Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 GDI Counterplan

Beam Advantage CP - GDI 2023

Beam Advantage CP - GDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Beam Adv CP
1NC
Shell
Text: The United States Department of Defense should substantially increase its investment in power beaming technology and infrastructure in the United States.
Energy beaming solves climate change, spurs private sector tech investment, and ensures US military readiness
MIT Technology Review Insights 2022
[MIT Technology Review Insights, “Power beaming comes of age,” MIT, 9—6— https://www.technologyreview.com/2022/10/06/1060650/power-beaming-comes-of-age/, accessed 7-2-23 MR]
Power beaming has long been a dream of engineers and innovators. Defined as the point-to-point transfer of electrical energy by a directed electromagnetic beam, the idea originated from Serbian-American physicist Nikola Tesla at the turn of the 20th century. After decades of alternating between optimism and abandonment, power beaming is finally becoming a reality, thanks to research led by space and military agencies, and increasing attention from startups and the private sector.
Three main factors have accelerated its development. Sectors that were once beyond the reach of private enterprises—such as satellites, the low-earth orbit economy, and drones—are becoming viable businesses. Enterprises face increasing pressure to offer radical energy solutions to achieve net-zero emissions.
The global need for power to provide ubiquitous connectivity through 5G, 6G, and smart infrastructure is rising. This report explains the prospects of power beaming; its economic, human, and environmental implications; and the challenges of making the technology reliable, effective, wide-ranging, and secure.
The following are the report’s key findings:
Lasers and microwaves offer distinct approaches to power beaming, each with benefits and drawbacks. While microwave-based power beaming has a more established track record thanks to lower cost of equipment, laser-based approaches are showing promise, backed by an increasing flurry of successful trials and pilots. Laser-based beaming has high-impact prospects for powering equipment in remote sites, the low-earth orbit economy, electric transportation, and underwater applications. Lasers’ chief advantage is the narrow concentration of beams, which enables smaller trans- mission and receiver installations. On the other hand, their disadvantage is the disturbance caused by atmospheric conditions and human interruption, although there are ongoing efforts to tackle these deficits.
Power beaming could quicken energy decarbonization, boost internet connectivity, and enable post-disaster response. Climate change is spurring investment in power beaming, which can support more radical approaches to energy transition. Due to solar energy’s continuous availability, beaming it directly from space to Earth offers superior conversion compared to land-based solar panels when averaged over time. Electric transportation—from trains to planes or drones—benefits from power beaming by avoiding the disruption and costs caused by cabling, wiring, or recharge landings.
Beaming could also transfer power from remote renewables sites such as offshore wind farms. Other areas where power beaming could revolutionize energy solutions include refueling space missions and satellites, 5G provision, and post-disaster humanitarian response in remote regions or areas where networks have collapsed due to extreme weather events, whose frequency will be increased by climate change. In the short term, as efficiencies continue to improve, power beaming has the capacity to reduce the number of wasted batteries, especially in low-power, across-the- room applications.
Public engagement and education are crucial to support the uptake of power beaming. Lasers and microwaves may conjure images of death rays and unanticipated health risks. Public backlash against 5G shows the importance of education and information about the safety of new, “invisible” technologies. Based on decades of research, power beaming via both microwaves and lasers has been shown to be safe. The public is comfortable living amidst invisible forces like wi-fi and wireless data transfer; power beaming is simply the newest chapter.
2NC
OV
Generic Solvency
The counterplan solves the key internal link to the economy and climate by eliminating carbon emissions and democratizing the availability of green energy in the United States by substantially investing in beam energy technology and infrastructure.
CC Module
Power beaming solves emissions and allows for an effective transition to renewables
Pultarova, Senior Writer for Space.com, 2022 (Tereza, London-based science and technology journalist , Space-based solar power could really work, experiment shows, 11-17-22, space.com, https://www.space.com/airbus-space-solar-power-test accessed: 07-02-23)-TL
Space-based solar power could also help wean the world off fossil fuels and contribute to a zero carbon future in line with calls of the international climate science community. Scientists believe that in order to prevent the planet from warming on average by more than 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit), the global economy would have to be fully decarbonized by 2050. However, this goal is still not within reach, according to a recent United Nations report on climate change.
