Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 ENDI Kritik

Capitalism Kritik - Emory 2023

Capitalism Kritik - Emory 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Capitalism Kritik
1NC
1NC – Capitalism Kritik
Basic income is the band-aid that legitimizes neoliberal capitalism and allows market priorities to continue unchallenged.
Tom McDowell 21 Department of Politics and Public Administration at Ryerson University, 2021. “Basic Income and the Legitimization Crisis of Neoliberalism”, Journal of Social Policy, p. 1-18.
Conclusion Contrary to popular belief, neoliberalism’s foundational thinkers were generally not opposed to helping people in need of income support; indeed, they believed there were both moral and practical imperatives for the state to do so. However, the raison d’etre of their entire theoretical project was to oppose modern forms of liberal democracy, which they claimed had been irreparably corrupted by the diseases of rationalism and collectivism. This theoretical commitment to opposing the welfare state and government coercion limits the practical options available to resolve neoliberalism’s legitimization crisis internal to its logical structure. A guaranteed, or basic income, however, could soften some of the impacts of the market’s contradictions, while at the same time stabilizing the hegemonic order. The fragmenting of the progressive neoliberal hegemonic bloc in the mid-2010s has created a moment of instability and transition that also provides opportunities for new ruling coalitions to form. Although the vacuum in this political crisis has been filled in some countries by the rise of an ‘illiberal’ form of right-wing authoritarianism, the case made in this article is that basic income is uniquely positioned as a policy around which a progressive neoliberal bloc based upon a redistributive, competitive logic could coalesce. As a policy issue that was advanced by seminal neoliberal thinkers, basic income holds the potential to raise living standards and well-being without deviating from most of the essential assumptions of the neoliberal orthodoxy. Although classical liberal arguments for basic income have largely ignored Marxist analytical categories, this article has made the case that Hayek and Friedman’s advocacy for basic income emerged from a recognition that the intensification of certain contradictions of the marketplace render external economic redistribution through the establishment of a wage floor necessary. A critical understanding of the historical contradictions that have brought about neoliberalism’s legitimization crisis, then, can help to explain why basic income, given its ability to address some of these specific issues, while at the same time securing and extending free market relations, has emerged as a popular policy response to rising inequality in recent years. It also holds the potential to bolster classical liberal accounts for a guaranteed income by demonstrating a practical benefit to fending off the forces of illiberalism, while preserving an order devoted to competitive market principles in an increasingly unstable political climate (Preiss, 2015). Since the state’s primary objective, from a Poulantzian perspective, is to re-establish equilibrium to consolidate the authority of the hegemonic system, it is probable that governments will continue to seek solutions to the present crisis by searching for new ruling coalitions to legitimize the neoliberal order. Although there are other policy approaches, such as the trend towards social impact bonds, that could arguably fulfill a redistributive function within a market-based framework, there are few policies that offer the potential to improve income security in a non-coercive manner. This paper claims that basic income may provide the ‘best possible shell’ for a revitalized progressive neoliberalism for the 2020s, offering stability to the existing order, and counterbalancing the consolidation of a right-wing authoritarian governing bloc. As Chrisp and Martinelli (2019) have noted, there are considerable practical challenges for basic income as a consensus issue, given that there exist significant differences between left and right factions about what such a scheme should look like. To satisfy the conditions necessary to stabilize the hegemonic order, any guaranteed income programme would have to meet two minimum conditions. First, it would have to be sufficiently generous, reliable, and accessible to resolve neoliberalism’s distribution problem by raising the income floor and providing additional security. If it is insufficiently funded, or not widely available to those who need it, it is unlikely to provide the income security necessary to meaningfully reduce discontent with material conditions under neoliberalism. Second, its conditions must be designed so that, in keeping with the essential logic advanced by the neoliberals themselves, the guaranteed income programme is non-coercive and does not interfere with market relations (Preiss, 2015). From the neo-Marxist perspective, the reconstitution of the centrist, neoliberal