Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 ENDI Affirmative

UBI Affirmative - Emory 2023

UBI Affirmative - Emory 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AFF
1AC
1AC---Automation Advantage
Rapid automation causes inequality---that triggers global wars from authoritarian populism
Aaron James 20. PhD from Harvard and is professor and chair of philosophy at the University of California, Irvine, September 2020. “Planning for Mass Unemployment: Precautionary Basic Income,” Ethics of Artificial Intelligence, https://academic.oup.com/book/33540/chapter/287905325
Rapid automation leads to unemployment on a mass scale—not as a temporary shock, but as a new normal. Such was once the stuff of dystopian fiction. Now it could be our future, especially given amazing recent advances in machine learning and robotics. Not this year or this decade, necessarily. But down the road. After all, it’s only dawn in the new machine age.1
Keynes warned in 1930 of a “new disease” that he called “technological unemployment,” by which he meant “unemployment due to our discovery of means of economizing the use of labor outrunning the pace at which we can find new uses for labor.”2 Alas, his fears didn’t materialize in much of the twentieth century. But by the close of the millennium there were signs that it’s no iron law of economics that jobs destroyed will invariably bring new opportunities for human work. As Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAffee explain, citing trends in computing capacity, digitization, and the power in recombining older technologies, “Employment grew alongside productivity up until the end of the twentieth century. [But then] job growth decoupled from productivity in the late 1990s.”3 Even as productivity rose, employment fell off. The long trend didn’t hold. And so, in due course at least, artificial intelligence (AI) really might cause lasting structural unemployment on a mass scale.4
Imagine the scene: jobs are steadily automated, year after year. In the old days, for every job destroyed, a new one was eventually created, leaving total employment more or less unchanged. Now deep-learning machines, aided by clever entrepreneurs, race ahead and do the new tasks as well. The routine tasks, both manual and cognitive, have been mostly automated away. The best workers are those that work best with machines, in some cases besting both person and machine alike. A fair number still do what computers still can’t (as of yet). But many workers—maybe most workers—are left to do the relative few manual or service jobs left. Wages have long stagnated or slipped. Joblessness used to be temporary for most; it wasn’t fun, but the hand of technological fate was relatively arbitrary, spreading disruptions relatively evenly across the population, so that no one took the losses over and over again and nearly everyone shared the rising average standard of living. Now the lag between jobs grows ever longer. Many people—most people, even in their prime years—simply can’t find tolerable work and stop looking. You wouldn’t bet on mortgages, vacations, and college, rising wages over a lifetime, or better prospects for the children. It’s enough just to try to get by. Reared in the Protestant Work Ethic, people are frustrated, distrustful, and angry, nursing contempt for the institutions that promised steady rewards for “hard work” and then failed to deliver decade after decade. With people driven ever farther apart by social media, and public discourse long since polluted, there’s ever less scope for addressing common problems. Democracy, after its dramatic rise in the twentieth century, has become but a shell for corrupt authoritarianism, as hungry political entrepreneurs conspicuously feast on the unraveling.
It’s an awful scenario. Relentless wage stagnation, the decline of trust, the hollowing out of democracy—that’s all bad enough by itself, even without mass unemployment. Add millions of anxious souls out of work, and it’s a terrible state of society—but now seemingly possible.
We certainly don’t know work will be automated faster than reemployment any time soon. The economic historian Robert Gordon even calls the prospect “unlikely” (of which more later). Yet he has no doubt that a different slow-moving automation crisis is already upon us: the quality of the jobs there are has markedly declined.5 Among the many factors (including trade, the decline of unions) that have brought stagnating wages since the mid-1970s, automation is an important part of the story.6 He writes, “The problem created by the computer age is not mass unemployment but the gradual disappearance of good, steady, middle-level jobs that have been lost not just to robots and algorithms but to globalization and outsourcing to other countries, together with the concentration of job growth in routine manual jobs that offer relatively low wages.”7
If nothing else, the idea that a mass unemployment crisis could eventually have awful social and political consequences, such as the rise of authoritarianism and hollowing out of democracy, shouldn’t seem fanciful. The long trend of bad jobs and stagnant wages has arguably already had social and political consequences, in part for aiding the rise of authoritarianism and the hollowing out of democracy. Gordon thinks “this time is not different” as regards mass unemployment. But we’re already in a sort of employment crisis that may warrant a precautionary basic income—precautionary, because things might get even worse.
