Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 GDI Disadvantage

Politics DA - Farm Bill and Elections - GDI 2023

Politics DA - Farm Bill and Elections - GDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Politics Disadvantages
***NEGATIVE Scenarios
NEG – Farm Bill Scenario
1NC – Farm Bill 1NC Shell
Farm Bill 1NC Shell
A. Uniqueness and internal link – Window for farm bill negotiations narrow – running out of time – fights risk collapse of the Farm Bill – triggering price hikes and increasing poverty
Hill, POLITICO food and agriculture policy reporter, 6-15-23
[Meredith Lee, 6-15-23, Politico, “Far-Right Republicans Threaten To Derail Another House Party”, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/06/14/mccarthy-house-gop-farm-bill-00101968, accessed 7-3-23, EH]
The farm bill came up only in passing during McCarthy’s meeting with the leaders of the so-called “five families” GOP caucus factions earlier this week, as one of the many legislative items Republicans need to get done this fall, according to two House Republicans who were granted anonymity to discuss private conversations.
House Agriculture Committee staff have started compiling a 2023 draft of the farm bill as the panel races to complete a series of farm bill hearings. Negotiations on the text are expected to heat up later this month, with aides and lawmakers pushing for a committee markup by early September. The House-passed legislation will have to be reconciled with the version approved by the Senate. According to Senate Agriculture Chair and No. 3 Democrat Debbie Stabenow of Michigan, Congress is “done” discussing SNAP work requirements in the wake of the debt limit talks.
Many lawmakers are beginning to worry that given the current trajectory, the reauthorization process could drag into 2024, which would put additional pressure on a U.S. agriculture sector already reeling from high inflation and, in turn, become a political headache for lawmakers in agriculture-heavy districts and states ahead of the 2024 election. Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell recently took to the floor to warn that “time is running out” to pass a farm bill this year.
McCarthy has experienced a similar farm bill scenario in the past. He was the No. 2 Republican in the House in 2018 when Freedom Caucus members helped to sink a partisan House GOP farm bill on the floor. It took another seven months for Congress to get the final bill to then-President Donald Trump’s desk, giving Democrats ammunition to go after rural-district Republicans in the meantime. The Republican-majority Senate eventually stripped the House GOP’s steep SNAP restrictions from the final legislation, despite months of toil by McCarthy and then-Speaker Paul Ryan.
This time around, congressional leaders are facing even more of a time crunch and far-right Republicans are taking an even harder line, arguing McCarthy and fellow GOP leaders “watered down” new SNAP work requirements in their deal to raise the debt limit. Although he hails from an agriculture-heavy district in California’s Central Valley, McCarthy is still not heavily involved, personally, in the farm bill policy talks.
In private, however, the speaker has told fellow Republicans that in order to appease hardliners, the party will need to at least push for stricter work requirements and other restrictions on federal food assistance for low-income Americans beyond the debt deal provisions, according to three other GOP lawmakers who were granted anonymity to discuss internal matters.
“I think what the Speaker is saying is that let’s not just let that be the end of the conversation. Let’s have a good conversation, a bipartisan conversation about how we can have the most integrity and serve the most people with the dollars that we have,” said Rep. Brad Finstad (R-Minn.), chair of the House Agriculture subcommittee that oversees the country’s leading anti-hunger program.
Many moderate House Republicans, however, are done having that conversation for now — especially those who delivered their party the House majority in 2020 by flipping districts Biden won over Trump. Democrats are already attacking many of those vulnerable Republicans for their support of the debt deal and the new SNAP restrictions in it.
“We’ve negotiated a new level of requirements on SNAP and I think it’s time to move forward from there,” said Rep. John Duarte (R-Calif.), who represents an agriculture-heavy California region that Biden carried by double digits in 2020.
Nebraska Rep. Don Bacon, another Republican in a Biden district, warned that pushing for SNAP restrictions beyond what Biden and McCarthy agreed to in the debt limit law would threaten the viability of the entire farm bill.
“You can’t just have an agreement and then say we’re gonna change it,” Bacon said. “In the end, if we get a bipartisan bill, you’ll get enough Democrats on board where [opposition from some far-right House Republicans] won’t be an issue.”
“I think that’s the goal,” Bacon added. We don’t want this to be a partisan bill.”
Some of the more centrist House Democrats who McCarthy will need to vote for the farm bill have also publicly warned him against attempting to include further restrictions on SNAP in the farm bill.
“SNAP is certainly one of the best tools we have for reducing poverty,” said Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez (D-Wash.) during a recent hearing, who noted rural communities like hers are more likely to be enrolled in the program than their urban counterparts.
Like Bacon, Rep. Sanford Bishop, a moderate Democrat who represents a rural stretch of Georgia, warned that additional GOP efforts to pare back nutrition spending in the farm bill threatens the future of the entire legislation — which includes key farm safety net programs moderate Democrats and Republicans need in their districts.
“It’s inextricably tied together,” said Bishop.
B. Link – Plan triggers massive fight [Insert link evidence here]
C. Farm Bill Good
1. Farm Bill key to food security
Munch, American Farm Bureau economist, 6-21-23
[Daniel, 6-21-23, Ohio’s Country Journal, “Farm Bill Math”, https://ocj.com/2023/06/farm-bill-math/, 7-3-23, accessed EH]
Like consumers purchasing food at the grocery store, farmers and ranchers face macroeconomic pressures when they purchase inputs and services. Few pieces of legislation are more significant than the farm bill when it comes to safeguarding our domestic food supply. Ensuring that program funding is reflective of market changes is critical to maintaining the farm bill’s role in national security and the health and well-being of rural communities.
2. Food insecurity escalates every hotspot to go nuclear causing extinction
Castellaw, Founder and CEO of Farmspace Systems LLC founder & CEO, 17
[John, Lieutenant General, former President of the non-profit Crockett Policy Institute, Agri-Pulse, “Opinion: Food Security Strategy Is Essential to Our National Security,” https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/9203-opinion-food-security-strategy-is-essential-to-our-national-security, accessed 7-16-23]
The United States faces many threats to our National Security. These threats include continuing wars with extremist elements such as ISIS and potential wars with rogue state North Korea or regional nuclear power Iran. The heated economic and diplomatic competition with Russia and a surging China could spiral out of control. Concurrently, we face threats to our future security posed by growing civil strife, famine, and refugee and migration challenges which create incubators for extremist and anti-American government factions. Our response cannot be one dimensional but instead must be a nuanced and comprehensive National Security Strategy combining all elements of National Power including a Food Security Strategy.
An American Food Security Strategy is an imperative factor in reducing the multiple threats impacting our National wellbeing. Recent history has shown that reliable food supplies and stable prices produce more stable and secure countries. Conversely, food insecurity, particularly in poorer countries, can lead to instability, unrest, and violence.
Food insecurity drives mass migration around the world from the Middle East, to Africa, to Southeast Asia, destabilizing neighboring populations, generating conflicts, and threatening our own security by disrupting our economic, military, and diplomatic relationships. Food system shocks from extreme food-price volatility can be correlated with protests and riots. Food price related protests toppled governments in Haiti and Madagascar in 2007 and 2008. In 2010 and in 2011, food prices and grievances related to food policy were one of the major drivers of the Arab Spring uprisings. Repeatedly, history has taught us that a strong agricultural sector is an unquestionable requirement for inclusive and sustainable growth, broad-based development progress, and long-term stability.
The impact can be remarkable and far reaching. Rising income, in addition to reducing the opportunities for an upsurge in extremism, leads to changes in diet, producing demand for more diverse and nutritious foods provided, in many cases, from American farmers and ranchers. Emerging markets currently purchase 20 percent of U.S. agriculture exports and that figure is expected to grow as populations boom.
Moving early to ensure stability in strategically significant regions requires long term planning and a disciplined, thoughtful strategy. To combat current threats and work to prevent future ones, our national leadership must employ the entire spectrum of our power including diplomatic, economic, and cultural elements. The best means to prevent future chaos and the resulting instability is positive engagement addressing the causes of instability before it occurs.
This is not rocket science. We know where the instability is most likely to occur. The world population will grow by 2.5 billion people by 2050. Unfortunately, this massive population boom is projected to occur primarily in the most fragile and food insecure countries. This alarming math is not just about total numbers. Projections show that the greatest increase is in the age groups most vulnerable to extremism. There are currently 200 million people in Africa between the ages of 15 and 24, with that number expected to double in the next 30 years. Already, 60% of the unemployed in Africa are young people.