"Power beaming technologies would enable the creation of new energy networks in the sky and could help solve the energy problem," Coste said. "They would enable countries to fully control and distribute their energy where needed, independently."
Solar power energy generation is much more efficient in space than on Earth's surface, where clouds and the day-night cycle prevent achieving maximum illumination. In fact, solar radiation is 50% more intense in space, where no air stands in the way of the rays. However, the technology is not without its drawbacks.
"If satellites were to collect the sunlight, they would need to measure about 2 kilometers [1.2 miles] across to achieve the same power level as a nuclear power plant," Thueux said.
And nothing of that size has ever flown in space. The largest space-borne structure ever assembled in orbit is the International Space Station, which is about the size of a football field.
Coste said that the microwave beams that carry harvested solar energy "can be designed to prevent harm" to technology as well as living creatures. He sees further advantages of the system in its ability to distribute power all over the world without the need for any further ground-based infrastructure.
"There is no need for complex and costly ground infrastructure, power plants, pipelines or cables, for example, to distribute the electricity on Earth," Coste said. "That, too, is done by power beaming."
Tech Invest Module
Energy beaming will compliment and spur on investment in other renewables – strengthening tech development and ensuring a transition to a green economy
European Space Agency 2022 (FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions on Space-Based Solar Power, 09-23-22, https://www.esa.int/Enabling_Support/Space_Engineering_Technology/SOLARIS/FAQ_Frequently_Asked_Questions_on_Space-Based_Solar_Power accessed: 07-02-23)-TL
How can SBSP be competitive with terrestrial renewables (e.g., solar, wind), when the cost of renewables is falling rapidly and given the typically high costs of launch and space hardware?
This question is at the heart of the two cost benefit studies commissioned by ESA, the results of which are available online in full. These studies assessed the economic and technical benefits of investing in the enabling technologies needed to realise large scale SBSP scenarios, and compared them to other energy sources, taking into consideration future market needs and technology forecasts. They conclude that due to the nature of the electricity provided by SBSP (“baseload” power), SBSP doesn’t compete with intermittent renewables, but rather could serve a complementary role to terrestrial intermittent renewables, helping to provide stability and reliability to the grid. It therefore needs to be compared to other baseload sources like nuclear, carbon and gas with carbon capture technology or very large-scale deployment of storage solutions. The studies conclude based on the current available information that SBSP could contribute to a future diverse CO2 neutral energy mix that has a high proportion of intermittent renewables, despite being more expensive than them. The IEA Net Zero 2050 roadmap demonstrates clearly that terrestrial wind and solar needs to expand rapidly, but even with the hoped-for availability by then of new storage solutions, the energy mix in 2050 still foresees some significant capacity from baseload and dispatchable sources to provide flexibility and reliability.
