Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 ENDI Counterplan

States CP Answers - Emory 2023

States CP Answers - Emory 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
ENDI 2023 - States Counterplan Affirmative Answers
---Permutations
2AC – Perm - Do Both (Federalism Net Benefit)
Permutation do both
The perm is the best option to avoid the federalism DA – federal and state redistribution programs complement each other
Howard Chernick, 07. Professor of Economics at Hunter College in New York. “A Reconsideration of the Optimal Assignment of Redistribution Under Fiscal Federalism.” Vol. 100 Proceedings of the 100th Annual Conference on Taxation (November 15-17, 2007), pp. 216-224.
Conclusion
The classic fiscal federalism argument is that redistribution should be assigned to the central level of government. This argument is based on the economic costs of subnational redistribution, and the incentive for states to race to the bottom (i.e., underprovide redistributional benefits to avoid becoming a welfare magnet). Despite this dictum, and the major expansion of redistributional pro-grams at the federal level, roughly a third of total spending on redistribution in the United States (excluding age-based Social Security and Medicare) is financed by state and local governments. Over time, federal and subnational spending on redistribution appear to be complementary, rather than substituting.
Taking into account the political and economic costs of redistribution at both the federal and subnational levels, I argue that, while the central government should play the primary role, optimal redistribution in a federal system requires sharing of fiscal responsibility between central and subnational governments. While too much decentralization leads to suboptimal redistribution in low capacity or weak preference states, too much centralization can lead to welfare losses in high capacity or strong preference states. The appropriate degree of sharing depends on the variation in fiscal capacity and need across jurisdictions, and on the social marginal cost of subnational redistribution, relative to the social marginal cost of national redistribution. My assessment of the evidence is that at the state level the social cost is relatively small, with little evidence that higher redistribution hurts a state’s economy. The wide and even increasing variation in fiscal capacity across U.S. states over the past 25 years has increased the importance of the central government in raising redistributional levels in states with low fiscal capacities, but at the same time it has increased the importance of supplemental subnational redistribution in the high fiscal capacity states. Both matching grants and block grants may be deficient as national fiscal strategies for eliminating the societal deadweight losses from both decentralized underprovision and centralized underprovision of redistribution.
1AR - Perm - Do Both (Federalism Net Benefit)
Permutation do both
Overlapping federal and state statutes don’t link to federalism
Gerald G. Ashdown, 96. Professor of Law, West Virginia University College of Law; B.B.A., 1969, Univ. of Iowa; J.D., 1972, University of Iowa. Federalism, Federalization, and the Politics of Crime. April 1996. https://researchrepository.wvu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1810&context=wvlr
B. Overextension of Federal Jurisdiction
Where does the debate then lie? Initially, the point must be emphasized that the issue is not joined each time Congress passes criminal legislation that applies to conduct already covered by state law — dual or overlapping jurisdiction does not necessarily trigger the debate. As noted above, dual jurisdiction is often essential. The problem arises when Congress makes federal crimes of behavior already adequately covered by state law. The difficulty is then compounded when significant federal resources are devoted to enforcement.
Permutation solves - its cooperative federalism
Jessica Bulman-Pozen & Heather Gerken 09. Bulman-Pozen has a Juris Doctorate degree from Yale University. Gerken is a Professor of Law at Yale Law School. “Essay: Uncooperative Federalism,” The Yale Law Journal 118.7 (2009): 1256-1583.
Federalism scholarship offers two distinct visions of federal-state relations. The dominant vision depicts states as rivals and challengers to the federal government - a role they play by virtue of being autonomous policymakers outside the federal system. A second vision is offered by scholars of cooperative federalism, who argue that the dominant vision ignores the substantial portions of "Our Federalism," n1 in which states are not autonomous policymakers but instead carry out federal programs. As the moniker suggests, scholars of cooperative federalism argue that states should serve not as autonomous outsiders, but supportive insiders - servants and allies to the federal government.
