Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 GDI Counterplan

States CP and Federalism DA - GDI 2023

States CP and Federalism DA - GDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
States CP
1NC Shell - Generic
CP Text: The 50 states and all relevant territories in the United States should substantially increase their fiscal redistribution by (Insert Plan)
States solve inequality – State Tax Policy is able to create fiscally redistributive policies that solves income inequality
McNichol, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, Senior Fellow, 16
(Elizabeth, 12-15-16, Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, “How State Tax Policies Can Stop Increasing Inequality and Start Reducing It”, https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/how-state-tax-policies-can-stop-increasing-inequality-and-start, Accessed 7-2-23, ED)
The income tax is the one major state revenue source that typically reduces inequality, but many states have weak income tax systems that do too little in this regard. A graduated-rate income tax, which taxes higher incomes at higher rates, affects high-income families more than low-income families, and in a few states this balances out the effects of sales and property taxes. But many state income taxes are flat (meaning all income is taxed at the same rate) or nearly flat, and a few states don’t have an income tax. As a result, some states do much more than others to reduce inequality through their tax codes.
Many states have made their tax systems even more out of balance since the late 1970s, even as inequality has risen, by increasing their reliance on sales taxes rather than income taxes. For example, the sales tax rate in the typical state has doubled since 1970 while the top income tax rate has remained unchanged.[9] (See Figure 4.)
The shift away from states taxing the wealthy has continued since the Great Recession hit. In the depths of the downturn in 2009 and 2010, for example, a number of states raised taxes as part of their response to recession-induced revenue declines, but while they raised both income taxes and sales taxes, the income tax increases were almost uniformly temporary while half of the sales tax-rate increases were permanent. Some states have cut income taxes as the economy recovers.
FIGURE 4
States Have Raised Sales Taxes, Cut Income Taxes
States can reverse these trends and use tax policy to reduce income inequality by taking the following actions.
Strengthen their income tax’s inequality-reducing impact. Tax increases on high-income individuals — who are best able to afford the higher tax and least likely to spend substantially less as a result of the increase — can reduce inequality directly while raising revenue to invest in a more broadly prosperous future. Policymakers can raise taxes on high-income households by raising income tax rates at the top end and by capping itemized deductions and other tax breaks for high-income taxpayers.
Establish or expand taxes on inherited wealth, such as the estate tax. Only the very wealthiest taxpayers pay estate taxes — just 2.56 percent of estates, on average, in the states with the tax. Some 18 states plus Washington, D.C. have an estate or inheritance tax. States with an estate tax can avoid increasing inequality by resisting calls to reduce or eliminate the tax. States without an estate tax can reduce inequality by adopting one.
Eliminate costly and ineffective tax breaks for corporations. State corporate income taxes are declining; the share of tax revenue supplied by this tax in the 45 states that levy it fell from nearly 10 percent in the late 1970s, to only a little more than 5 percent today. Many profitable corporations pay nothing in state income taxes in some states where they do business. States can strengthen taxes on corporations by carefully examining and eliminating costly tax breaks. They can also establish strong minimum taxes — a floor on the amount of tax owed each year. In addition, states that have not already done so can adopt a reform known as combined reporting, which nullifies three of the most common state corporate tax shelters.[10] Evidence does not support the claim that these kinds of changes will drive large numbers of affluent people and businesses to other states.[11]
Broaden the sales tax base. States can make their tax systems fairer by broadening the sales tax base to include more services that high-income families consume, such as investment counseling or country club memberships. While this would shift more of the responsibility for paying the sales tax to wealthier families, the effect would be relatively small; states should accompany such changes by other measures that go further to reduce inequality.
Enact state earned income tax credits. States can boost the incomes of low- and moderate-wage working families or offset the impact on these families of other tax changes by enacting or expanding a state earned income tax credit (EITC). Many states have created EITCs to build on the strengths of the federal EITC, which offsets low-wage workers’ payroll taxes, supplements the earnings of low- and moderate-income families, and helps families move from welfare to work. [12]
Over half of the states with an income tax and one state without an income tax — in all, 26 states plus the District of Columbia — have established EITCs.[13]
Avoid costly tax shifts and tax cuts aimed at the wealthy. Public discussions about strengthening the economy often center on tax cuts, despite growing evidence that they don’t create many jobs or promote broad prosperity.[14] Maintaining and improving schools, transportation networks, and other public services shown to generate growth will require resources, both now and in the future.
