Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 CNDI Disadvantage

Inflation DA - CNDI 2023

Inflation DA - CNDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Inflation DA – CNDI 23
Notes
Explanation
You can understand this disadvantage as an “Inflation DA,” “Interest Rates DA,” or simply an “Economy DA.”
It argues that if the federal government pursues significant fiscal redistribution it would lead to the Federal Reserve (aka “The Fed”) raising interest rates to combat the real or perceived inflation that results from plan.
The uniqueness is pretty good because the while inflation has been high for a while, the Fed recently paused rate hikes and signaled that inflation is cooling off. The economy is avoiding a recession and we’re recovering from many of the supply issues from Covid. Growth might be slow, but the Fed is ensuring a soft transition.
The link should be massive. A federal jobs guarantee would cost hundreds of billions of dollars in new fiscal spending, but it would also cause wage inflation (functionally raise the minimum wage to $15/hour). Any UBI would require massive spending and give everyone a lot more money to spend, causing a huge increase in aggregate demand throughout the economy. You do have to be careful about the way the aff funds the plan (tax increases vs deficit spending), but the effect of the plan would be inflationary regardless. \
The impact debate is multifaceted and lethal because you can argue that it turns the aff and has external impacts. Choose either the warming or the developing economies impact for your 1nc (ideally you pick an impact that’s not claimed in the 1ac). Both impacts deal directly with raising interest rates (you don’t have to win actual inflation) and identify broader consequences outside the US economy. Still, the most important part of the impact debate will be turning the aff. You need to argue that inflation hurts the economy, causes slow growth, produces inequality and poverty, etc.
For affirmative answers, I’d focus on long-term and inevitable economic issues. On the uniqueness side, the Fed is probably still going to eventually raise interest rates in the future. On the impact side, the aff should be able to win that the current system (which produces inequality, poverty, etc.) is unsustainable.
To get great at this DA you need to know a lot of theory and be comfortable with different terms (think AP Econ). Luckily there are a lot of youtube videos out there and I’d recommend the Investopedia as a go-to website for short readings on each topic.
Good luck!
1NC
1nc – Top
a. Uniqueness: Inflation is decreasing and the Fed has stopped raising interest rates.
Rugaber, 6/14 (Christopher, AP News Journalist, “Fed Chair Powell sees progress on inflation, though not quickly enough,” June 14, 2023, https://apnews.com/article/interest-rates-inflation-federal-reserve-economy-f6318be5023f6e50afc115778c9ec174
WASHINGTON (AP) — Inflation may be cooling — just not yet fast enough for the Federal Reserve. Chair Jerome Powell offered a nuanced view Wednesday of how the Fed intends to address its core challenge at a time when inflation is both way below its peak but still well above the central bank’s 2% target: Give it more time, and maybe some help from additional interest rate hikes. Yet on a hopeful note, Powell also suggested that the trends that are needed to further slow inflation, from lower apartment rents to slower-growing wages, are starting to click into place. As a result, the Fed decided Wednesday to forgo another increase in its benchmark interest rate, leaving it at about 5.1%. The pause followed 10 straight hikes in 15 months — the fastest series of increases in four decades. By leaving rates alone, at least for now, Powell and other top Fed officials hope to use the extra time to more fully assess how higher borrowing rates have affected inflation and the economy. They also want to see whether the collapse of three large banks this spring will weigh on lending and growth. In a surprisingly hawkish signal, the Fed’s policymakers issued projections Wednesday showing they envision as many as two additional quarter-point rate hikes before the year ends. (In Fed parlance, “hawks” generally favor higher rates to quell inflation, while “doves” typically advocate lower rates to aid a healthy job market.) Before this week’s policy meeting, Fed watchers had expected the policymakers to signal just one more rate increase this year. In their new projections, the members of the Fed’s interest-rate committee were less divided than many economists had expected, with 12 of the 18 policymakers foreseeing at least two more quarter-point rate increases. Four favored one quarter-point hike. Only two envisioned keeping rates unchanged. The policymakers also predicted that their benchmark rate will stay higher for longer than they envisioned three months ago. Powell noted that wage growth has slowed and cited some signs that the job market is cooling. Those factors, he added, should reduce inflationary pressures. “I would almost say that the conditions that we need to see in place to get inflation down are coming into place,” Powell said. “But the process of that actually working on inflation is going to take some time.” Inflation dropped to 4% in May compared with a year earlier, down sharply from a 9.1% peak last June. And many economists expect it to decline further. Rental costs are falling, and used car prices, which spiked in April and