, Tax Policy Center, https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-role-monetary-policy-alleviating-economic-downturns#:~:text=Monetary%20policy%20can%20offset%20a,reduce%20the%20cost%20of%20investment, accessed 7-2-2023 CC) Monetary policy—adjustments to interest rates and the money supply—can play an important role in combatting economic slowdowns. Such adjustments can be made quickly, and monetary authorities devote considerable resources to monitoring and analyzing the economy. Monetary policy can offset a downturn because lower interest rates reduce consumers’ cost of borrowing to buy big-ticket items such as cars or houses. For firms, monetary policy can also reduce the cost of investment. For that reason, lower interest rates can increase spending by both households and firms, boosting the economy. The Federal Reserve can adjust monetary policy more quickly than the president and Congress can adjust fiscal policy. Because most contractions in economic activity last for only a few quarters, a prompt policy response is crucial. Yet fiscal policy in practice responds slowly to changes in economic conditions: it takes time first to enact a stimulus bill and then to implement it, and time for the spending increases or tax reductions to reach consumers’ pockets. As a result, the effect of fiscal stimulus on household and business spending may come too late. 2NC Solvency OV The counterplan avoids the Politics DA by not going through Congress and only working through the federal reserve, decreases inflation through increased interests rates, and helps boost employment NB OV Monetary Policy avoids the downsides of fiscal policy Hayes, Economic Sociologist, 2022 Adam Hayes, Economic Sociologist ,April 14, 2022,Investopedia, “Fiscal Policy vs. Monetary Policy: Pros Cons” https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/050615/fiscal-vs-monetary-policy-pros-cons.asp, DOA 7-8-23 DD/CC] Raising taxes can be unpopular and politically dangerous to implement. The effect of fiscal stimulus is muted when the money put into the economy through tax savings or government spending is spent on imports, sending that money abroad instead of keeping it in the local economy. A government budget deficit is when it spends more money annually than it takes in. If spending is high and taxes are low for too long, such a deficit can continue to widen to dangerous levels. Fiscal policy is policy enacted by the legislative branch of government. It deals with tax policy and government spending. Monetary policy is enacted by a government's central bank. It deals with changes in the money supply of a nation by adjusting interest rates, reserve requirements, and open market operations. Both policies are used to ensure that the economy runs smoothly; the policies seek to avoid recessions and depressions as well as to prevent the economy from overheating. 2NC Monetary Policy Good Monetary Policy boosts entrepreneurship, decreases inflation, and stabilizes prices Miller, Montgomery County Revenue Authority - CEO, 2023 [Keith Miller, Montgomery County Revenue Authority-CEO,2023, Future of Working,“11 Advantages and Disadvantages of Monetary Policy”, https://futureofworking.com/11-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-monetary-policy/ DOA 7-8-23 DD] A monetary policy is a process undertaken by the government, central bank or currency board to control the availability and supply of money, as well as the amount of bank reserves and loan interest rates. Its other goals are said to include maintaining balance in exchange rates, addressing unemployment problems and most importantly stabilizing the economy. In the US, the Federal Reserve System is the agency executing monetary policy, which can either be contractionary or expansionary, with the former aiming to slow down the supply and even limit it to prevent the devaluation of assets and slow down inflation and the latter increasing the supply of money by lowering loan interest rates to encourage businesses to expand and cut down unemployment rates during recession. Basically, the agency decides how much interest rates would be imposed on banks in terms of borrowing, where banks would also be the ones to determine how high these rates will they be asking from the borrowers. During elections, the controversial issue of monetary policy is ironically avoided by hopeful candidates, who would talk about other matters except for this subject. Why, it would seem that this topic has its own set of complicated and vague perks and setbacks, with the importance for people to understand what it really is and what its implications in our daily lives. To have a well-informed opinion on this subject, let us take a look at its advantages and disadvantages. In an expansionary monetary policy, where banks are lowering interest rates on loans and mortgages, more business owners would be encouraged to expand their ventures, as they would have more