T - Job SPEC - CNDI 2023
T - Job SPEC - CNDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Topicality – CNDI 23
Notes
Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by adopting a federal jobs guarantee, expanding Social Security, and/or providing a basic income.
1NC
1nc – No Spec
a. Interpretation – The aff can’t specify which jobs they guarantee, only the universal program.
‘Substantial’ means all and without qualification.
Lorne Slotnick 15, Chair of the Arbitration Board, Labour Arbitration Awards has issued the following decision: IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BETWEEN: St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton -and- Canadian Union of Public Employees Local 786, Labour Arbitration Awards: St. Joseph’s Healthcare Hamilton v Canadian Union of Public Employees, Local 786, 2015 CanLII 18978 (ON LA), 2015
The union points to the definition of “similar” in the online Oxford English Dictionary as “having a marked resemblance or likeness; of a like nature or kind,” and in Black’s Law Dictionary as “nearly corresponding; resembling in many respects; somewhat like; having a general likeness, although allowing for some degree of difference.” In addition, “substantially” is defined in the Oxford English Dictionary as “in all essential characters or features; in essentials, to all intents and purposes, in the main,” and in Black’s [Law Dictionary] as “essentially; without material qualification; in the main; in substance; materially; in a substantial manner.” The fact that the collective agreement uses both words together must mean that the two shift rotations have to be essentially corresponding or resembling each other in all essential respects for the conditions to be met, the union argues.
A ‘federal jobs guarantee’ is wholistic and includes multiple jobs.
Bhandari ’19 [Ryan Bhandari; March 25, 2019; Senior Policy Advisor at Thirdway’s Economic Program; Thirdway, “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?” https://www.thirdway.org/memo/what-is-the-federal-jobs-guarantee-and-what-are-people-saying-about-it]
What is the federal jobs guarantee? A federal jobs guarantee is as simple as it sounds on the surface: everyone in the country will be guaranteed a job by the US government should they desire one. There are two versions right now gaining attention. One plan is written by academics Mark Paul, Sandy Darity, and Darrick Hamilton. The other was written by Pavlina Tcherneva. In general, these plans promise:
Guaranteed jobs in infrastructure repair, ecological restoration, caregiving, and community development projects.
Benefits like health insurance, paid sick leave/vacation, and retirement plans.
Control for state and local governments that will decide which kinds of jobs to create.
A reduced uptake of welfare programs and unemployment insurance as well as decreased criminal justice costs.
The key difference between the two plans is the minimum wage for the new jobs. The Tcherneva plan establishes a $15 minimum wage and the Paul et al. plan calls for an $11.80 minimum wage for all federally guaranteed jobs. Yet, both have the same underlying goal: Permanently solve the problem of involuntary unemployment by making the federal government he federal government the employer of last resort.
b. Violation: The plan is only a subset, _______ isn’t universal and won’t allow local choice.
c. Vote Negative:
1. Limits
2. Ground
1nc – No Infrastructure
Infrastructure violates – it’s distinct from a job guarantee and wouldn’t be universal.
Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023
Ph.D., an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy, “The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability,” Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative. https://edi.bard.edu/research/notes/the-job-guarantee-mmts-proposal-for-full-employment-and-price-stability
Large-scale job creation programs are often mistaken for large-scale infrastructure projects. And while it is vital to invest in a nation’s infrastructure as a matter of national priority, such infrastructure investment should not be scheduled around fluctuations of the business cycle. Building schools should be done on as-needed basis, not as an anticyclical policy. Similarly, it would be irrational to build bridges only when the economy is in a recession or, conversely, to discontinue a high-speed rail project on the grounds that the economy is growing. In addition, infrastructure jobs are often high-skill and predominantly male, thus not always suitable for all jobseekers. Large scale infrastructure is not a particularly reliable method for addressing the spatial aspects of unemployment. Jobseekers may live in communities that do not need levees or fire prevention efforts, but may experience multiple other deprivations such as poor access to healthy food or childcare care.
2NC
2nc – Substantial
Extend our ‘substantial’ definition – Slotnick ’15. It lists three different definitions, but ALL support our interpretation. Substantial means WITHOUT qualification, that means no specification. A subset can’t be substantial because it qualifies the degree of the increase and excludes essential purposes and intents.
Other sources confirm those definitions:
a. ‘Substantial’ means totality of circumstances
US First Circuit Court of Appeals ’98
In Re Richard Lamanna, Debtor.first Usa, et al., Appellees, v. Richard Lamanna, AppellantUnited States Court of Appeals, First Circuit. - 153 F.3d 1Heard July 27, 1998.Decided Aug. 25, 1998 http://www.swlearning.com/blaw/cases/court_uses.html
Decision Affirmed. The court joins other circuits in adopting the "totality of the circumstances" test as the measure of substantial abuse under the Bankruptcy Code. This is a flexible standard adopted by Congress to allow bankruptcy courts to consider the factors involved in each case and to prevent abuse of Chapter 7 filings. When there is evidence that the consumer can pay their debts, there is likely to be found substantial abuse.
b. Requires “essential parts”
David S. Becker ‘14, Partner in the Litigation and Intellectual Property Practice Groups at Freeborn & Peters, LLP, J.D. from DePaul University College of Law, & John C. Hammerle, Associate in the Litigation Practice Group
at Freeborn & Peters, LLP, J.D. from DePaul University College of Law, “The Trouble With “Substantial Completion” in Construction Projects”, Committee News, Winter 2014, https://freeborn.com/assets/the_trouble_with_substantial_completion_in_construction_projects-aba_winter_2014_newsletter.pdf
3 See, e.g., Kinetic Builder’s, Inc. v. Peters, 226 F.3d 1307, 1315 (Fed. Cir. 2000); Ocean Winds Corp. v. Lane, 556 S.E.2d 377, 379 (S.C. 2001) (citing statutory definition of substantial completion as “that degree of completion of a project, improvement, or a specified area or portion thereof . . . upon attainment of which the owner can use the same for the purpose for which it was intended”) (internal citations and emphasis omitted); Daugherty v. Bruce Realty & Dev., Inc., 892 S.W.2d 332, 335 (Mo. Ct. App. 1995) (“a building is substantially complete . . . when it has reached the state of its construction so that it can be put to the use for which it was intended, even though comparatively minor items remain to be furnished or performed to conform to the plans and specifications of the completed building”); E.R. