Green Nuclear Deal CP - GDI 2023
Green Nuclear Deal CP - GDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Green Nuclear Deal CP 1NC Generic Shell Text: The United States Federal Government should adopt a Green Nuclear Deal. The counterplan solves climate change, transitions us to an effective green economy, and prevents nuclear infrastructure collapse. Fanto, doctoral student in the Department of Physics at Yale University, 2019 (Paul, A GREEN NUCLEAR DEAL:Why the U.S. Should Expand Nuclear Power, Distilled Periodical , 2019 Issue, accessed 07-07-23, https://yaledistilled.sites.yale.edu/browse-issues/2019-issue/green-nuclear-dealwhy-us-should-expand-nuclear-power)-AS Contrary to these perceptions, nuclear power is necessary for eliminating U.S. carbon emissions as quickly as possible. Nuclear power can provide large amounts of carbon-free electricity more rapidly than renewable technologies, and it can do so with commercially viable technology, without geographic constraints, and without a huge change to the current U.S. electrical grid. It is true that the risks due to the radioactive content of nuclear waste are unique, but these risks are outweighed by nuclear power’s potential contributions to eliminate fossil fuel emissions. Despite negative public perception, nuclear power has an excellent record of operational safety. For these reasons, the U.S. government should commit itself to an expansion of nuclear power. The U.S. should build third-generation reactor designs already commercially viable in the U.S. and worldwide and provide incentives for licensing, financing, and construction of nuclear plants. Finally, to ensure the long-term viability of nuclear power generation, it is important for the U.S. government to encourage the development of novel nuclear technologies that produce less waste than current technologies. To meet this goal, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) should provide a test site where prototypes of advanced reactor designs may be tested and licensed. 1NC BioD Shell Text: The United States Federal Government should adopt a Green Nuclear Deal. The United States federal government should ban future federal investment in solar and wind-based renewables. The counterplan solves climate change, transitions us to an effective green economy, and prevents nuclear infrastructure collapse. Fanto, doctoral student in the Department of Physics at Yale University, 2019 (Paul, A GREEN NUCLEAR DEAL:Why the U.S. Should Expand Nuclear Power, Distilled Periodical , 2019 Issue, accessed 07-07-23, https://yaledistilled.sites.yale.edu/browse-issues/2019-issue/green-nuclear-dealwhy-us-should-expand-nuclear-power)-AS Contrary to these perceptions, nuclear power is necessary for eliminating U.S. carbon emissions as quickly as possible. Nuclear power can provide large amounts of carbon-free electricity more rapidly than renewable technologies, and it can do so with commercially viable technology, without geographic constraints, and without a huge change to the current U.S. electrical grid. It is true that the risks due to the radioactive content of nuclear waste are unique, but these risks are outweighed by nuclear power’s potential contributions to eliminate fossil fuel emissions. Despite negative public perception, nuclear power has an excellent record of operational safety. For these reasons, the U.S. government should commit itself to an expansion of nuclear power. The U.S. should build third-generation reactor designs already commercially viable in the U.S. and worldwide and provide incentives for licensing, financing, and construction of nuclear plants. Finally, to ensure the long-term viability of nuclear power generation, it is important for the U.S. government to encourage the development of novel nuclear technologies that produce less waste than current technologies. To meet this goal, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) should provide a test site where prototypes of advanced reactor designs may be tested and licensed. Wind turbines decimate bird and bat biodiversity Biello TED science curator, 2008 [david, August 26, 2008, Scientific American, “On a Wing and Low Air: The Surprising Way Wind Turbines Kill Bats”, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/wind-turbines-kill-bats/ 7/2/23, KCD] Scientists have known since 2004 that wind farms kill bats, just as they kill birds, even though the flying mammals should be able to avoid them. Many biologists thought that the bats, like their avian counterparts, might be falling victim to the fast-spinning turbine blades. But an examination of 188 hoary and silver-haired bats killed at a wind farm in southwestern Alberta in Canada between July and September in 2007 showed that nearly half showed no external injuries—as would be expected if the giant blades had smashed the flying mammals to the ground. Instead, 90 percent of the 75 bats the researchers ultimately dissected had been killed by burst blood vessels in their lungs, according to results presented in Current Biology—suggesting