Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 ENDI Disadvantage

Federalism DA Answers - Emory 2023

Federalism DA Answers - Emory 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
---2023 ENDI Affirmative Answers to the Federalism DA
2AC – Non-Unique
Non-unique - Federalism is trashed now – excessive federal encroachment in a laundry list of areas
Diane Katz, 21. Former research fellow in regulatory policy at The Heritage Foundation. “Biden Administration’s Overreach Affecting States’ Rights, too.” December 10, 2021. https://www.heritage.org/government-regulation/commentary/biden-administrations-overreach-affecting-states-rights-too
KEY TAKEAWAYS
The Biden administration and congressional Democrats are trashing the federalism principles at the heart of our constitutional framework. The various conditions attached to the grants drive policy at the state level and inject federal involvement in virtually every aspect of local governance. The challenge before the nation is to divest power from the administrative state and restore the constitutional constraints that best safeguard liberty. Just like radicals toppling the statues of America’s Founders, the Biden administration and congressional Democrats are trashing the federalism principles at the heart of our constitutional framework. Along with imposing a vaccine mandate, they are meddling in how we fuel our cars, heat our homes, educate our children and treat their ailments, zone our communities, and construct our roads—all of which represents a vast expansion of federal powers that undermines political accountability, policy innovation, and civic participation. A recent Heritage Foundation report offers abundant evidence of excessive encroachment. The number and cost of federal mandates have increased markedly—an additional 457 enacted between 2006 and 2019—as have preemptions of state and local authority. (Federal dictates have likewise engulfed private enterprise, including 856 new mandates between 2006 and 2019.) Imbalance in the federal-state relationship has profound effects on self-government. The constitutional division of authority was intended to impede the consolidation of government power. Dispersed power also allows states to tailor policies to distinct geographic, cultural and political conditions brushed over by broad-stroke federal policies. Keeping elected officials and bureaucrats in plain sight—or closer, at least—heightens accountability, and citizens are more likely to participate in the democratic process when their impact is undiluted by political interlopers. Growth in the number and scope of federal mandates is largely a modern phenomenon. Researchers have documented one instance of Congress enacting a major mandate in 1931, one in 1940, none in the 1950s, nine in the 1960s, 25 in the 1970s, and 27 in the 1980s. Since 2000, Congress and various presidents have approved more than 190 statutes with intergovernmental mandates, according to the Congressional Budget Office. Collectively, the laws have imposed more than 1,000 separate directives. The volume of red tape is massive. States are also much more dependent on federal grants-in-aid, which comprised nearly a third (32.4%) of total state spending in fiscal year 2020. The number of federally funded grant programs grew from 132 in 1960, to 387 in 1968, and 664 in 1998. That number is now 1,274—and growing. Washington is about to unleash the second injection of COVID-19 cash—some $1.9 trillion under the American Rescue Plan Act—along with $1.2 trillion from the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. Moreover, if passed by the Senate, the inaptly named “Build Back Better” bill will dispense several trillion dollars more. The various conditions attached to the grants drive policy at the state level and inject federal involvement in virtually every aspect of local governance. Such excessive federal interference inhibits policy competition among states, as well as the relative transparency and accountability of state-level and local-level regulation. It also impedes the ability of both citizens and businesses to escape flawed policies by crossing state borders.
1AR – Non-Unique
Non unique – Biden already destroyed federalism
Steven G. Bradbury, 23. Distinguished Fellow in the Executive Vice President’s office at The Heritage Foundation. “Biden’s California Waiver: An Assault on Federalism.” January 27, 2023. https://www.heritage.org/energy-economics/commentary/bidens-california-waiver-assault-federalism
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Gov. Newsom's regulatory edicts will override the judgments of policymakers nationwide and dramatically narrow the vehicle options available to American families.
But by federal law, the California mandates ought to be dead on arrival.
The Biden administration has...[empowered] California to dictate a revolutionary new industrial policy for the people of every other state.