May, are also likely to drop. Yet Powell underscored that the Fed will need to feel confident that inflation is moving steadily closer to its 2% target. “We’re two and a quarter years into this, and forecasters, including Fed forecasters, have consistently thought that inflation was about to turn down ... and been wrong,” he said. “We want to get inflation down to 2%, and we just don’t see that yet.” At the same time, Powell stopped short of saying the Fed’s policymakers have committed to resuming their hikes when they next meet in late July. At one point in the news conference, he referred to Wednesday’s decision as a “skip,” which would imply that the Fed planned to raise rates at the July meeting. He then corrected himself: “I shouldn’t call it a skip,” he said. But Powell emphasized that the Fed wants to move more slowly after its breakneck pace last year, when it carried out four straight three-quarter-point hikes, followed by a half-point increase and then three quarter-point hikes this year. The Fed’s aggressive streak of rate hikes, which have made mortgages, auto loans, credit cards and business borrowing costlier, have been intended to slow spending and defeat the worst bout of inflation in four decades. Average credit card rates have surpassed 20% to a record high. “Given how far we have come, it may make sense for rates to move higher but at a more moderate pace,” he said. “It’s just the idea that we’re trying to get this right.” Should inflation come down further, some economists think the Fed may not actually have to raise rates again. “With inflation set to moderate noticeably, we are skeptical that the Fed will resume hiking interest rates,” Ryan Sweet, chief U.S. economist of Oxford Economics, wrote in a note. “Our baseline forecast is for the Fed to remain on hold through the remainder of this year before gradually easing in early 2024.”
b. Link: The plan freaks out the Fed – they see full employment as inflationary – that causes a return to rate hikes.
Popli ’23 (Nik, reporter at TIME, he covers economic policy and national politics, “It Could Be Harder to Find a Job and Get a Pay Raise if the Fed Gets Its Way,” FEBRUARY 9, 2023, https://time.com/6253699/federal-reserve-inflation-interest-rates-workers/)
Despite the good news, Fed officials were “probably hoping for more of a slowdown in the jobs report,” says David Wessel, director of the Hutchins Center on Fiscal & Monetary Policy at the Brookings Institution. “What we’ve seen in the last couple of months with a falling rate of inflation and slowing wage growth at a very tight and strong labor market does challenge the conventional wisdom on which economists, including those at the Fed, generally rely,” Wessel tells TIME. In his first public comments since the jobs report, Powell acknowledged this week that the jump in hiring was “stronger than anyone I know expected” and that the process of getting inflation back to normal levels will require some pain for workers. “There has been an expectation that it will go away quickly and painlessly—and I don’t think that’s at all guaranteed,” Powell said during a moderated discussion before the Economic Club of Washington, D.C. on Tuesday. “The base case for me is that it will take some time, and we’ll have to do more rate increases, and then we’ll have to look around and see whether we’ve done enough.” To Powell and central bankers, the hiring boom is viewed as an obstacle in its fight to corral the fastest inflation in decades. Officials are also worried that wage growth could stop inflation from returning to their 2% target, another of the Fed’s aims that puts its interests at odds with American wage-earners. Wessel points out, for instance, that the Fed was likely glad to see the pace of wage increases come down. Average hourly pay grew 4.4% in January from a year earlier, down from a peak of 5.6% in March. The Fed’s long-standing belief is that a job market with strong hiring and increased wages typically fuels higher inflation. Under this economic model, consumers are more likely to spend freely when they have higher incomes, and companies tend to raise their prices to help cover climbing labor costs. It might seem odd to regard wage increases as a problem, but the Fed’s approach highlights the harsh trade-offs at the heart of the battle against inflation: To keep prices stable, it needs to be harder for workers to find a job and get a pay raise, according to the Fed. The central bank has been aggressively increasing interest rates to slow the economy and bring inflation back to around its 2% target. Last Wednesday, the Fed raised its benchmark interest rate for an eighth time since March, although at a slower pace, and indicated that further increases were probable. Fed Chair Powell has suggested that hard times are coming, particularly for workers. “I wish there were a completely painless way to restore price stability,” Powell said at a news conference on Dec. 14. “There isn’t.” Reich believes that the Fed has been too focused on the dangers of a tight labor market leading to higher wages, a stance that he says “neglects the other side of their mandate—to promote maximum employment.” For the most part, the approach appears to be working to reduce inflation—but not without painful consequences. Price increases are moderating, and some economists think consumers have seen the worst of it. The Consumer Price Index, which is the government’s main inflation gauge, rose 6.5% year-over-year