Avoids Politics
SSP has massive support in Congress among all special interest groups, lobbyists, and the military
National Security Space Office, DoD department for space security (NSSO, Space‐Based Solar Power As an Opportunity for Strategic Security 10/10/07, https://space.nss.org/wp-content/uploads/Space-Based-Solar-Power-Opportunity-for-Strategic-Security-assessment.pdf)-TL
The SBSP Study Group found that SBSP is an idea that appears to generate significant interest and support across a broad variety of sectors. Compared to other ideas either for space exploration or alternative energy, Space‐Based Solar Power is presently not a publicly well‐known idea, in part because it has no organizational advocate within government, and has not received any substantial funding or public attention for a significant period of time. Nevertheless, DoD review team leaders were virtually overwhelmed by the interest in Space‐Based Solar Power that they discovered. What began as a small e‐mail group became unmanageable as the social network & map‐of‐expertise expanded and word spread. To cope, study leaders were forced to move to an on‐line collaborative group with nearly daily requests for new account access, ultimately growing to over 170 aerospace and policy experts all contributing pro‐bono. This group became so large, and the need to more closely examine certain questions so acute, that the group had to be split into four additional groups. As word spread and enthusiasm grew in the space advocacy community, study leaders were invited to further expand to an open web log in collaboration with the Space Frontier Foundation. The amount of media interest was substantial. Activity was so intense that total e‐mail traffic for the study leads could be as high as 200 SBSP‐related e‐mails a day, and the sources of interest were very diverse.USAF Security Forces, and installations personnel, all of which have an interest in clean, low environmental‐impact energy sources, and especially sources that are agile without a long, vulnerable, and continuing logistics chain. There was clear interest from both traditional “big aerospace,” and the entrepreneurial space community. Individuals from each of the major American aerospace companies participated and contributed. The subject was an agenda item for the Space Resources Roundtable, a dedicated industry group. Study leaders were made aware of significant and serious discussions between aerospace companies and several major energy and construction companies both in and outside of United States. As the study progressed the study team was invited to brief in various policy circles and think tanks, including the Marshall Institute, the Center for the Study of the Presidency, the Energy Consensus Group, the National Defense Industry Association, the Defense Science Board, the Department of Commerce’s Office of Commercial Space, and the Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP). Interest in the idea was exceptionally strong in the space advocacy community, particularly in the Space Frontier Foundation (SFF), National Space Society (NSS), Space Development Steering Committee, and Aerospace Technology Working Group (ATWG), all of which hosted or participated in events related to this subject during the study period.
Avoids Econ DA
Now is the core economic moment for energy beaming to fix the economy
Harrison, vice president of operations and director of defense technology programs at the American Foreign Policy Council, 2023 (Richard, US can’t afford to dawdle on investing in space-based solar power, 01-26-23, https://thehill.com/opinion/technology/3831460-us-cant-afford-to-dawdle-on-investing-in-space-based-solar-power/ accessed 07-02-23)-TL
Is a limitless source of green energy within reach? With unrelenting global reliance on fossil fuels, a worsening climate, and growing dependency on (often-unreliable) renewables, the world desperately needs a solution.
Scientists in the U.S. appeared to come close to one with a recent breakthrough in fusion technology. Unfortunately, while a positive technological advancement, several decades of development are still necessary before fusion becomes a commercially viable energy alternative. Yet there may be another way to alleviate our energy dilemma — and soon. The answer lies in space-based solar power (SSP).
The premise is simple. Traditional terrestrial solar power is a suboptimal source of energy because it is inhibited by the Earth’s atmosphere and unavailable at nighttime. By contrast, by placing large solar energy collecting satellites in space and transmitting energy via microwave beams down to rectifying antennas on Earth, it would be possible to obtain power 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
This may sound like science fiction, but the idea has been around for decades. SSP as a concept was first formally proposed way back in 1968. Fast forward more than half-a-century, and today most of the technology needed to accomplish this esoteric feat is readily available.
Domestically, the U.S. military is at the forefront of pioneering SSP component technology and developing a proof of concept. In April of 2022, the Naval Research Laboratory (NRL) conducted a successful terrestrial microwave power beaming test to demonstrate the feasibility of electrical energy transmission. The following month, the NRL launched the Photovoltaic Radio-frequency Antenna Module (PRAM) to test capturing sunlight and converting it to microwaves on board the secretive X-37B orbital space plane. Meanwhile, the Air Force Research Laboratory is investing in the Space Solar Power Incremental Demonstrations and Research Project (SSPIDR), which will culminate in a demonstration of solar energy collection in space, conversion to microwave energy, and power beaming down to Earth in 2025.
The economic potential is enormous. A constellation of commercial SSP satellites could produce cost-competitive clean energy, serve as a complement to renewable sources, and help phase out fossil fuel use. All of which would lead to strengthened U.S. economic security.
American national security would benefit greatly as well. With satellites able to collect energy and beam it to anywhere on the globe, the U.S. military would be able to provide energy to forward operating bases and conflict zones without worrying about adversaries cutting off vulnerable energy supply lines. SSP could similarly power America’s drones to carry out persistent surveillance, since costly and time-consuming refueling would be rendered unnecessary.
