Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 CNDI Counterplan

UI And FIIB CP - CNDI 2023

UI And FIIB CP - CNDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
CNDI 2023 – Infrastructure and Unemployment CP
Notes
Plank 1 solves adv. 1 and plank 2 adv. 2 (that is the plan at least). Net benefit is a wage inflation or spending link.
NEG
CP Texts
Plank Text
CP Text: The United States federal government should –
Plank 1: establish and regulate a privately funded national infrastructure investment bank in the United States
Plank 2: expand eligibility and compensation of unemployment benefits in the United States.
Advantage CP Text
The United States federal government should expand access to unemployment benefits in the United States.
FIIB Solvency Evidence
1NC Solvency
FIB mobilizes over 1 trillion for infrastructure investment while distributing resources more efficiently than the federal government
Teveia Barnes & John Kramer in 2022
Teveia Barnes is the former commissioner of the California Department of Financial Institutions and executive director of the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank. John E. Kramer is the former chief financial officer and assistant secretary of the U.S. Department of Transportation. Both are members of the advisory board of Infra-Bk, LLC.
The Urgent Need for a Private Infrastructure Bank; Real Clear Politics; https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2022/05/24/the_urgent_need_for_a_private_infrastructure_bank_147645.html
The enactment of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, which received 19 Republican votes in the Senate, was an achievement of rare bipartisanship. But it is not enough. Massive financing is needed for U.S. infrastructure, going far beyond the IIJA – especially now, with a dire need for more pipelines and terminals to supply Europe with natural gas and with continuing bottlenecks in the U.S. supply chain. The best way to fill this gap is by creating a new, private financial institution. The IIJA is just a down payment. Look at the math. The headline figure is $1.2 trillion, but new spending in the bill totals only $550 billion, with the rest already committed from previous legislation. The American Society of Civil Engineers estimates that the shortfall in the nation’s total needs for surface-transportation infrastructure alone amount to $1.2 trillion through 2029. And even making that investment would bring U.S. infrastructure up to a grade of only “B” – good, but far from exceptional. How to fill the gap and bring the nation up to “A”? The answer is a private infrastructure bank that could raise investment dollars and put them to work on the most effective projects throughout the United States. Legislation to create such a bank was introduced in the last Congress, and a similar bill, establishing a Federal Infrastructure Bank, is expected soon. An FIB would require a congressional charter but no government funding or loan guarantees. It would be modeled on the successful Federal Home Loan Bank System, a wholesale lender that has operated free of the political influence that had such a negative impact on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Like the FHLB, the FIB will sell bonds to institutions such as pension funds and endowments. Demand is strong, and it is likely that at least $1 trillion can be raised in the next eight to 10 years. “Trillions of dollars of private capital are both ready and willing to be deployed for high-quality infrastructure projects that generate revenue streams,” says Terrence Keeley, a top official at BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager. Moreover, federal money is both limited in scope and slow to be released. State and local governments must not only provide significant portions of the funding themselves but also must wait (usually for years) to be reimbursed by Washington for most of their spending. When one of us departed his post at the Department of Transportation, over $150 billion in infrastructure funds were still being processed. The FIB’s funding – like that of any private financial institution serving the needs of investors and borrowers, public and private – would be flexible and efficient, which will put more projects and people to work sooner. An FIB would devote a sizable proportion of its funds to rural projects and work with state infrastructure banks. One of us served as executive director of the California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank (IBank), whose bonds are rated AAA. IBank, which has completed $43 billion in financings since 1994, could be a major beneficiary of the FIB, which can act as a wholesale lender to state I-banks, most of which are dormant due to lack of funds. The need is especially great today. It will take years to disburse the IIJA’s funds. Meanwhile, supply chains are constrained by failing infrastructure, which causes higher prices for America’s consumers. In its new Blueprint 2025 Initiative, CG/LA Infrastructure, a leading authority on project development, listed ten recommendations for the year ahead. One is to “establish a national infrastructure bank . . . that is privately owned, managed, and funded, similar to the Federal Home Loan Bank.” The IIJA can’t do the job alone. To sustain expansive infrastructure funding and bring Americans the infrastructure they need and deserve, a private bank with federal oversight is the best solution.