Too often these situations deteriorate into shooting wars requiring the deployment of our military forces. We should be continually mindful that the price we pay for committing military forces is measured in our most precious national resource, the blood of those who serve. For those who live in rural America, this has a disproportionate impact. Fully 40% of those who serve in our military come from the farms, ranches, and non-urban communities that make up only 16% of our population.
Actions taken now to increase agricultural sector jobs can provide economic opportunity and stability for those unemployed youths while helping to feed people. A recent report by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs identifies agriculture development as the core essential for providing greater food security, economic growth, and population well-being.
Our active support for food security, including agriculture development, has helped stabilize key regions over the past 60 years. A robust food security strategy, as a part of our overall security strategy, can mitigate the growth of terrorism, build important relationships, and support continued American economic and agricultural prosperity while materially contributing to our Nation’s and the world’s security.
Uniqueness
Farm Bill Will Pass Now
Farm Bill likely to pass – coalition-building now
Knight, The Community Word, 7-8-23
[Bill Knight, 7-8-23, Community Word "Bill Knight: Can bipartisanship outdo ‘Cavity Caucus’ and Big Ag for next Farm Bill?,", http://thecommunityword.com/online/blog/2023/07/08/bill-knight-can-bipartisanship-outdo-cavity-caucus-and-big-ag-for-next-farm-bill/, accessed 7-11-23, S.A.M]
It’s not hoping against hope to see possibilities for reasonable people in Congress to put country above party and again work together to compromise and construct a new, five-year Farm Bill, which is being drafted this summer.
Optimism is justified despite the obvious divisiveness on Capitol Hill.
On the House Agriculture Committe, Chair Glenn Thompson (R-Pa.) has defended nutrition programs in general and SNAP in particular (although he’s opposed expansion of SNAP benefits). Instead, Thompson is focusing on crop insurance.
“The Farm bill is always bipartisan,” Thompson’s said, “At the end of the day, final votes are fairly bipartisan, and my goal is to keep it that way from the very beginning.”
In the Senate, Ag chair Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.) is working on conservation.
Also, Biden’s Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack has built an informal coalition involving interests as varied as corporate giant Archer-Daniels-Midland and the grassroots-oriented Farmers Union to discuss renewable energy, sustainable production and other ideas tied to climate change, which farmers know is here, now.
Enacted about every five years, Farm Bills affect how the nation farms and eats, how we use the outdoors and our money, and how we all protect the land and rural America — where 46 million people live (14% of U.S. population).
Forecast to cost $700 billion over five years, the next Farm Bill will determine how food is grown, who has access to it and at what cost. It can seem too complex, which is how political mischief can occur.
The last recent bill, costing about $430 billion, passed in 2018 after negotiations were prolonged when conservatives attacked food stamps, and it expires Sept. 30.
Current construction
The current Farm Bill has four main types of entitlements (programs that guarantee certain benefits to a specific group): income and price-support subsidies for commodity farmers (despite most of the corn and beans covering the Midwest feed more livestock than people, or are processed for fuel or plastics), crop insurance, conservation, and nutrition (in fact, three-fourths of overall funding went to nutrition programs such as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP, formerly called food stamps), which help low-income families access healthy food.
“I’m feeling less discouraged than I could be,” said Rep. Chellie Pingree (D-Maine), who’s also on the Agriculture Committee.
Farm bill will pass now, but not guaranteed
Coppess, University Of Illinois Department Of Agricultural And Consumer Economics professor, 6-15-23
[Jonathan, 6-15-23, Farm Doc Daily Illinois, “Farm Bill 2023: Trying To Reason With Expectations For Farm Policy”, https://farmdocdaily.illinois.edu/2023/06/farm-bill-2023-trying-to-reason-with-expectations-for-farm-policy.html, accessed 7-3-23, EH]
The debt limit barrier to a farm bill has been removed, which may increase the odds that Congress can reauthorize a farm bill this year but certainly doesn’t guarantee it. A collision between expectations for farm program payments and the rules governing a farm bill budget could be among the most significant barriers remaining. This article reviews some of what may be driving expectations for farm program payments and the challenges that result.
The farm bill will pass but the window is closing
Hart Brownfield anchor/reporter 7/10/23
[Carah, 7/10/2023, Brownfield news “TIME AND MONEY BOTH SHORT IN THE FARM BILL,” https://brownfieldagnews.com/news/time-and-money-both-short-in-the-farm-bill/, accessed 7/12/2023, eo]
The president of the American Farm Bureau Federation says he is optimistic the new farm bill will be completed by the end of the year.
