Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 GDI Disadvantage

Coercion DA - GDI 2023

Coercion DA - GDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Coercion Neg
Coercion 1nc
Fiscal redistribution is theft- violating property rights isn’t justified, even if the state has a better use for the money than the taxpayers.
Huemer, UC Boulder Philosophy Professor, 17 [Michael, Professor of Philosophy at University of Colorado, Boulder “Is Wealth Redistribution a Rights Violation”, Published in The Routledge Handbook of Libertarianism, ed. Jason Brennan, David Schmidtz, and Bas van der Vossen (Routledge, 2017), pp. 259-71, https://philpapers.org/archive/HUEIWR.pdf Accessed 7/16/23]-grh
Wealth redistribution financed by taxation is a violation of the property rights of taxpayers. In response to recent objections to this thesis, I have argued: a. The fact that one produces wealth through cooperation with other members of society, rather than through entirely solitary efforts, does not prevent one from acquiring an unencumbered property right in the money one receives from market transactions, given that the others on whom one relies make their contributions voluntarily and receive the compensation in exchange for which they agree to make those contributions.
b. The fact that the state provides valuable services, even services that are necessary to one’s productivity (if indeed this is the case), does not prevent taxation from constituting a rights violation. It is possible for a rights violation to have beneficial consequences; it is also possible for a person to steal money that he (the thief) helped the victim to obtain in the first place.
c. There is a tension in any libertarian position that countenances taxation to fund the minimal state while criticizing taxation used to fund wealth redistribution. Libertarians should resolve the tension by holding either that the minimal state is unjustified, that the minimal state can be financed voluntarily, or that the harms averted by the minimal state are sufficiently dire to justify the violation of property rights.
d. It is plausible to hold that (provided that the state is legitimate in general) the state has a legitimate role in defining property rights. However, the state’s definition of property rights is not morally unconstrained; it must respect certain broad, prepolitical moral norms governing ownership. These broad norms establish certain kinds of behavior as paradigmatic property-rights violations, including the sort of behavior in which the state is engaged when it taxes citizens. None of this proves that wealth redistribution could not be ethically justified, all things considered. What it shows is that there is an important consideration against redistribution. It remains possible that humanitarian or other values outweigh the property rights of taxpayers. The preceding reasoning has practical importance nonetheless, because it raises the threshold for the justification of redistributive taxation. Theft can be justified, but this requires fairly serious reasons; theft is not justified, for example, merely because the thief has a somewhat better use for some property than the original owner. Similarly, taxation might be justified, but this would require fairly serious reasons, something stronger than merely that the state has a somewhat better use for the money than the taxpayers.
Individual liberty comes first—rejecting every instance of coercion is key
Petro, 74
[Sylvester, Professor of Law at NYU, Toledo Law Review, Spring, p. 480, "Civil Liberty, Syndicalism, and the NLRA." University of Toledo Law Review, vol. 5, no. 3, Spring 1974, pp. 447-513. HeinOnline, https://heinonline.org/HOL/P?h=hein.journals/utol5&i=455.]
However, one may still insist, echoing Ernest Hemingway - "I believe in only one thing: liberty." And it is always well to bear in mind David Hume's observation: "It is seldom that liberty of any kind is lost all at once." Thus, it is unacceptable to say that the invasion of one aspect of freedom is of no importance because there have been invasions of so many other aspects. That road leads to chaos, tyranny, despotism, and the end of all human aspiration. Ask Solzhenitsyn. Ask Milovan Dijas. In sum, if one believed in freedom as a supreme value and the proper ordering principle for any society aiming to maximize spiritual and material welfare, then every invasion of freedom must be emphatically identified and resisted with undying spirit.
