Geoengineering CP - CNDI 2023
Geoengineering CP - CNDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Geoengineering CP Advantage CP to solve warming. Avoids Natural Gas DA and other GND Neg. Neg 1nc Text: The United States federal government should adopt sufficient geoengineering measures to solve climate change. Solar geoengineering can reverse global warming – it’s cheap, fast, and flexible Conca ‘19 [James Conca has been a PhD scientist in the field of the earth and environmental sciences for 35 years and is a Forbes contributor., 09-10-2019, "Why Solar Geoengineering May Be Our Only Hope To Reverse Global Warming," Forbes, https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2019/09/10/solar-geoengineering-we-better-do-it-or-well-burn/?sh=5f7cadb818ad] Solar geoengineering is the process by which humans deliberately reduce the effect of heat-trapping greenhouses gases by reflecting a small fraction of sunlight back into space. It sounds strange, but it isn’t as odd, or as difficult, as it might seem. And we know that it works because it happens every time a huge volcano erupts. And we’ve been studying those for over 100 years. [image omitted] Some serious scientific mojo has been applied to this idea at universities around the world. Harvard’s Solar Geoengineering Research Program is a research initiative devoted entirely to the science, technology and public policy of solar geoengineering. But too few scientists, and too little funding, has been applied to this solution. Which is sad since it doesn’t need much. There are several technologies for this approach, including injection of aerosols (fine droplets or particulates as fine as powder) into the stratosphere, where they would scatter some sunlight back to space, thus cooling the planet by reducing the amount of heat that enters the lower atmosphere (see figure). Marine cloud brightening is another way to reflect solar radiation back into space. This would use automated ships to spray droplets of seawater into the atmosphere above the ocean where they evaporate to form an elevated concentration of sea-salt aerosols which seed higher concentrations of cloud droplets in clouds over the ocean, increasing their reflectivity (see figure). [image comitted] According to one the fields long-time researchers, Dr. David Keith at Harvard, solar geoengineering could limit global warming’s predicted side effects such as sea level rise and changes in precipitation and other weather patterns. Because these changes would have their most powerful impact on the world’s most vulnerable people, who lack the resources to move or adapt, Keith finds a strong ethical case for research into solar geoengineering. Besides, we’ve been geoengineering the atmosphere for over a century - in the wrong direction – by injecting huge amounts of CO2 and other greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere. Let’s face it. As a species, we just have not risen to the occasion of fighting the planetary crisis of global warming. And by all measures we’re not going to. Global emissions are continuing to rise. Oil and gas keep getting cheaper and easier to find, and coal is the easiest energy source to emplace in a poor country with little infrastructure. To bring this home, all you have to do is see how climate scientists are seeking psychiatric help for the depression, anxiety and PTSD that happens when you see a train wreck coming but no one seems to want to do anything about it - and you’re on the train. And America seems to have gone on a carbon binge. We’re producing more oil, gas and coal than any other country, and more than ever before. Along with trying to repeal over 80 environmental rules going back to the Nixon Administration, the Trump Administration has moved to eliminate federal curbs on methane emissions from oil and gas operations. Even the oil companies don’t want this. Prior to the United States pulling out of the Paris climate accords, there was growing skepticism that the world could, or would, decrease its total greenhouse gas emissions by 2040 enough to actually prevent the worst of global warming. All climate models show that the next 20 years is critical. The best we can do is keep warming to 3 to 4°F, and that only if we get global emissions to zero by 2040. If we don’t, temperatures rise by 6 to 8°F. That’s because CO2 has a half-life in the atmosphere between 30 and 300 years, depending on the various chemical mechanisms that naturally remove CO2 from the atmosphere. And that’s just the half-life. We have to start reducing emission now by almost 10% per year until 2040 when anthropogenic emissions will have to be zero. We are extremely unlikely to meet this target - global emissions are still growing and it looks like we will not even start declining for at least 10 more years. At that time we would have to reduce emissions by 20% per year. Let me state that clearly – there is no way to reduce carbon emissions in the next 20 years sufficient to mitigate the worst effects of climate change. This is