Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 ENDI Counterplan

States CP - Emory 2023

States CP - Emory 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan
---1NC Shells
1NC Shell - Basic
Text: The 50 state governments and relevant territories should [insert mandates of the plan].
States are best suited to implement basic income.
Michael Tanner, 15. Tanner is a senior fellow with the Cato Institute and the author of numerous books, including The Poverty of Welfare: Helping Others in Civil Society. “The Pros and Cons of a Guaranteed National Income.” CATO Institute Policy Analysis, May 12, 2015. Number 773. https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa773.pdf
Any guaranteed income proposal would, of course, involve both coercion and redistribution. It would also represent a federally imposed one-size-fits-all approach. As such, it should be approached with caution and skepticism. In an ideal world, private charity would be the primary mechanism for assisting the poor. Certainly private charity has a much stronger track record of providing the type of assistance that offers a route out of poverty. And, because charity is voluntary, it comes without the moral questions inherent in any redistribution scheme. At the very least, welfare should be a function of state and/or local governments, not the federal government. States can, in Justice Brandeis’ words, “serve as a laboratory; and try novel and social experiments without risk to the rest of the country.”12 Putting states and localities in charge of welfare, as was the case for much of this country’s history, would allow greater experimentation and competition.
1NC Shell - Devolve
Text: The United States federal government should devolve authority over [insert plan mechanism] to the 50 state governments and relevant territories. The 50 state governments and relevant territories should [insert mandates of the plan].
The counterplan solves the case and avoids the federalism DA
Stephen Moore, 04. Senior Fellow, IPI Center for Economic Growth. “Putting Taxpayers First: A Federal Budget Plan to Benefit the Next Generation of American Taxpayers.” Institute for Policy Innovation, Policy Report 174, February 2004, https://www.ipi.org/docLib/PR174-PuttingTaxpayersFirst.pdf-OpenElement.pdf
Step 3. Devolve federal education, transportation and health and welfare programs to the states.
Our federalist system is based on the sound principle that states should be “laboratories of democracy” and that through competition, experimentation and innovation states would learn from one another and adopt best policy practices. This was the type of governmental system our founding fathers envisioned for the United States. The too-often forgotten and neglected 10th amendment of the U.S. Constitution grants all authority not specifically designated to the federal government to the “states and the people.” There are 3 areas in particular that the federal government ought to devolve down to the states: education, transportation, and welfare. Education U.S. education policy has been the primary responsibility of the states and localities for at least 150 years. In fact, the word “education” is nowhere to be found in the U.S. Constitution. School funding was never envisioned as a congressional responsibility. Institute for Policy Innovation: Policy Report #179 15 Since 1996 not a single federal program of any fiscal consequence has actually been eliminated. Not one. Efforts to end the federal role in education, which began on a widespread scale in the late 1970s, have been undermined by the left’s effective response that to cut federal education funding is an assault against America’s public schools and the children who attend them. But there is almost no factual basis for this attack. Federal funding of the schools has not had any measurable impact on student achievement. In fact, the evidence suggests that the school system in America produced better results before the federal government intervened into education policy. There are signs that the federal money is more of a hindrance than a help to improving schools. Despite the fact that the federal government still only accounts for about 10 percent of school funding, well over half of the most expensive regulations imposed on schools are generated in Washington, D.C., not at the state and local levels. In any case, Washington now spends $60 billion a year and there is little support in Congress for retreating from that level of support. In fact, the cost of these programs is expected to increase by another $11 billion over the next five years at the insistence of the Republicans in Congress. The best solution would be to abolish this spending, cut taxes commensurately, and let the states deal with the consequences. But realistically the best we could hope for is a policy alternative that is “pro-education” but at the same time returns much of the funding responsibility for the schools to the states, cities, and local school districts. Toward this end, Congress should end all federal education spending programs and divert $40 billion a year to funding a universal education tax credit. This $1,000 tax credit should be made available to all individuals. For families with school-aged children, the credit should be refundable, meaning that every family would be eligible. For families without children, the credit could be counted against donations to scholarship programs to allow lower income children to select better schools. These