Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 CNDI Disadvantage

Natural Gas DA - CNDI 2023

Natural Gas DA - CNDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Natural Gas DA – CNDI 23
1NC
1nc
a. Uniqueness: U.S. natural gas industry is strong
– production is up to meet demand and there are profit incentives that causes increase reliance.
Slav, 4/20 [Irina Slav; Apr 20, 2023; Why U.S. Gas Production Is Growing So Fast; https://oilprice.com/Energy/Natural-Gas/Why-US-Gas-Production-Is-Growing-So-Fast.html; //TMS—GK]
U.S. natural gas production is booming. The country is pumping so much of the commodity that prices have dropped to multi-year lows after last year, soaring to over $7 per mmBtu amid the European energy crunch. Now, U.S. benchmark gas is trading around $2 per mmBtu and likely to remain at this level for the observable future. Because of associated gas. Just four shale basins in the United States are currently producing some 36 billion cubic feet of associated gas daily. Those are the Permian, the Eagle Ford, the Niobrara, and the Bakken. And the reason they are producing so much is that oil production is also on the rise. Because of higher prices. "About a third of U.S. gas production is associated gas - produced from oil wells," Jacques Rousseau, a managing director at research firm ClearView Energy Partners, told Reuters earlier this month. "This production is unlikely to decline given current oil prices." Indeed, the Energy Information Administration recently forecast that associated gas production in the country will continue rising until the middle of the century. The EIA also estimated associated gas would account for a fifth of all U.S. natural gas production between 2023 and 2050. Now, this is great news for natural gas importers as various regulators within the U.S. itself clamp down on natural gas use, effectively stifling demand, or at least trying to. But even before these regulators set their sights on natural gas, domestic demand was flattish and unlikely to grow by any substantial amounts unless energy transition plans fail spectacularly. This means that gas prices in the U.S. won't be going anywhere higher anytime soon. Until they do, as demand for LNG from overseas ramps up. Unlike the domestic market, international demand for natural gas remains strong and likely to become even stronger as the transition push favors gas over coal for power generation—a big target for decarbonization efforts. As the biggest natural gas producer in the world, the United States is perfectly placed to take advantage of the opportunity this gas-favoring offers, as long as it can tackle its capacity-building problems. Last year, all reports about U.S. LNG and its future were upbeat. The U.S. was going to overtake Qatar as the world's largest exporter. The U.S. was adding new LNG capacity at breakneck speed. Until it hit a speed bump. Rising costs and intensifying competition are making life difficult for LNG developers and many projects currently in the pipeline may never see the light of day. This is what the Financial Times reported this month, citing industry executives as saying it had become more difficult to secure the long-term offtake commitments necessary for any LNG project. There are already several LNG export projects under construction or close to commissioning that will boost U.S. export capacity by 70 percent by 2027, and that's quite an increase. It will make the U.S. the largest LNG exporter in the world as soon as this year. Yet many other projects are getting delayed and may get canceled eventually because it's getting harder to secure funding for such massive facilities in countries whose governments are betting everything on the transition away from fossil fuels, including gas, despite its favorable place. Even without these projects, assuming all the ones under construction get finalized, the United States can claim the crown of the world's biggest LNG exporter and keep it for quite a while, thanks to that cheap associated gas. It is going to continue flowing because, with OPEC+ determined to keep control over global oil prices through supply constraints, prices are likely to remain at levels that make production growth attractive to U.S. drillers.
b. Link: Government mandated green energy crushes the US gas production platform.
- Investment flight and lost efficiency reduces our ability to export affordably to allies.