INSERT Aff Area (UBI, FJG, SS) Solvency Card
1NC FJG Half Guarantee Module
Text: The 50 states and all relevant territories in the United States should substantially increase their fiscal redistribution by implementing an half-time jobs guarantee in coordination with local and municipal partners.
Solves the aff and spurs federal follow-on without collapsing the economy or federalism
Newman, writer and professor who teaches criminal justice and sociology at CUNY. , 2021 (Nathan, Reset Labor Markets With a Local Half-Time Job Guarantee, 09-21-21 https://www.thenation.com/article/economy/half-time-job-gaurantee/ accessed 07-13-23)-TL
In the wake of the Covid recession, state and local governments have the chance to remake local labor markets—and public assistance—by adopting a policy guaranteeing half-time employment at $15 an hour for every resident.
Despite the hype of supposed proliferating job openings, long experience shows that even if we approach rates of nominal “full employment” again, such statistics will inevitably ignore higher unemployment rates for Black, Latino, formerly incarcerated, and many other workers. In a Covid-based recession where women in particular have struggled to return to previous levels of employment, a job guarantee may be critical to restore real employment alternatives for everyone who wants a job.
So why only a half-time job guarantee?
Because any state or local government will inevitably struggle with the costs of launching such a program, guaranteeing half-time jobs will be far more economically feasible. And because of the perversity of welfare benefit phaseouts, a half-time work guarantee will deliver much of the income of full-time employment, particularly for parents with kids. As importantly, a half-time program addresses some of the political and social challenges even progressive critics of job guarantees highlight, since it would give recipients time to care for their children, pursue education, or seek additional part-time work in fields where they eventually want to gain full-time, better-paying permanent employment.
Such local job guarantee programs would build on federal proposals in recent years by Bernie Sanders, Cory Booker, proponents of the Green New Deal, and policy centers like the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, the Center for American Progress, and the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College—all pushing federal programs to ensure that anyone wanting a job is guaranteed one by the government.
While no federal job guarantee program looks likely to be approved in the current congressional session, the federal dollars flowing to states and local governments from the American Rescue Plan Act and Biden’s projected “Build Back Better” program create an opportunity for some states and local governments to pilot local versions that could be models for a future federal policy.
Beyond supporting participants themselves, a key goal of a job guarantee is to expand overall worker power in the economy to demand higher wages. Reducing the desperation of the unemployed will strengthen individual and collective bargaining in all local industries; the resulting higher wages and consumption in turn will stimulate local economies and tax revenue.
But can workers and their families thrive on a half-time job guarantee?
Obviously, income from half-time work even at $15 per hour is not going to be a comfortable life, but because government supports have become more generous—particularly with policy changes made during the pandemic—a half-time job guarantee offers a reasonable safety net for working families.
1NC EITC UBI Module
Text: The 50 states and all relevant territories in the United States should substantially increase their fiscal redistribution by implementing an indefinite Earned Income Tax Credit for their respective taxpayers.
States EITC expansion solves UBI – A expansion of state Earned Income Tax credit (EITC) would be able to act as guaranteed income to low income communities
Downey, Legal Impact Network at the Shiver Center, Staff Attorney, et al., 22
(Nolan, Jeremy Rosen, Shiver Center staff, Marie Claire Tran-Leung, Shiver Center staff, Michelle Nicolet, Shiver Center staff, Emily Coffey, Shiver Center staff, Marcus Samuel, Shiver Center staff, Dina Kostrow, Shiver Center staff, Gabriela Camargo Martins, Economic Security Project staff, Michael Conti, Economic Security Project staff, Andrea Diaz, Economic Security Project staff, Pedro Morillas, Economic Security Project staff, Madeline Neighly, Economic Security Project staff, April 2022, Shiver Center on Poverty Law, and Economic Security Project, “States Lead the Way in Reimagining the Social Safety Net”, https://economicsecurityproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/States_Lead_the_Way.pdf, Accessed 7-2-23, ED)
State Considerations:
Implementation
Strategies
As states consider the creation of a large-scale, publicly funded guaranteed income program, they need to choose how to implement the program. Implementation strategies do not merely affect overall program cost and administration, but they are also highly relevant in determining how publicly funded guaranteed income payments interact with other means-tested public benefits.