funds could be used for tuition, tutoring, and purchasing school supplies. The plan could be expanded to allow businesses to qualify for a $5,000 education tax credit. The credit would offset up to $5,000 of funds that the business donated to school scholarship programs. This approach would remove federal direct interference with schools, but would enhance the principle of increasing parental choice in education. There is compelling evidence that support for such an education tax credit system is far more popular with voters than a voucher program, which uses direct government money for private and even religious schools. A tax credit program incites few of those “separation of church and state” objections. The education tax credit is also generally consistent with the goals of tax reform. Any consumption based tax system must regard educational expenditures as at least part investment, which should be ideally exempt from tax. Transportation The original rationale for the U.S. Department of Transportation was to build the interstate highway system. That was a legitimate federal function, since all U.S. citizens benefit from a coordinated network of interstate highways. But the interstate highway system was completed almost 20 years ago. The vast majority of DOT funds are now spent on non-interstate highways, local roads, and urban transit systems. It makes no sense to collect the federal gasoline tax, send it to Washington, D.C., pass it through a federal bureaucratic maze at DOT with 50,000 workers, and then send it back to the states where the funds originated. In transportation policy, the federal government has become a costly and meddlesome middleman. Until 1996, states were forced to comply with a federal 55 mile an hour speed limit in order to get back their 16 Putting Taxpayers First A Federal Budget Plan To Benefit The Next Generation Of American Taxpayers The U.S. Department of Education’s funding over the past 25 years has actually been negatively associated with test scores and school performance. About half of all federal agencies cannot pass a basic audit that all businesses must undertake. gas tax revenues from Washington. It was the federal government that mandated airbags. Federal highway funds come with other federal strings that inflate construction costs: the Davis-Bacon Act (requiring union wages on federal highway projects); minority set-aside programs; and buy-America provisions. These add about 30 percent to the cost of federal construction projects and thus contribute to the decay of America’s public infrastructure. Moreover, increasingly Congress uses the DOT budget as a pot of money to deliver pork barrel projects that states would rarely fund if they were spending their taxpayers’ own money. No single bill exemplified this GOP infatuation with pork more than the 1998 highway bill. This six-year, $214 billion bill drafted by House Transportation Committee Chairman Bud Shuster was the most expensive public works bill in American history. To my knowledge, no bill in the history of Congress has contained so many special projects for members. The bill was crammed with some 1,500 white elephant transportation “demonstration” projects—for bicycle paths, bus museums, parking garages, university research grants, and even $16 million to pay for artwork in the Los Angeles subway. That was ten times more pork projects than in the Democrats’ highway bill that Ronald Reagan vetoed a decade ago. It passed overwhelmingly in both houses. Table 1 Earmarked Demonstration Projects in Highway Bills Year # of Projects Cost (Millions $) 1982 10 386 1987 152 1,300 1991 539 6,200 1998 1,500 9,000 Source: U.S. General Accounting Office data. Closing down the DOT and repealing the 18.4-cent federal gasoline tax could end all of this inefficiency and redundancy. States could then raise the gas tax themselves (as much as they wish) to pay for whatever road building and repair is needed. By eliminating the cost of the federal bureaucracy in Washington, construction and maintenance costs for highways, bridge and transit systems will fall. Many governors have endorsed this idea as consistent with federalism and the Tenth Amendment. If closing the DOT is not politically viable, another option would be to limit the DOT to financing only interstate transportation projects. This way, states would maintain the authority to implement these programs, eliminating a large amount of the bureaucratic waste in the current system. Welfare Reform – Finishing the Job Thirty-five years ago, when President Lyndon Johnson launched the “War on Poverty,” he declared: “the days of the dole are numbered.” We have now surpassed day 10,000. Over this period, some $5 trillion has been spent on this war—more in current dollars than the cost of fighting World War II. The federal government, along with the states and cities, spend an estimated $300 billion per year on anti-poverty programs. That is almost three times the amount that would be needed to lift every poor family to above the poverty level. Still, the poverty rate in the United States remains extremely high and is no lower than when the avalanche of spending to prevent it began. As Charles Murray of the American Enterprise Institute emphasizes, “The tragedy of the welfare state is not how much it costs, but how little it has bought.” The system does not work well for either the poor or the taxpayer. The welfare state is fundamentally flawed because it rewards bad behavior—illegitimacy