sobering indeed. But don’t get too bummed because it’s not the end. Many scientists have wondered how to either remove GHGs from the atmosphere or mitigate the effects some other way. Indeed, an entire scientific discipline has evolved around this issue and some great work has been done. Removing GHGs is really difficult and really expensive. Much more expensive than preventing them from entering in the first place. So if we refuse to spend the amount of money and effort needed to reduce emissions, we certainly wouldn’t spend even more trying to get them back out. But we still need to try. [image omitted] The other strategy is to mitigate the effects of warming by directly cooling the planet. Cooling occurs naturally when millions of tons of particles such as soot from huge fires, particulates and gasses from large volcanic eruptions, or excessive amounts of ice crystals, enter the atmosphere and either block incoming solar rays or reflect them back into space. Enter Solar Geoengineering. Solar geoengineering should not replace reducing emissions (mitigation), coping with a changing climate (adaptation), or carbon dioxide removal and sequestration. Solar geoengineering does not change the CO2 concentrations in the atmosphere, it treats a symptom - heat. It’s like putting some serious sunblock on Planet Earth, giving us time to figure out how to lower our carbon emissions to near-zero. Changing the Earth’s albedo, or reflectivity, is what these strategies target. Lower albedos capture and hold solar radiation, higher albedos reflect it back. Speaking as a geologist, we have seen the cooling effects of big fires and big volcanoes in the geologic record going back many millions of years, so we know it works, and how it works. When the huge volcano Krakatoa erupted in 1883, the billions of tons of particulates thrown into the stratosphere dropped global temperatures about two degrees. But as the particulates came out of the atmosphere over the next few years, the effect went away. [image omitted] But these natural processes are uncontrolled and in many cases cause very big adverse environmental changes themselves. Of course, the particulates and gases coming out of a volcano are not the ones we would choose in solar geoengineering. And that’s the whole point of research, says Dr. Tom Ackerman at the University of Washington Department of Atmospheric Sciences. Because we have studied large volcanic eruptions like Krakatoa, Tambora and Pinatubo, there aren’t any real basic science unknowns. We know that stratospheric aerosols can achieve cooling that offsets half of the warming from a doubling of CO2 concentrations. It’s just figuring out how to do it effectively without causing other problems. By choosing where to release the aerosols, a uniform global aerosol layer could be created. Its thickness could be varied as needed - thicker at high latitudes or in one hemisphere or the other - in order to craft a desired outcome. Within certain limits. As Keith describes, solar geoengineering has three essential characteristics: it is cheap, fast and imperfect. Long-established estimates show that solar geoengineering is at least 100 times cheaper than cutting emissions in offsetting the expected global temperature rise through 2100. A few grams of particles in the stratosphere can offset the radiative forcing of a metric ton of atmospheric carbon dioxide. At about US$1,000 a metric ton for aerosol delivery, that adds up to maybe a billion dollars per year, not the trillions of dollars it will take to replace all fossil fuels with hydro, nuclear and renewables. And $50 to $100 million a year for about 10 years is all it would take to do the research needed to figure out how to do this right. That’s barely the cost of a single fighter jet, not much for saving the planet and half the species on it. Not to fund this research program is like being too cheap to buy sunblock, knowing skin cancer runs in your family. This research will answer a lot of things, even the ethics questions of whether we should do it at all. But if you don’t do the research in the next ten years, you may not be able to implement this correctly when you realize we need to do this fast. And others may do it anyway, without the care we might show. The Chinese have specifically said they will do exactly this if things get too out of hand with global warming. And they have a robust research program already underway. [image omitted] As Joseph Lassiter of Harvard calculates, “Assuming humanity continued to make a net addition of CO2 into the atmosphere every year for a decade, and some of the sulfate aerosol shield would dissipate every year, continuous injections of greater amounts of sulfates would be needed each year in order to maintain the concentration required to manage the earth’s temperature.” For example, in the first year it would take about 25,000 metric tons of sulfates dispensed by 1 or 2 aircraft to offset about 50% of that year’s increase in warming. In order to maintain the 50% reduction, in year