Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 GDI Affirmative

UBI Affirmative and Negative - Wave 3 - GDI 2023

UBI Affirmative and Negative - Wave 3 - GDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Notes on this file
General – and vocab
This file provides supplements [on the aff and neg] for the UBI files produced by the Mega Lab.
And, the 1ac [and aff extensions] contained here provides another example of the BI part of the topic – one that focuses on UBI + rather than UBI – [minus]. But you can use major chunks for the existing workshop UBI aff [for example homeless adv].
But please be aware of the UBI + and UBI – difference:
UBI + = UBI that gives everyone a BI and an additional amount to different groups [this is where the proposals differ] BUT doesn’t claim to trade off with the existing social safety net [ie isn’t funded through the elimination of welfare programs]
UBI - = UBI that gives everyone a BI and claims that this will displace/replace existing social safety net
Neg notes versus UBI +
Versus the UBI + 1AC in this file, there are negative cards also in this file; however, we wanted to provide some ideas for other places you would look for additional neg arguments:
Cap Answers – because the degrowth portion of the Aff and racial capitalism portion call into question capitalism and argues the system is bad, you can read the cap good offense against the aff
Econ/Spending/Inflation – the aff defends UBI AND, unlike the other UBI minus versions of UBI aff, it says that the aff increases progressive taxes and doesn’t displace the existing welfare programs. The link args in Inflation DA and Econ DA [preinstitute] apply – and you can make args about the cost and economic impact of the plan [both UBI and taxation link]
Environment part of the aff – CPs and the case args from the FJG preinstitute/GND CPs that engage climate provide offense and defense against the aff.
CPs – States CP, solve environment adv with an adv cp
Neg in this file – stuff for UBI +/-; degrowth bad/growth sustainable in the file.
UBI + 1AC
The Advantage:
Income and wealth inequality on the rise in the US, multifaceted causes including long standing racial discrimination exacerbated by COVID
Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022
[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]
Income and wealth inequality in the United States is substantially higher than in almost any other developed nation, and it is on the rise, sparking an intensifying national debate. The 2008 global financial crisis, the slow and uneven recovery, and the economic shock caused by the COVID-19 pandemic have deepened these trends and challenged policymakers to respond.
Economists say the causes of worsening inequality are complex and include a failure to adapt to globalization and technological change, shifting tax policy, reduced bargaining power among workers, and long-standing racial and gender discrimination. The effects of inequality are similarly varied, and they have exacerbated crises such as the pandemic and deepened societal divisions. Inequality can also weaken democracy and give rise to authoritarian movements. President Joe Biden has pledged to reduce economic inequality with new social spending financed by higher taxes on the wealthy and corporations, but he faces opposition from those who say his plans go too far.
And, Income and wealth inequality correlates to race and systemic racism, allowing exploitation
Siripurapu, Council on Foreign Relations, 2022
[Anshu, “The U.S. Inequality Debate”, Council on Foreign Relations, 4/20/22, https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/us-inequality-debate, 7/11/23 GDI- SC]
* Figure omitted
The relationship between race, ethnicity, and inequality has been well-documented. Since 1960, the median wealth of white households has tripled while the wealth of Black households has barely increased. For decades, the unemployment rate among Black Americans has been roughly twice that of white Americans. Black Americans are also underrepresented in high-paying professions, including corporate leadership. As of 2020, only four of the CEOs of Fortune 500 companies are Black. Black and American Indian children have far lower economic mobility compared to white, Asian, and children of Hispanic ethnicity, according to Chetty’s research. U.S. inequality today is rooted in systemic racism and the legacy of slavery. Through a policy known as redlining that resulted from a New Deal program in the 1930s, Black Americans were systematically denied mortgages, leading to housing segregation and a disparity in home ownership, which is a major source of wealth. Though racial discrimination in housing was banned by the Fair Housing Act of 1968, the effects persist. Black Americans were similarly excluded from the benefits of the G.I. Bill after World War II, which is widely credited with helping to grow the middle class. Black Americans also face discrimination in the labor market, because hiring is often done internally via networks that exclude them, says William E. Spriggs, an economics professor at Howard University and the chief economist at the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO). The COVID-19 pandemic laid bare many of these disparities. American Indian, Black, and Latinx Americans were more likely to be hospitalized with and die from COVID-19 than white Americans—an inequity that CFR’s Catherine Powell calls the “color of COVID.” People of color were more likely to be laid off; and they were more likely to be considered essential workers, performing jobs that typically came with greater exposure to the virus, such as cashiering and package delivery. The existence of a gender pay gap is also well-founded, though there is a debate over its causes. The pay gap has narrowed over the past forty years as women have obtained more education, but it has not shrunk as much since 2000, according to the Economic Policy Institute’s Elise Gould. Gould attributes this in part to discrimination and the underrepresentation of women in high-paying jobs.
