UBI Affirmative and Negative - Wave 2 - GDI 2023
UBI Affirmative and Negative - Wave 2 - GDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
WAVE 2 AFF ***Big stick v.2*** Advantage [ ] – Economy NOTE: replace the wave 1 Goodkind ’23 economy uniqueness (“recession now”) with these ev The U.S. economy will trend downward over the next few years – inflation is inevitable – recession becomes a risk when disposable income runs dry and employment opportunities decrease Erik Lundh, Principal Economist for The Conference Board, ‘23 JUNE 15, “The Conference Board Economic Forecast for the US Economy,” THE CONFERENCE BOARD, https://www.conference-board.org/research/us-forecast The Conference Board forecasts that weaknesses emerging in some parts of the economy will intensify and grow more diffuse over the coming months, leading to a recession. This outlook is associated with numerous factors, including, persistent inflation, Federal Reserve hawkishness, dampened bank lending amid the banking crisis, reduced government spending due to the debt ceiling deal, and underlying trends in consumer spending and income, and business investment. We forecast that real GDP growth will slow to 1.0 percent in 2023, and then fall to 0.0 percent in 2024. Consumer spending has fallen in four of the last six months. However, a large spike in January and a smaller spike in April offset this weakness. While spending on services has continued to gradually expand, spending on goods has been volatile. Recent PMI data suggest that the services sector is beginning to cool, and we expect high interest rates to further dampen spending on goods. We forecast that overall consumer spending will grow in Q2 2023 but anticipate a contraction in H2 2023. Two trends underlie the recent persistence in consumer spending, but both are likely fading. First, excess savings associated with federal government checks to households amid the pandemic period buttressed consumer balance sheets , but our assessment of these savings show that they are being depleted and will likely runout before the end of the year. Second, gains in disposable personal income have outpaced inflation since last summer. However, tightness in the labor market is moderating somewhat and wage gains are slowing. We expect this trend to continue as the economy cools and unemployment ticks up. Another notable drag on future consumer spending will be the reintroduction of mandatory student loan repayments in September. Prefer our long-term projections – their ev is a mere “snapshot” – even if growth will ‘tick up’ at times, the overall trend is downward without the plan ** Can save for 2AC ** Gee Lefevre et al, Jessica Egan & Adam Hobbs, ’23, March 8, “U.S. Economic Outlook 2023: A ‘Soft Landing’ or ‘Deep Recession’” TENEO – a global CEO advisory firm, https://www.teneo.com/us-economic-outlook-2023-a-soft-landing-or-deep-recession/ The U.S. government is currently trying to navigate its economy through a challenging inflationary period and orchestrate an outcome that has never been achieved. In other words, manage the dual challenges that rising inflation and rising interest rates have on economic growth while avoiding a recession and achieving its fabled soft landing. Positive indicators point to its achievability – inflation is down, the labor market remains strong. Despite evidence of declining real wages, this has not yet translated into declines in household consumption. The line between a soft landing and a recession is thin. Consumer confidence is at record lows, and the U.S. is seeing the biggest real wage declines in the wealthiest income brackets, which make up the majority of consumption. In this paper, we outline four potential economic scenarios for the U.S. going forwards; from a soft landing to the risk of long-term inflation and a deep recession. While there is cause to be optimistic about the U.S. economy, there remains a significant macroeconomic uncertainty, with the very real possibility that the economy could be about to enter a deep and lengthy recession. Advantage [ ] – Competitiveness NOTE: If you want to fortify this advantage, add to 1AC – or save for 2AC to answer presses UBI supercharges American AI advancement – key to collaboration and investment in projects the government is already forwarding MaMo TechnoLabs ’23, April 14, 2023, “Tech and AI: How Progress and Peril Have Shaped Our Changing World,” https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/tech-ai-how-progress-peril-have-shaped-our-changing-world/ To sum up, there is an urgent need for increased collaboration between government, industry, and civil society to ensure the fair and equitable sharing of the benefits brought about by technology developments and artificial intelligence. Programmes like the universal basic income, which would ensure that everybody get a basic income regardless of whether or not they are working, might help achieve this goal. Activities like this may help make sure that the benefits of technology progress and AI are shared