available funds to borrow with affordable interest rates. Plus, prices of commodities would also be lowered, so consumers will have more reasons to purchase more goods. As a result, businesses would gain more profit while consumers can afford basic commodities, services and even property. The Federal Reserve can make use of a monetary policy to create or print more money, allowing them to purchase government bonds from banks and resulting to increased monetary base and cash reserves in banks. This also means lower interest rates and, eventually, more money for financial institutions to lend its borrowers. As monetary policy would lower interest rates, it would also mean lower payments home owners would be required for the mortgage of their houses, leaving homeowners more money to spend on other important things. It would also mean that consumers will be able to settle their monthly payments regularly—a win-win situation for creditors, merchandisers and property investors as well! One of the biggest perks of monetary policy is that it can help promote stable prices, which are very helpful in ensuring inflation rates will stay low throughout the country and even the world. As inflation essentially makes an impact on the way we spend money and how much money is worth, a low inflation rate would allow us to make the best financial decisions in life without worrying about prices to drastically rise unexpectedly. 2NC Monetary Policy True Monetary Policy is true and effective to avoid economic disaster. Kinsley, Freelance Journalist, 19 [Anne, ,March 18, 2019,Bizfluent ,“Examples of Monetary Policy” , https://bizfluent.com/facts-5241421-examples-monetary-policy.html, DOA 7-8-23 DD/CC] In the U.S., the Federal Reserve maintains control over our money supply, issuing currency as needed and making decisions that support the stability of our economy. These policies and decisions are called monetary policy and they ensure that unemployment levels are low, the gross domestic product (GDP) maintains stability, prices remain stable, foreign exchange rates are relatively predictable and select sectors are growing properly. The actions of the Federal Reserve are intended to create the kind of stability that empowers our nation to thrive and prevents crashes that result in bank runs and other economically disastrous dynamics. 2NC Avoids PTX If PTX – CP avoids politics, it doesn’t require congress meaning it can’t affect the current docket or political capital Monetary Policy does not go through congress, avoids backlash from both parties Segal, Bankrate Senior Editor, 2023 [Troy Segal, Bankrate Senior Editor,June 07, 2023,Investopedia,“Monetary Policy vs. Fiscal Policy: What's the Difference?” ,https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/100314/whats-difference-between-monetary-policy-and-fiscal-policy.asp DOA 7-8-23 DD] While the overall goal of monetary and fiscal policy is generally the same—to influence the economy—there are inherent differences between the two. Among the key differences between monetary and fiscal policy is the party responsible for carrying them out. Monetary policy is carried out by a nation's central bank, such as the Fed in the U.S., the Bank of Canada (BOC), and the Bank of England. Fiscal policy, on the other hand, is the sole responsibility of a country's government. The tools that are used are also distinct between the two. While monetary policy relies on open market operations, reserve requirements, and/or the discount rate, fiscal policy involves the use of government spending and/or changes in government tax policies. Monetary and fiscal policy are different tools used to influence a nation's economy. Monetary policy is executed by a country's central bank through open market operations, changing reserve requirements, and the use of its discount rate. Fiscal policy, on the other hand, is the responsibility of governments. It is evident through changes in government spending and tax collection. Monetary policy through the Federal Reserve operates outside of political influence Miller, Montgomery County Revenue Authority - CEO, 2023 [Keith Miller, Montgomery County Revenue Authority-CEO,2023, Future of Working,“11 Advantages and Disadvantages of Monetary Policy”, https://futureofworking.com/11-advantages-and-disadvantages-of-monetary-policy/ DOA 7-8-23 DD/CC] It promotes political freedom. Since the central bank can operate separately from the government, this will allow them to make the best decisions based upon how the economy is performing doing at a certain point in time. Also, the banks would operate based on hard facts and data, rather than the wants and needs of certain individuals. Even the Federal Reserve can operate without being exposed to political influences. 