that the air pressure difference created by the spinning windmills had terminated them, not contact with the blades. Bats are the key internal link to ecosystem collapse which escalates humanity’s path to extinction Cumberland Group 2011 [Cumberland Group, 2011, National Park Service, “What Is Killing Our Bats? Facts About White-Nose Syndrome, https://www.nps.gov/cuga/planyourvisit/upload/correct-wns-brochure.pdf, 7-3-23, AS] Bats are an essential, beneficial part of our ecosystem. The loss of our bat populations will have substantial ecological consequences that will even affect us. Bats provide a vital nutritional link between a cave ecosystem and the environment outside; often the base of the food chain. Bat guano supplies the only food source for cave-dwelling micro-organisms and invertebrates, which become a food source for fish, salamanders and other large animals. Although many people misunderstand them, bats are something we can’t do without. They are the only major predator of night flying insects. One bat can eat between 600 to 1,000 mosquitoes and other flying pests in just one hour! If bats disappear the insect population will boom, causing crop failure, economic damage and human illness. 2NC OV The counterplan institutes a green nuclear deal which leads to a strong federal roll out of investment in updating and integrating nuclear energy in the US. This solves climate change and other aff internal links while avoiding the external net benefit to the CP. Bio Net Benefit OV Wind and solar power allow for the destruction of the environment and collapse biodiversity which creates a new root causes of climate change and collapse. Turns the aff and shows that the aff accelerates climate destruction through the strip mining of deep ground resources for solar panels and the massive roll out of wind power decimates the bat population which is key to all agriculture. 2NC AT: PDCP Green New Deal excludes nuclear energy Shellenberger, contributor at Forbes, 2019 (Michael, Green New Deal Excludes Nuclear And Would Thus Increase Emissions -- Just Like It Did In Vermont, 02-07-19 , accessed 07-13-23 https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaelshellenberger/2019/02/07/green-new-deal-excludes-nuclear-and-would-thus-increase-emissions-just-like-it-did-in-vermont/?sh=4cc0cbbe9afd)-TL The Green New Deal proposed by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D) today excludes nuclear energy from the proposed mix. If it were ever actually attempted nationally, it would increase greenhouse gas emissions — just as a similar effort did in Vermont. The written statement distributed by the office of Ocasio-Cortez says "the plan is to transition off of nuclear." 2NC BioD Collapse -> E! Biodiversity Loss Causes Human Extinction Dizro, department of Biology at Stanford University, Ceballos, professor at the Institute of Ecology at UNAM, & Ehrlich department of Biology at Stanford University 2022 [Rodolfo, Geraldo, Paul, 6-27-2022, The Royal Society Publishing, “Circling the drain: the extinction crisis and the future of humanity”, https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2021.0378, accessed 7-8-23, AS] The environmental translation of these socio-economic drivers includes the correspondingly accelerated rate of greenhouse emissions (carbon dioxide, methane and nitrous oxide), leading to climate disruption on land and in oceans. Such climatic disruption encompasses global warming, with dramatic snow- and ice-thawing from polar and high-elevation lands and consequent global sea-level rise, ocean acidification and increased frequency and intensity of extreme weather events (see [14,17]). Despite the active disinformation efforts of deniers (often sponsored by big corporations and special interest groups, in particular the fossil fuel industry; see https://www.climaterealityproject.org/blog/climate-denial-machine-how-fossil-fuel-industry-blocks-climate-action), climate change-related calamities do manage to make their way into mainstream media, including movies and documentaries. This is understandable, given the increasingly vivid, short-term catastrophic consequences on humans (and their infrastructures) around the world. However, this is not the only global environmental change of the Anthropocene. Land-use change, over-drafting of soils and groundwater, rampant terrestrial and aquatic toxification, the proliferation of invasive organisms (plants, animals and pathogenic microbes) and, especially, the intimately connected loss of biodiversity are also grave manifestations of the Anthropocene [14,18]. Here we are concerned with the latter, which is one of the most critical manifestations of the Anthropocene. Save for the ethically and ecologically unsound arguments of de-extinction advocates (see [19]), the loss of biological diversity is irreversible on a time scale of interest to humanity. The loss of biodiversity could ultimately become the most pervasive global environmental change our species will face, since all taxa that have disappeared from Earth will be gone forever. Biodiversity loss is both a cause and a consequence of global environmental change. Therefore, our destruction of the global biological richness on which we utterly depend represents an unprecedented threat to the existence of civilization that could even threaten the persistence of humanity. 