Links
Links- Redistribution
Government interventions to decrease poverty are in violation of the proper role of government – they take resources from some and give them to others, resulting in the expansion of government
Conrad Waligorski, Professor of Political Science at the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville, 1990
[The Political Theory of Conservative Economists]
Spontaneous order demands that governments stay out of autonomous economic relations. Public policy can do nothing positive to permanently reduce or eliminate poverty or the unhappy effects of market forces. Even if interpersonal comparison was possible and intervention increased happiness, taking resources from some to aid others must reduce freedom to use one's resources as one chooses and enlarge government. Requests for intervention based upon claims of collective needs mask partisan interests. Government should be small and inconsequential. In the name of freedom, the conservatives accept only those policies that narrowly support the market: impartial laws that are "neutral" between classes; protection of private property; defense; some limited provision of public education and welfare; enforcement of contracts; and so forth. Anything more undermines the interdependence between market and freedom.
Along with the assumptions in the previous chapter, this picture of freedom is the basis upon which the conservative economists build their politics. Their primary value is negative freedom, particularly economic freedom conceived as noninterference in the use of talents and property. There is only the actor and the absence of any coercive agent. Ability to act is incidental to freedom. Conservative freedom rules out conflict with other desirable values, since it always takes precedence. Thus there is no need to balance conflicting claims. Economic freedom is superior to all other political and social values, the basis for achieving whatever is good, and a condition of free and democratic governments. Any other concept of freedom must, in the long ran, destroy freedom and democracy. The conservatives' policy advice follows from this picture of freedom and is designed to support it. As with individualism, equality, democracy, justice, and other fundamental values, they have selected the narrowest possible interpretation-requiring the least amount of government and holding the least possibility of expansion, particularly by collective or public intervention. The primary role of government in freedom is to leave it alone and enforce the law. A wider meaning for freedom or coercion cannot be admitted, because that portends a larger role for freedom-destroying public intervention.
Governmental pursuit of social services serves as the stepping stone for more coercion
Smith, freelance writer and recipient of the Amigas Peace Power Prize for her works, 2008 (Christina, “So Welfare Is Now Patriotic?,” Apr 20, http://www.christinesmith.us/id93.html)
Government handouts weaken this nation to its core economically, socially and morally. Government handouts are financed by force, by coercion; taxation strips you of money you deserve to keep and is then often wasted through bureaucracy and corruption. But even if such a program were administered efficiently (and government does little if anything efficiently), but even if it were so, it is fundamentally wrong to tax some people in order to provide assistance to others. You don't take freedom from one by eliminating their free will and taking the fruits of their labor to supposedly give freedom/help/assistance to another. Freedom exist without coercion of any kind. And only in freedom is compassion expressed. It's not immoral to be in need, to be in a situation requiring the assistance of others - but it is immoral and disgusting when the pain and suffering of those in need is exploited by the government to justify its existence, its greed, its legalized stealing. Cloaked in the guise of compassion, from birth to death, the government intrudes into every area of American's lives making such important vital parts of life such as one's education, livelihood, health care, and retirement all tied to government control. Socialism (and socialist programs such as welfare) are the antithesis of a free society, just as they are the antithesis of a compassionate society.
Links- UBI
UBI entails an unethical acquisition of property through taxes
Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” https://philpapers.org/archive/AMATRT.pdf, Accessed 6/30/23, EP]
Kaza (2018) suspects that Robert Nozick would have condemned the UBI as an "illegitimate state acquisition of property." Therefore, those who share a similar political view to Nozick will not support UBI like Van Parijs and Vanderborght propose.8 Raventos (2007) also argues that for Nozick, any type of equality that breaches individual property rights can not be justified.
Duignan (2021) remarks that Nozick was against the power of states in terms of controlling prices or setting a minimum wage. For Nozick, this intervention is against the natural rights of citizens. The state also should not impose education or health programs funded by taxes; this is also a violation of the natural rights of citizens. Since UBI is mainly discussed to be funded by taxes, we can conclude that UBI is not a policy that Nozick would approve.
UBI forcibly takes money from taxpayers under a threat of punishment
Reed 22 [Garry, “Universal Basic Income is Universal Theft,” October 12, https://soapboxie.com/us-politics/Universal-Basic-Income-is-Universal-Basic-Theft EP]
But let’s begin at the beginning. Universal Basic Income (UBI) is, according to Wikipedia definition at least, “a form of social security in which all citizens or residents of a country regularly receive an unconditional sum of money, either from a government or some other public institution, in addition to any income received from elsewhere.”