You may have heard that California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s climate regulators have ordered automakers to give up on the gas-powered cars, pickups, and SUVs consumers love and begin a forced march toward selling 100% electric vehicles in that state by 2035. Better pay attention: When it comes to Mr. Newsom’s Green Dream for the auto industry, what happens in California won’t stay in the Golden State. If allowed to remain in force, the governor’s regulatory edicts will override the judgments of policymakers nationwide and dramatically narrow the vehicle options available to American families. That’s because California’s market is so big and important that automakers have little economic choice but to spend tens of billions of dollars converting their entire production systems and fleets to comply with the state’s activist climate rules. When popular models disappear from dealerships and the price of all vehicles rises significantly, hundreds of thousands of jobs will be lost in the domestic auto industry. Worse, traffic deaths and injuries will jump in every part of the country as millions of Americans are stuck driving older, less safe vehicles. Our already vulnerable power grid will be strained beyond limits by an accelerated switchover to battery-powered cars. And of course, the United States will come to depend on China even more to supply the inputs EVs require. But by federal law, the California mandates ought to be dead on arrival.
Congress decided back in the 1970s that our country needs uniform national fuel economy and environmental standards for the auto industry, and it directed the Department of Transportation and the Environmental Protection Agency to establish federal requirements that (1) are feasible for conventional gas-powered automobiles to meet, (2) protect the vitality of our domestic auto industry and the millions of jobs it sustains, (3) preserve a wide range of affordable new vehicle models that America’s consumers want to buy, (4) maintain highway safety and (5) promote national security, including by weaning the nation of dependence on unfriendly foreign powers. To reinforce these policy directives, Congress prohibited states from imposing any different requirements for new vehicles covered by the federal rules, a broad prohibition meant to foreclose disruptive state auto regulations such as California’s mandates, which work against every one of Congress’ objectives.
So how is Mr. Newsom able to push his anti-consumer campaign against the internal combustion engine? The answer is President Biden. The EPA has authority to grant California (and only California) a waiver from preemption under the Clean Air Act when necessary “to meet compelling and extraordinary conditions” affecting local air quality. Congress singled out California for special treatment because of its history of smog, particularly in the Los Angeles region. The Biden administration has now employed this waiver authority to greenlight Mr. Newsom’s radical climate mandates for the auto industry, even though those mandates are motivated by a desire to advance global climate goals, not to address air-quality conditions unique to California. In the American system of federalism, all 50 states are supposed to be equal in sovereignty and dignity. True federalism means that each state has an equal ability to experiment with different rules in its own local markets, and unless Congress prescribes a national solution, each state can choose to adopt rules that are stricter or looser than those that apply in other states. That’s not what’s happening here.
Contrary to Congress’ judgment that the auto industry requires uniform federal standards, the Biden administration has used the Clean Air Act waiver process to empower one single state in the Union, California, to dictate a revolutionary new industrial policy for the people of every other state. And the policy mandates Mr. Newsom is handing down are far stricter than anything the residents in most states would find acceptable—if they ever got the chance to decide the question for themselves. What Mr. Biden has unleashed with his California climate waiver is the antithesis of true federalism.
Federalism is terminally non-unique.