governing bloc (that generated the legitimization crisis of neoliberalism in the first place) paints a bleak outlook for the future. A basic income developed by and for a neoliberal environment, Clarke (2020) argues, is likely to bear the hallmarks of its “strategic imperatives” to promote an agenda that places primary emphasis on market competition and the profit margins of private capital (n.p). This could lead to the development of a ‘neoliberalized’ guaranteed income scheme that seeks to replace, rather than supplement, existing welfare supports. This would raise the possibility of the implementation of a permanent basic income scheme, which could lead to what Jäger and Zamora (2021) have termed “welfare without the welfare state” (n.p). Such concerns are well-founded. In the late 1960s, Friedman (1967) noted that one of the benefits of a guaranteed income scheme is that it weakened the foundations of the welfare state by making individuals less reliant upon it. He suggested that if the left-wing were to embrace such a programme, it “will find that it has bought a Trojan Horse”, since it will provide citizens with “reasoned alternatives to present programs that will permit a gradual withdrawal from them” (Friedman, 1967, 241). It is possible, and perhaps likely, that the establishment of a more redistributive neoliberalism based upon guaranteed income transfers would lead to the continued erosion of welfare state programmes and protections. However, as this article has claimed, in the absence of an organized, counterhegemonic movement on the left, the most likely outcome to neoliberalism’s unravelling hegemony is for it to undergo yet another mutation, transforming itself while remaining dominant. While it may be the case that there can be “no social policy detour” around the economic contradictions at the heart of the neoliberal policy paradigm, neoliberalism has proven adept at reconstituting itself to accommodate variegated and complex environments, making short-term concessions to ensure the consolidation of its hegemony (Clarke, 2020, n.p.). Basic income is uniquely positioned as a policy approach that corresponds sufficiently to both the political demands of the present moment, and to the essential logic of the neoliberal intellectual tradition, to temporarily stabilize the political order, while at the same time addressing the problem of rising inequality.
Capitalism fuels a laundry list of impacts—catastrophic environmental degradation, war, and violent police states are all driven by the system.
William I. Robinson 14 Professor of sociology at the University of California, Santa Barbara, 5-27-2014. “Global Capitalism: Crisis of Humanity and the Specter of 21st Century Fascism”, World Financial Review. https://worldfinancialreview.com/global-capitalism-crisis-humanity-specter-21st-century-fascism/
Cyclical, Structural, and Systemic Crises Most commentators on the contemporary crisis refer to the “Great Recession” of 2008 and its aftermath. Yet the causal origins of global crisis are to be found in over-accumulation and also in contradictions of state power, or in what Marxists call the internal contradictions of the capitalist system. Moreover, because the system is now global, crisis in any one place tends to represent crisis for the system as a whole. The system cannot expand because the marginalisation of a significant portion of humanity from direct productive participation, the downward pressure on wages and popular consumption worldwide, and the polarisation of income, has reduced the ability of the world market to absorb world output. At the same time, given the particular configuration of social and class forces and the correlation of these forces worldwide, national states are hard-pressed to regulate transnational circuits of accumulation and offset the explosive contradictions built into the system. Is this crisis cyclical, structural, or systemic? Cyclical crises are recurrent to capitalism about once every 10 years and involve recessions that act as self-correcting mechanisms without any major restructuring of the system. The recessions of the early 1980s, the early 1990s, and of 2001 were cyclical crises. In contrast, the 2008 crisis signaled the slide into astructural crisis. Structural crises reflect deeper contradictions that can only be resolved by a major restructuring of the system. The structural crisis of the 1970s was resolved through capitalist globalisation. Prior to that, the structural crisis of the 1930s was resolved through the creation of a new model of redistributive capitalism, and prior to that the structural crisis of the 1870s resulted in the development of corporate capitalism. A systemic crisis involves the replacement of a system by an entirely new system or by an outright collapse. A structural crisis opens up the possibility for a systemic crisis. But if it actually snowballs into a systemic crisis – in this case, if it gives way either to capitalism being superseded or to a breakdown of global civilisation – is not predetermined and depends entirely on the response of social and political