We isolate two impacts to racialized income inequality:
First, racialized capitalism
Racism is an inherent part of income inequality – UBI helps mitigate the effects of distorted wealth accumulation and concurrent prejudice
Iannuzzi & Oishi, Assistant and Professor of Phycology, 21
(Jazmin Brown Iannuzzi, assistant professor at the University of Virginia, Shigehiro Oishi, professor of psychology at the University of Virginia, Racial Inequality at the Brink: How Economic Inequality Exacerbates Racial Prejudice and the Potential Alleviating Role of a Universal Basic Income”, https://www.russellsage.org/sites/default/files/racialprej_LOI_example.pdf-grh)
In the U.S., both economic inequality and racial economic inequality – or the unequal distribution of financial resources across racial groups – is large and growing. From 1983 to 2016, the median White family went from approximately 8 times to 13 times more wealth than the median Black family (Pew, 2016). More recently, the pandemic has left Black families more vulnerable to death by COVID-19 and its economic shocks (Hardy & Logan, 2020; Wrigley-Field, 2020). Making matters worse, data suggest that income inequality precedes rises in White-on-Black racial prejudice (Connor et al., 2019; see also Hovland & Sears, 1940). Unfortunately, little empirical data investigates how inequality impacts individuals’ psychological processing and, in turn, increases prejudice. And, almost no work investigates the impact of inequality on racial minorities (Bianchi, 2020). Critically, inequality could also exacerbate prejudice between low-social power groups, stifling coalition building across these groups. The global pandemic’s widening of economic inequality makes now a crucial moment for understanding how inequality may exacerbate prejudice and for developing effective strategies to mitigate this process’s dire outcomes. The current application (1) puts forth a new hypothesis: inequality group-competition hypothesis, and (2) examines whether a policy, such as universal basic income, could mitigate the impact of inequality on prejudice (see Figure 1). We hypothesize that higher inequality triggers beliefs that people are in competition for limited resources because people tend to think the economy is zero-sum, meaning that one person’s higher earnings implies others’ lower earnings (Friedman & Friedman, 1990; related work see Buttrick & Oishi, 2017; Sommet et al., 2017). Perceiving others as competitors for scarce resources increases individuals’ concerns about their individual position and their groups’ position within society (Elliot, 2006; Esses et al., 2001). Status concerns activate both the desire to gain more resources for the self and group, as well as fear of losing relative position in the socioeconomic hierarchy (e.g., Davidai & Ongis, 2019; Sommet et al., 2017). Further, because inequality fosters the mindset of living in an intensely competitive environment, residents may be particularly attuned to group membership cues, such as race, as a way to determine whether someone has the potential to be economically beneficial (because they are ingroup member) or harmful (because they are an outgroup member). Providing for basic needs via a universal basic income may mitigate the impact of higher inequality on increasing prejudice by assuaging people’s zero-sum biases and their fears that others are competing for limited resources. However, to whom basic income is provided must be carefully considered to mitigate resentment toward a specific income and racial group.