and family break-up—and discourages good behavior—work, marriage, and individual responsibility. A 1996 Cato Institute study originated in Texas by David Hartman and James Coder and written by Michael Tanner Institute for Policy Innovation: Policy Report #179 17 and me shows that welfare benefits are so high for the non-working, and taxes are so high for the working poor, that a typical female-head of household on welfare and receiving public housing would have to find a job in most states that pays total benefits of $8.50 an hour to compensate for the loss of welfare benefits.22By not working, the poor are not lazy—they simply are responding to the monetary incentives that the welfare state has created. The 104th Congress enacted a major welfare reform bill that took several positive steps in ending the welfare state. The primary cash assistance program—Temporary Aid to Needy Families (TANF), which used to be called AFDC – is now run by the states. The entitlement feature of the program has been ended in favor of an annual appropriated block grant. The bill also technically requires work after two years of assistance—but it remains to be seen whether the work requirements will be enforced and, more importantly, whether the new system will discourage illegitimacy and entry into the welfare system in the first place. Welfare caseloads have fallen by 57% in the states since the 1995 bill was enacted.23 Congress should finish the job by ending the TANF block grant and leaving the funding to the states and private sector as well. Congress must also recognize that TANF is just one small brick in the modern welfare empire. In Washington there are now more than 60 means tested programs to help the poor. Three of the most expensive “anti-poverty” programs are Medicaid, food stamps, and public housing. As with TANF, they should now be returned to the states and to the fullest extent possible, private charities. Devolving these remaining welfare programs to the states would be advantageous for several reasons. First, it would allow states full flexibility in serving as innovators and laboratories to devise welfare programs that provide a basic safety net without rewarding destructive behavior. State governments have already begun to experiment with promising reforms in welfare. The most ambitious of those experiments, designed to get people off welfare and into jobs, have been adopted in Wisconsin, under then-Governor Tommy Thompson, and in Michigan under John Engler. Devolution of welfare to the states would help quickly sort out approaches that work from those that do not. It would also end the federal government’s meddlesome middleman role in welfare. In many cases it stymies reform, as when Washington recently denied a waiver for the state of Texas to privatize welfare agencies. Second, interstate competition would force states to control bureaucratic costs, hold down benefit levels, and impose meaningful restrictions on eligibility—all things Washington has failed to do. Third, states are more likely to see the role of government as one of augmenting successful private charitable support systems, rather than supplanting them.
1NC Shell - Interstate Compacts
Text: The 50 states and U.S. territories should establish an interstate compact to offer [insert mandates of the plan]
Interstate compacts on fiscal redistribution work better than the federal government
Chris Edwards, 19. Kilts Family Chair in Fiscal Studies at the Cato Institute and is the editor of Down​siz​ing​Gov​ern​ment​.org. He is a top expert on federal and state tax and budget issues. “Fiscal Federalism.” May 20, 2019. https://www.downsizinggovernment.org/fiscal-federalism
Economists who support federal aid point to two main advantages. They argue that aid may address externalities or spillovers that states may impose on one another and that redistribution is better carried out by the central government. See Wallace E. Oates, "An Essay on Fiscal Federalism," Journal of Economic Literature 37, no. 3 (September 1999): 1120–49. But to properly address spillover effects, federal planners would need detailed local information that they usually do not have, and they would need to be guided by the public interest, not political pressures. Experience over the past century shows that aid programs are generally not created and designed to address spillovers. Also note that many actual spillovers, such as those relating to interstate water resources, can be handled by interstate compacts rather than federal programs. Regarding redistribution, aid programs do not redistribute resources to low-income states in many cases, even if that were a good idea. On these two theoretical advantages of aid, the ACIR concluded in a major 1981 study on federalism, "The record indicates that federal aid programs have never consistently transferred income to the poorest jurisdictions or individuals. Neither do most existing grants accord with the prescriptions of ‘externality theory.' " Advisory Commission on Intergovernmental Relations, "The Federal Role in the Federal System: The Dynamics of Growth," no. A-86, June 1981, p. 94. And see pp. 53, 54. Finally, note that any possible advantages of aid need to be balanced by the disadvantages, as discussed in this study. A thorough, cross-country examination of the pros and cons of aid is in Robin Boadway and Anwar Shah, Fiscal Federalism: Principles and Practice of Multiorder Governance (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009).
