Feminist UBI Neg - CNDI 2023
Feminist UBI Neg - CNDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Feminist UBI NEG *Use cards from the regular UBI cae neg. Case Turns Distraction Turn UBIs shift focus away from core issues, doing more harm than good. Lorena Lombardozzi 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at the School of Social Sciences & Global Studies, Co-Director of IKD “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income”, Political Quarterly, 04/03/2020, https://oro.open.ac.uk/69470/3/69470-converted.pdf - A. K. Weeks notes that the ‘demand for a UBI does not directly address either the unequal gendered division of household-based reproductive labour or its privatization’, even ‘serv[ing] simply to offer more support for the traditional hetero-patriarchal family’s gender division of productive and reproductive labour, with more men participating in waged work and more women working in the home’. But even with the rise of the ‘dual-earner’ household model, women still possessed a much more precarious and undervalued relationship with work than men. Indeed, once women are cut off from the wage-subsistence relationship, they face additional direct and indirect risks of segregation, subordination, and dependence based on asymmetrical income relations. For instance, less work means less and smaller pensions and social insurance. Therefore, welfare benefits and public services have to be accessed through the husband. Yet, this institutionalised disadvantage is unlikely to be substantially challenged by the implementation of the UBI, which risks deepening the dependence on men for income and reinforcing both the gender pay gap and social poverty gaps in the long-term. Furthermore, UBI could well reduce women’s space for formative and rewarding work by creating an incentive for women to remain at home, intensifying gendered social segregation and isolation with respect to social, political and economic arenas. The consequent alienation could reduce the chance of joining political movements and trade unions, which are still fundamental formative institutions for political engagement in a capitalist society. This indicates how the most common shortfall of analyses of the effect of UBI on women thus far are their static approach. Put in another way, it is observable that there exists a generalised lack of understanding of the dynamic consequences of UBI. We lack an analysis that, for instance, would assess comprehensively the inter-generational consequences of UBI in the long-run. UBI may create incremental changes in a time of crisis like the one we are currently living but can also smooth out and anesthetise any short-term shocks it contributes to create. As an example, UBI can relieve pressure from gendered poverty in the immediate term. However, if the sources of such poverty, such as gender-based discrimination, wage gaps, an andro-centric welfare system, unequal care duties and lack of job opportunities persist and remain embedded in the dominant social relations of production and reproduction, the UBI will only amount to a short-term solution unable to transform the underlining causes of such poverty and unable to stop the current pervasive socio-economic disenfranchisement. Furthermore, UBI runs the risk of amounting to little more than ‘cash-in chips’. Rather than expanding women’s bargaining power, it could divert the attention from the actual source of structural gender inequality. Instead of increasing women’s freedom to say no, UBI, by watering-down the material complexities but also the social differences between work and labour, could reduce women’s political space for claiming back their rights to self-determinations and dismantle the constraints in which women operate and resist. This is not to downplay the urgency in addressing social and economic injustice, but rather recognises the need to focus our attention on equally probable risks that the implementation of the UBI can entail in terms of de-politicization of the causes and consequences of everlasting poverty. Last but not least, the entitlement to UBI will not automatically eliminate the sexist attitudes and norms that originated gender conflicts in the first place. In this sense, UBI could worsen poor women’s wellbeing by exposing them to new dynamics of expropriation by men, as it has happened in situations where women start engaging with income earning opportunities and yet do not have full control of their spending decisions. Men could manage to even divert the funds allocated to women under UBI. UBI trades-off with the early education and child care programs Koslowski and Duvander ’18 (Allison, Professor of Social Policy and Research Methods @ the University of Edinburgh and Ann-Zofie, Professor of Demography @ Stockholm University, “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?”, Social Inclusion (ISSN: 2183–2803) 2018, Volume 6, Issue 4, Pages 8–15 DOI: 10.17645/si.v6i4.1487) Many claims are made on what a basic income might achieve. Claims for a basic income include re- ducing poverty and benefit traps, cutting bureaucracy, matching security systems to better correspond with changes in working life, increasing wages, supporting cre- ativity and entrepreneurship, reducing unhealthy depen- dencies within relationships, increasing wellbeing, and the list continues (Kela, 2016). Some also claim that a basic income would reduce gender inequalities in soci- ety (McKay, 2001). However, the basic income move- ment makes no claims to be an explicitly feminist project (whilst acknowledging there are various feminisms). In some ways, a basic income would be similar to existing ‘cash for care’ policies, which are not generally associated with increased gender equality (e.g. Mandel, 2009). In part, this is because such cash benefits reduce political pressure to provide comprehensive care, educa- tion and health services. Although advocates of a basic in- come are clear that a basic income only replaces benefits up to that amount, and in no way replaces existing ser- vices, it is quite common in parental leave policy debates, that cash benefits are explicitly used instead of provid- ing care services for very young children (e.g., Kurowska, 2019). The concern is that should such political trade-offs around resources occur, and should a basic income be seen as a replacement for early years education and care services as political compromise kicks in, this would have significant gendered implications. Workplace Discrimination Turn A UBI would increase discrimination towards women in the workplace Robeyns ’01 (Ingrid Robeyns, PhD, Chair in Ethics of Institutions at the Ethics