UBI addresses the precarity of marginalized groups and changes our view of social relations – only the 1ac challenges the violent system of racial capitalism
Taiwo Associate Professor of Philosophy at Georgetown University 2021
[Olufemi, “Universal Basic Income, Racial Justice, Climate Justice” LPE Project 02/15/21 https://lpeproject.org/blog/universal-basic-income-racial-justice-climate-justice/ 7/11/23 CB]
Basic income can inoculate us as well from the worst aspects of economic crisis – the kind that the COVID-19 crisis proved are powerfully linked to the natural world. Our system’s current failures to distribute vaccines, then, are a bad omen of what’s to come.But whether or not basic income plays this role comes down to the second of our two distinctions. Some (especially on the political right) treat basic income as a replacement for other aspects of our social system that currently work to secure people, like unemployment assistance and food stamps. This approach tries to (or pretends to) treat all forms of protection as interchangeable through the medium of currency would likely on net work out to only further precarize marginalized people. But Black, Indigenous, disabled, and trans people, particularly those who are women or gender nonconforming, are not a check away from solving all of the problems of insecure housing, safety in their homes and personal lives, and environmental risk that our institutions must address specifically and by means more broad than what can be accomplished via cash transfer. This basic income-as-substitution approach, UBI-, doesn’t live up to the promise of collaborative security. But basic income could be tethered to a larger body of transformative political moves, rather than a replacement for them. Dorian Warren of the Economic Security Project, who also helped develop the Movement for Black Lives’ section on basic income, wrote about one possibility in this vein. He is in good company in African-American political history, noting that “both Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and the Black Panther Party to argue for full employment and a ‘guaranteed income’ for African Americans specifically and all Americans more than fifty years ago.” His version is “identical to most UBI proposals”, save for the inclusion of “a pro-rated, additional amount for black Americans over a specified period of time.” This would safeguard universal economic security through a strategy of “targeted universalism” that both responds to the history of racial slavery and injustice in and by the United States and anticipates the effect of future, persisting racial injustice on African-Americans’ life chances. The time for this kind of broad based, collaborative security is now. As the climate crisis accelerates, we risk our social system warping around its old and longstanding inequalities. By century’s end we may face persistent forms of climate apartheid and climate colonialism, in which inequalities within and across countries are increasingly tied to the extent to which families, communities, and whole nations can pay to deal with the consequences of a warming planet. Our current trajectory risks genocidal realities – perhaps most dramatically if our governments continue to respond to movement across borders with border militarization and warehousing, and to social upheaval within them by means of increasingly violent and exploitative policing and caging. The pandemic should serve as a grave wake up call. The virus, after all, was just one part of the deeper political problem: how our society distributes risk, vulnerability, and security. Since our global society is built on racial capitalism, distributes these in a deeply stratified way, where different tiers of society experience markedly different levels of risk of exposure to environmental, financial, and interpersonal harm and violence. Responding to such a system must involve more than challenging this or that political leader or installing a few solar panels. It calls for us to find a way of protecting ourselves beyond the cannibalistic, violent model Provided by the history of racial capitalism that built so much of today’s world – to find a way to protect ourselves by protecting each other. Basic income is one way forward.
Second, the environment
Climate crises is surpassing planetary boundaries – we need an alternative model of economics
Pinto, Universidade do Minho, ‘20
[Jorge, “Environmentalism, Ecologism, and Basic Income”, Basic Income Studies Vol 15.1 https://doi.org/10.1515/bis-2019-0026accessed 7-11-2023 GDI-FLC]
The enduring social and global climate crises are challenging society to look for alternatives to existing economic models. Nevertheless, in order to move away from the existing situation of unsustainability (Barry, 2012) we face, old solutions will hardly be enough, as the Anthropocene is characterised by countries already living above their limits.1 This is strongly suggested by indicators such as the ecological footprint and the planetary boundaries. With the ecological footprint we conclude that according to the goods and services we use, human- ity currently needs the regenerative capacity of 1.6 Earths (WWF, 2016). The concept of planetary boundaries is particularly interesting. It consists of the definition of boundaries for nine Earth system processes that should not be passed in order for the planet to remain within “safe operating space”, with four of those systems having already passed beyond the limit (Rockström et al., 2009; Steffen et al., 2015).