2NC Generic Solar & Wind Bad Materials Needed for Solar and Wind Power Messes Up the Environment Around It Nayar, Harvard International Review, 21 [Jaya, August 12, 2021, Harvard International Review, “Not So ‘Green’ Technology: The Complicated Legacy of Rare Earth Mining”, https://hir.harvard.edu/not-so-green-technology-the-complicated-legacy-of-rare-earth-mining/, accessed 7-2-2023, AS] But as much as technology is hailed as the panacea of the future, most of these innovations have a dirty underside: production of these new technologies requires companies to dig up what are referred to as rare earth elements (REEs). REEs describe the 15 lanthanides on the periodic table (La-Lu), plus Scandium (Sc) and Yttrium (Y). Contrary to what the name suggests, REEs are abundant in the earth’s crust. The catch is that they come in low concentrations in minerals, and even when found, they are hard to separate from other elements, which is what makes them “rare.” Perhaps these elements also get their name from being rarely discussed, even though everything from the iPhone to the Tesla electric engine to LED lights use REEs. Demand for these elements is projected to spike in coming years as governments, organizations, and individuals increasingly invest in clean energy. An electric car requires six times the mineral inputs of a conventional car, and a wind plant requires nine times more minerals than a gas-fired plant. With current estimates, demand for REEs could increase six-fold by 2040. Lithium and cobalt demand could increase ten to twenty times by 2050 because of electric cars. Demand for dysprosium and neodymium is estimated to increase seven to twenty-six times over the next 25 years as a result of electric vehicles and wind turbines. But REEs also have grim prospects: the way companies extract REEs largely damages communities and contaminates surrounding areas. Mining Externalities There are two primary methods for REE mining, both of which release toxic chemicals into the environment. The first involves removing topsoil and creating a leaching pond where chemicals are added to the extracted earth to separate metals. This form of chemical erosion is common since the chemicals dissolve the rare earth, allowing it to be concentrated and then refined. However, leaching ponds, full of toxic chemicals, may leak into groundwater when not properly secured and can sometimes affect entire waterways. The second method involves drilling holes into the ground using polyvinyl chloride (PVC) pipes and rubber hoses to pump chemicals into the earth, which also creates a leaching pond with similar problems. Additionally, PVC pipes are sometimes left in areas that are never cleaned up. Both methods produce mountains of toxic waste, with high risk of environmental and health hazards. For every ton of rare earth produced, the mining process yields 13kg of dust, 9,600-12,000 cubic meters of waste gas, 75 cubic meters of wastewater, and one ton of radioactive residue. This stems from the fact that rare earth element ores have metals that, when mixed with leaching pond chemicals, contaminate air, water, and soil. Most worrying is that rare earth ores are often laced with radioactive thorium and uranium, which result in especially detrimental health effects. Overall, for every ton of rare earth, 2,000 tons of toxic waste are produced. 2NC Solar Bad Solar panels use rare earth minerals, the mining of which is extremely harmful Huber, University of Graz Center for Climate Change, and Steiniger, University of Graz Center for Climate Change, 2022 [Sophie and Karl, 3-10-2022, Elsevier, “Journal of Cleaner Production”, Volume: 339, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2022.130720, accessed 7-12-2023, KCD] Extended implementation of renewable energy technologies is vital to limit global warming. However, there are critical sustainability issues connected to the production of wind turbines, solar photovoltaic modules, electric vehicles and lithium-ion batteries. These include the use of conflict minerals, toxicity, and finite availability or supply chain governance risks of rare earth elements, cobalt, and lithium, that need to be taken into consideration. “Conflict minerals” refer to tantalum, tin, tungsten and gold, and their current mining is frequently linked to human rights violations and the financing of violent conflicts. This article focuses on one conflict mineral used in solar panels, tin, the three rare earth elements praseodymium, dysprosium and neodymium, mainly used in permanent magnets that are employed in wind turbines and electric motors in electric vehicles, and lithium and cobalt, as they are needed in lithium-ion batteries for solar and wind energy technologies, and