more widely and that no one is left behind. Conclusion In conclusion, technological and AI advancements have had a profound impact on our daily lives, bringing with them many benefits and also some challenges. There are concerns about the loss of employment, ethics, and the potential exploitation of artificial intelligence despite the fact that these innovations have made our lives simpler and more efficient. However, by investing in education and training programmes, increasing transparency and accountability, and encouraging increased collaboration between governments, businesses, and civil society, we can help assure that the benefits of technology and AI are given fairly and equitably. If used correctly, technology and AI have the potential to improve the lives of everyone in the world. 1AC Plan & Solvency – Progressive Income Tax The United States Federal Government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by adopting a basic income funded through progressive income taxation. Raising taxes on the rich to fund UBI is topical and optimal in terms of feasible solvency Stephen Nuñez ’20, January 17, “UBI & the City,” PHENOMENAL WORLD, https://www.phenomenalworld.org/analysis/universal-basic-income-the-city/ The progressive income tax, which at baseline mirrors the actual marginal tax rates in New York City, is altered to finance this new expenditure. Income taxes can be adjusted by shifting the tax level without altering its progressivity (the relative difference in marginal tax rates across income categories remains constant) or by directly altering the progressivity. In the latter case, for example, one could alter marginal tax rates for the very wealthy without changing them for lower and middle income households. The paper explores financing the UBI through separate changes to the income tax’s level and progressivity, and builds a foundation to test optimal combinations of the two. Like all such models, the paper’s DSSE has some important limitations. Because interest rates are exogenously given and do not change in response to taxes or savings behavior, the model effectively excludes bond markets from general equilibrium calculations. This is a reasonable assumption when looking at city-level policy; what happens in NYC alone does not have a large effect on national bond markets or interest rates. It is also a reasonable assumption when analyzing small open economies in an international setting, as the central banks of economically smaller countries have little control over the price of borrowing in international bond markets. Second, because the policy analyzed is city-level, the revenue to fund it is raised entirely within the city and only city residents receive it. At the US federal level, safety net policy is not subject to that constraint: states may raise more revenue for a program than their residents receive or vice versa. Taken together, these features mean we should exercise caution in extrapolating from city-level analysis to a national level guaranteed income policy. Findings The first important takeaway is that whether the program is financed by changing the tax level or progressivity, the UBI increases aggregate welfare. From the paper: UBI is financed by income taxes which are, in their nature, distortionary. As is typical with distortionary income taxes, they reduce the incentive to work, resulting in households choosing more leisure hours and fewer working hours. This leads to lower city-wide output, income, and consumption. At the same time, UBI is a net transfer from wealthier to poorer households. Since poorer households have higher marginal utility, this is a transfer to those who need money the most. Under an equally weighted social utility measure, UBI is welfare improving. This is because, despite creating large distortions through the taxes needed to finance UBI, it provides a large benefit to those who need it most. Progressive taxation funds the plan – best balance of welfare and growth JEFF SPROSS ’19, SEPTEMBER 24, “Andrew Yang's UBI problem,” THE WEEK, https://theweek.com/articles/858097/andrew-yangs-ubi-problem Having people choose between the UBI check and their existing welfare benefits is meant to save the government money. But simply adding the annual cost of Yang's $1,000-a-month Freedom Dividend to all existing spending — state, local and federal — would still leave America with less government spending than France as a share of GDP. Granted, that's no small political task, but it's entirely doable from a budgeting and basic economic perspective. Meanwhile, Yang could get the additional financing he needs by increasing the progressive income tax the U.S. already has, starting from the top down. That would avoid the regressive hit to struggling Americans that comes with a VAT. If you're going to do something as wildly ambitious as call for a national UBI, you might as well call for a return to Franklin Roosevelt's income tax rates while you're at it. Finally, it's worth dwelling on the larger narrative Yang tells