2NC Avoids Fism DA If Fism – CP avoids Federalism, it doesn’t require any federal action meaning it doesn’t touch federalism. Only the federal government can interfere with federalism, history proves Ross Veolia North America Chief Sustainability Officer, et al 21 [Dave“, March 5, 2021, Troutman Pepper, Don’t Forget the States as You Grapple with Federal Regulation," JD Supra, https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/don-t-forget-the-states-as-you-grapple-5333302/, Accessed: 7-12-23, /MB] Historically, federal enforcement displaces state enforcement, either because the federal government demands primacy or because states defer to the federal lead and reallocate their enforcement and compliance assistance resources to other priorities. Many states for that second reason may not mind a more active federal role. Others, however, prefer to manage enforcement within their borders under their delegated federal authorities or under other state programs. One concern for those states is that heavy-handed federal involvement and elongated negotiations may alter state relationships with the regulated community, or with the federal government. More active federal enforcement also tends to increase federal audits and oversight of state programs, creating further opportunity to erode the federal-state relationship. At base, the regulated community and the environment are better served by efficient government focused on compliance assistance and preventative measures, with targeted enforcement used to level the regulatory playing field across industry sector groups. 2NC Solves CC Stabilizing inflation through Monetary Policy gives the chance to solve Climate Change Suchnabel, economist, and European Central Bank Executive Board member,2023 [Isabel Schnabel, economist and member of the Executive Board of the European Central Bank, 10 January 2023, European Central Bank, “Monetary policy tightening and the green transition”, https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/key/date/2023/html/ecb.sp230110~21c89bef1b.en.html DOA 7-3-23 DD] Over the past year, we have moved forcefully to contain inflation by first stopping net asset purchases and then by raising our key policy rates by a cumulative two and a half percentage points. We have also announced that the Eurosystem will no longer reinvest all of the principal payments from maturing securities in the asset purchase programme (APP). We judge that interest rates will still have to rise significantly at a steady pace to reach levels that are sufficiently restrictive to ensure a timely return of inflation to our 2% medium-term target. As interest rates rise, financing investments in green technologies will become more expensive, generating the risk that higher costs of capital may slow down the pace of decarbonisation. There are, however, three interrelated reasons why tighter financing conditions are the appropriate response to the challenges we are facing today. First, current high inflation is a tax on investment. In many countries, it raises the user cost of capital by raising the effective tax rate on business investment.[ High inflation also increases uncertainty and distorts relative price signals relevant for investment decisions. And it may slow down productivity growth, as occurred in the United States in the 1970s. Therefore, the green transition would not thrive in a high inflation environment. Price stability is a precondition for the sustainable transformation of our economy. Second, inflation will not subside by itself. What started as a relative price shock has gradually morphed into a broad-based increase in the general price level. Preliminary inflation data for December point to a persistent build-up of underlying price pressures even as energy price inflation has started to subside from uncomfortably high levels. To resolve today’s inflation problem, financing conditions will need to become restrictive. Tighter financing conditions will slow growth in aggregate demand, which is needed to reduce the upward pressure on prices that has resulted from the long-lasting damage to the euro area’s production capacity inflicted by the energy crisis. By bringing aggregate supply and demand back into balance, we will accelerate the process by which inflation will fall back to our 2% target and thereby ensure that longer-term inflation expectations remain anchored. Third, the experience of the 1970s shows that a policy that is falsely calibrated on the assumption that inflation will decline by itself could ultimately put the green transition more fundamentally at risk. In this case, monetary policy would need to raise interest rates even more forcefully to restore trust in the economy’s nominal anchor. In the 1970s, financing conditions tightened to an extent that made capital accumulation prohibitively expensive. 