Farm Bill Politics DA - Emory 2023
Farm Bill Politics DA - Emory 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Farm Bill DA --- ENDI 23 1NC Farm Bill Politics DA---1NC Farm bill reauthorization will pass now. Insiders are confident. Ian Kast 5-24. Writer for the Michigan Farm Bureau. "'We will get one' — Stabenow confident on farm bill, concerned about debt ceiling". Farm News Media. 5-24-2023. https://www.michiganfarmnews.com/stabenow-confident-on-farm-bill-concerned-about-debt-ceiling Debate over the 2023 Farm Bill is in full swing as Congress considers raising the nation’s debt ceiling to avoid a default on the federal debt. Despite the more-than-challenging circumstances, Senate Ag Committee Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow is confident the farm bill will pass. “We will get one,” Stabenow told Michigan Farm News during a recent visit to Michigan State University to celebrate its selection as one of 12 USDA Regional Food Business Centers. “My biggest concern right now is whatever happens on a possible default could create a real devastating effect.” Among the potential effects of a default are higher interest rates, possible stoppages of USDA programs, and impacts to crop insurance — just to name a few. “I don’t know what would happen because we’ve never defaulted before, but it’s not good,” Stabenow said. “So, we need to get this past us so that we can get back to the work of putting together a great bipartisan farm bill.” Stabenow has been involved in six farm bills during her time as a lawmaker — including leading the passage of three farm bills, but this one will be her last. She announced she won’t seek re-election in 2024. Biden’s political capital is key. Jim Wiesemeyer 5-11. Washington analyst for Pro Farmer, previously a Washington editor with Doane’s Agricultural Report and Washington editor and managing editor of the Washington Farmletter. "Lawmakers Meet with Biden to Discuss Farm Bill 2023". Drovers. 5-11-2023. https://www.drovers.com/news/ag-policy/lawmakers-meet-biden-discuss-farm-bill-2023 President Biden invited a bipartisan group of lawmakers to the White House this afternoon to discuss the upcoming farm bill reauthorization. Invitees include Rep. G.T. Thompson (R-Pa.), Sen. John Boozman (R-Ark.), Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.), Rep. David Scott (D-Ga.), and USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack. Stabenow labeled the session as a chance to “have a broader discussion about the farm bill and all the implications for it,” and that it will show “we are working together in a bipartisan way.” She also noted it was a chance for both sides to share their priorities for the bill. Thompson signaled he wants to hear a “commitment from everyone including the president that we will get this done and done in the manner I've been speaking about. Bipartisan, bicameral, on time and highly effective." Boozman said the session is a “step in the right direction” and he wants to see the discussion focus on “the fastest path forward” for the omnibus legislation. Farm Bill Meeting Perspective It’s always good to have a president’s attention on a big topic like the farm bill. It will be interesting to see if Biden/Vilsack detail any must-haves in a new farm bill. Food stamp funding and implementation flexibility, conservation and climate-smart programs are key possible administration topics. History has a lot of examples of how some White House officials wanted to take a more active role in a farm bill only to find that lawmakers write it, not the executive branch. However, a president must sign the omnibus bill and if it is vetoed, override votes are needed--a situation that has occurred before. Basic income legislation is highly controversial. Getting it through congress requires a heavy lift. Richard Morrison 21. Senior fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, expert in environmental, social, and governance (ESG) theory, former managing editor at OpenMarket, B.A. in Government from Claremont McKenna College. "The Case Against a Universal Basic Income". Competitive Enterprise Institute. 7-3-2021. https://cei.org/opeds_articles/the-case-against-a-universal-basic-income/ That common sense approach to work and responsibility poses a big obstacle for any UBI proposal. Despite the UBI’s approval ratings when Americans are asked about it, actual legislation to implement it would be highly controversial. In the 1970s, presidents Richard Nixon and Jimmy Carter — who had famously divergent political views — both endorsed UBI proposals that went down to defeat when the public was confronted with the details. Many recent UBI proposals have called for a new benefit to replace much, if not all, existing social welfare spending. This radical simplification, often called a “grand bargain,” would theoretically ally conservatives, who want to reform the system’s cost and complexity, with progressives, who want to avoid anyone “falling through the cracks” of the many different current programs. But anyone who