Pugliaresi ‘23 – President of Energy Policy Research Foundation [Lucian Energy Policy Research Foundation, 29 March United States Senate Committee on the Budget Hearing on "Left Holding the Bag: The Cost of Oil Dependence in a LowCarbon World” Mr. Lucian Pugliaresi - Testimony - Senate Budget Committee, https://www.budget.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/Mr.%20Lucian%20Pugliaresi%20-%20Testimony%20-%20Senate%20Budget%20Committee1.pdf, EME]
Introduction
The North American oil and gas production platform is an instrument of national power and wealth creation that can deliver affordable, reliable, and secure energy that sustains our national economy. Today the United States is the world’s largest oil and gas producer and a net exporter of both oil and gas to the world market. This production platform operates at a high level of efficiency and solves a wide range of complex technical and cost challenges starting with the exploration and production of oil and gas, its distribution to processing facilities and export markets, and the production of transportation fuels to American consumers and a wide range of essential products, including fertilizers, pharmaceuticals, and plastics. Both natural gas and refined products routinely move through cross-border pipelines in Canada and Mexico and waterborne supplies move in and out of U.S. ports. Efficient operation of this production platform has placed the United States in a unique position, not only to deliver affordable energy to U.S. consumers, but also to provide a secure energy lifeline to our allies. As shown in Figure 1, the U.S. alone provided over 80% of world demand for oil between 2010 and 2020. This production surge kept U.S. gasoline prices affordable for American consumers. More importantly, does anyone think the Europeans would have been able to sustain opposition to the Russian invasion of Ukraine without U.S. LNG?
Today, this production platform and its associated assets face two sources of financial risk; (1) an unanticipated, sustained and long-term reduction in consumer demand for petroleum fuels and feedstocks from a rapidly implemented energy transition, and (2) policy initiatives from U.S. and other governments to restrict the use of petroleum and other fossil fuels, i.e., a government mandated transition. As outlined in this testimony, the risk of stranded petroleum assets from a precipitous and permanent decline in demand remains quite low. The most significant risks are directly related to government policies and mandates that seek to halt domestic petroleum investment or restrict its development. Financial institutions responding to environmental, social and governance criteria that restrict investment in fossil fuel can also contribute to the risk of stranded petroleum assets.
c. Impact:
1. Maintaining natural gas exports is key to victory in Ukraine and stability in Asia.
- capabilities key to deterrence and upstream key to Asian supplies
Collins, et. al, 22 --- Baker Botts Fellow in Energy & Environmental Regulatory Affairs (August 4, 2022, Gabriel Collins, Anna Mikulska - Fellow in Energy Studies & Baker Institutes, Steven R. Miles - Fellow in Global Natural Gas & Baker Institute, “Winning the Long War in Ukraine Requires Gas Geoeconomics,” https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/winning-long-war-ukraine-requires-gas-geoeconomics)
Gas Geoeconomics in Europe Would Help Contain a Global Axis of Autocracy
Europe has aggregate economic output approximately 10 times larger than Russia’s and should, in theory, be able to generate enough military capacity to thwart Russian attempt to establish hegemony. Yet the macro balance obscure three harsh realities. First, European solidarity is an illusion and those in Eastern Europe with the will to confront Russia lack the industrial heft found further west. Second, the political will to translate economic and industrial heft into hard power and a credible deterrence posture can be compromised by high dependence on Russian gas. Putin now works to exploit this seam and he (or future Russian leaders) will continue doing so if the vulnerability is left unaddressed. Third, Ukraine is the first 21st century test of the West’s capacity and will to defeat violent revisionism by an emerging axis of autocracy whose charter members are Russia and China.
Decisive continued application of economic warfare against Russia plus expanded and sustained arms deliveries to Kyiv over the next 12-18 months can help Ukraine restore its sovereignty and also degrade Russian military capabilities on a longer-term basis. This would make it easier to Ukraine + NATO to deter future aggression, or in a worst case, defeat the attacks much more quickly. But without decisive gas security moves, time will instead work in Russia’s favor faster than sanctions will in Europe’s.
What’s more, gas security is a global issue—especially for the United States. Were conflict to erupt in East Asia (whether China, North Korea, or both), Russia would almost certainly seek to capitalize on the diversion of American strategic focus to the Asian contingency. Indeed, preparing for (and hopefully, deterring war in Asia already increasingly dominates thinking and spending in Washington. This makes sense because China now marshals economic power equal to all of its regional neighbors combined, making U.S. participation irreplaceable to ensure a free and open Indo-Pacific.