The counterplan doesn’t link to politics - compacts avoid Congressional action
Claire Carothers, 06. J.D. Georgia Law School, Assistant Professor of Law at Wayne State University. “Note: United We Stand: The Interstate Compact as a Tool for Affecting Climate Change.” Georgia Law Review, Fall 2006. 41.229. Lexis.
Before 1921, the thirty-six compacts enacted with the consent of Congress dealt mainly with the establishment of boundaries between adjacent states. n92 States continue to use boundary compacts to avoid litigation. n93 However, since the New Deal era, modern scholars and judges have adopted a more expansive view of interstate compacts as effective and underused mechanisms to solve regional and national problems without direct congressional action. n94 While the exact number of compacts is hard to calculate, one survey estimates over 140 agreements enacted after 1920. n95 An increasing percentage of these have established administrative agencies with jurisdiction over important regional issues. n96 In identifying and classifying new compacts enacted since the 1970s, Patricia S. Florestano reported a decrease in the number of border and boundary compacts, an increase in regional compacts, and a sharp increase in environmental and transportation compacts. N97
---2NC/1NR
2NC/1NR - UBI Solvency – Other states follow on
Other states would say yes – multiple states already experimenting with basic income projects now
Josephine Fuller, 22. Fuller is a reporter for The US Sun covering all things regarding money and consumers. Prior to moving to finance, she was part of the news desk covering events. “HELPING HAND 29 cities and states sending payments between $200 and $1,200 monthly – full list of universal basic income in 2023.” Nov 26, 2022. https://www.the-sun.com/money/6761547/cities-states-universal-basic-income-2023/
AMERICANS all over the country are getting help making ends meet through universal basic income (UBI) programs. These guaranteed income programs provide monthly payments to eligible participants. These programs offer money to low-income residents with no strings attached. Usually, the programs are government-sponsored or run by not-for-profits. In most cases, there are no strings attached to how the cash can be used and it doesn't have to be paid back. While there is growing support or these programs, those who oppose them say they discourage people from finding work.
Here are some of the UBI programs across the country.
1. Birmingham, Alabama
Program: Embrace Mothers
Length: March 2022 to February 2023
Payments: $375 a month for one year
Participants: 110 single mothers
2. Los Angeles, California
Program: Big Leap
Length: January 2022 to January 2023
Payments: $1,000 a month for one year
Participants: Approximately 3,000
LA has a second UBI program as well.
Program: Breathe
Length: Three years
Payments: $1,204 a month
Participants: 150 people ages 18 to 24 who are receiving general relief benefits
4. Marin County, California
Length: 2021 to 2023
Payments: $1,000 a month for two years
Participants: 125 low-income women raising at least one child under 18 years old
5. Mountain View, California
Program: Elevate MV
Length: One year beginning December 2022
Payments: $500 every month
Participants: 166
6. Oakland, California
Program: Oakland Resilient Families
Length: Summer 2020 to present
Payments: $500 a month
Participants: 600
7. West Hollywood, California
Program: West Hollywood Pilot for Guaranteed Income
Length: April 2022 to October 2023
Payments: $1,000
Participants: 25 randomly selected West Hollywo

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.