2AC - Perm - Do Both - General
Permutation do both
Perm solves best - federal dollars supplemented by state funds is the best way to achieve UBI
Girard Miller, 21. Miller is the finance columnist for Governing. He is a retired investment and public finance professional and the author of Enlightened Public Finance (2019). “Can the Idea of a Universal Basic Income Really Fly?” August 31, 2021. https://www.governing.com/finance/can-the-idea-of-a-universal-basic-income-really-fly
Today's wider push for a universal basic income is a new twist on the public assistance that our states, counties and many municipalities have long provided to needy residents. For the most part this has taken the form of earmarked aid for shelter, food, health care and other in-kind services. Often the primary funding source has been federal dollars supplemented by state appropriations. Last year, a few dozen localities began reallocating money from public safety to community services, housing the homeless and getting at the root causes of criminal behavior. But these targeted social services programs are not to be confused with the concept of universal income, which begins with the idea that everybody should have a floor income level and would be free to spend it as desired.
2AC – Perm - Do the Counterplan
Perm do the Counterplan – “federal government” includes state governments in a shared division of power – Washington DC is the “central government”
Legal Dictionary 16 [Federal Government. August 7, 2016. https://legaldictionary.net/federal-government/]
A federal government is a system of government that divides the power between a larger central government, and the local and regional governments beneath it. In the United States, the federal government’s powers were established by the Constitution. Perfect examples of federal governments are those that function best in large countries with a broad diversity among its citizens, though where a common culture still exists, which ties everyone together. To explore this concept, consider the following federal government definition.
Definition of Federal Government
Noun
A system of government in which power is divided between a central, larger government, and the local, regional, or state governments beneath it.
Origin
1635-1645 Latin foederal – (league)
---Solvency Deficits
2AC - No solvency – Federal government key
Federal UBI key - funding
Stephanie Cutler et al, 19. *Stephanie Cutler graduated from Duke University in May 2021 with a bachelor's degree in Public Policy and Visual and Media Studies. *Brennan Zook graduated from Duke University in 2021 with a degree in Public Policy, Political Science, and an Arts Innovation & Entrepreneurship Certificate. *Elijah Williams is a graduate of Duke University and current Enterprise Associate Account Executive at Amazon Web Services (AWS). “Universal Basic Income and Job Guarantees: Feasible or Unrealistic?” 2019. https://sites.duke.edu/policylab/files/2019/10/Brockman-UBI-Job-Guarantee-Memo.pdf
Universal Basic Income: Universal Basic Income (UBI) offers potential on a national level, but currently is not sustainable at the state level to address unemployment and poverty. It is intended to be an individual, unconditional, and frequent payment, in order to counter job-loss from automation.11 Traditional UBI policy lacks means-based testing or work requirements typical in welfare policy.
Barrier: State-Level Funding
Finding adequate funding for a UBI is more feasible nationwide than statewide because states lack adequate discretionary funds. In “Raising the Floor,” Andy Stern outlines a feasible solution to implement a nationwide UBI of $12,000 per year per adult. To cover the approximate $2.7 trillion cost, he notes that most anti poverty programs, earned income tax credits, military spending, tax breaks, must be cut and a permanent fund must be created.12 While state’s policy costs are lower with smaller programs, states have fewer “disposable and discretionary funds” to easily reallocate, ultimately limiting the success of a UBI on a state scale.13 The Alaska Permanent Fund (PFD) is the closest approximate to successful state-level UBI policy, though it is not replicable in North Carolina due to welfare-drive migration and a lack of profitable sources of income. Since 1982, the PFD provides adult residents with an annual flat cut of state oil dividends ($1600 last October), typically preventing 2-3% of the Alaskan population from slipping into poverty.14 However, research illustrates a moderate welfare-driven migration for residents along state borders, an issue Alaska does not have.15 Furthermore, North Carolina lacks a natural resource as steadily abundant and profitable as Alaskan oil.