in December, down from a peak increase of 9.1% recorded in June. But last month’s labor benchmarks tell a different story. The unemployment rate dropped to a new 53-year low of 3.4% as employers added an explosive 517,000 jobs. And despite the pain of inflation, most businesses have appeared busy over the last year—from airplanes to restaurants to stores. The Fed’s main inflation-fighting tool is its ability to move interest rates, effectively raising the cost of borrowing money and ultimately slowing the economy. But to some economists and labor experts, this isn’t the most effective tool. “The Fed is using the one tool it has—raising interest rates—and that’s dangerous,” says Reich, who believes the Fed is showing callous disregard for the economic welfare of millions of Americans by pursuing policy that stunts job growth. “The people who are most likely to lose their jobs and certainly who are no longer getting wage increases are poor and low-income people, who are disproportionately, people of color and women,” Reich says. “They are the ones who are being drafted into the inflation fight when the economy slows. They’re the first to lose their jobs, just as they are the last to get jobs when the economy tightens.” Most estimates say that unemployment will have to reach as high as 7.5%, more than double its current level, to get inflation down to the Fed’s target of 2%. “The Fed wants more unemployment,” Wessel says. “[Chair] Jerome Powell keeps saying that, well, maybe we can just reduce the number of unfilled jobs, the job vacancies without anybody actually losing their job, but that’s a bit harder.”
1nc – Warming Impact
c. Impacts:
1. Rate hikes reverse the green energy transition – guarantees climate change.
Ferguson and Storm ’23 (Thomas Ferguson is professor emeritus at the University of Massachusetts, Boston, and director of research at the Institute for New Economic Thinking, Servaas Storm is a senior lecturer at the Delft University of Technology, “Central banks raising interest rates makes it harder to fight the climate crisis,” 6 May 2023, https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/may/06/central-banks-interest-rate-hike-climate-crisis)-mikee
Higher rates slow the renewable energy transition and shield oil and gas producers from competition by low-carbon producers In late 2021, consumer price inflation surged in many countries. Prices shot up again following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. In response, central banks drastically tightened monetary policy – raising interest rates from near zero to around 5% or more. Since the interest rate hikes have failed to bring down core inflation to the target rate of 2% favored by the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank (ECB), the pressure for further rate hikes has been insistent. We have long doubted that central bank rate rises could control the new inflation at a socially acceptable price. In most countries, wages lag well behind inflation. Too much of the rise in prices clearly reflects the impact of higher profit margins and obvious supply bottlenecks. In such conditions, leaving control of inflation to central banks is like asking an old-time central bank to fix a harvest failure. Only targeted policies to increase output and control profit margins in strategic sectors, not general increases in the price of borrowed money, have much chance of working. But relying on central bank rate rises in the current situation is folly for another reason: the reality of the climate crisis, which now greatly complicates the task of central banks and policymakers. One reason is obvious: higher interest rates considerably slow down the renewable energy transition. This happens in two ways. First, newly applied renewable energy technologies, which have relatively large front-loaded costs, are more competitive (relative to the already installed fossil fuel technologies) only when interest rates are low. Engineering studies show that the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of solar photovoltaics (PV) and wind onshore will increase by 11% and 25%, respectively, if interest rates are 4-4.5% (rather than around zero). Investments in new renewable energy capacity are thus only viable if market prices allow them to earn their full LCOE. Estimates by the International Energy Agency suggest that the LCOE of a gas-fired power plant would increase by about 4% if interest rates were to increase from 3% to 7%, whereas that of offshore wind and solar PV (utility scale) could rise by more than 30%. Second, high interest rates shield legacy oil and gas producers from the competition of up-and-coming low-carbon energy producers. They will enable oil and gas giants to continue to maximize revenues from their decaying, sun-setting assets; oil in particular can keep charging more and more for less and less for a long time. The year 2022 already gave us a flavor of the shape of things to come: Exxon posted $56bn in net profits for the year, while all oil majors combined made close to net $200bn. These windfall profits are very good news for shareholders, as Exxon is planning to spend $30bn on share repurchases in 2023 and another $50bn in 2024. But they are bad news for the rest of us – as high interest rates de-incentivize investments in renewables, lock our economies more deeply into fossil-fuel dependence, slow down decarbonization and put us even more strongly on the road to hothouse Earth.