2NC Solves Inflation Monetary policy solves inflation, has direct control of interest rates. Ross, Free Lances Ltd founder and Financial Advisor, 21 [Sean] Ross, Free Lances Ltd founder and Financial Advisor, October 08, 2021, Investopedia, “Monetary Policy and Inflation”, https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/122214/how-does-monetary-policy-influence-inflation.asp DOA - 7-2-23 [DD] Using these specific parameters, the term deflation is used to describe productivity increasing faster than the money stock. This leads to a general decrease in prices and the cost of living, which many economists paradoxically interpret to be harmful. The arguments against deflation trace back to John Maynard Keynes' paradox of thrift. Due to this belief, most central banks pursue a slightly inflationary monetary policy to safeguard against deflation. Most modern central banks target the rate of inflation in a country as their primary metric for monetary policy. If prices rise faster than their target, central banks tighten monetary policy by increasing interest rates or other hawkish policies. Higher interest rates make borrowing more expensive, curtailing both consumption and investment, both of which rely heavily on credit. Likewise, if inflation falls and economic output declines, the central bank will lower interest rates and make borrowing cheaper, along with several other possible expansionary policy tools. As a strategy, inflation targeting views the primary goal of the central bank as maintaining price stability. All of the tools of monetary policy that a central bank has, including open market operations and discount lending, can be employed in a general strategy of inflation targeting. Inflation targeting can be contrasted to strategies of central banks aimed at other measures of economic performance as their primary goals, such as targeting currency exchange rates, the unemployment rate, or the rate of nominal Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth. Contemporary governments and central banks rarely ever print and distribute physical money to influence the money supply, instead relying on other controls such as interest rates for interbank lending. There are several reasons for this, but the two largest are: 1) new financial instruments, electronic account balances and other changes in the way individuals hold money make basic monetary controls less predictable; and 2) history has produced more than a handful of money-printing disasters that have led to hyperinflation and mass recession. The U.S. Federal Reserve switched from controlling actual monetary aggregates, or number of bills in circulation, to implementing changes in key interest rates, which has sometimes been called the "price of money." Interest rate adjustments impact the levels of borrowing, saving, and spending in an economy. When interest rates rise, for example, savers can earn more on their demand deposit accounts and are more likely to delay present consumption for future consumption. Conversely, it is more expensive to borrow money, which discourages lending. Since lending in a modern fractional reserve banking system actually creates "new" money, discouraging lending slows the rate of monetary growth and inflation. The opposite is true if interest rates are lowered; saving is less attractive, borrowing is cheaper, and spending is likely to increase, etc. In short, central banks manipulate interest rates to either increase or decrease the present demand for goods and services, the levels of economic productivity, the impact of the banking money multiplier and inflation. However, many of the impacts of monetary policy are delayed and difficult to evaluate. Additionally, economic participants are becoming increasingly sensitive to monetary policy signals and their expectations about the future. There are some ways in which the Federal Reserve controls the money stock; it participates in what is called "open market operations," by which federal banks purchase and sell government bonds. Buying bonds injects new dollars into the economy, while selling bonds drains dollars out of circulation. So-called quantitative easing (QE) measures are extensions of these operations. Additionally, the Federal Reserve can change the reserve requirements at other banks, limiting or expanding the impact of money multipliers. Economists continue to debate the usefulness of monetary policy, but it remains the most direct tool of central banks to combat or create inflation. 2NC Solves Labor/Unemployment Monetary policy solves unemployment and perpetuating racial discrimination. Scherer, LSF Editorial Senior Editor ’22 [Lauri] S. Scherer, LSF Editorial Senior Editor ,March 2022, National Bureau of Economic Research, “Monetary Policy’s Disparate Impact on Labor Market Subgroups” https://www.nber.org/digest/202203/monetary-policys-disparate-impact-labor-market-subgroups DOA 7-03-2023 [CC] Employment among populations with lower labor force attachment responds more to expansionary monetary policy in tight labor markets than employment among more attached groups, according to Nittai K. Bergman, David A. Matsa, and Michael Weber in Inclu
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.