thinks that such a bargain is likely has spent too much time in political theory seminars and not enough time on Capitol Hill. In order for such a bipartisan effort to work, policymakers would have to wipe enough current spending off the books to finance a universal benefit. That means that many programs that anti-poverty activists currently cherish would be permanently eliminated. Say goodbye to Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (“food stamps”) and Supplemental Security Income for people with a disability. The version advanced by conservative policy analyst Charles Murray, a frequently cited advocate, would abolish all of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid as well. There are plenty of reasonable — even radical — arguments for reforming current welfare spending, but any plan to do so must reckon with reality. A plan that would eliminate current anti-poverty programs and replace them with a single UBI is simply not politically feasible. Any attempt to repeal longtime anti-poverty programs would be attacked as an attack on vulnerable people, while any effort to create a UBI system that would maintain current benefits would break the bank and undermine the compromise with those who want a smaller, more affordable plan. We would likely end up with a UBI on top of existing programs, which would be both more complex and more expensive. Passing the farm bill is key to global food security. Grace Yarrow 23. Editorial intern at The Hill. "How the farm bill could alleviate food insecurity fueled by Ukraine war". Hill. 5-25-2023. https://thehill.com/policy/international/4021371-how-the-farm-bill-could-alleviate-food-insecurity-fueled-by-ukraine-war/ The war raging in Ukraine has exacerbated food insecurity across the world — and food aid experts are looking to the 2023 farm bill for solutions. Ukraine’s massive grain supplies typically feed 400 million people per year, but the war has “drastically cut supplies” and driven up food costs for consumers in rich and poor countries alike, according to the World Food Program (WFP). U.S. legislators are currently drafting the farm bill, an omnibus agriculture act passed every five years, which includes provisions for international food assistance. The farm bill authorizes a number of domestic and international food aid programs. The legislation doesn’t fully authorize funding for this aid, which must be decided in separate appropriations, but it outlines how each program runs and how it can use future funds. Lawmakers can use the must-pass farm bill draft to amend these programs as needed. Experts like Rebecca Middleton, chief advocacy and engagement officer for World Food Program USA, are hoping to see “robust authorization” for food aid support in the 2023 farm bill — especially the Bill Emerson Humanitarian Trust, Middleton said. The Bill Emerson Humanitarian Trust builds up over time and then can be cashed out at the authorization of the secretary of Agriculture. In April 2022, $282 million was withdrawn from the Emerson Trust to support countries in need after the start of the Russia-Ukraine conflict threatened food supplies in six major countries facing food insecurity: Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Sudan, South Sudan and Yemen. The withdrawn money was used to obtain U.S. commodities and bolster existing aid in those countries, according to a U.S. Agency for International Development spokesperson. The Emerson Trust was renamed to honor former Mississippi Rep. Bill Emerson in 1998 but was originally established in 1980 as a wheat reserve. Because of rising food prices, in 2008, the Department of Agriculture converted the trust into a cash reserve that can be used to purchase U.S. commodities in times of need. The trust was most recently reauthorized in the 2018 farm bill, and Congress must reauthorize the Emerson Trust in the 2023 legislation. Congress also has the authority to replenish funds after they are withdrawn. “For all of those accounts [in the farm bill], the one that we’re really interested in is the Emerson Trust because it’s an account that’s not very well known, but is absolutely vital in situations like the one that we found ourselves in in 2022,” Middleton said. “It’s really absolutely vital assistance that the U.S. was able to provide because of that emergency account in this time of historic need.” The 2018 farm bill did not account for such crises like the COVID-19 pandemic or the Russia-Ukraine conflict, both which have had severe effects on supply and triggered more aid from the federal government, so the Emerson Trust was an essential resource in recent years. “I mean, the need was extraordinary and then just compounded with the shock to the global food supply chain with the Ukrainian crisis,” Middleton said. Rep. Jim McGovern (D-Mass.), the former ranking member of the House Agriculture Committee’s subcommittee on nutrition, said in a statement that he supports keeping international food aid well-funded in the new legislation. “The FY 2023 farm bill reauthorization