electric vehicles. Focusing on these we identify unfavorable implications of using these elements, including issues of lacking transparency and human rights violations, toxicity and finite availability. Alleviating measures are reviewed for their past contributions as well as their future potential to reduce supply chain risks. These include analyzing the supply chain according to ethical standards, extending regulations beyond the scope of conflict minerals, looking for possible minerals or component substitutes, somewhat diverse across these fields, and increasing the minerals’ recycling rates. China Conflict Module China has a monopoly on REE, reliance on them is highly risky Seligman, award-winning defense reporter for POLITICO, 22 [Lara, 12-14-2022, POLITCO, “China Dominates the Rare Earths Market. This U.S. Mine Is Trying to Change That”, https://www.politico.com/news/magazine/2022/12/14/rare-earth-mines-00071102, accessed 7-12-2023, KCD] China could easily decide to restrict access to rare earths again with disastrous consequences. As of today, China accounts for 63 percent of the world’s rare earth mining, 85 percent of rare earth processing, and 92 percent of rare earth magnet production. Rare earth alloys and magnets that China controls are critical components in missiles, firearms, radars and stealth aircraft. The risk of relying on Beijing for these components was brought into stark relief in September, when the Pentagon suspended deliveries of the F-35 for about a month after discovering that a magnet in the jet’s turbomachine was made with cobalt and samarium alloy that came from China. The alloy, which is sourced only in China, does not transmit sensitive information, or put the fighter at risk, Najieb-Locke said. But the presence of Chinese-made materials may have violated a new defense federal acquisition regulation requiring contractors to disclose any work in China on certain military contracts. DoD’s rule is designed to incentivize the defense industry to rely on only American contractors. The mining practices of rare earth minerals is exploitative and causes tensions in the globe to rise Watson Ph.D, professor at Asia- Pacific Center for Security Studies in Honolulu, Hawaii, 2013 [Virginia Bacay, 2-19-2013, The Interface of Science, Technology & Security, 48-49, DKIAPCSS EDU, accessed 7-8-23, AS] There is also an emerging race in deep-sea mining for rare earth elements (REEs), which are key ingredients used in high technology manufacturing, e.g., hybrid cars, lasers, aviation, smart phones, clean-energy technologies and defense technologies. China controls about 95% of the world’s output of these minerals, and in 2009 and 2010 made a series of policy decisions that tightened its exports of these elements, citing protection of its natural resources, environmental concerns, excessive exploitation and illegal mining as reasons for their REE strategy .14 Seriously concerned about this development, the U.S., Japan and the European Union (EU) filed a complaint to the World Trade Organization (WTO) in March alleging that China was using the exports restrictions on REEs as an economic and political weapon, i.e., to protect domestic manufacturing and as a retaliatory measure against Japan for the latter’s detention of a Chinese fishing boat captain when his boat collided with two Japanese Coast Guard vessels near the contested Diaoyu/Senkaku Islands in 2010. China’s REE strategy served as a wake-up call for other countries whose response was multi-pronged: Japan, India and the U.S. established R&D programs on deep-sea prospecting, initiated searches for alternative deep-sea deposits in the region and started programs that developed technologies to improve prospects for mining under sea metals. In June 2012, Japan announced its discovery of a large deposit of REEs in its Pacific sea bed, estimated at 6.8 million tons, enough to supply Japan’s high-tech industries for at least 200 years.15 Concerned about having China suspend their REE supplies yet again in light of the ongoing island disputes, Japanese companies are resorting to innovation to lessen their dependence on China: according to the Asahi Shimbun, Japan’s largest newspaper, Honda Motor Corp. is planning to “start extracting rare earths from nickel-metal hydride (NiMH) batteries used in hybrid vehicles,” i.e., to recycle rare earths from its existing products. 16 The establishment of mining companies in several countries has also facilitated technology transfer and diffusion. For instance, when Colorado- based Molycorp acquired China-based Neo Materials, the purchase included the company’s technology needed to provide the more purely refined rare earth oxides used in computer, defense and telecommunications equipment. Given the level of deep-sea mining technology right now, commercialization of any recently-discovered deposits will take years. Innovations will be critical: the minerals are found deep beneath the seabed (5,600 m) and difficult to find in
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.