for why he thinks the country needs his Freedom Dividend. Basically, he argues that automation and robotics are going to wipe out large segments of the workforce, and a UBI is needed to catch the people who fall through the cracks. This prediction has clearly fired up a lot of Yang's supporters, but it's far from obvious that future disruptions brought by automation will be any worse than what our economy's already endured for the last two centuries. More to the point, Yang treats automation that increases joblessness and inequality as an inevitability that must simply be endured and ameliorated. And that means treating the nature of work itself — how many jobs there are, who gets them, how much people get paid, which workers do and don't get paid well, who has power, and so on — as somehow fixed by natural law. By all accounts, Yang's argument comes from a place of genuine concern and personal political reflection. But rather than approach work as a malleable social arrangement, whose terms and conditions can be altered by politics and policy, Yang essentially demurs to the idea of the market as a god-like institution. He leaves the evolution of that institution to the whims of the capitalist class, with his Freedom Dividend check as a kind of consolation prize for capitalism's losers. Critics on both the left and right understandably lambast this vision of the UBI as politically poisonous, further reinforcing the (very wrong) assumption that pursuing a UBI puts you on a rival and mutually exclusive team from those pursuing full employment and a democratized economy. Again, what's so frustrating is how unnecessary all this is. The combination of the two goals would deliver far more freedom and happiness to Americans than either could achieve on its own. From a practical perspective, a UBI itself could easily be part of a larger full employment program: If financed through a combination of deficit spending and progressive tax hikes, a UBI would increase aggregate demand and thus boost both jobs and wages. One hardly needs tales of robot apocalypse to convincingly argue that a (properly designed) UBI would make U.S. society vastly more just and humane. Studies prove UBI solves Lu, Science Writer at Guardian Australia, 2020 [Donna, 5/6/20, NewScientist, “Universal basic income seems to improve employment and well-being,” https://www.newscientist.com/article/2242937-universal-basic-income-seems-to-improve-employment-and-well-being/, 6/27/23, PE, accessed June 29, 2023] The world’s most robust study of universal basic income has concluded that it boosts recipients’ mental and financial well-being, as well as modestly improving employment. Finland ran a two-year universal basic income study in 2017 and 2018, during which the government gave 2000 unemployed people aged between 25 and 58 monthly payments with no strings attached. The payments of €560 per month weren’t means tested and were unconditional, so they weren’t reduced if an individual got a job or later had a pay rise. The study was nationwide and selected recipients weren’t able to opt out, because the test was written into legislation. Minna Ylikännö at the Social Insurance Institution of Finland announced the findings in Helsinki today via livestream. The study compared the employment and well-being of basic income recipients against a control group of 173,000 people who were on unemployment benefits. Between November 2017 and October 2018, people on basic income worked an average of 78 days, which was six days more than those on unemployment benefits. There was a greater increase in employment for people in families with children, as well as those whose first language wasn’t Finnish or Swedish – but the researchers aren’t yet sure why. When surveyed, people who received universal basic income instead of regular unemployment benefits reported better financial well-being, mental health and cognitive functioning, as well as higher levels of confidence in the future. When asked whether basic income could help people dealing with situations such as the economic fallout of the covid-19 pandemic, Ylikännö said that it could help alleviate stress at an uncertain time. “I think it would bring people security in very insecure situations when they don’t know whether they’re going to have an income,” she said. The findings suggest that basic income doesn’t seem to provide a disincentive for people to work. However, the effect of basic income was complicated by legislation known as the “activation model”, which the Finnish government introduced at the beginning of 2018. It made the conditions for accessing unemployment benefits stricter. The timing made it difficult to separate the effects of the basic income experiment from the policy change, said Ylikännö. “We can only say that the employment effect that we observed was as a joint result of the experiment and activation model,” she said. Preliminary findings, released in February last year, had previously found no difference between the two groups for the number of days