needs to continue to build on the trajectory of the past two decades and ensure that the U.S., in partnership with American farmers and non-profits, can respond swiftly and comprehensively to global humanitarian emergencies and invest in longer-term resilience and sustainability, especially for small farmers, so that they may more successfully withstand future economic and climate shocks,” McGovern said in a statement to The Hill. In addition to the Emerson Trust withdrawal, the Biden administration committed $2.76 billion toward global food security last summer, on top of Biden and other G7 leaders’ contributing $4.5 billion to the issue in 2022. High prices for fuel and fertilizer, theft of farm equipment, destruction of agricultural facilities, and the blockade of Black Sea ports all threatened to push millions of people internationally into poverty, hunger and malnutrition starting in 2022, according to the White House. The Horn of Africa faced a particularly acute crisis due to prolonged drought and famine. Dalton Henry, vice president of policy for U.S. Wheat Associates, is hoping to see solutions in the 2023 farm bill that prioritize using U.S. commodities as a “cornerstone” of donations to regions in need. “We have a tremendous priority placed on making sure that hungry people around the world get fed and the farm bill programs do such a good job at doing that with commodities,” Henry said. He added that it’s “hard to say” how much farm bill policies will change from past years, but that the Russia-Ukraine war has inflamed existing hunger and food insecurity due to global conflicts like those in Ethiopia and Yemen. Henry said the war in Ukraine has made the need for international food aid more prominent. “I think that, if anything, one of the big impacts is that the war has put global food security much more front of mind for a lot of folks,” Henry said, “and probably shone a little bit more of a light on some of these programs that normally kind of fly under the radar.” Food insecurity goes nuclear. Julian Cribb 22. Fellow of the Royal Society for the Arts, the Australian Academy of Technological Science (ATSE) and the Australian National University Emeritus Faculty, “How food can end wars, repair climate and restore the Earth”, https://juliancribb.blog/2022/05/25/how-food-can-end-wars-repair-climate-and-restore-the-earth/ Humans have fought over food and the means of producing it for 20,000 years, as rock art in Australia shows. Food, water and land scarcity are primary drivers in two thirds of modern conflicts today. Indeed, many people seem to have forgotten that the primary German war aim in World War II was to take farmland from the Soviets and put German farmers on it. It is very likely that controlling the Ukraine’s bountiful and reliable food bowl is among Putin’s main aims also. In the short run this is imposing hunger and even starvation on hundreds of millions of people far beyond Europe. Spreading hunger in turn snowballs into government failures, civil wars and refugee tsunamis around the world – as it did in 2008 when a shortfall in Ukrainian grain exports led to revolutions in three Arab countries. Already, a third of a billion people – equal to the entire population of Europe – leave their homes each year, either as refugees or economic migrants, to seek better lives in countries which seem more stable and food secure. War will add to the flood. Thus, in developing a new food system for the world of the 21st Century, we also have to find a way to curb the human appetite for war. In Food or War, I trace the links between food and conflict through human history, explore the role of food in recent conflicts and examine nine regions of the world which are at high risk of food failure and conflict in the foreseeable future – conflicts ranging from riots and government failure to nuclear war. My aim is to show that the link between food and war is inexorable – but that it can be broken. And that having enough good food is the most under-rated, under-recognised and precious ‘weapon of peace’ in the world today. Uniqueness---2NC/1NR Will Pass---2NC Farm bill reauthorization will pass. Debt ceiling clears the path for passage. Eric Bohl 6-2. Staff writer for National Hog Farmer, your leading source of all hog- and slop-related news. "Debt ceiling deal may clear way for farm bill". National Hog Farmer. 