States can choose to adopt one of the following implementation strategies:
• Use the tax system by implementing or expanding a state Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Earned Income Credit (EIC).
• Create an invested public sovereign wealth fund and declare periodic dividends for eligible households (similar to Alaska’s program).
• Construct robust new infrastructure to administer the program, or, at the very least, integrate the program into existing benefit distribution processes.
Expanding State Earned Income Tax Credit
The federal Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) is a refundable tax credit for working families created in 1975 by the Ford Administration. Its aim was to shield low-wage workers from the regressive effects of rising payroll taxes and to provide an additional income boost for workers near or below the poverty line.43 While the majority of an individual’s EITC comes from their federal tax return, thirty states, the District of Columbia, and a few municipalities44 have established their own EITCs to supplement the federal credit.45
Similar to the recently expanded federal Child Tax Credit, what distinguishes the federal EITC from many other credits in the tax code is its ”refundability,” meaning the full amount of the credit is given to low- income workers as cash, rather than merely reducing their tax liability. In 2018, the federal EITC lifted roughly 5.6 million people out of poverty, including about 3 million children. A state approach that modifies and bolsters a state EITC to achieve a functional guaranteed income for low-income people is an attractive proposition because it both comes with an existing mechanism to get payments to recipients, and those payments have a stronger basis for exemption from consideration as income in other benefits programs
like SNAP and TANF.
$1,600
Average annual amount paid to Alaska residents from the Permanent Fund Dividend Program since 1980
Source: Alaska Permanent Fund Corporation (APFC)
Unfortunately, the current federal EITC framework does not provide the full credit to households that do not meet the minimum threshold of earnings to qualify, excluding the lowest wage earning and non-wage earning households. Additionally, some groups like unpaid caregivers and domestic workers, as well as immigrants who file taxes with an Individual Tax ID number are not able to access these valuable credits. A state could create an efficient avenue to a functional guaranteed income for a large swath of a state’s population by enacting reforms to the state EITC that:
• Is fully refundable, ensuring that extremely low- and no-income families are eligible,
• Expands the state’s federal match rate to provide recipients with greater support,
• Raises income eligibility thresholds to extend eligibility to some middle-income earners, and
• Provide access to immigrants and other previously excluded groups.46
2NC Solvency O/V
Labor/Unemployment
States solve Labor/Unemployment by establish a jobs gurantee
Haim, MS Economic Theory and Policy., 2021
[Daniel, January 2021, Levy Economics Institute, “What Jobs Should a Public Job Guarantee Provide?Lessons from Hyman P. Minsky,” https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_981.pdf , Accesed 07/02/23, BS]
INTRODUCTION Instability and with it what Orwell called “the haunting terror of unemployment” is the damning weakness of capitalism. (Minsky 2008b, 329) Following the COVID-19 pandemic, governments around the world have started to implement far-reaching social policies to alleviate the effects of what is set to become the largest economic recession since World War II (World Bank 2020). A public job guarantee is among the ideas that have garnered renewed interest in the United States and abroad. India’s Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme has helped push rural joblessness down to 7.3 percent in June 2020, with 33 million households benefitting from the scheme in May 2020 (Times of India 2020). In the United States, Congresswomen Bonnie Watson Coleman (D-NJ) and Ilhan Omar (D-MN) have announced the introduction of the Workforce Promotion and Access Act (WPA Act 2020). Their proposal calls for the US Department of Labor to establish a job guarantee for states, localities, and tribal entities where the unemployment rate is greater than 10 percent or double the national unemployment rate. Public support for a job guarantee has been high, even before the current crisis, with approval ratings of up to 78 percent among US voters (The Hill 2019).