forces to the crisis and on historical contingencies that are not easy to forecast. This is an historic moment of extreme uncertainty, in which collective responses from distinct social and class forces to the crisis are in great flux. Hence my concept of global crisis is broader than financial. There are multiple and mutually constitutive dimensions – economic, social, political, cultural, ideological and ecological, not to mention the existential crisis of our consciousness, values and very being. There is a crisis of social polarisation, that is, of social reproduction. The system cannot meet the needs or assure the survival of millions of people, perhaps a majority of humanity. There are crises of state legitimacy and political authority, or of hegemony and domination. National states face spiraling crises of legitimacy as they fail to meet the social grievances of local working and popular classes experiencing downward mobility, unemployment, heightened insecurity and greater hardships. The legitimacy of the system has increasingly been called into question by millions, perhaps even billions, of people around the world, and is facing expanded counter-hegemonic challenges. Global elites have been unable counter this erosion of the system’s authority in the face of worldwide pressures for a global moral economy. And a canopy that envelops all these dimensions is a crisis of sustainability rooted in an ecological holocaust that has already begun, expressed in climate change and the impending collapse of centralised agricultural systems in several regions of the world, among other indicators. By a crisis of humanity I mean a crisis that is approaching systemic proportions, threatening the ability of billions of people to survive, and raising the specter of a collapse of world civilisation and degeneration into a new “Dark Ages.”2 This crisis of humanity shares a number of aspects with earlier structural crises but there are also several features unique to the present: 1. The system is fast reaching the ecological limits of its reproduction. Global capitalism now couples human and natural history in such a way as to threaten to bring about what would be the sixth mass extinction in the known history of life on earth.3 This mass extinction would be caused not by a natural catastrophe such as a meteor impact or by evolutionary changes such as the end of an ice age but by purposive human activity. According to leading environmental scientists there are nine “planetary boundaries” crucial to maintaining an earth system environment in which humans can exist, four of which are experiencing at this time the onset of irreversible environmental degradation and three of which (climate change, the nitrogen cycle, and biodiversity loss) are at “tipping points,” meaning that these processes have already crossed their planetary boundaries. 2. The magnitude of the means of violence and social control is unprecedented, as is the concentration of the means of global communication and symbolic production and circulation in the hands of a very few powerful groups. Computerised wars, drones, bunker-buster bombs, star wars, and so forth, have changed the face of warfare. Warfare has become normalised and sanitised for those not directly at the receiving end of armed aggression. At the same time we have arrived at the panoptical surveillance society and the age of thought control by those who control global flows of communication in paper service and digital media, images and symbolic production. The world of Edward Snowden is the world of George Orwell; 1984 has arrived; 3. Capitalism is reaching apparent limits to its extensive expansion. There are no longer any new territories of significance that can be integrated into world capitalism, de-ruralisation is now well advanced, and the commodification of the countryside and of pre- and non-capitalist spaces has intensified, that is, converted in hot-house fashion into spaces of capital, so that intensive expansion is reaching depths never before seen. Capitalism must continually expand or collapse. How or where will it now expand? 4. There is the rise of a vast surplus population inhabiting a “planet of slums,”4 alienated from the productive economy, thrown into the margins, and subject to sophisticated systems of social control and to destruction – to a mortal cycle of dispossession-exploitation-exclusion. This includes prison-industrial and immigrant-detention complexes, omnipresent policing, militarised gentrification, and so on; 5. There is a disjuncture between a globalising economy and a nation-state based system of political authority. Transnational state apparatuses are incipient and have not been able to play the role of what social scientists refer to as a “hegemon,” or a leading nation-state that has enough power and authority to organise and stabilise the system. The spread of weapons of mass destruction and the unprecedented militarisation of social life and conflict across the globe makes it hard to imagine that the system can come under any stable political authority that assures its reproduction.
