Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 CNDI Disadvantage

DA Link Supplement - CNDI 2023

DA Link Supplement - CNDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
---------------------NEG---------------------
Military Readiness DA
Universal Healthcare
L- Universal Healthcare
Universal healthcare prevents military recruitment
Kels 08 (Capt. Charlie Kels, judge advocate general in the U.S. Air Force, 12-22-2008, "Bump in the rug," Modern Healthcare, https://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20081222/MAGAZINE/812199928/bump-in-the-rug) @HA?
Healthcare reform could be costly in a different way for military Assuming that campaign proposals translate into government policy, the incoming administration and Congress will establish a new public health insurance plan that provides "the same kind of coverage that members of Congress give themselves." Uninsured Americans who can't afford to pay for the plan will receive a tax subsidy to do so, the cost of which will presumably be financed in part by a payroll tax on large businesses that don't already insure their employees. By all accounts, a sizable portion of Americans appear ready to embrace this proposal, or a universal healthcare plan like it. In addition to the results of the most recent national elections, the Harvard School of Public Health found in a poll conducted earlier this year that a plurality (45%) of respondents who said they understood what the term "socialized medicine" meant also felt that such a system would be better than the current one. Fully 70% of Democrats felt this way, as did 55% of young adults aged 18 to 34. If "socialized medicine" no longer functions as a pejorative, then it would seem that those who oppose such a policy have lost the philosophical ground war. Some form of socialized medicine is on its way. Regardless of one's views on healthcare policy, one thing we can probably all agree on is that government-funded universal coverage is going to be expensive. In addition to the significant direct costs associated with such a plan, there are indirect costs as well (just as there are to having millions of uninsured and underinsured citizens). These indirect costs need to be factored in, or at least considered, in order to paint a fuller picture of what the final tab is going to run. Thus far, at least, one of the seemingly overlooked items has been the potential impact of universal healthcare on military recruitment and retention, and the corresponding cost of rectifying this unintended effect. Whatever the complaints and negative press aimed at the Military Health System, the fact remains that the comprehensive medical care provided to active-duty service members and their families constitutes a significant benefit of military service. The Defense Department estimates the average annual premium of a comparable civilian plan at $15,804 per family. Providing a national health insurance plan thus places the government in a possible Catch-22: the better the plan is perceived as being, and the more" generous the proposed tax subsidies are, the less comparatively attractive the military's medical program becomes to those considering joining or extending their commitments. The point here is emphatically not that our nation's military is a mercenary force fighting for health benefits. There are many ways to obtain healthcare coverage that require infinitely less effort, risk and sacrifice than donning the uniform and taking up the profession of arms. Rather, what's worth noting is that the medical care provided and paid for by the military enables the government to pay our service members less in salary, and instead tout the "indirect compensation" associated with military service. A high-quality universal healthcare plan might require us to pay our service members more to rebalance the scales. Each year, the Defense Department mails out a "personal statement of military compensation" to all uniformed personnel. This document purports to make military compensation more "visible," primarily by highlighting the indirect benefits of service, particularly medical care. The drafters of the statement are refreshingly candid as to their intentions, suggesting that the reader peruse it "to help determine whether specific civilian employment offers would let you maintain the same standard of living you had while serving in the military." Ignore the pay charts, the document all but implores, as the personal statement is a truer gauge of whether a civilian position will bring the same standard of living as military employment. The primary purpose of military medical care is national security readiness; the nation needs a healthy military force that can perform the required mission. A secondary purpose--at least since 1966 legislation establishing a Pentagon-run health insurance plan--is to reward those who serve, as well as their dependents and retirees. Universal healthcare operates under a different set of assumptions. Its impetus is neither military readiness nor support of those who wear the uniform, but instead equity and humanity. These principles need not be mutually exclusive, but their simultaneous implementation may require rethinking military entitlements. If the Defense Department can no longer convincingly claim that its healthcare program provides sufficient indirect compensation to make military pay competitive, even if not lucrative, then innovative ideas may be essential to provide incentives to serve. Perhaps military retirement will need to vest at 10 years instead of 20. Maybe the government will need to match service members' Thrift Savings Plan contributions, like it currently does for certain civilian employees. In other words, depending on how recruitment and retention trends respond to the rollout of national healthcare coverage, something in the equation may have to give. It's an added cost of an already expensive proposition. We're better off thinking about it sooner rather than later
GND
L - Green New Deal
Green New Deal enaction hurts military readiness and emboldens China to invade Taiwan
Center for Military Readiness 21, (Center for Military Readiness, October 2021, “WHY THE DEFENSE BILL DESERVES DEFEAT,” Center for Military Readiness, https://cmrlink.org/data/sites/85/CMRDocuments/CMR%20Policy%20Analysis%20October2021.pdf ) @HA?