Solves Competitiveness
Facilitating private investment in infrastructure projects solves modernization and competitiveness
BPC in 2016
Bipartisan Policy Center; BPC staff produced this report in collaboration with a distinguished group of senior advisers and experts. BPC would like to thank Aaron Klein, Fellow, Economic Studies and Policy Director, Initiative on Business and Public Policy, the Brookings Institution, and the council's staff for their contributions and continued support; Bridging the Gap Together: A New Model to Modernize U.S. lnfrastructure; https://bipartisanpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/BPC-New-Infrastructure-Model.pdf
We have an extraordinary opportunity in America — to confront the pressure being placed on our nation's roads, water systems, ports, airports, and energy grid with available private capital. This report establishes the frame work to unite projects that need funding with private capital ready to invest in a transparent system that allocates risks and resources to the public 's benefit. America is a nation of innovators — we are inspiring new industries through interconnected devices, commercializing suborbital space flight, and advancing cures to life-threatening diseases. Yet if we hope to foster the next generation of entrepreneurs that can push our economy forward and maintain our quality of life, we must invest in our infrastructure. Wise infrastructure investments would create millions of jobs, maintain the health, safety, and security of our communities, and set our nation on track for decades of greater prosperity. This is a choice between action and paralysis. Not making decisions today has serious consequences for tomorrow. We are already confronting prior mistakes as our infrastructure today is failing us. We are living at risk: driving every day on eroding roadways, questioning whether our water is really safe to drink, and sending our children off to schools built for our parents' generation. The problem is growing worse. It shouldn't be this way in a country that for so long has led and inspired the world. The Challenge We Face: Short-Term Focus Fuels Mounting Liabilities The investments made 50 to 100 years ago are nearing the end of their useful life. We have no coordinated vision or plan for their replacement. And public agencies have struggled to maintain existing assets or plan for their replacement, let alone to make the investments necessary to support future population growth and economic needs. The price tag to adequately prepare America for the future is hefty — likely requiring trillions of dollars to upgrade, modernize, and expand our infrastructure. Long-term needs — operations and maintenance, repair, expansion and modernization of infrastructure systems — are too often ignored in favor of a focus on short-term costs. There are many competing demands for public resources — healthcare, public pensions, and existing debt — that are expected to overwhelm public budgets. If we are to meet our nation's future needs and preserve our American quality of life, the public sector cannot continue to cover the cost and absorb the risk of our degrading infrastructure alone. We have to act before lasting damage is done to our economy and the next infrastructure- related failure consumes another American community. The Solution Is Clear: Long—Term Outlook Compels New Model, Delivers More Infrastructure There is another way. The private sector stands ready to partner and assist — bringing an appetite for risk, necessary capital, and valuable expertise. Investors with hundreds of billions of dollars to deploy are actively seeking infrastructure projects to support. Unfortunately, there are a number of barriers preventing the investment of private capital into US. infrastructure projects. As a result, America is leaving dollars on the table as capital flows to more receptive shores. Together the public and private sectors can establish a new model for infrastructure investment that confronts risk and captures value over a project's full life-cycle — propelling America's infrastructure into a modern, technologically advanced, and integrated network that enables prosperity long into the future. Our council aims to increase the flow of private capital into US. infrastructure projects — by: - addressing the pervasive underappreciation of future infrastructure liabilities in America; - encouraging partnerships with the private sector to share risks and maximize the value the public receives from infrastructure assets; - ensuring communities across the country have tools to make necessary investments. The challenge before us is enormous, but we have the resources to address it — if we can overcome the barriers that are pushing those resources away.