2. Climate change causes extinction – it triggers every impact.
Kemp et al. '22 [Luke Kemp: Centre for the Study of Existential Risk, University of Cambridge; Chi Xu: School of Life Sciences, Nanjing University; Joanna Depledge: Cambridge Centre for Environment, Energy and Natural Resource Governance, University of Cambridge; Kristie L. Ebi: Center for Health and the Global Environment, University of Washington; Goodwin Gibbins: Future of Humanity Institute, University of Oxford; Timothy A. Kohler: Department of Anthropology, Washington State University; Johan Rockström: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research; Marten Scheffer: Department of Environmental Sciences, University of Wageningen; Hans Joachim Schellnhuber: Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research; Will Steffen: Fenner School of Environment and Society, The Australian National University; Timothy M. Lenton: Global Systems Institute, University of Exeter; PNAS;"Climate Endgame: Exploring catastrophic climate change scenarios"; 5-20-2021; published by PNAS; accessed 4-3-2023; https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2108146119#sec-3; ror]
The Potential for Climate Catastrophe There are four key reasons to be concerned over the potential of a global climate catastrophe. First, there are warnings from history. Climate change (either regional or global) has played a role in the collapse or transformation of numerous previous societies (37) and in each of the five mass extinction events in Phanerozoic Earth history (38). The current carbon pulse is occurring at an unprecedented geological speed and, by the end of the century, may surpass thresholds that triggered previous mass extinctions (39, 40). The worst-case scenarios in the IPCC report project temperatures by the 22nd century that last prevailed in the Early Eocene, reversing 50 million years of cooler climates in the space of two centuries (41). This is particularly alarming, as human societies are locally adapted to a specific climatic niche. The rise of large-scale, urbanized agrarian societies began with the shift to the stable climate of the Holocene ∼12,000 y ago (42). Since then, human population density peaked within a narrow climatic envelope with a mean annual average temperature of ∼13 °C. Even today, the most economically productive centers of human activity are concentrated in those areas (43). The cumulative impacts of warming may overwhelm societal adaptive capacity. Second, climate change could directly trigger other catastrophic risks, such as international conflict, or exacerbate infectious disease spread, and spillover risk. These could be potent extreme threat multipliers. Third, climate change could exacerbate vulnerabilities and cause multiple, indirect stresses (such as economic damage, loss of land, and water and food insecurity) that coalesce into system-wide synchronous failures. This is the path of systemic risk. Global crises tend to occur through such reinforcing “synchronous failures” that spread across countries and systems, as with the 2007–2008 global financial crisis (44). It is plausible that a sudden shift in climate could trigger systems failures that unravel societies across the globe. The potential of systemic climate risk is marked: The most vulnerable states and communities will continue to be the hardest hit in a warming world, exacerbating inequities. Fig. 1 shows how projected population density intersects with extreme >29 °C mean annual temperature (MAT) (such temperatures are currently restricted to only 0.8% of Earth’s land surface area). Using the medium-high scenario of emissions and population growth (SSP3-7.0 emissions, and SSP3 population growth), by 2070, around 2 billion people are 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.