Deterrence and serious intent to use our military force are the only things standing between the People’s Liberation Army and Taiwan. Passage of the NDAA this year would weaken deterrence by sending the message that Congress does not take national defense seriously. 2 It is unconscionable that radical, unjustified changes in defense and national service policies could be rubber stamped by passage of the massive defense bill, even without House or Senate hearings presenting testimony from independent witnesses who would spark an informed public discussion and debate. Members of the House and Senate should apply the brakes and withhold support for a defense bill that suggests a shift in priorities toward woke weakness, not military strength. A. “Blank Check” Provisions for Changing the Purpose of Selective Service The NDAA approved by the Senate Armed Services Committee (SASC) declares, “. . . adequate military strength [requires] a requisite number of personnel with the necessary capabilities to meet the diverse mobilization needs of the Department of Defense during a national emergency.” (Senate Sec. 511, pp. 156-160, emphasis added throughout) Language in this bill is imprecise, but it likely would be interpreted the same way as the House-approved version, which is more specific in referring to the “mobilization needs of the Department of Defense during a national emergency and not solely to provide combat replacements.” (House Sec. 513, pp. 224- 235) It is significant to note that the House version repeats word-for-word draft legislation that the National Commission on Military, National, and Public Service included in an Appendix to their Final Report. (Title IV, pp. 161-170) Center for Military Readiness — Policy Analysis — CMR Policy Analysis Page 2 of 6 October 2021 Both provisions, as written, would change the very purpose of Selective Service with "blank check" language. Enactment in law would allow Pentagon bureaucrats to commandeer the lives of young people for reasons that have never justified conscription before. This is a blank check that Congress must not sign. 1. Incremental First Step Toward Universal National Service The pending Senate and House NDAA bills include passages that clearly reflect the grandiose Inspire to Serve Act, which the National Commission on Military, National, and Public Service released with its Final Report. Under the Senate bill, the Defense Department would designate a senior civilian official within the office of the Secretary of Defense as an “Executive Agent for National Mobilization.” This office would be responsible for producing a plan for inducting “large numbers of volunteers who may respond to a national call for volunteers during an emergency . . . It would also address scenarios that would include 300,000, 600,000 and 1,000,00 new volunteer and other personnel inducted into the Armed Forces under the MSSA.” (Senate NDAA Sec. 514, pp. 168-170, and House NDAA, Sec. 1076, pp. 1090-1092) The recommendation for a “lead national mobilization executive agent within the Office of the Secretary of Defense,” together with the numbers of “volunteers” cited above, are straight out of the National Commission’s Final Report. (p. 183) Never mind that talk about “volunteers” in the context of the Military Selective Service Act (MSSA) is an oxymoron. The MSSA is all about involuntary service, meaning conscription. The proposed new language appears to be an incremental step toward the creation of a bureaucratic infrastructure to manage future national service requirements, both military and civilian. The ultimate objective recommended by the National Commission would be a permanent Cabinet-level Council on Military, National, & Public Service. This would be a powerful bureaucracy empowered to use both economic “carrots” and penalty “sticks” to obtain two years of government directed “service” for reasons other than combat or national defense. Once the Executive Agent for National Mobilization begins operations, after passage of the NDAA, there would be no going back. Incrementalism + Consistency = Radical Change. 2. Prospects for a “Modernized” Selective Service System For what “national emergencies” would a “modernized” Selective Service bureaucracy register and potentially draft thousands of young men and women? Possibilities are apparent right now. As its first major initiative under President Joe Biden, the Department of Defense released a Climate Adaptation Plan declaring “Climate change is an existential threat to our nation’s security.” 