6-2-2023. https://www.nationalhogfarmer.com/news/debt-ceiling-deal-may-clear-way-farm-bill This week's bipartisan agreement to suspend the debt ceiling until 2025 in exchange for various spending reforms may directly impact the farm bill's chances this year. The bill, called the Fiscal Responsibility Act, made several eligibility changes to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP. Disagreement over these changes had been a major point of contention standing in the way of a farm bill reauthorization. The agreement requires able-bodied SNAP beneficiaries without dependents up to age 54 to work or be in a work training program, an increase from the current maximum age of 49. It also added new exemptions to the work requirements for the homeless, veterans and people younger than 24 who were formerly in foster care. The changes are estimated to result in a net addition of about 78,000 new recipients. Senate Agriculture Committee Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) told reporters Tuesday that the bill "takes the issue of SNAP work requirements off the table. So, that's just one less issue we're going to have to negotiate" in the farm bill. House Agriculture Committee Chairman Glenn "GT" Thompson (R-PA) told Agri-Pulse, "I think it helps the farm bill process, absolutely." However, he suggested that the House may still consider changes to SNAP work requirements as it proceeds through the farm bill debate. The current farm bill, passed in 2018, expires September 30, 2023. Both Stabenow and Thompson have publicly expressed optimism that they can complete a reauthorization before the end of the year. The Fiscal Responsibility Act passed the House Wednesday by a 314-117 vote and cleared the Senate late Thursday by a 63-36 vote. Industry groups are confident. The pressure is on for passage. Kellan Heavican 6-5. "NCGA expects on-time farm bill with debt ceiling raised". Brownfield Ag News. 6-5-2023. https://brownfieldagnews.com/news/ncga-expects-on-time-farm-bill-with-debt-ceiling-raised/ With Congress raising the debt ceiling, the National Corn Growers Association says that could clear the way for lawmakers to pass the 2023 Farm Bill on time. President Tom Haag tells Brownfield leaders of the Senate and House Ag Committee know the clock is ticking. “They understand where they have to be and I think with this debt limit, they have the reinforcements to go a little bit faster with it and hopefully we can get it taken care of.” There’s broad support for farm bill reauthorization now, but PC is key. Allura Leggard 5-24. "Sen. Schumer pushes for passing of Farm Bill to help farmers and consumers save money". WSTM. 5-24-2023. https://cnycentral.com/news/local/sen-schumer-pushes-for-passing-of-farm-bill-to-help-farmers-and-consumers-save-money AUBURN, N.Y. — The 2018 Farm Bill will expire in September 2023, and dairy farmers and consumers have started to worry about how this can negatively impact them if the bill doesn’t pass. Sen. Chuck Schumer (NY-D) was in Auburn Wednesday morning and said the passing of this bill is major. If the bill expires so will some of its programs which include commodity programs. In it is the “Margin Protection Program for Dairy,” which helps dairy producers protect the financial "margin" between milk prices and the feed costs to produce that milk. “It would cause huge supply chain disruptions and market panic,” said Sen. Schumer. Other programs have permanent authority and do not need reauthorization like crop insurance. The first Farm Bill came in the 1930s as part of President Roosevelt’s New Deal, in response to the Great Depression and the Dust Bowl. Since then, Congress has enacted a bill every five years. The 2018 Farm Bill is the 18th one enacted by Congress and if a new one isn’t passed, it could hugely impact dairy farmers said farm owner Julie Patterson. Dairy farmers need amenities in their toolbox to survive volatile times within the dairy industry when it comes to prices for milk and feed and other supplies that we have. New York is the fourth largest producer of milk in the country and Sen. Schumer said Central New York is a big reason for that. One of the main goals of the bill is to keep prices fair for farmers and shoppers. So, if the bill isn't passed, it could be an expensive trip to the supermarket. We have great production of milk, and the DMC keeps the price lower. If this were to go away the price of milk would go up by a whole lot. Not only would milk prices go up, but so would other dairy products. “First of all. It would hurt your wallet, but I would probably still buy the products,” said Baldwinsville neighbor, Candace Edwards, “Find the place that has the most reasonable prices. Dairy is important to a family and their growth with the kids.” For the bill to be authorized, it needs to be debated, passed by Congress, and get President Biden’s signature. Sen. Schumer said the bill has good bipartisan support but adds they need to make this a major push federally to get the bill passed. Debt ceiling deal speeds the way to passage. USMEF 5-30. U.S. Meat Export Federation."Trade needs to be a higher priority in next farm bill". Beef Magazine. 5-30-2023. https://www.beefmagazine.com/news/trade-needs-be-higher-priority-next-farm-bill With the current farm bill set to expire Sept. 30, Peterson said a one-year extension is likely. But he noted that if work requirements for those receiving nutrition assistance are included in negotiations on raising the debt ceiling, this could help accelerate the farm bill debate. "And I think if that gets handled in the debt ceiling, however they handle it, and people get a chance to v
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.