Vote negative to endorse socialist revolution. Only total overthrow and replacement of capitalism can solve.
Kieran Allen 17. Associate Professor of Sociology at University Dublin College, 2017. Marx: The Alternative to Capitalism, 2nd edition, Pluto Press, p. 157-158.
In one of his early writings, Marx declared that ‘without revolution, socialism cannot be made possible’.23 In the Communist Manifesto, he and Engels were even more forthright, declaring that ‘their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing conditions’.24 A number of reasons were advanced for why revolution was necessary. The machinery of the state could not be used for this purpose because it had been shaped by the dominant class and their economic goals. Marx, therefore, argued that his purpose was not to ‘transfer the bureaucratic-military machine from one hand to another, but to smash it’.25 While this point was made in relation to Continental powers and Marx held open the possibility of a parliamentary transition in the US and Britain, the ‘bureaucratic- military machine’ has now grown in all countries. Unlike the capitalist class, workers need direct political power to begin the process of liberating themselves. In 1789, the bourgeoisie of France carried out a radical overthrow of the old feudal regime, but after the upheavals of 1848 in Europe they became ever more fearful of the growing class of workers below them. They are aware that in revolutions the rabble gets insolent and lays hands on things. The bourgeois gentlemen therefore seek as far as possible to make the change from absolute to bourgeois monarchy without a revolution, in an amicable fashion.26 They learnt that sometimes aristocrats could be left in political control as long as they, the capitalists, had the freedom to make money. However, a similar separation of political and economic power was not possible for workers because, unlike both the bourgeois and the aristocracy, they are an exploited class. Uprooting a system of exploitation that is embedded in the very nature of commodity exchange, therefore, required direct political force. It was also only in the process of revolution that the mass of people learnt to clarify their own interests and develop a different understanding of their society. In normal times, the majority accept the legitimacy of their rulers and at least some of their ideas. This cannot be changed simply through preaching, teaching or good example. A new consciousness cannot emerge on a mass scale by workers ‘waking up’ and then passively following the teachings of their intellectual masters or clever television presenters. Experience of class struggle is the only way in which people can learn and, as Draper put it, ‘revolution speeded up the curriculum and enriched the course’.27 In the German Ideology, Marx and Engels summed up their views on how traditional ideas were changed: Alteration ... can only take place in a practical movement, a revolution; this revolution is necessary, therefore, not only because the ruling class cannot be overthrown in any other way, but also because the class overthrowing it can only in a revolution succeed in ridding itself of all the muck of ages and become fitted to found society anew.28 Revolutions are neither accidental nor planned. They may start in the most unpredictable way, often with spontaneous mobilisations, but they arise from deeper contradictions in society. As Engels put it, ‘revolutions are not made deliberately and arbitrarily, but ... have been the necessary outcome of circumstances entirely independent of the will and leadership of particular parties and entire classes’.29 They develop from a general tumult in society that affects all social classes. Typically, the lower class does not suddenly embrace a vision of a bright new world, but rather fights for aspirations it considers just in the old world. It is only when society has reached a massive impasse that it adopts revolutionary methods to achieve these ‘moderate’ demands. The Russian Revolution of 1917 was fought, after all, over ‘land, bread and peace’.
2NC/1NR
2NC/1NR – Framework
Counterinterpretation—evaluate the 1AC as a discursive project, including its justifications, which matter for policy implementation and effects. Making the 1AC the focus of the debate instead of the plan is key to policymaking.
Markus Kornprobst 12. Professor, Chair of Political Science and International Relations at Vienna School of International Studies, 7-18-2012. “From Political Judgements to Public Justifications (and Vice Versa): How Communities Generate Reasons upon Which to Act,” European Journal of International Relations, vol. 20(1) p. 1-2.
Agents travel down many different roads in establishing leg

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.