UBI Neg - CNDI 2023
UBI Neg - CNDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
UBI NEG Innovation Adv UBI Hurts Economy There are many jobs available, but UBI would lower the labor force, causing a decline in economic growth. Minogue 18 (Rachel, Senior Analyst on Supply Chain Resiliency, International Trade Administration, “Five Problems with Universal Basic Income,” Third Way, 5/24/2018, https://www.thirdway.org/memo/five-problems-with-universal-basic-income#:~:text=UBI%20has%20the%20potential%20to,resulting%20in%20lower%20overall%20prosperity.) Many of the most ardent UBI supporters believe the policy is an answer to a world where work is vanishing. This is a popular view in Silicon Valley, where many predict widespread technological unemployment is just around the corner.4 But there is almost no evidence that work is ending. Instead, work is changing. The US economy employs more people today than ever, with 37 million jobs added since the introduction of Microsoft Windows in 1993 and 190,000 new jobs created per month over the last year on average.5 As Baby Boomers retire, the US working-age population will grow more slowly than the economy as a whole. For that reason, the US is just as likely to experience a shortage of labor to fill growing jobs as it is to have a labor market oversaturated with workers.6 Many professions are rising in demand today, including those in health care, advanced manufacturing, skilled construction, education, technology, hospitality, and business management. At this very moment, there are 6 million job openings across the country, more than half of which are middle-class jobs or better.7 While we may see a net gain in jobs over the coming years, disruption will still be rampant. These jobs will be in different locations, require different skills, and offer different benefits. That’s why we need policies that help workers adjust to these new realities—not surrender. Reinventing postsecondary education to create more options outside of a four-year college degree, as well as redesigning worker pay and benefits, would do far more for the next generation of workers. With a foundational, albeit limited, income under UBI, some Americans may choose to work part-time instead of full-time. Others may leave the labor force for years when they would have otherwise worked. Eduardo Porter writes that, as almost one quarter of US households make less than $25,000 a year, a $10,000 check each for two parents could change their decisions on how to balance work, child care, and other obligations, resulting in less full-time participation in the labor force.8 If people transition away from full-time work, the US economy would suffer. Macroeconomic theory holds that economic growth is dependent on three factors: increases in capital, advances in technology, and growth of the labor force. UBI has the potential to directly decrease the growth of the US economy, namely GDP growth, through reductions to labor force participation. With GDP shrinking, tax revenues would fall. This would in turn mean fewer resources to help the disadvantaged or to invest in the future, resulting in lower overall prosperity. UBI is a bad idea for the economy – it imposes distortionary costs. Acemoglu 19 (Daron, Professor of Applied Economics, Department of Economics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, “Why Universal Basic Income might not be the answer,” World Economic Forum, 6/26/2019, https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/06/why-universal-basic-income-is-a-bad-idea) But UBI is a flawed idea, not least because it would be prohibitively expensive unless accompanied by deep cuts to the rest of the safety net. In the US (population: 327 million), a UBI of just $1,000 per month would cost around $4 trillion per year, which is close to the entire federal budget in 2018. Without major cost savings, US federal tax revenue would have to be doubled, which would impose massive distortionary costs on the economy. And, no, a permanent UBI could not be financed with government debt or newly printed currency. Sacrificing all other social programs for the sake of a UBI is a terrible idea. Such programs exist to address specific problems, such as the vulnerability of the elderly, children, and disabled people. Imagine living in a society where children still go hungry, and where those with severe health conditions are deprived of adequate care, because all the tax revenue has gone to sending monthly checks to every citizen, millionaires and billionaires included. Though UBI makes for a good slogan, it is a poorly designed policy. Basic economic theory implies that taxes on income are distortionary inasmuch as they discourage work and investment. Moreover, governments should avoid transfers to the same people from whom they collect revenue, but that is precisely what a UBI would do. In the US, for example, around three-quarters of households pay at least some federal income or payroll taxes, and an even greater share pays state taxes. UBI costs too