1AR - No solvency - Federal government key
Federal key - state level UBIs are not sustainable - $$
Stephanie Cutler et al, 19. *Stephanie Cutler graduated from Duke University with a bachelor's degree in Public Policy and Visual and Media Studies. *Brennan Zook graduated from Duke University with a degree in Public Policy, Political Science, and an Arts Innovation & Entrepreneurship Certificate. *Elijah Williams is a graduate of Duke University and current Enterprise Associate Account Executive at Amazon Web Services (AWS). “Universal Basic Income and Job Guarantees: Feasible or Unrealistic?” 2019. https://sites.duke.edu/policylab/files/2019/10/Brockman-UBI-Job-Guarantee-Memo.pdf
Barrier: Sustainability
North Carolina’s partisan instability makes a state UBI politically unsustainable. North Carolina is a swing state with resulting frequent leadership changes; budgets and legislation are particularly susceptible to reversal. Residents may prefer to preserve well-established welfare programs to disassembling them in favor of a UBI program which may be soon reversed. Previous trials, such as in Finland, were canceled as public support waned and the stipend proved inadequate.16
Not feasible for states to implement UBI - cost
Stephanie Cutler et al, 19. *Stephanie Cutler graduated from Duke University with a bachelor's degree in Public Policy and Visual and Media Studies. *Brennan Zook graduated from Duke University with a degree in Public Policy, Political Science, and an Arts Innovation & Entrepreneurship Certificate. *Elijah Williams is a graduate of Duke University and current Enterprise Associate Account Executive at Amazon Web Services (AWS). “Universal Basic Income and Job Guarantees: Feasible or Unrealistic?” 2019. https://sites.duke.edu/policylab/files/2019/10/Brockman-UBI-Job-Guarantee-Memo.pdf
A job guarantee is more feasible to implement at a state-level than a universal basic income, given its lower cost in relation to raising the standard of living. The greatest barriers to feasibility lie in state funding and questionable policy sustainability. In order to address North Carolina’s issues of unemployment and poverty, a job guarantee should be implemented at a local level by offering on-the-job training through North Carolina’s Work First program.
1AR - No solvency - States have no money
States have no money – budget shortfalls, unemployment
Anshu Siripurapu & Jonathan Masters, 21. *Anshu Siripurapu covers economics, energy, and geopolitics, and helps edit the Daily News Brief. He holds a BA in political economy from the University of Southern California. *Jonathan Masters leads writers and editors who produce wide-ranging content for CFR.org. Masters has a BA in political science from Emory University and an MA in social theory from the New School. “How COVID-19 Is Harming State and City Budgets.” March 19, 2021. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/how-covid-19-harming-state-and-city-budgets
Many U.S. state and local governments, on the front lines of the response to the coronavirus pandemic, are facing severe budget shortfalls. A distressing combination of dwindling tax revenues, record unemployment, and rising health costs have pushed them to cut back on spending for infrastructure and education—of which states and cities are by far the primary funders. Some still bear the scars of the 2008 financial crisis, which forced painful spending cuts to public services. Even before the pandemic, subnational governments were grappling with ballooning costs, including health care and pensions for public employees. Some had already sought bankruptcy protection. In response to COVID-19, states and municipalities have made cuts, frozen spending and hiring, laid off workers, and drawn down rainy day funds. Some states have seen revenues rise due to the uneven nature of this recession, but by and large the pandemic has drained state and local coffers. The federal government has stepped in to provide substantial aid.
The majority of states are seeing revenues shrink – unemployment, public health problems
Anshu Siripurapu & Jonathan Masters, 21. *Anshu Siripurapu covers economics, energy, and geopolitics, and helps edit the Daily News Brief. He holds a BA in political economy from University of Southern California. *Jonathan Masters has a BA in political science from Emory, MA in social theory from the New School. “How COVID-19 Is Harming State and City Budgets.” March 19, 2021. https://www.cfr.org/backgrounder/how-covid-19-harming-state-and-city-budgets
States ended the 2020 fiscal year in better shape than was initially forecast because of hundreds of billions of dollars in federal aid and the unusual nature of the pandemic recession. Low-wage earners in the service industries, who pay less in taxes, were devastated by job losses, while the stock market boomed and high-wage workers were relatively unscathed. But states were still projected to see huge shortfalls in the years ahead, even before the surge of COVID-19 cases in late 2020. The situation varies significantly across states, depending on the structure of their economies and their prepandemic fiscal health: for example, California has seen record revenues, fueled by the stock market and income gains among its wealthiest residents. But the majority of states have seen tax revenues shrink, according to an analysis by the Washington Post; five states, including Alaska and Florida, suffered double-digit percentage declines. Tax revenues have fallen sharply as states faced record unemployment claims and rising public health costs. Though the economy is slowly adding jobs, nearly ten million of them have been lost since the pandemic began, with restaurants and hotels among the hardest-hit businesses. As people lose jobs, more qualify for Medicaid, the costs for which are shared by states and the federal government. Moreover, in the first quarter of 2020, state pension funding levels fell to their lowest point in three decades, as the pandemic caused the value of pension fund assets to plummet. Though the stock market later recovered, there are still concerns about its performance, as well as the effect of low interest rates from bonds on pension funds.