And the different employment issues aren’t in competition. The onset of mass technological unemployment would vastly worsen the bad jobs crisis we’re in. We don’t know we are proverbial frogs in boiling water, but caution seems to be in order, if only because of how bad things could become, if not next year or decade, then in the further future. By now it is not hard to imagine an upheaval so radical as to frighten anyone conservative enough to value advanced peaceable civilization as we have come to know it (including those on the left who value what is by now a long history of progressive achievements). The risks to democracy alone are already grave enough. Recall that the historical rise of democracy is associated with the “long peace,” a period of markedly reduced war and violence amid unprecedented prosperity. With the sunset of democracy, that trend might end.
Universal basic income solves---limits the material deprivations that fuel populism.
RDI 21. Renew Democracy Initiative, 3-11-2021. "Universal Basic Income Program a Success in Stockton, California," https://rdi.org/universal-basic-income-program-a-success-in-stockton-california/.
2. Why might UBI be important for our democracy?
Many UBI advocates frame the policy as a necessary response to the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), which could cause mass unemployment that could in turn trigger political radicalization.
AI innovations have the potential to raise global GDP by a massive 26% by 2030, but could also automate away up to 47% of American jobs over the next few decades. While automation has historically created jobs faster than it has replaced them, many argue this transition is fundamentally different because fewer workers are needed to train robots capable of training themselves, among other reasons.
Establishing a basic safety net may also quell some of the economic anxiety that empowers ideologues: research has directly linked automation with increased support for populism, and the issue may have even swung the 2016 election to a candidate with authoritarian tendencies.
Figures from Martin Luther King Jr. to Milton Friedman have supported versions of a UBI because it would ensure that no American would suffer from material deprivation. This is a perfect example of a policy that could have a transformative impact on our democracy in a way that transcends partisanship. However, if put in place, the policy could prove very difficult to roll back—we must follow a data-driven approach, cautious following where the evidence leads.
UBI is key to harnessing the benefits of AI---that averts automation-driven inequality.
Annie Lowrey 23. Staff writer at The Atlantic, author of Give People Money, which was shortlisted for the Financial Times and McKinsey Business Book of the Year Award. Prior to joining The Atlantic, she was a staff writer for The New York Times and New York magazine, as well as the Moneybox columnist for Slate. At The Atlantic, she writes about the economy and politics, 5-17-2023. "Before AI Takes Over, Make Plans to Give Everyone Money," https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/05/ai-job-losses-policy-support-universal-basic-income/674071/.
Artificial intelligence is coming for all our jobs.
That is a prevalent fear these days, and not one easily dismissed. The specific effects of revolutionary technologies are impossible to predict, and perhaps AI will turn out to be overhyped. But it really is different from past advances: The work it can do really is different; the jobs it threatens really are different; its effects on the labor market really might be different. A pair of economists at Goldman Sachs recently estimated that two-thirds of American occupations are now “exposed” to AI-driven automation. In the coming decade, the technology will wipe out 300 million jobs, they forecast. That’s one in every 11 jobs on the planet.
Here in the United States, an AI jobs revolution need not be anything for average wage-earning families to fear. If AI does not enslave the human race or destroy humanity outright, this generative technology can and should be a very, very good thing. It should lift productivity growth, increase our national wealth, and contribute to our commons of knowledge. Every person in this country can and should benefit from such an awe-inspiring invention.