In fact, Russia has already started to play the same game of gas economic warfare in Asia. On June 30, Russia announced the nationalization of the Sakhalin II LNG liquefaction plant.xliii The plant, which was owned in part by Shell, Mitsui and Mitsubishi, supplied 10% of Japan’s LNG needs, which Russia has now declared to be an “Unfriendly State” due to Japan’s support of sanctions against Russia.xliv Although Japan's Industry Minister Koichi Hagiuda said the decree did not mean that Japan's LNG imports will become “immediately impossible,” he also noted that it would be necessary for Japan “to take all possible measures” to prepare for a possible cutoff of LNG from Russia. Russia’s nationalization of the Sakhalin II LNG plant took place just days after the last cargo finished loading before Shell’s 3.6 mtpa Prelude LNG plant shutdown for an extended labor dispute (after just reopening following a four-month mechanical repair) and days after a fire took the 15.0 mtpa Freeport LNG terminal in the U.S. offline indefinitely. Japan was a significant participant in all three LNG projects, and will likely have to go into the market to compete with Europe to buy LNG (and other fuels) for this winter. Russia’s timing in nationalizing Japan’s interest in the Sakhalin II project and threatening its LNG supply coming days after the shutdown of both Prelude and Freeport can hardly be considered a coincidence.
Yet Europe is also a key security interest and deep U.S. participation is essential to bridge significant divisions between Eastern and Western European countries over how to handle Russian revanchism. Russia’s attack on Ukraine now directly threatens the world’s second-most important economic region as China doubles down its efforts to establish hegemonic control over the single most important economic area. The threat is global and responses must be commensurate. As our Russian counterparts might put it: “Всё переплетено” (it’s all intertwined).
Proactive U.S. efforts to enhance Europe’s gas security and blunt Russia’s ability to use gas for hybrid warfare would directly support its ability to sustain and upgrade its combat credibility in East and Southeast Asia. By incentivizing upstream gas investments globally through the demand call associated with a broader European move to replace Russian gas with LNG, Gas Geoeconomics would over the medium term also help increase global LNG supply to the ultimate benefit of U.S. allies in Asia, foremost among them Japan and South Korea. Meanwhile, the sooner Europe can end purchases of Russian gas, the sooner the Kremlin faces a decision between effectively exiting the global gas market or else spending tens of billions to build more gas pipelines to China—obligating financial resources that would otherwise be used to rebuild Russia’s military. Gas geoeconomics is an essential prerequisite for victory in Ukraine, U.S. credibility in Asia, and should be one of Washington’s top national security priorities.
2. Failure in Ukraine triggers World War 3.
Farkas ‘22 (Evelyn N., former deputy assistant secretary of defense for Russia, Ukraine, Eurasia in the Obama administration and former senior advisor to the Supreme Allied Commander of NATO, "The US must prepare for war against Russia over Ukraine," Defense One, 1-11-22, https://www.defenseone.com/ideas/2022/01/us-must-prepare-war-against-russia-over-ukraine/360639/) DGW
The United States must do more than issue ultimatums about sanctions and economic penalties. U.S. leaders should be marshalling an international coalition of the willing, readying military forces to deter Putin and, if necessary, prepare for war.
If Russia prevails again, we will remain stuck in a crisis not just over Ukraine but about the future of the global order far beyond that country’s borders. Left unrestrained, Putin will move swiftly, grab some land, consolidate his gains, and set his sights on the next satellite state in his long game to restore all the pre-1991 borders: the sphere of geographical influence he deems was unjustly stripped from Great Russia.
The world will watch our response. Any subsequent acceptance of Russian gains will spell the beginning of the end of the international order. If Europe, NATO, and its allies in Asia and elsewhere fail to defend the foundational United Nations principles of sanctity of borders and state sovereignty, no one will. Any appeasement will only beget future land grabs not only from Putin, but also from China in Taiwan and elsewhere. And if the world’s democracies lack the political will to stop them, the rules-based international order will collapse. The United Nations will go the way of the League of Nations. We will revert to spheres of global influence, unbridled military and economic competition, and ultimately, world war.
2NC
2nc – GND Bomb
Green New Deal GND’s a gift to Putin – transition’s too fast without a bridge fuel – locks in Russian energy dependence and European energy insecurity.