much and hurts economic activity and growth. Ezrati 19 (Milton, MSS in mathematical economics from Birmingham University in England and a BA in economics from the State University of New York at Buffalo, “Universal Basic Income: A Thoroughly Wrongheaded Idea,” Forbes, 1/15/2019, https://www.forbes.com/sites/miltonezrati/2019/01/15/universal-basic-income-a-thoroughly-wrongheaded-idea/?sh=66ecf71545e1) Cost is an obvious consideration. The most quoted schemes today would, according calculations from Commerce Department data, cost the federal government between $2 and 4 trillion a year, amounting to a 50% increase in current federal outlays or more than 10% of last year’s gross domestic product (GDP). Such a draw on the economy would markedly burden taxpayers and increase government debt with all the associated economic ills. At the same time, such a huge draw on federal financial resources would also preclude other government priorities, such as infrastructure refurbishment, including the building of hospitals and the construction of affordable housing. Both effects would undermine productive incentives and otherwise constrain both public and private investment in the economy. Economic activity and growth potentials would suffer accordingly, not the least because UBI payouts would do little to invest in the future except if recipients really do use the funds for education and training. Not surprisingly, several UBI proponents suggest ways the country might finance the entitlement. These, though sometimes imaginative, would hardly lift the associated economic burdens. Some would sell off government land. That could certainly raise a lot of money initially, perhaps even enough to finance the giveaway for a while. As the government disposed of the land, however, this source of revenue would dwindle and fail to support what the proposers describe as a huge, ongoing entitlement. In any case, such an answer would surely provoke intense resistance from the green lobby. Other UBI proponents suggest a tax on the market capitalization of public companies. One proposal calls for an initial 3% levy on all corporations followed by a lower ongoing tax. Some would add a 5% levy on initial public offerings and a 3% tax on mergers. A carbon tax occasionally makes it into the mix. Even if these financing options could balance the accountant’s books, and that is doubtful, they, like other taxes, would still have ill effects on economic incentives as well as investing and hence on growth prospects generally. AT UBI Helps innovation UBI reduces entrepreneurship and innovation – it would just replace current social safety nets, doesn’t draw in financers, and causes bankruptcy of companies Seamans 17 --- Robert Seamans is an Associate Professor at New York University’s Stern School of Business and Director of the Center for the Future of Management. In 2015-2016 they served as a Senior Economist on President Obama's Council of Economic Advisers where they worked on a wide range of policies relating to technology, innovation and entrepreneurship. 6/6/2017 (“Universal Basic Income Is Not An Innovation Policy.” Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/washingtonbytes/2017/06/06/universal-basic-income-is-not-an-innovation-policy/?sh=6018e38f2e8f. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.) UBI Is Unlikely To Stimulate Entrepreneurship And Innovation In my view, while there may be other benefits to UBI, the argument that UBI might stimulate entrepreneurship and innovation suffers from two key problems. First, the U.S. economy already has multiple safety nets in place for would-be entrepreneurs and innovators, including bankruptcy laws, unemployment insurance, the Affordable Care Act (which allows employees to leave their firms without fear of losing health care), and other programs described below. It is not clear that replacing one set of safety nets with another will stimulate entrepreneurship and innovation. For UBI to stimulate additional entrepreneurship and innovation, it would need to provide an additional cushion above and beyond what already exists. This is an important point because most advocates of a UBI argue that its costs will largely be covered by replacing existing (but arguably inefficiently-run) programs. But if we want to stimulate more entrepreneurship than we already have, we need to do more than just replace existing programs; we need to provide even more of a cushion, which will increase the costs of implementing a UBI. The second problem with the argument that UBI will stimulate entrepreneurship is that it neglects the potential response from financiers (lenders, investors, and other providers of capital). If a UBI (or any other policy that shields borrowers from downside risk) increases the propensity for entrepreneurs to take risks because their downside is limited in the case of failure, this means that the capital provided by the financier is at greater risk. Thus, the financier may cut back on the amount of lending provided, or may continue to