3 At the same time, liberals in are working to establish a new 8 billion Congress Civilian Climate Corps (CCC) – part of the Green New Deal – which would be funded by the pending $3.5 Trillion Reconciliation Bill. 4 If the purpose of Selective Service is changed to include “diverse mobilization needs” that are “not solely to provide combat replacements,” Pentagon and White House bureaucracies, coordinated by the Executive Agent for National Mobilization or some other Big Government bureaucracy, could easily induct “volunteers” for open-ended make-work Civilian Climate Corps tasks that have little or nothing to do with national defense. Center for Military Readiness — Policy Analysis — CMR Policy Analysis Page 3 of 6 October 2021 When President Biden announced unprecedented COVID shot mandates on millions of Americans, without congressional authorization, he said with a grimace, “This is not about freedom of choice.” 5 Mandates with congressional authorization would be even more onerous. Since the Defense Department has officially announced that climate change is an “existential threat” and a national security priority, all sorts of CCC mandates would seem to fall right into place. Meanwhile, China is getting ready to take Taiwan.
L - Green Tech
Green tech rules hurt defense production amidst backlog of weapons
Doornbos 06-06 (Caitlin Doornbos, staff writer for the New York Post, 6-6-2023, "Defense industry contractors would have to abide by proposed Biden green rule for work," New York Post, https://nypost.com/2023/06/06/biden-green-rule-would-throttle-defense-industry-despite-arms-backlog/) @HA?
WASHINGTON – House Republicans are trying to thwart a Biden-proposed rule that would require the Pentagon to select only the greenest contractors for multimillion-dollar weapons awards – even as the defense industry races to keep up with growing production needs. In November, Biden proposed the “Federal Supplier Climate Risks and Resilience Rule,” which would blackball contractors who decline to set what the White House calls “science-based emissions reduction targets.” The rule, which has yet to be finalized but is on track for official review, would force the defense industry to put the environment ahead of production while it works to reduce a growing weapons backlog worsened by more than a year of donations to Ukraine and a pressing need to arm Taiwan ahead of a potential Chinese attack. If finalized, the rule would force contracting agencies to publicly disclose their greenhouse gas emissions and “climate-related financial risks,” which would be taken into consideration when Pentagon acquisitions teams decide which company to select for a contract. Companies that pursue contracts under the rule would have to create emission-reduction plans, submitting them for review by a consortium of climate activist organizations dubbed the “Science Based Targets initiative.” The non-governmental group would thus have the power to ban any company from competing for DOD contracts if their plans aren’t up to their standards. House Republicans are attempting to stop a Biden administration proposed rule that would require the Pentagon to award weapons contracts to green companies. The “Federal Supplier Climate Risks and Resilience Rule" would require companies to set “science-based emissions reduction targets.” ‘Mission not Emissions‘ The “Mission not Emissions Act” would outright ban the federal government from issuing “any requirements for recipients of federal contracts” to disclose their greenhouse gas emissions or otherwise provide an “inventory or any other report” of such emissions. A shipment of military aid arriving in Ukraine on February 13, 2022. Republicans claim the proposal would make the country's weapons production backlog worse. The bill would also prohibit federal agencies from requiring government contractors to “develop and submit greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets for validation by any non-governmental organization,” explicitly mentioning the Science-Based Targets initiative. Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC), one of the bill’s 15 co-sponsors, in a statement said the bill “recognizes the importance of protecting American businesses from unnecessary burdens and promoting competitiveness on a global scale.” “By prohibiting the disclosure of greenhouse gas emissions and climate-related financial risks for federal contract recipients, we can ensure companies can focus on innovation and productivity without being weighed down by excessive reporting requirements and bureaucratic red tape,” she said. US preps military aid package for Taiwan to confront China: Pentagon The proposed rule would place another hurdle before the defense industry as it attempts to ramp up production of needed weapons and military equipment. The Pentagon for months has been meeting with industry leaders to learn which contractors need to boost production of weapons for Ukraine’s ongoing war with Russia. “We cannot allow the Biden Administration to continue to play politics with our military and force through a radical environmental agenda,” another of the bill’s co-sponsors, Rep. Pat Fallon (R-Texas), said in a statement. “We cannot address national security concerns if our military is hamstrung by the reckless pursuit to lower emissions.” Expanding production capability is a high priority as the Pentagon aims to backfill its weapons and equipment stockpile, which has dwindled after Biden has sent more than three dozen packages of military aid to Ukraine since August 2021 using his presidential drawdown authority. The administration has also pledged to send more in the future as needed. Meanwhile, Taiwan is waiting for the US to deliver roughly $19 billion in weapons and equipment it purchased to deter China from invading the island and possibly drawing the US into war in the Pacific. Delivery was delayed as the US defense industry works to boost production. Rep. Jodey Arrington said the rule is "a thinly-veiled attempt to penalize companies that rely on American energy" Additionally, Congress authorized President Biden to send Taiwan up to $1 billion worth of military aid from US stocks as part of the fiscal year 2023 budget. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin last month told Congress that the Pentagon is preparing a weapons package for Taiwan using part of those funds. The legislation was forwarded last month to the House Oversight Committee, whose chairman, Rep. James Comer, called the proposed rule “another example of [Biden’s] attempt to carry on a radical Green New Deal climate agenda.” “By introducing the ‘Mission Not Emissions Act,’ Republicans are taking steps to stop the all-out war on American-Made energy,” Comer (R-Ky.) said. “This bill prevents the Biden Administration from using federal agencies to attack companies that use and produce domestic energy, from killing American jobs, and from harming the economy by sending costs even higher on all Americans.”
Politics DA
Universal healthcare:
L - GOP
Conditions ripe for Republican backlash against health reform; ACA proves.
Oberlander ’20 (Jonathan Oberlander (oberland@med.unc.edu) is a professor in and chair of the Department of Social Medicine in the School of Medicine and a professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management in the Gillings School of Global Public Health, both at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.) https://www.healthaffairs.org/doi/10.1377/hlthaff.2019.01444) – simon.says
Additionally, electoral incentives may be increasing partisanship. American elections in recent decades have been highly competitive by historical standards.25 Competitive elections can exacerbate partisanship because if the minority party believes it has a realistic chance to win the next election, then it has incentives to pursue obstructionist strategies to deny the majority party legislative victories.15,25 The result is more delays and brinksmanship, and less ability for lawmakers to form cross-party coalitions to address policy problems.23 The ACA was born into a fiercely polarized and partisan crucible that it has been mostly unable to escape. Large Republican gains in federal and state elections in 2010, which partly reflected a backlash against the ACA, provided the GOP with institutional platforms to undermine the law and its institutionalization.12 In contrast, Medicare did not face Republican majority control of the House and Senate until thirty years into its operation. Partisanship has infused every aspect of the ACA’s political life, from enactment to state implementation, federal administration, and litigation.15 The extraordinary levels of polarization and partisanship in US politics help explain many things: why Republicans have abandoned health policy ideas they once favored, why not a single Republican voted for the ACA, why many states have rejected Medicaid expansion, why the ACA has been subject to so many legal challenges and why the courts have become another venue of political conflict, why public opinion has been divided over the law, why there has been no successful bipartisan effort to remedy the law’s shortcomings, why ACA politics persist as existential rather than incremental, and why the ACA has engendered so much controversy 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.