two, about 50,000 tons of sulfates would need to be dispensed and so on each year into the future. After 10 years this number would reach over a million metric tons of sulfates dispensed by 100 aircraft. This is still not much. And we should finally start decreasing carbon emissions after 2030, decreasing over the next few decades until we no longer need solar geoengineering. Let’s be clear - solar geoengineering is not to be done, or even considered, as a replacement for cutting carbon emissions. It’s just to buy us the several decades we need to actually cut emissions to near zero without frying the planet. This is because solar geoengineering cannot eliminate all of the damages caused by green-house gas-driven warming, even if it tried to restore global average temperatures to pre-industrial levels. Compared to the warming caused by GHGs - which trap long wave radiation - climate variables such as temperature and precipitation respond differently to cooling caused by solar geoengineering which reflects short wave radiation. For example, if temperatures were restored to pre-industrial levels by solar geoengineering, the water cycle would be weaker than it was in the 1700s. An important point to remember about solar geoengineering is that it inherently self-limiting. You have to keep doing it continuously until we get a handle on emissions. If you stop, the effect goes away in a year or two as the aerosols come out of the atmosphere, just like happens a few years after every huge volcanic eruption. But this turns out to be a good thing. Solar geoengineering can be adjusted easily and relatively quickly, even reversed, if you don’t like the effects. We wouldn’t have to accept even a few degrees temperature increase, we could keep it the way we want it, even cool off a bit back to where we were 100 years ago. As Keith puts it, “Because the warming impact of carbon is more or less forever [on biological lifetimes], all that we can achieve this century by cutting emissions is to stop making the problem worse. Solar geoengineering allows a more optimistic outcome. In combination with technologies to remove carbon that is already in the atmosphere, it would allow humanity to aim to restore the preindustrial climate over two human lifetimes.” 2nc – Solvency Geoengineering solves climate – growing scientific support. Jacobo et al. 4/21/23 [Julia Jacobo is a multimedia reporter at ABC News. Daniel Manzo is a meteorologist and weather producer at ABC News. Ginger Zee is the chief meteorologist at ABC News, reporting on the nation’s weather on “Good Morning America” and across ABC News broadcasts and digital platforms., 4-21-2023, "These geoengineering technologies could help combat the climate crisis, scientists say," ABC News, https://abcnews.go.com/US/geoengineering-technologies-combat-climate-crisis-scientists/story?id=98476205]//gbs-aarz Climate scientists have been warning for decades of global warming's devastating consequences. Now that the effects of climate change are being experienced around the globe -- droughts, rising sea levels and stronger storm systems -- scientists are exploring how geoengineering technology can help to alleviate the effects of rising temperatures. Here are the different ways these techniques are being used to combat the climate crisis: What to do when there isn't enough precipitation Drought-stricken regions have been left scrambling to ensure water supplies after years of minimal rainfall and snowpack. One of the techniques already being used in several places in the U.S. is weather modification, or cloud seeding, which involves injecting microscopic particles of silver iodide into the atmosphere to encourage rain and snowfall. The particles then act like magnets for water droplets and bind together until they are heavy enough to fall as rain or snow. [image omitted] The practice could boost snowpack by up to 15% in one year, according to a 2020 study authored by Sarah Tessendorf, a researcher at the National Center for Atmospheric Research in Boulder, Colorado. That extra precipitation could be the difference between being able to irrigate agriculture during the last three weeks of the dry season. While the technique has been around for decades, interest has exploded in the past decade due to the decades-long megadrought plaguing the Western U.S., which houses important bodies of water, Garrett Cammans, president of North American Weather Consultants, one of the largest cloud seeding companies in the country, told ABC News. There are currently 42 cloud seeding projects across the U.S. with another 200 stations opening up by next season. [image omitted] The technology is helping to ease the effects of the drought in the American West, which has reduced water levels in the Colorado River, one of the most important river systems in the country. "We’re now seeing flows of the Colorado River we’ve never seen before since records were kept," Brad Udall, senior water and climate research scientist at Colorado State University, told ABC News. The