Some in the private sector have begun to recognize SSP’s potential. For instance, a decade after it received a generous donation to support SSP initiatives, CalTech just launched a Space Solar Power Demonstrator (SSPD) to evaluate multiple energy collection and transfer technologies. At least three U.S. startups are developing the tech as well, and one U.S. design is also being considered as a model for development by the European Space Agency (ESA).
But that interest isn’t matched in the U.S. government — at least not yet.
While the U.S. military is investing in SSP, and the private sector is now beginning to experiment with the concept, there is — as yet — no concerted government-led effort to develop a commercially viable SSP architecture.
Why the failure to launch? Historically, the concept of SSP has not been without its detractors, due to a variety of flaws, from photovoltaic inefficiency to prohibitive launch costs. But times have changed, and dramatic improvements in technology have yielded new possibilities. In just one example, the advent of reusable rockets has reduced launch costs by roughly 95 percent over the last two decades — and more savings are on the horizon, with SpaceX’s reusable Starship waiting in the wings. Moreover, the feasibility of SSP is now on solid ground, with more and more policy institutes and foreign governmental entities advocating for SSP deployment.
The most prohibitive cost, however, might be in not acting on the promise of SSP.
America’s allies and adversaries are all forging ahead with plans to have SSP power their electric grids. The European Space Agency has developed an activity plan for 2025; Japan has plans for an SSP demonstration in 2025, and the UK has set up a Space Energy Initiative (SEI). But the biggest worry is China, which is currently the leader in the SSP space sector. Beijing has already constructed a massive power receiving station, is planning SSP experiments on their new Tiangong space station, has laid the groundwork for a high voltage space-to-ground test in 2028, and has laid out plans for an SSP operational capacity equivalent to a nuclear power plant by 2050.
Recent years have given the world a glimpse at the true face of Xi Jinping’s China, with its gross human rights abuses, flouting of global norms, and growing international belligerence. If the PRC manages to become the world’s leading supplier of cheap, clean energy as well, the consequences would be massive — and the power Beijing would gain over global commerce and diplomacy would expand exponentially.
You might stop banking crises and bailouts, but not bank failures
Building clean: Permitting reform we can all agree on
To avoid such a dystopian future, the U.S. government needs to start investing in space-based solar power now. And in the process, we can help address the climate issue, as well as bolster both U.S. economic and national security.
There’s not a moment to waste.
Avoids Inflation DA
Massively expanding solar energy solves inflation
Energy Economics 2022 (Energy Economics is a solar research, development, and design firm that successfully designed, installed, and commissioned over 400 top-of-the-line systems across British Columbia., SOLAR SYSTEMS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA IS SOLAR ENERGY THE SECRET HEDGE AGAINST INFLATION?, 10-07-22, https://energyeconomicssolar.ca/is-solar-energy-the-secret-hedge-against-inflation/ accessed 07-02-23)-TL
IS SOLAR ENERGY THE SECRET HEDGE AGAINST INFLATION?
Inflation has been in the news a lot recently. And for good reason – it’s affecting everyday Canadians in a very real way. Gas prices are rising, food costs are increasing, and wages aren’t keeping up. This is putting a huge strain on budgets all across the country and creating market uncertainty. Market uncertainty equals risk and risk affects investments. Combined with the impact of COVID on worldwide supply chains and the crisis in Ukraine, home security and cost certainty has never been more top of mind.
At Energy Economics, we believe energy is one of the most essential currencies in our world today. The majority of our clients are concerned with the future cost of energy, its’ sustainability, as well as its dependability and security. Producing your own renewable energy on your rooftop can hedge against this market uncertainty while reducing reliance on grid power and adding to your financial independence.
WHAT IS INFLATION AND HOW DOES IT AFFECT OUR EVERYDAY LIVES?
Inflation is a rise in the general level of prices for goods and services. It occurs when the value of money falls due to an increase in the amount of money available in the economy. Rising prices put a strain on our economy as a whole, 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.