worked in 2017. “Money matters, but alone it’s not sufficient to significantly promote either labour supply or demand,” said Ylikännö. Any trade-offs with other social services are good – welfare has failed Thomas Straubhaar, University of Hamburg, ’17. “On the Economics of a Universal Basic Income,” INTERECONOMICS, Volume 52, 2017 · Number 2 · pp. 74–80, accessed June 29, 2023, https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2017/number/2/article/on-the-economics-of-a-universal-basic-income.html While the extent of redistribution requires a (normative) political discussion, the (positive) economic analysis can convincingly demonstrate that a “blind” social policy is the most effective, most efficient and thus the most equitable social policy.21 An efficient social policy should support people, and not specific factors of production or regional or sectoral industries. Furthermore, it should refrain from paternalistic behaviour and simply flow unconditionally. The fundamental aim should be to redistribute some degree of purchasing power from people with higher incomes to those with lower incomes. Direct individual payments to economically weaker people are more targeted, less expensive and more effective than indirect measures which require the fulfilment of specific criteria, particular preconditions or certain behaviours, for example, the requirement of being employed or at least searching for employment, or the attainment of a specified age. It is part of the tragedy of a misunderstood social policy that it attempts to reach a political goal with unsuitable means. Social-politically motivated interventions in the markets’ mechanisms are inappropriate. In many cases, they provoke outcomes that are the opposite of what should be achieved. They lead to unnecessary duplicate structures and an expensive bureaucracy. Many people receive financial support through the current procedure via the social insurance system, only to have that support contradicted through the tax system. The UBI completely replaces today’s social insurance systems. At first glance, this may appear to be a dismantling of social rights and claims. On closer inspection, however, it becomes clear that such a judgement is based on a fallacy. ***Structural Violence Advantage**** 1AC Advantage – Structural Violence Rapid widespread labor automation is inevitable – basic income is a safety net for people becoming more vulnerable as tech advances Kelly, RMIT University in Melbourne, ‘22 Kelly, Lauren. School of Media and Communication, RMIT University, Melbourne Australia, “Re-politicising the future of work: Automation anxieties, universal basic income, and the end of techno-optimism.” Journal of Sociology, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1177/14407833221128999. October 9, 2022. Accessed: 06/15/23. AR. Predicting the technological future of work is back on the academic agenda, exemplified by the swathe of influential literature published on the subject since the mid-2010s (Brynjolfsson & McAfee, 2014; Ford, 2015; Frey & Osborne, 2013; Kaplan, 2015; Schwab, 2016; Susskind & Susskind, 2015). While history has often been punctuated by concerns of technological job loss (Gorz, 1999; Keynes, 1930; Leontief & Duchin, 1986; Rifkin, 1995), it is now argued that this time it’s different due to advances in particular technologies – namely robotics, big data, and artificial intelligence. The rise of smart machines and automated decision-making technologies now threatens non-routine, professional, and even creative occupations that were, until recently, considered immune to automation. Assumptions of inevitable job loss are widespread and reproduced through the policy recommendations of international organisations, influential consultancy firms, and government white papers. Adherents of this view span the political spectrum – from Silicon Valley self-proclaimed futurists to the radical left. Where these perspectives differ is on the political question of what this means for labour. Techno-pessimists predict a dystopian future of technological unemployment, while techno-optimists argue that full automation can emancipate workers from the drudgery of work and create new possibilities for a post-work, or post-capitalist future. Regardless of political inclination, it is typically agreed that something akin to a UBI will be necessary to smooth the transition from wage-earning to incomes by other means. The techno-pessimist view declares a new era characterised by the ‘rise of the robots’, a ‘second machine age’, and ‘fourth industrial revolution’ is upon us. Here I do not attempt another review of this well-discussed literature (see Wajcman, 2017) but instead seek to emphasise the extent to which popular automation discourse rests upon one highly influential 2013 report by Frey and Osborne. Using a predictive algorithm, the authors claim as many as 47% of jobs in the United States are ‘at risk’ of automation in the next ten to twenty years (
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.