Many advocates for the job guarantee build on the work of Hyman P. Minsky. Minsky became famous for his contributions on the financial instability hypothesis, with many economists referring to the 2007–8 financial crisis a “Minsky moment.” However, Minsky also published numerous articles and papers on how to effectively end poverty in the United States. Inspired by Franklin D. Roosevelt’s New Deal reforms that focused on job creation in the 1930s, he proposed full employment policies that offer anyone willing to work a guaranteed minimumwage job. Minsky envisioned the government to be an employer of last resort,1 analogous to the central bank’s function as a lender of last resort. With recent unemployment numbers at unprecedented heights, the introduction of a public job guarantee could be another Minsky moment. The job guarantee was a macroeconomic necessity to Minsky. “Big government,” as he called it, provides floors and ceilings to the booms and bust of the business cycle. A full employment policy would reduce instability while supporting price stability. However, Minsky also viewed unemployment as a moral evil that democratic societies need to remedy. He was critical of welfare payments as a strategy to combat poverty, often repeating that “a dole is anathema: a bad thing”2 (Minsky 1994a). This working paper not only summarizes Minsky’s moral and economic arguments for a job guarantee but also suggests what type of jobs a public job guarantee should provide. Drawing on the rich sources in the Hyman P. Minsky Archive at the Levy Economics Institute of Bard College, I want to examine what jobs Minsky had in mind when formulating his full employment policies. In the second part of the paper I discuss the implications of these ideas for today’s economy. During the COVID-19 pandemic, a targeted public job guarantee program can assist in the social provisioning and distribution of food, shelter, and medical services. Parents that need to stay at home to help school their kids or have care duties can also be employed. After the pandemic, a public job guarantee can reduce poverty and inequality, and bring about a more democratic, sustainable, and socially cohesive economic system. The current unprecedented economic crisis calls for unprecedented policy answers. Minsky’s framework for a public job guarantee offers a useful toolkit to draw from.
Inflation
Federal action to fix inflation could trigger a recession
Karabell, TIME author, investor and commentator, Expada, reporter at TIME. Kohli, reporter at TIME, ‘22
[Zachary, Mariah and Anisha name, 11/7/2022,, TIME Magazine, “A PAINLESS INFLATION FIX,” https://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=a9h&AN=159888949&site=ehost-live&scope=site., Accessed 07/3/2023, BS]
The Fed's moves represent a broad consensus that high inflation imperils the stability of the system, erodes living standards, and must be brought down even at the risk of squashing growth and triggering a recession., The lack of doubt by the Fed, most economists, and many businesses about what the problem is and what to do about it is a troubling sign of economic group think. In short, the Fed is making an epic mistake. It should not have done what it has done, should not be doing what it's doing, and should not do what it plans to do. Past mistakes can't be undone, but future ones can be avoided. Group think is standing in the way. There is, of course, inflation right now, in the U.S. and in most countries throughout the world. There's also broad agreement about what caused this inflation: too much government spending as the pandemic began subsiding in the spring of 2021; too much pent-up demand from pandemic lockdowns exploding in the summer of 2021 onward, which created massive supply- chain bottlenecks and demand for labor; too much easy money from global central banks that kept assets such as stocks and homes elevated; too little action from the Fed until it was too late; and Russia's invasion of Ukraine leading to a doubling or more of the price of oil and gas.The belief that this period of inflation is so dangerous that it is worth the price of squashing the strongest job and wage market in a generation has taken hold in almost every central bank and every government in the developed worldBUT THAT LEAVES one rather crucial question: is it true? Must central banks take aggressive measures to cool the labor market, dampen financial markets, and likely cause a recession? Is it a fact that waiting longer would lead to elevated levels of inflation becoming intractable and entrenched? If you listened to what the Fed and many economists are saying, you'd hardly be aware that this has been 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.