LaVarr Webb, 17. Publisher of Utah Policy. “Will the Trump administration honor federalism principles?” Utah Policy January 30, 2017. http://utahpolicy.com/index.php/features/policy-buzz/12197-will-the-trump-administration-honor-federalism-principles
Meanwhile, some (mostly liberal) states are indicating they would like to maintain a form of Obamacare as their healthcare system. A few Republicans are saying they should be allowed to do so. But Republican congressional leaders and some committee chairs are saying no. They’re following the Obama administration top-down approach that the federal government should dictate healthcare. Why not allow states to do what they want to do, as long as they’re not being subsidized by other states? It seems it doesn’t matter whether conservatives or liberals are in charge of the federal government. The pattern has been that they can’t control themselves in the use of power. States get stepped on no matter who is in Washington. In fairness, it’s probably too early to pass judgement on the Trump administration and the Republican Congress. They’re barely getting started. But if they really cared about balanced federalism they would be convening high-level meetings with governors and local government leaders and saying, let’s figure out how we govern this country respecting the prerogatives of each level of government. And doing away with a few federal regulations and easing up on public land and environmental mandates won’t balance the federal system. A future administration can easily reverse pro-federalism initiatives. What is needed are some structural changes that empower states and give them tools to push back. For example, an amendment that allowed two-thirds of states, by resolution, to invalidate a federal law or regulation would give states a real tool. Such a tool wouldn’t change anything immediately. It would be used sparingly and it would be very difficult to actually overturn a federal law or regulation. And it would be a tool liberals could use as well as conservatives. But it would provide a means for states to push back against federal encroachment, as was clearly intended by the Founders.
Non unique – federalism already destroyed now
Adam M. Carrington, 23. Associate professor of politics at Hillsdale College. “How the 17th Amendment Ruined Federalism.” April 8, 2023. https://www.nationalreview.com/2023/04/how-the-17th-amendment-ruined-federalism/
Importantly, whereas the Founders desired the Senate to be a body more rational, cool, and distant from popular passions, the House’s two-year terms and direct selection by the voters would reflect the people’s more knee-jerk responses. Of course, gut reactions can prove rash, dangerous, and often damaging to both public good and individual rights. The Senate’s more stoic and thoughtful poise would not result merely from its six-year term but also from the distance state legislative selection created between it and the people. State legislatures would be more likely to pick on the bases of knowledge and virtue rather than mere popularity — hence, the reason the Senate holds special powers the House doesn’t in confirming judicial nominees and ratifying treaties. Such objections to the 17th Amendment aren’t grounded in a distrust of republican government. On the contrary, they confirm the foresight of the Founders in the original constitutional structure — a wisdom that didn’t oppose government by the people but sought to channel its exercise to foster more rational and just decision-making. Right now, our country suffers from states overpowered by the national government and a Congress that’s both weak and feckless against bureaucracies, courts, and presidents alike. The 17th Amendment surely isn’t the sole culprit in the development of these woes, but it’s certainly not helping. Its anniversary is no cause for celebration.
2AC – Thumper
Federalism is about to be destroyed – numerous 2023 challenges before the 2024 election
Donald F. Kettl, 23. Columnist for Governing, professor emeritus and the former dean of the School of Public Policy at the University of Maryland, College Park. “5 Ways the Tensions of Federalism Will Play Out in 2023.” January 4, 2023. https://www.governing.com/now/5-ways-the-tensions-of-federalism-will-play-out-in-2023
That leads to a two-part prediction for 2023: The new Republican-controlled House will turn up the heat on immigration issues. But Republican governors, especially Texas’ Greg Abbott and Florida’s Ron DeSantis, will jostle for control of the spotlight. Not much will happen, but the glare of the klieg lights will be blinding.
And here’s a bonus prediction about something else that won’t happen: The good old days where budget battles dominated state legislatures and local governments will take a back seat in 2023. It’s not that they won’t be important — it’s always a good time to fight about money. But it will be a year when Republicans at every level of government will line up instead behind social policies, from abortion to immigration to library books to crime. Democrats, meanwhile, will try to advance policies like California’s positions against big oil and “forever chemicals.” Rules, not money, will be the basic currency in 2023.
So next year about this time, get out your scorecards and see if I’m right. But one prediction is sure to be correct: With the presidential race gearing up and governors looking to nose their way into both parties’ fields, with mayors seeking to make their own national mark, and with the Supreme Court once again in the middle of federalism battles, 2023 is sure to be a big year for sorting out federal, state and local politics and policies.