Repeat: “In addition to any income received from elsewhere.” That means in addition to redistributing money forcibly confiscated from taxpayers to benefit people who are truly needy, it also means that thieves, robbers, gangsters, sex traffickers, murderers for hire and mafia-made men will also be collecting loot from taxpayers.
Dolan, in his rebuttal article, explains how some people with “libertarian sympathies” justify the idea of government forcibly redistributing incomes from people who have earned them to people who have not earned them this way:
“By some calculations, the government already spends enough on poverty programs to raise all low-income families to the official poverty level, even though the poverty rate barely budges from year to year. Wouldn’t it be better to spend that money in a way that helps poor people more effectively?”
Translation: Government’s “right” to collect taxes from its citizens under threat of punishment is a given; the only question is figuring out how to redistribute the loot in order to maximize voter support for the redistributors.
The politically-connected have always made their living from taxes.
UBI Taxation Is Theft
This doesn’t exactly align with the fact that the majority of modern libertarians understand that taxation is theft. As Joshua Paladino put it in a Being Libertarian article, “When it comes to universal basic income, libertarians somehow forget their principles. Theft suddenly becomes legitimate under the cloak of efficiency, and the redistribution of wealth becomes a worthy goal because UBI could actually make it happen.”
Governments, throughout history and around the world, support their elitist rulers by forcibly extracting human capital (i.e., taxes) through coercion, intimidation and fraud.
“human capital noun The skills, knowledge, and experience possessed by an individual or population, viewed in terms of their value or cost to an organization or country.” – Oxford Dictionary
UBI distributed by the state only increases its power- will spiral out of control
Amanov, University of Szeged Business and Management MA, 2022 [Shamsaddin, 2022, “The Right to Exist: The Position of Universal Basic Income in the Works of the Most Influential Contemporary Philosophers,” https://philpapers.org/archive/AMATRT.pdf, 6/30/23, EP]
However, the conflicting side of Nozick's views with UBI is the state intervention. In "Anarchy, State, and Utopia," Nozick (1974) advocated “a night-watchman state” - a limited and 23 minimal state model. In UBI, the state plays an important role and maybe increases its actual power. UBI is also becoming an influential tool for election campaigns. Gentilini et al. (2020) remind that in the 2008 elections of Mongolia, political parties competed over the guarantee of cash transfers for the citizens. Andrew Yang, in the United States of America, is promising UBI in the elections. What if an opposition always promises more amount of basic income than the government? In an ideal situation, UBI does not necessarily have to be under the control of the state. It would be a far better decision to establish a free and independent institution of UBI. An independent institution of UBI must be beyond any political party and government. There are some similar institutions like the Supreme Court or Constitutional Court. Notable economists like Thorstein Veblen, Douglass North, Daron Acemoglu pointed out the importance and necessity of excellent and working institutions on the progress and performance of the economy and welfare. Nevertheless, the state budget is the only resource that can afford UBI. If the state (e.g., Department of Treasury) is funding UBI, then how can UBI be run as an independent institution?