Institute of Utrecht University, “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?”, Analyse & Kritik, 22, 5/1/2001, https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/auk-2001-0108/html?lang=en) A last second order effect is an expected increase of statistical discrimination against women. Statistical discrimination is a form of indirect discrimination based on the fact that a person belongs to a group that has certain characteristics. These characteristics are used as proxies for the average productivity of that group. Women on average get one or two children and take maternity leave. They also work less hours on the labour market than men, and bear more responsibility for the household and the care of the children and the elderly. They have more career interruptions and are more absent from the workplace. For all these reasons, it is assumed by many employers that women are on average less productive than men. Furthermore, it is rational for an employer to think of an individual woman that she will share these characteristics of her group, as he has no information on her future commitments. Hence, an employer discriminates a woman (by not hiring her or giving her a lower wage) because the employer has no exact information on her productivity and therefore his perception of the average productivity of all women will count. A woman who does not want children, or wants to make a career or has a husband who takes half of the household responsibilities, will still bear the consequences of the fact that other women are more 'child and household oriented'-which is perceived as a good indicator for lower productivity. This implies that if a basic income is introduced, and a group of women decreases her labour supply, it will also be expected from other women that they will be less labour market attached. Hence, a basic income will probably worsen the statistical discrimination against women. One could argue that if statistical discrimination increases efficiency, this efficiency gain can be used for the worse off, for example women. If one follows this argument, statistical discrimination should not per definition be morally condemned. However, I strongly oppose to this argument. First, the little empirical research on discrimination that contains detailed and direct information on productivity (e.g. Wenneras/Wold 1997) shows that even when a woman is two times as productive as a man, employers might prefer to offer a job to him instead of her. I would therefore argue that the best assumption to start from is that statistical discrimination lowers aggregate productivity and efficiency. Nevertheless, this efficiency suboptimality can sustain because of three elements. First, it is rational for employers who have no information on individual productivity to use groups-based proxies. Second, perception biases (which can be formed by sexist, racist or other believes) can lead to a misfit between the observed proxies and real productivity. And finally, I see no reason why other considerations next to productivity (like a preference for employee homogeneity or preferences for certain types of people) would not interfere with the profit maximising strategies of employers hiring people. Furthermore, even if statistical discrimination would lead to efficiency gains, it should still be condemned on moral grounds. It violates the basic principle of equal concern and respect for all individuals. Therefore, I think it is a real challenge for theorists of justice, including basic income proposers, to find strategies to end statistical discrimination and integrate them in their theories. UBI is only radical in theory, while in practice it will leave gendered divisions of work unchallenged – prefer our comparative analysis Koslowski and Duvander ’18 (Allison, Professor of Social Policy and Research Methods @ the University of Edinburgh and Ann-Zofie, Professor of Demography @ Stockholm University, “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?”, Social Inclusion (ISSN: 2183–2803) 2018, Volume 6, Issue 4, Pages 8–15 DOI: 10.17645/si.v6i4.1487) Should the state not take action too with regard to gender equalities? Norms will develop: there is no such thing as total ‘real’ freedom. Legal frameworks how- ever, such as parental leave policies can see changes to norms, even those as deeply embedded as parenting practices. In Sweden, such statements are hardly contro- versial, but choice and gender equality are sometimes contrasted, and the limits to state intervention are con- stantly renegotiated. Basic income would potentially change the bound- aries for state intervention, which for many sounds intu- itively positive, and may well bring many benefits. How- ever, if the state does not intervene regarding gender- equality, gender norms will be determined by other less visible forces, such as the power dynamics within house- holds. It is likely that a universal basic income has the potential for empowerment for all, but for this to be achieved, attention will need to be paid to its potential for gendered outcomes. The concerns raised here regarding the limitations of empowerment for women from a basic income— particularly with regard to whom remains holding the baby, doing the majority of domestic work and the ma- jority of both formal and informal care work—are not in themselves arguments against the implementation of a basic income. However, there are certainly strong rea- sons to not let basic income replace other structures that have been shown to be relevant for gender equality, in particular the ones directed at supporting families, such as parental leave and childcare services. McLean (2015, p. 2) notes that ‘basic Income is in some ways a microcosm of wider feminist controversies regarding how the state can recognise the unpaid work women largely do without reinforcing existing inequal- ities, also known as Wollstonecraft’s Dilemma (Lister, 1995; Pateman, 1988)’. Indeed, feminists involved with policy making sometimes find themselves falling into one of two camps: that of a more pragmatic approach and that of a more idealistic approach. The former aim to take the situation they see at a current time in front of them, such as mothers doing most of the childcare, and to sup- port women in that situation. The latter might rather take issue with the root imbalance of this situation and aim to create a new situation where fathers are doing more childcare. Arguably, many aspects of the current Swedish welfare state are more radically ambitious than the idea of basic income in that it seeks change to the gendered division of both paid and unpaid work. The implemen- tation of a