The problem with AI is not the technology. The problem is not even the technology's potential effect on the labor market. The problem is that we do not have any policies in place to support workers in the event that AI causes mass job loss. The good news is that we do not need to invent them.
Say hello to the universal basic income, a 500-year-old policy idea whose time has perhaps finally come. It is simple and radical in its design. The government would raise revenue by raising taxes. It would then distribute the money to everyone, in small amounts, in perpetuity, with no strings attached.
To understand why this might be beneficial, imagine our economy as transfigured by AI-not 1,000 years from now, but 20 or 50 years. (This is still a hyper-speculative exercise, I admit, but a useful one nevertheless.) Let's assume that AI will continue to improve at cognitive tasks. More and more people will use it to kill time. More and more businesses will use it for clerical, administrative, and creative work. This will reduce employment in the "middle tier of white-collar jobs," David Autor, an economist at MIT and one of the country's foremost experts on technological change and employment, told me recently.
If that happens slowly, workers will have time to adapt, shifting into new jobs created by AI or into sectors impervious to automation, such as care work. (Autor and his co-authors have estimated that three in five workers today are employed in occupations that did not exist 80 years ago.) But if job obsolescence happens quickly, mass unemployment and wage stagnation are likely, with inequality yawning to previously unseen levels. Employees will get piddling pay raises, shareholders huge dividends. The whole country will become richer while workers become poorer.
But none of that has to happen. The government could capture some of the enormous bounty generated by this new technology and redistribute it to the people who supplied the training data that created it in the first place. A UBI would act as a tax-and-transfer program on steroids, correcting the inequality that AI is likely to gin up. The program would act as a social dividend, ensuring that everybody gets to share in the country's new growth. It would also act as societal insurance, making certain that technological change does not damage our families and our polity, as has happened before. The China Shock, for instance-the large, persistent job losses in American and European manufacturing communities caused by China's entry into the World Trade Organization in 2001-worsened workers' health, shortened their lives, and polarized their political views, all of which could have been mitigated by smart policy making.
Independently, universal basic income is critical to resolving lack of trust in government
Daniel Geitz 21. Freelance Health Writer and Registered Nurse, 7-13-2021. "The Government Needs to Rebuild Trust. Is UBI The Answer?," https://aninjusticemag.com/the-government-needs-to-rebuild-trust-is-ubi-the-answer-bb055edc0bfa.
Lack of trust in government needs to be addressed before almost any other issue in the United States.
In one of my recent posts, I discussed the lack of trust in our biggest institutions as one of the most significant factors affecting COVID vaccination rates. I’ve been thinking more about that lack of trust recently — specifically the lack of trust in government.
Polling data tracking the public’s trust in government since 1958 has shown a decrease over time in confidence that the government “will do what is right.” Confidence generally tends to wax and wane depending on the country’s economic circumstances, and increases during time of international conflict. For example, a spike in confidence is noted immediately following September 2001 (high water mark of 60% of respondents demonstrating trust) , and a sizeable dip can be seen following the financial crisis of 2008 (as low as 10% in 2011). It’s also worth noting that confidence among Democrats increases during a Democratic presidential administration and decrease when a Republican takes the White House, and vice versa with Republicans.
However, the public trust in government did not rebound along with the economy in the 2010’s as it previously has done. In fact, public trust has been floating between 10% and 25% for the last 13 years. For comparison, that figure was 60–70% or so in the 50’s and 60's.
So what’s causing the lack of trust?
One factor that cannot be ignored is the rhetoric of of our elected officials — mostly in the Republican Party — since the late 70’s and 80’s. The idea of keeping the federal government small and fighting overreach has been a guiding light for many individuals and political coalitions since the country’s birth. But its current form, which has dominated the GOP for about half a century, has been especially effective in convincing large swaths of voters for generations that the federal government is fundamentally inefficient at best and fundamentally corrupting at worst (recall Reagan’s famous line, “The nine most terrifying words in the English language are: I’m from the Government, and I’m here to help.”)