Barton ‘19
Michael James Barton is the founder of Hyatt Solutions and speaks around the country on energy and energy security matters. He previously served as the deputy director of Middle East policy at the Pentagon.; “Green New Deal Strengthens Putin But Weakens America,” 02/22/2019; https://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/green-new-deal-dictators-america/; //[TMS—GK]
Death Of The Energy Revolution? The Green New Deal would undo this energy revolution which America has worked so hard to achieve. In addition to massively subsidizing solar and wind power, it would place enormous restrictions on drilling and fracking. The 14-page document is light on details, but its ultimate goal is clear — effectively eliminate fossil fuels and generate "100 percent of the power demand in the United States through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources." No word from a fan of this plan, presidential candidate Sen. Cory Booker, on how exactly this renewable energy production will avoid rolling blackouts in every city and town in America. Perhaps his imaginary drug dealer friend "T-Bone" relayed an invention to Sen. Booker that makes the plan possible. The Green New Deal would also put many oil and gas firms out of business. If America gives up its role as the global leader in oil and gas production, hostile foreign governments will gladly take our place and weaponize their energy resources. The bill would transport us back to the 1970s, when the Arab oil embargo brought the U.S. economy to a standstill and caused gas lines and fuel rationing. America produces more than 11 million barrels of oil a day. Removing that supply from global markets would give Putin and his ilk a stranglehold on the entire world economy. Perhaps plan supporter Sen. Bernie Sanders likes the idea of American workers wasting their time in a socialist line for basic products like fuel and bread. Not steaks though, as the plan's proponents also call for the end of cattle in the United States. Green New Deal: Just Hot Air Progressive activists dismiss such concerns, arguing that America will generate almost all its energy from renewable sources and thus be immune to oil market fluctuations. But that's fantasy. Leading researchers doubt it's possible to transition to renewable sources within three decades — much less the 10 years called for in the Green New Deal. In addition to hurting U.S. consumers, the Green New Deal would undermine the security of America's closest allies. Consider that the European Union gets more of its oil and gas from Russia than from any other country — an arrangement that stymies Europe's ability to check Russian power. Should Russia seek to expand its influence and control in the region, as it did when it annexed Crimea in 2014, Europe will be forced to choose between standing up for its values and protecting its energy imports. That's a precarious position. Supporters of this plan have been screaming from the rooftops about Russian influence in the 2016 election, but seem eager to hand over power to Russia in exchange for some vague promises of new things that haven't yet been invented. A Gift To Putin The United States is Europe's best hope of breaking its dependence on Russian energy. American firms have been ramping up their sales of liquefied natural gas to the continent. In October 2018, the United States traded more LNG with the EU than any month on record. The Green New Deal would make such trade impossible. Our rapid exit from the oil and gas sector would be a gift to the Putin regime. The Green New Deal would be a geopolitical disaster for America. Lawmakers shouldn't give it the time of day.
2nc – Clean Transition
LNG’s the real GND – environmentalists fail to recognize how it’s solved our emissions and is continuing to do so.
Weinstein ‘19
BERNARD L. WEINSTEIN, OPINION CONTRIBUTOR - Bernard L. Weinstein is associate director of the Maguire Energy Institute and an adjunct professor of business economics in the Cox School of Business at Southern Methodist University in Dallas. - 07/31/19; Natural gas is the ‘real’ green new deal; https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/454824-natural-gas-is-the-real-green-new-deal/; //[TMS—GK]
As proposed, the Green New Deal was naively impractical and prohibitively expensive. For example, according to a study by the Mises Institute, transition to a power sector with net zero emissions of greenhouse gases in 10 years would require a capital investment of $5.4 trillion by 2029. In addition, the annual operation, maintenance and capital-recovery costs would exceed $387 billion. Amid all the brouhaha over climate change, a major milestone has been ignored — namely, that America’s greenhouse gas emissions are 13 percent lower today than in 2005, even with an economy that is a third larger. This achievement isn’t the result of environmental regulations or the huge subsidies available to wind and solar investors; rather, it has been the increased use of natural gas that has helped reduce GHGs in the U.S. It is a well-known fact that natural gas burns a lot cleaner than coal or oil. At the same time, thanks to the “shale revolution,” natural gas is abundant, inexpensive and likely to remain so for the foreseeable future. Consequently, the power generation sector, which is responsible f

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.