Infrastructure investment bank solves competitiveness and jobs by leveraging private capital instead of government spending
Business Wire 2020
Proposed Privately-Funded Infrastructure Bank Offers Innovative Solution to U.S. National Infrastructure Crisis; https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20200731005118/en/Proposed-Privately-Funded-Infrastructure-Bank-Offers-Innovative-Solution
U.S. House members have filed a bill to set up a private infrastructure bank designed to provide more than one trillion dollars to rebuild America's crumbling bridges, tunnels, roads, railways, airports, electric grid and more. The new bank could break a logjam in Congress that has lasted more than a decade. Republicans and Democrats, Congress and the President all say they recognize the need for reviving U.S. infrastructure, but there is no money in the Treasury to fund projects. As highways, dams, ports and utilities across the U.S. face a state of decay, repeated attempts at federal legislation to address the problem have clearly demonstrated that government funding is not the answer. The bank outlined in the bill would require no government funding or loan guarantees. The current bill, H.R. 7231 – Infrastructure Bank for America Act of 2020, proposes to establish a federally chartered bank that will be privately owned, privately managed and privately funded, removing partisan priorities and spending. The bill’s initial sponsors are Rep. Daniel Webster (R, FL-11), Rep. Daniel Meuser (R, PA-9), Rep. Doug LaMalfa (R, CA-1), Rep. Tom Reed (R, NY-23). They represent major urban, industrial and rural areas and are seeking broad bipartisan support. The founders of the Infrastructure Bank for America (IBA) plan to establish a trillion-dollar wholesale bank modelled after the highly successful Federal Home Loan Bank (FHLB), established in 1932 to pump money into the economy in response to the Great Depression. “Infrastructure is the foundation of all economic activity; as it crumbles, so does our economy,” said William T. Nolan, president of Infra-Bk, LLC, the development entity that plans to establish the new bank. “There are ample funds worldwide willing to invest in U.S. infrastructure. As a private bank, The Infrastructure Bank for America will provide a conduit to access those funds and direct them to areas in need across the U.S.” A major benefit to the IBA plan is that it will divert some of the trillions of dollars currently being invested in China into the U.S. economy. IBA will provide a new investment vehicle for private investors including domestic and global institutions, corporations, retirement funds, and more. It will strengthen both infrastructure and the economy, funding projects that will create jobs nationwide, while enabling the U.S. to regain its footing on the global playing field.
Federal Action Key
Lack of federal promotion is the key barrier to private investment in infrastructure
BPC in 2016
Bipartisan Policy Center; BPC staff produced this report in collaboration with a distinguished group of senior advisers and experts. BPC would like to thank Aaron Klein, Fellow, Economic Studies and Policy Director, Initiative on Business and Public Policy, the Brookings Institution, and the council's staff for their contributions and continued support; Bridging the Gap Together: A New Model to Modernize U.S. lnfrastructure; https://bipartisanpolicy.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/03/BPC-New-Infrastructure-Model.pdf
Private investment in infrastructure is happening around the globe, serving as a major source of capital in countries such as Canada, Australia, and the UK. Yet, here in the United States it is rare, due to a number of unique barriers associated with the American market. We identified three major risks hindering the flow of private capital to US. infrastructure: the lack of a project pipeline, political risk, and permitting risk. Lack of a project pipeline. The key barrier is the lack of identified projects that are both attractive to private investors and tied to a clear public benefit. Public agencies, including the federal government, are not conducting the analyses needed to put forward projects that satisfy these criteria, so there are few opportunities for private investment.