However, I’m not convinced that rhetoric alone can explain the crisis of (dis)trust that we see today. The past 50 years have also seen wage stagnation for the vast majority of workers, trade agreements that have led to mass outsourcing of traditionally good jobs, an increasingly undemocratic election system (with a few local exceptions such as ranked choice voting), and the bipartisan systematic gutting of welfare. The past 20 years alone include an illegal war in Iraq, a boondoggle in Afghanistan, a financial crash caused by poor housing market regulation and rampant speculation, and a recovery from said crash that failed to hold anyone responsible to account.
All of these things have had real and measurable impacts on the working class, whose material conditions are getting worse. Even if regular people can’t identify and craft detailed arguments to support the federal government’s policy failures affecting their lives, they know that they’re being left behind. Unfortunately, it seems that the distrust in government is justified.
I’m not reflexively in favor of government solutions to the country’s problems, but there are certainly areas that I see the market as being incapable of solving and therefore needing public intervention.
Let’s take healthcare as an example. Strong arguments can be made for multiple types of universal, single-payer and multi-payer healthcare systems — and it seems clear that we could craft a much better system than what we have now.
However, the task of convincing someone to transition to “government-run healthcare” (or another fearmongering label) when that same government has failed them in so many other ways is much more difficult. It doesn’t matter whether the system would be better if they don’t trust the institution in charge of its execution. The fact that Medicare for All polls as well as it does — usually between 50 and 70% — speaks more to the scope of the healthcare crisis in our country and the massive campaign to adopt it from the left flank of the political establishment and activists more than anything else.
If even the best-crafted policy that would almost surely be beneficial for a strong majority can be kneecapped by the “government-run” label, how can we improve trust in government? And because we’re seemingly staring into the barrel of the climate change shotgun, how can we improve trust in government quickly?
The best option may be another metaphorical “shotgun”: a money shotgun.
Want to improve the perception of the federal government? Blast everyone with monthly checks from Uncle Sam.
If we go by the deeply flawed poverty line, about 10% of the population lives in poverty and about 30% are either in poverty or pretty close. The weighted poverty threshold is $12,784 annual income for individuals and $16,247 for families of two. Imagine if a $1000/month UBI were instituted. Of course, that alone would not eliminate poverty or even come close; there are lots of factors that would decrease the buying power of that monthly check. But it would certainly make a dent.
Those who are lifted out of precarity will likely contribute more to the economy, commit fewer crimes, abuse drugs and alcohol at a lower rate, be happier and healthier, and serve as shining examples of the positive impact that government can have. They might be able to go back to school, or quit that second job and spend the time with the kids instead of paying for childcare. They will likely vote more frequently. And for the middle class who aren’t quite living paycheck-to-paycheck, an extra thousand dollars per month could allow for more retirement savings, less debt, and increased risk-taking ability such as a new business venture.
There’s lots of debate around the different proposals for UBI, especially around its relationship to existing welfare programs and the question of “how do you pay for it?” I understand that the devil is always in the details when it comes to public policy and I don’t want to diminish the complexity of the issue, but I’m not going to get bogged down with details here. But I don’t support the most recent right-wing iteration that popped up during COVID, for instance, and would not blindly accept any UBI proposal without careful analysis.
I’m currently most interested in an Andrew Yang-esque proposal that doesn’t eliminate welfare completely but rather provides a way to transition to something more permanent that would eliminate the need for most traditional welfare programs that tend to stigmatize those who use them. I think there are better ways to do it that would be more soothing to my socialist tendencies, but as of now I’d rather run with something that already has an enthusiastic base of support and could attract widespread bipartisan appeal instead of arguing over details while trust in government continues to dwindle.
UBI won’t solve the big problems that we face. But if we blast a bunch of people with “free money” and start to see the positive effects, hopefully trust in government could continue to be rebuilt with good long-term policy that does solve some of the big problems.
Low levels of trust in the 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.