UBI just adds to an already fiscally unsustainable welfare state- we need more, not less means testing
Caplan, Professor of economics, 2017 [Bryan, 1/24/23, The Many Faces of Means-Testing , Econlog, “The Many Faces of Means-Testing,” https://www.econlib.org/archives/2017/01/the_many_faces.html, 7/2/23, PE]
Isn’t a Universal Basic Income just another name for a negative income tax, such as Tax = -$10,000 + .3*Income? If so, isn’t a Universal Basic Income means-tested by definition? The answer to the first question is Yes. UBI is just Milton Friedman’s negative income tax in new packaging. The answer to the second question, however, is more equivocal. The UBI is means-tested in the weak sense that your net payment falls with income. But the UBI dispenses with many other traditional forms of means-testing. Most notably: 1. Means-testing by age. Most welfare states prioritize children and the elderly. The implicit theory is that, unlike prime-age adults, the very young and the very old are unable to provide for themselves. 2. Means-testing by dependents and marital status. Most welfare states prioritize single moms with minor children. The implicit theory is that single moms have reduced opportunities to work due to their family responsibilities. 3. Means-testing by health. Most welfare states prioritize the disabled. The implicit theory is that they’re not healthy enough to work. 4. Means-testing by job history. Most welfare states prioritize people who recently lost their jobs over people who have never worked, or lost their jobs a long time ago. The implicit theory is that the short-term unemployed are unlucky, while the long-term unemployed are lazy. If your UBI proposal includes factors like these in its formula, it’s very hard to see what makes it a UBI. If your UBI proposal dispenses with most or all these factors, then it is a distinctive reform indeed. But “distinctive” is a far cry from “good.” Advocates correctly note that dropping multi-faceted means-testing reduces moral hazard: If your monthly payment doesn’t depend on your health, you have no reason to fake bad health. But there is also an gargantuan disadvantage: Dropping multi-faceted means-testing greatly increases the number of eligible recipients. If perfectly able-bodied, childless adults are eligible for free money, plenty will take it – and many won’t work at all. Taxes on remaining workers have to rise to pay for them. This probably won’t create a “UBI death spiral,” but a milder sloth spiral definitely kicks in, especially over the longer run as stigma against idleness erodes. And the burden of supporting able-bodied non-workers is also very likely to cut into funding for the more deserving poor. Frankly, given the bleak long-run fiscal forecast for the U.S., I’m baffled that anyone with libertarian sympathies takes the UBI seriously. The welfare state is already unsustainable, largely because our means-testing by age and health isn’t stringent enough. The elderly may have trouble working now, but since they had a lifetime to save for their own retirements, few of the indigent elderly are victims of circumstance. And given the huge long-run rise in the share of U.S. adults on disability despite rising health and less strenuous jobs, its clearly far too easy to plead disability. What’s especially strange is that the bleak long-run fiscal forecast makes old-school libertarian austerity more relevant than ever. Why are so many libertarians running away from our core ideas when conditions are nearly ripe for mainstream America to finally listen to us?
Links- UBI- AT: SQ Worse
UBI is worse than the status quo, multiple reasons- forced charity whether the recipient needs it or not, waste, bad incentives, and very expensive.
Caplan, Professor of economics, 2017
[Bryan, 2/20/17, EconLog, “Why Libertarians Should Oppose the Universal Basic Income,” https://www.econlib.org/archives/2017/02/why_libertarian_2.html, 7/2/23, PE]
Libertarians have a standard set of fundamental criticisms of the welfare state. 1. Forced charity is unjust. Individuals have a moral right to decide if and when they want to help others. 2. Forced charity is unnecessary. In a free market, voluntary donations are enough to provide for the truly poor. 3. Forced charity gives recipients bad incentives. If the government takes care of you, you’re less likely to take care of yourself by work and saving. 4. The cost of forced charity is high and growing rapidly, leading to a future of exhorbitant taxes or financial crisis. Taken together, I think these criticisms justify the radical libertarian view that the welfare state should be abolished. But this is an extremely unpopular view, so it’s natural for libertarians to consider more moderate reforms like the Universal Basic Income. And when you’re considering moderate reforms, the right question to ask isn’t: “Is it ideal?” but “Is it better than the status quo?” My claim: the Universal Basic Income is indeed worse than the status quo. In fact, all the fundamental criticisms of the welfare state apply with even greater force. 1. Some forced charity is more unjust than other forced charity. Forcing people to help others who can’t help themselves – like kids from poor families or the severely disabled – is at least defensible. Forcing people to help everyone is not. And for all its faults, at least the status quo makes some effort to target people who can’t help themselves. The whole idea of the Universal Basic Income, in contrast, is to give money to everyone whether they need it or not. Of course, the UBI formula normally reduces the net payment as income rises; but if a perfectly able-bodied person chooses never to work, the UBI gravy train never stops. 2. The UBI is an extremely wasteful form of forced charity. Helping the small minority of 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.