NB = Inflation DA
FIB mobilizes existing capital to fund infrastructure- it doesn’t require any new federal spending
David Dreier August 17, 2020
Dreier served 22 years in the U.S. House of Representatives, including 10 years as chairman of the Rules Committee. He chairs the Annenberg-Dreier Commission, which seeks to strengthen the free flow of goods, services, capital, ideas, information and people throughout the greater Pacific region; How to Rebuild America at No Cost to Taxpayers; Real Clear Policy; https://www.realclearpolicy.com/articles/2020/08/17/how_to_rebuild_america_at_no_cost_to_taxpayers_574293.html
Meanwhile, we desperately need to restart an economy ravaged by COVID. This is the time. Interest rates are at rock-bottom, and investors are ready to deploy capital in the world’s largest market. Massive investment in infrastructure will quickly put Americans to work at home improving roads, bridges, sewage systems, energy pipelines, an electric grid that ranks 26th in the world, airports that are a global embarrassment, and much more. What’s missing? Money. A 2017 report card on the condition of infrastructure from the American Society of Civil Engineers gave the U.S. a grade of D+ and estimated that $4.5 trillion was required by 2025 for remediation; that figure is now $1.5 trillion higher. While there is bipartisan will in Congress and the White House to address the problem, the cupboard is bare. The U.S. faces a record $3.7 trillion budget deficit this year. Reviving infrastructure, however, does not require taxpayer dollars. A new private institution can attract investment money from around the world and put it to work in rebuilding projects in the United States. That institution is a nationwide infrastructure bank that requires zero federal funding or loan guarantees. As a “non-bank bank,” it would take no deposits. Its model is the Federal Home Loan Bank (FHLB) system, which is privately owned, managed, and funded. With $1.3 trillion in assets, the FHLB has been a safe source of funds for the U.S. housing market for the past 88 years. During the 2008 financial crisis, for example, the FHLB provided $1 trillion in advances when other sources of credit dried up. The U.S. is the only major developed country without an infrastructure bank. The European Investment Bank (EIB) has helped Europe become “more adept than America at mobilizing private capital for public infrastructure,” writes Terrence Keeley, global head of the official institutions group at BlackRock, the largest investment management firm in the world. The EIB is credited with creating 1.7 million jobs. The U.S. has state infrastructure banks, but most are moribund or tiny. The proposed new private infrastructure bank would provide funding to help revive these state banks so they can put money to work. Funds, as well, would go to private-sector projects. According to a Cato Institute study, just 3% of fixed assets are held by the federal government, 19% by state and local governments, and 78% by private owners. No matter who owns the assets, every trillion-dollar investment creates 12 million new jobs, according to Georgetown University researchers. There are hundreds of important projects waiting for the funding an infrastructure bank could offer: the Camden Spaceport in Georgia, the Gateway Tunnels in New York and New Jersey, the Texas Central Railway (high-speed train line), the Sites Reservoir in California, and many more. Where would the money come from? The U.S. is a magnet for investors around the world — investment and pension funds, sovereign wealth funds, wealthy individuals, banks and other financial institutions. What these investors demand is a responsible manager for their money, a bank that can select and oversee the right projects to produce a profit. The federal government’s role — as outlined in a bill introduced just last month, the Infrastructure Bank for America Act — would be to charter the bank, oversee it, and offer a tax credit. The five-year credit would amount to 10% annually of the amount of equity an investor purchases in the bank. This is not an unusual incentive for directing funds to socially valuable projects, and the foregone revenues would pale in comparison to the hundreds of billions that the Treasury would receive in new taxes from the projects. The equity would provide the capital cushion that all banks need, and shareholders would elect directors, who in turn would hire management — all without political interference. The Federal Reserve would provide oversight for the bank, which would be designated, like any large commercial bank, as a SIFI, or systemically important financial institution, to ensure its safety. The Fed might also use funds from its quantitative easing program to buy infrastructure bank bonds – purchases that have no effect on the federal debt. A national private infrastructure bank will make America a better, more productive place to live – all the while generating millions of new jobs at no cost to taxpayers a time of high unemployment. The question now is whether Democrats and Republicans can get together in this time of crisis to rebuild America.
UI Solvency Evidence
General
Permanent federal reform to unemployment benefits is good and solves.
Gwyn 22 [Nick Gwyn, “Historic Unemployment Programs Provided Vital Support to Workers and the Economy During Pandemic, Offer Roadmap for Future Reform,” Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, 3/24/2022, cbpp.org/research/economy/historic-unemployment-programs-provided-vital-support-to-workers-and-the-economy]
Promoting Equity
The regular federal-state UI system was providing coverage to less than a third of jobless workers before the pandemic, and o

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.