Growth is incompatible with the survival of the biosphere. It is the root cause driving mass species extinction.
Moranta et al, Senior researcher at the Ecosystem Oceanography Group, 2021
[Joan, “Transcending capitalism growth strategies for biodiversity conservation” Conservation Biology, 18 August 2021, https://conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/cobi.13821#cobi13821-bib-0060 Accessed 7/15/2023 GDI-HB]
We suggest conservationists liaise with political ecologists and ecological economists to underline the problems and contradictions in the relationship between growth and biodiversity. We argue here that capitalism's metabolism is not compatible with an economy that respects the limits of the biosphere. The negative impact of economic growth on biodiversity is evident in the literature, and environmental and biodiversity conservation programs grounded in economic growth are ineffective. To ensure growth, continuous extraction of value from and commodification of nature is required to safeguard the capital, which in itself constitutes one of the most critical contradictions of capitalism. A capitalist economy not only exhausts the material basis for its reproduction, but also deteriorates the biophysical conditions that enable life on Earth (Foster et al., 2010; Harvey, 2014; Moore, 2015). Capitalism's commodification of nature and its derived conservation policies, such as payments for ecosystem services and biodiversity offsets, will result in perpetuating the growth-based status quo.
By synthesizing the main findings of the existing research on the contradictions between growth and biodiversity conservation, we add to the conservation science literature an important argument to take into account during the negotiations of the post-2020 GBF. One of the main challenges to be faced by society in the 21st century is not biodiversity conservation itself but the need to restructure the current socioeconomic metabolism in such a way it is not driven by the logic of profit and growth through the destruction of nature and human lives. If this is not done, it will be difficult to stop biodiversity loss and ecosystem destruction and the resulting environmental and social damages. It is necessary to urgently reconvert the socioeconomic system into one that pursues an ecologically and socially healthier society.
The socioecological crisis demands urgent transformative action (Díaz et al., 2019; IPBES–IPCC, 2021) to move humanity away from the paradigm of economic growth, as stated in emerging research on nongrowth-oriented social transformation in the conservation literature. Büscher et al. (2017a) postulate that “we need to recognize that it is ultimately economic growth itself that is the root cause of biodiversity loss and hence to take the possibilities of degrowth economics seriously.” Büscher and Fletcher (2020) develop revolutionary ideas for conservation that help one think and completely reframe the question of biodiversity conservation. They state that “if conservation is tied to capitalism and capitalism necessitates growth, then degrowth, in its more radical incarnation, means moving beyond capitalism and hence should have profound consequences for conservation.” Fletcher, Massarella, et al. (2020) propose a global green new deal for conservation grounded in the need for an overarching structural shift to a postgrowth society that “given capitalism's systemic imperative to incessant growth requires the liberating prospect of transcending capitalism, as well as the statism and patriarchy with which it is associated.” Sandbrook et al. (2020) argue for a post-COVID, transformative, economic reconstruction that questions growth; involves adopting a long-term vision; and accepts short-term costs, such as losing some conservation funds, projects, and even organizations dependent on unsustainable aspects of the pre-COVID-19 economic model. Otero et al. (2020) propose a nongrowth scenario to support this transition and “recommend that in the negotiations of the next CBD Conference of the Parties and in future assessments of the IPBES, endorsement of economic growth is replaced by at least a precautionary recognition that it can be problematic for biodiversity.” In turn, IPBES states that the focus of their work is not on a single scenario but on a diversity of human–nature relationships and positive visions of the future post-2020 framework that ultimately enables transformative change (Lundquist et al., 2021).
Climate change is a threat multiplier that ensures collapse---prefer peer-reviewed climate models
Kemp et al. 22 (Luke, Research Associate at the Centre for the Study of Existential Risk (CSER) at the University of Cambridge, PhD in International Relations from the Australian National University. Joanna Depledge, Research fellow at the Centre for Environment, Energy and Natural Resource Governance, Editor of the int

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.