1AR - Thumper
Federalism about to get wrecked – upcoming court case
Mario H. Lopez, 22. President of the Hispanic Leadership Fund, a public policy advocacy organization that promotes liberty, opportunity, and prosperity for all Americans. “An animal rights case could impact federalism and weaken the Constitution.” The Hill, October 18, 2022. https://thehill.com/opinion/judiciary/3690956-an-animal-rights-case-could-impact-federalism-and-weaken-the-constitution/
A case before the U.S. Supreme Court could have surprising, and perhaps counterintuitive, implications for supporters of federalism and the long-protected ability of states and municipalities to regulate their own commerce and pass what is broadly known as “morals-based” legislation.
The nine justices on Oct. 11 heard arguments in National Pork Producers Council (NPPC) v. Ross, which centers around California’s Proposition 12, a law passed in 2018 with overwhelming support from voters of both political parties.
The law set minimum public safety and animal welfare standards for pork and eggs produced or sold within the state’s borders. Those requirements state that pigs used for breeding, egg-laying hens, and calves raised for veal must have enough space simply to turn around and extend their limbs. Proposition 12’s guidelines parallel those being implemented successfully by hundreds of restaurant, grocery and food companies, and by many farmers across the country.
Concern about welfare of animals that are destined for human consumption goes beyond that of the animals’ themselves. Many health experts have weighed in on the threat to human health posed by the extreme confinement of pigs. In a brief submitted to the court in the NPPC case, the American Public Health Association, Infectious Diseases Society of America, Center for Food Safety and others wrote that confining female pigs in crates causes them enormous stress, which in turn makes them more prone to disease that can be passed on to their piglets. The implications are quite real: Hundreds of thousands of Americans are sickened every year by contaminated pork.
Indeed, Proposition 12 specifically implemented those concerns, prohibiting sales — within the state — of specified farm animal products if the animals were raised under extreme conditions that are not merely “cruel,” but that state officials determine “threaten the health and safety of California consumers” by (for example) increasing the risk of “foodborne illness.” Some conservative-leaning states, it should be said, have banned gestation crates within their borders, including Ohio, Arizona and Florida.
However, some multinational pork companies are pushing back against the will of voters and have sued to overturn the law. Courts from Iowa to California have rejected those companies’ claims that states cannot set standards on products sold within their borders.
In the court of public opinion, the pork producers are hoping to capitalize on conservatives’ often reflexive antipathy to California’s progressive tendencies that often do infringe on free-market principles. But there is a vital element that some voices on the right appear not to have fully considered. If the court rules in the pork producers’ favor, it could wreak havoc on the Constitution’s federalist system of government and open the door for liberal activist judges to strike down dozens of state and local laws across the country that are based on values that many conservatives claim as their own.
The longstanding state power to advance public morals, including preventing animal cruelty, traditionally has included the power to keep immoral products out of the marketplace as well. The Supreme Court long has respected the “State’s broad powers to regulate commerce and protect the public environment” and the “right to maintain a decent society.” (Paris Adult Theatre I v. Slaton.) If the court were to curtail California’s exercise of its traditional morals-based lawmaking power in this case, that restriction would also strip other states of this authority.
Existing laws that could be jeopardized by NPPC v. Ross include those regulating the sale of liquor, blocking trafficking in stolen goods, banning the sale of fetal tissue, outlawing prostitution, and limiting gambling.
Conservatives can debate the merits of such laws, but we can agree that these issues should remain at least partially in the purview of state and local governments. Notably, Proposition 12 does not attempt to project California’s moral views out-of-state, and is consistent with the federalist principle of states and municipalities setting laws that are right for their own communities. Blocking this ability would open the door for politicians and bureaucrats in Washington to fill the void with one-size-fits-all mandates, effectively emboldening the federal government to impose its own value judgments.
The Founding Fathers intended for states to retain extensive power and to not cede all of it to the federal government, including the authority to regulate commerce within their own borders. If the Supreme Court sides with the pork producers in NPPC v. Ross, this constitutional principle would be dramatically weakened.
Federalism is about to be destroyed – new SCOTUS cases
Donald F. Kettl, 23. Columnist for Governing, professor emeritus and the former dean 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.