lend, but at a higher rate than before. Or, if the financier has trouble distinguishing between high- and low-quality risky projects, the financier may stop funding altogether. The negative response to higher levels of borrower protection by financiers has been documented in a number of settings. For example, Michelle White, a professor at UC San Diego, and coauthors find that higher levels of bankruptcy exemptions (the amount of money that an individual can retain when declaring bankruptcy) are correlated with more loan denials and higher interest rates. The negative effect on innovation has been documented in other settings as well. Ramana Nanda and Tom Nicholas of Harvard Business School find that credit rationing by banks during the Great Depression led firms to produce fewer, and less novel innovations. A recent paper with my coauthors Geraldo Cerqueiro, Deepak Hegde and Fabiana Penas shows that higher levels of bankruptcy exemptions lead to less innovation—in terms of lower number of patents and lower overall patent quality—by small firms. This is because innovation is a costly undertaking, and when the supply of capital shrinks, these small firms have no choice but to cut back on innovation. We find particularly strong effects in industries with high costs of innovation. To be clear, a UBI would function differently than bankruptcy exemptions, and it is possible that, even if financiers cut back funding, the net effect of a UBI may still be to increase entrepreneurship and innovation. The point is that these other effects should not be neglected, because instead of stimulating entrepreneurship and innovation, a UBI may perversely lead to a reduction in entrepreneurship and innovation in some cases. AT UBI Helps Small Businesses California proves UBI would result in a tax on small business and force them to go out of business Wilford 22 --- Andrew Wilford, DIRECTOR OF NTUF'S INTERSTATE COMMERCE INITIATIVE. 8/22/2022 (“San Francisco Would Fund UBI With Tax Hit on Small Businesses”. https://www.ntu.org/foundation/detail/san-francisco-would-fund-ubi-with-tax-hit-on-small-businesses. Date Accessed: 7-21-2023.) First and foremost, Prop K would represent an undue burden on interstate commerce, one that is likely to face challenges under the dormant commerce clause. The structure of the tax ensures that San Francisco-based businesses face significantly lower tax rates than businesses that sell into the city, as Tables A and B show, with no justification. A main reason the United States has a Constitution rather than Articles of Confederation is to prevent sub-national bodies from attempting to fill their coffers with revenue from non-residents in order to offer their residents lower tax rates. Not only is this manifestly unfair, it is also bad for the country as a whole, as it unmoors the taxpayer from representation in the legislative body taxing them. Absent a federal government protecting taxpayers from states and localities trying to “import” revenue from each others’ citizens, interstate commerce suffers. The burden created goes beyond just the rate increases themselves. Creating a separate tax rate for e-retail transactions requires small businesses to determine what is and isn’t taxable under the new rates, and track this in their accounting operations. Many likely will not have the capability to do so. What’s more, San Francisco’s compliance burden increase does not take place in a vacuum. States and localities have been steadily increasing compliance burdens on businesses selling around the country for years now in an effort to glean more revenue from the digital economy, from economic nexus sales tax rules to expansions of income tax nexus to delivery fees. For small businesses trying to run their businesses and pay their taxes, it is death by a thousand cuts. There’s another potential legal barrier as well. The federal Internet Tax Freedom Act (ITFA) prohibits states and localities from imposing discriminatory taxes on internet commerce. One such form of prohibited discriminatory taxation is defined under ITFA as taxes that are “not generally imposed and legally collectible at the same rate by such State or such political subdivision on transactions involving similar property, goods, services, or information accomplished through other means.” Taxing e-retail transactions at rates that are several times higher than domestic brick-and-mortar businesses face appears to be a rather straightforward violation of this principle. Should Prop K be passed into law, it would likely face a strong challenge under ITFA. And for good reason — it is bad for the country if states and localities are smothering the baby in the crib by targeting the innovativeness of the digital economy for special taxes. Lastly, while this measure will certainly harm small businesses selling into San Francisco and is structured to try to export the tax burden, it is likely to also hurt San Franciscans. Businesses selling into San Francisco would most likely respond by increasing prices or attaching