basic income would be gender-neutral and so, in theory, fathers and mothers would have the same sup- port. In practice, however, and especially given the likely low level of basic income, this policy might have the (un- intended) consequence of encouraging a return to the breadwinner model of parenting, with one parent bet- ter able to stay at home, but another parent still need- ing to remain firmly attached to the labour market. Once again, we have a political movement, which has not fully embraced the challenge from radical feminism to move us beyond the ‘fundamental biological condition’ as ob- served by Shulamith Firestone (1970, p. 1) towards an equal distribution of care work. UBI Fails UBI perpetuates inequalities for women Katrin Hermann, 9/28/21, permanent author at A Path for Europe "Reimagining Care: Feminist degrowth and UBI," A Path For Europe (PfEU), https://pathforeurope.eu/reimagining-care-feminist-degrowth-and-ubi/ - Myra A main concern with this proposal is that instead of enabling more women to enter the labour market, they instead continue to perpetuate the caregiver role and exit the labour market completely, while men continue to free-ride on their unpaid domestic work. As Pateman argues, democratization must be included in debates on UBI; meaning “women’s freedom and standing as citizens” must be recognized as well. Thus, it should be noted that UBI is not a panacea – due to the deeply entrenched patriarchal norms about men and women’s roles in productive and reproductive work (which then become institutionalized norms), introducing a basic income will not suddenly overcome this challenge. Within the EU, the Universal Basic Income proposal is still a topic of debate. Though well-known philosophers and economists such as Philippe van Parijs have endorsed the idea, the main fear relates to its effect on the labour market. UBI entrenches structural inequalities and doesn’t pay enough Un Women, 2021, "Universal Basic Income: Potential and Limitations from a Gender Perspective", UN Women Policy Brief, 3/4/2021, https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf - Annie Feminists have also expressed doubt about how far UBI truly challenges ongoing gender- and race-based inequalities in unpaid care and paid employment.26 They have cautioned that, rather than shifting gender norms on care, UBI in higher income contexts and heterosexual partnerships may mean that women cut back on paid work while men continue in full-time employment and receive additional income on top. UBI would therefore be little more than a “housewives wage”, reinforcing gender inequalities.27 The impacts of this potential reshuffling of household labour on migrant domestic workers remains unknown.28 Given the enormous fiscal implications, most UBI schemes will likely not be generous enough to cover basic living costs, meaning that recipients will require additional sources of income, particularly from paid work. In this regard, UBI cannot make up for lack of fulfillment of worker’s rights or access to decent work, especially for women and transgender and gender-diverse people experiencing multiple and intersecting inequalities in access to employment. Trade unionists have rightly warned that UBI does not solve issues of low pay, precarious work or lack of negotiating power in the workplace and could potentially detract from the need to tackle exploitative labour conditions and strengthen workers’ rights, including through living wages, universal job guarantees, affirmative action, unionization and collective bargaining.29 In this case, UBI would merely act as a band aid for a broken economic system and divert attention from more radical, transformative change needed to address structural inequalities. Finally, UBI raises important questions around who is included in a purportedly ‘universal’ scheme. For example, if receipt were attached to narrow notions of citizenship, incarcerated or formerly-incarcerated persons (a group often including disproportionately high numbers of people of colour and people living in poverty), migrants and their children (particularly those who are undocumented), unhoused people and those without government-issued IDs that reflect their identity (including many transgender and intersex individuals) might all experience exclusionary treatment.30 Box 2 further discusses the extent to which UBI could address structural inequalities. Structural Inequality Turn UBI structurally disadvantages women Bergmann ’08 (Barbara, Professor Emerita in Economics @ American University, “Basic Income Grants or the Welfare State: Which Better Promotes Gender Equality?”, BASIC INCOME STUDIES An International Journal of Basic Income Research, Vol. 3, Issue 3, December 2008) An important difference between BIG and a welfare state is that in a BIG regime benefits are spread evenly over the population, while in the latter most benefits are targeted toward those with special needs that are expensive to fill – those who have children requiring constant care, those whose income is insufficient for decent housing, those whose children could profit from an expensive college education, and so on. Obviously, a high proportion of those having such needs are women, lone mothers in particular. Benefits targeted toward those with particular needs can be universal in the sense of being open to all who have such needs regardless of income, marital status, or gender. But targeting allows awarding very expensive benefits to only part of the population -- those in particular need of them -- without requiring that huge sums be expended to deliver to everybody benefits of equal value. A second difference is that BIG gives cash, while a welfare state gives a significant proportion of benefits in the form of goods and services, or vouchers that can only be spent on these. This insures that public money goes to fill publicly agreed-upon needs and that taxpayers’ money is not spent on things of lower public priority or that are wasteful, such as gambling or larger cars. Another feature of in-kind benefits is that they deter labor force participation less than cash benefits do. On the contrary, some in-kind benefits, such as child care, encourage it. The targeting and non-cash features of a welfare state reduce opposition to the state provision of benefits. When expensive benefits in the form of goods and services are given to those who obviously need them, the fact that they are not given to those who do not need them is not a cause for resentment, or at any rate less of a cause for resentment than the distribution of hugely unequal cash benefits w
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.