Zippy Duvall tells Brownfield the four agriculture committee leaders have confidence a bill can pass the finish line, but says time is an enemy as the window narrows to get a bill passed by September 30.
“The legislative calendar is getting full and short.”
He says getting money for the farm bill is also a challenge, but nothing new. Duvall says if Congress wants to add new provisions to the bill, including a boost in reference prices, they’ll find a way to get it done.
“We’re going to push hard to make sure it happens and we’ll be there everyday to make sure it happens.”
Duvall was in South Dakota in early July meeting with South Dakota Farm Bureau members.
Farm Bill likely to pass now – high priority
Dorenkamp, Brownfield Ag News, 7-5-23
(Mark, 7-5-23, 1430wcmy, " House Majority Whip: “massive failure” if new farm bill isn’t done on time, https://1430wcmy.com/2023/07/05/house-majority-whip-massive-failure-if-new-farm-bill-isnt-done-on-time/, Accessed 7/11/23, S.A.M)
Pressure is mounting on lawmakers to pass a new farm bill before the current bill expires.
House Majority Whip Tom Emmer was recently asked by Brownfield Ag News if he thinks that will happen.
“Well for me, it would be a massive failure if it wasn’t.”
The Minnesota Republican suggests the farm bill is a national security issue.
“A country that can’t feed itself does not survive, so people have to understand this is a top priority.”
Emmer says House Ag Committee chair Glenn “GT” Thompson will put together the best possible bill that hopefully passes long before the September 30th deadline.
Farm bill will pass – McCarthy promising bipartisan Farm Bil now
Brasher and Wicks, Agri-Pulse editors, 6/21/2023
[Phillip, Noah, Agri-Pulse, “GOP hardliners' anger could delay, imperil new farm bill”, https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/19583-gop-hardliners-anger-could-delay-imperil-new-farm-bill, Accessed 7/12/2023, S.P.]
One longtime GOP lobbyist and Capitol Hill veteran says conservative demands could make it difficult, if not impossible, for McCarthy to put a bipartisan farm bill on the House floor. If he does do that, he risks being ousted as speaker, said the lobbyist, who asked not to be identified.
“In the old days, you persuaded people with a bridge or leadership post or appointment to a committee or something like that. I don't think that works very well for these guys,” the lobbyist said of the conservatives angry over the debt agreement.
“They thought they had a deal … and they are really hot. And I don't see that settling down anytime soon.”
But another veteran lobbyist with Republican ties, Randy Russell, doesn’t think McCarthy will have any choice but to put a bipartisan measure on the House floor.
In 2018, the House GOP majority successfully passed a partisan farm bill that included SNAP cuts that angered Democrats. But this time, the Republican majority is so slim that a GOP-only bill is unlikely to get enough votes to pass the House, Russell told Agri-Pulse. Republicans currently control the House 222-212, with one vacancy in a Democratic-leaning district.
“I think there are those in the Republican caucus, and there's probably some in the Democratic caucus, that aren't going to vote for the farm bill regardless of what it says, for various reasons,” Russell said.
Farm Bill passage likely now
RFD TV, 6/22/23
[6/22/23, RFD TV, “There is optimism for an on-time Farm Bill now that these hurdles are done, according to Rep Lucas,” https://www.rfdtv.com/there-is-optimism-for-an-on-time-farm-bill-now-that-these-hurdles-are-done-according-to-rep-lucas, accessed 7/12/2023, EJ]
There is some growing optimism that this year’s Farm Bill will be passed on time.
Former House Ag Chair, Frank Lucas says that Congress has overcome one of the most important hurdles to get it done this year.
“One of the most important things we had to do was pass a piece of legislation dealing not only with the debt ceiling but setting spending levels for the next few years. The allocation process in the House and Senate is going on,” Rep Lucas states. “As we wait for those final numbers in the House, Chairman Thompson is now moving us in the direction of not just hearing here in DC, but also field hearings around the country laying the groundwork.”
Farm Bill will pass now
Salant, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-3-23
[Johnathan D., 6-3-23, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, “A Pa. congressman is in the middle of the action as Congress debates the farm bill,” https://www.post-gazette.

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.