surcharges to cover the added cost of doing business in San Francisco. Some may even decide that the cost of selling to San Francisco customers outweighs the benefit. Conclusion Responding to concern about the tax not applying to Amazon, Prop K’s backers have since suspended their campaign for the ballot measure and are seeking to remove it from the ballot. But they have also dismissed concerns about the impact on small businesses and, should they succeed in removing it from November’s ballot, will likely try again with a substantially similar proposal next November. If San Francisco deems a UBI to be a policy priority, it should find a means to fund it that does not involve half-baked schemes to export the costs and import revenues. Not only is Prop K likely to create significant compliance and tax burdens on e-retail businesses for no reason, it will also send a message to businesses that San Francisco intends to take advantage of any business unwise enough to do business in the city. UBI fails for small business – cant solve rising costs Krämer 20 - a German trade unionist and politician Ralf, 2020, Abstract of "Universal Basic Income - not really an alternative." International Union Rights, vol. 27 no. 3, 2020, Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/iur.2020.a838153. 24 | International Union Rights | 27/3 FOCUS | IMPACTS OF COVID-19 ON WORK AND THE CHALLENGE FOR UNION RIGHTS Universal Basic Income – not really an alternative The idea of a Universal Basic Income (UBI) sounds intriguing at first: everyone should be guaranteed an income which covers their basic needs. Who would argue with that? Taking a closer look, however, there is much uncertainty as to what exactly is meant and how a UBI should work and be financed. This was also evident during the Covid 19 pandemic, when proposals were made to use a temporary basic income to cushion the economic consequences for the population and especially its particularly vulnerable sections. For example a study for the United Nations Development Programme proposed this for the world’s three billion poorest people. But this would be neither universal nor sufficient – in average US$ 2.50 per person per day. In the paper there is also a positive reference to Spain, where a ‘basic income’ was introduced. There it concerns however an even worse Spanish variant of the German model of basic security for needy unemployed (‘Hartz IV’), which is criticised by the trade unions as too low and too repressive. UBI as a rescue against the crisis? For Germany this discussion makes little sense. This is a country with a highly developed social welfare system, which showed its performance in the ongoing crisis – despite of all problems and legitimate criticisms. This system is characterised by social insurance schemes, which involve the vast majority of the population – in particular, dependent employees and their families – which provide benefits on the basis of contributions paid. Especially, the short-time work allowance saved millions from falling into unemployment. But nevertheless many mini-jobbers, self-employed and small entrepreneurs are particularly hard hit. They often have low incomes anyway and need every euro, but do not receive short-time work benefits or unemployment benefits because they are not covered by unemployment insurance. If they are needy, they can apply for basic security, but this is below the German poverty line. For the German UBI community this is rather a deterrent example, they see a ‘real UBI’ as the fundamental alternative to this means-tested basic provision. A UBI as they mean it is intended to be an income that the government pays unconditionally to each person, regardless of what income that person receives or what assets they possess. There is no means testing and each person receives the same amount (only children less). The UBI should be high enough to cover basic needs and guarantee social participation. The search for gainful employment would not be required. As a response to the Covid 19 crisis more than 400,000 people supported a petition that demands the introduction of an unconditional basic income of 800-1200 euro per person and month in Germany for 6 months. This would cost about 500 billion euro, which would be 3 or 4 times the complete public expenditure on education. But why should everyone receive such an unconditional basic income (BGE) as a measure against the crisis, although for many, fortunately the majority of employees, the income is not at all lost, but continues as before? For the majority of the employees hit by the crisis the short-time work allowance or even the unemployment benefit is better than such a UBI would be. On the other hand, such an UBI would not be a rescue for the many self-employed and small businesses that are on the verge of bankruptcy because their income is lost but they still have to pay various running costs, rents, etc. Targeted aid for those who need it would also make more economic s
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.