Bureau of Reclamation has pledged $2.4 billion in funding for cloud seeding projects to slow the effects of drought on the Colorado River. Alter how much sunlight the Earth absorbs Solar geoengineering, which would involve pumping aerosols into the atmosphere to reflect sunlight, thus cooling Earth, has been a "controversial" topic in recent years, Paul Wennberg, a professor of atmospheric chemistry and environmental science and engineering at the California Institute of Technology, told ABC News. The tiny particles are released about 10 miles into the stratosphere and create a "reflective blanket," the idea being to reflect about 1% of total incoming sunlight, Chris Field, director of the Stanford Woods Institute for the Environment, told ABC News. "You could basically cool the Earth down because it's absorbing less sunlight," Wennberg said. Scientists already know this is possible due to the eruptions of large, sulfur-rich volcanoes, Wennberg said. About a month after large amounts of sulfur gases are emitted from the volcano into Earth's upper atmosphere, the particles that form reflect away a small amount of sunlight, Wennberg said. Earth's temperature temporarily dropped 1 degree Celsius in 1991 following the large eruption at Mount Pinatubo in the Philippines, according to the U.S. Geological Survey. [image omitted] Solar geoengineering, however, is not considered a viable solution in the long term because the particles will eventually leave the atmosphere and temperatures will return to normal, Wennberg said. Therefore, adding sulfur and other constituents to the stratosphere would need to be a continuous effort. "Not only would you have to do it forever, you'd have to do more and more of it over time," Wennberg said. "And if you ever stopped, the Earth would rebound very, very quickly to the state that you would have without those particles." In addition, the infrared blanket placed over the clouds prevents them from radiating energy upward, which could cause the clouds to break up and lead to strong warming, according to Cal Tech. Other approaches to solar engineering include increasing the abundance of bright, reflective clouds in coastal areas, which could be more effective because they reflect more sunlight going over a smaller part of the Earth's surface, Field said. Pluck the carbon straight out of the atmosphere As greenhouse gases continue to be emitted into Earth's atmosphere, carbon sequestration, the process of capturing and storing atmospheric carbon dioxide, is being touted by experts as an effective way to lower temperatures. The method is aimed "try to clean up the mess we've made," Wennberg said. "It's effectively trying to do what the Earth will do in a millennium if we were to wait," Wennberg said. "But in this case, we're trying to speed it all up so that we can get back to lower atmospheric carbon levels." Geoengineering solves warming at a faster rate than emissions cuts and addresses the root cause of excess CO2. Kulkarni 22 [Sanjana Kulkarni is a PhD candidate in Dr. Maha Farhat's lab at Harvard Medical School. She studies infectious diseases using genomics and machine learning. Before graduate school, she studied bioengineering at Caltech., 01-03-2022, "Reversing Climate Change with Geoengineering," Harvard University: The Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, Science in the News, https://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2022/reversing-climate-change-with-geoengineering/]//gbs-aarz The average global temperature is increasing faster now than at any time in the last 2 million years. This has fueled record-breaking droughts, heat waves, and wildfires, and has intensified weather patterns, causing more extreme and damaging hurricanes and rainfall. Human activity is driving this change, primarily through the emission of carbon dioxide (CO2) and other greenhouse gases, which are released when fossil fuels like coal, oil, and natural gas are burned to produce energy. When sunlight strikes the Earth’s atmosphere, around 30% of it is reflected back out to space, and 70% is incorporated into the climate’s energy system. The Earth radiates some of this absorbed heat out to space, but greenhouse gases in the atmosphere prevent it from escaping. Greenhouse gases are necessary to keep the planet warm enough for living things, but very high concentrations are increasing global temperatures beyond the normal range (Figure 1). Although the best way to slow climate change is to reduce greenhouse emissions by switching to clean energy sources like solar, wind, water, and nuclear energy, the CO2 already in the atmosphere can persist and continue to exert warming effects for centuries. Geoengineering, the large-scale modification of Earth’s climate, is worth exploring because countries have been cutting their emissions too slowly to make any near-term impact on climate change. [image omitted] Giving Earth Some Shade The greenhouse effect increases the amount of sunligh
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.