2AC - No solvency – Laundry List
State level UBIs fail - laundry list
Adam Crepeau, 19. Adam Crepeau is a former policy analyst at Maine Policy Institute. “Is it feasible to provide a universal basic income in Maine?” The Maine Wire, November 25, 2019. https://www.themainewire.com/2019/11/is-it-feasible-to-provide-a-universal-basic-income-in-maine/
In addition to the hefty cost estimates and potential new taxes, there are other problems with a UBI program in Maine. Between 1968 and 1980, the federal government experimented with a negative income tax, a program that guarantees a minimum income and phases out when earnings increase. Research found that for every $1,000 in additional benefits, earned income reduced by $660, decreasing the net benefit to individuals. The study also found that desired work hours decreased among both men and women. Proponents of UBI point to Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend as the exemplar of success when discussing the idea of direct cash payments. However, this program gives just $1,606 annually to Alaskans in 2019. According to the Fund’s Annual Report, it cost more than $1 billion to provide an annual payment of $1,600 to 639,247 eligible individuals in 2018. While lower than the national average, Alaska’s poverty rate has hovered between 9 and 11 percent for the last decade. In addition, Alaska funds the Permanent Fund Dividend with a portion of the royalties collected from oil and mineral development. According to the Alaska Department of Revenue, individuals are eligible in 2019 as long as they can answer “yes” to these requirements:
I was a resident of Alaska during all of calendar year 2018; On the date I apply for the 2019 Permanent Fund Dividend, I have the intent to remain an Alaska resident indefinitely; I have not claimed residency in any other state or country or obtained a benefit as a result of a claim of residency in another state or country at any time since December 31, 2017; I was not: Sentenced as a result of a felony conviction during 2018; Incarcerated at any time during 2018 as the result of a felony conviction; or Incarcerated at any time during 2018 as the result of a misdemeanor conviction in Alaska if convicted of a prior felony or two or more prior misdemeanors since January 1, 1997 If absent from Alaska for more than 180 days, I was absent on an allowable absence; and I was physically present in Alaska for at least 72 consecutive hours at some time during 2017 or 2018. Another major difference in Alaska’s Permanent Fund Dividend is that the benefit it provides is relatively small compared to the proposals being tossed around on the national stage. It becomes much more enticing to reduce working hours if an individual can receive $12,000 annually as opposed to $1,600. Nonetheless, adopting this criteria would reduce overall cost estimates. Yet Maine remains the oldest state in the nation with a median age of 44.9 years. Implementing a universal basic income would likely exacerbate Maine’s workforce shortage by reducing individuals’ reliance on work to receive income. The state is slated to lose six percent of its workforce by 2026 as baby boomers age over 65 years. If the state provides a minimum income to people on the verge of retirement, individuals may retire at a faster pace. Able-bodied adults may also reduce their work hours, depending on the size of the UBI subsidy. In other words, the effects of a UBI program could actually worsen Maine’s current and projected workforce shortage. Even if a UBI program supplanted other anti-poverty program spending, the political climate in Augusta does not appear conducive to facilitating this trade-off, and doing so would still pose serious risk to state taxpayers.
1AR - No solvency - Laundry list
State governments fail at redistributing - federal government is key
Seth Giertz & Mehmet Tosun, 12. *Giertz is an Associate Professor in the Department of Economics at the University of Nebraska Lincoln. *Mehmet Tosun is a Professor at the University of Nevada, Reno. “Migration elasticities, fiscal federalism, and the ability of states to redistribute income.” National Tax Journal 65.4 (2012): 1069–92. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1084&context=econfacpub.
For several decades, the dominant view among economists was 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.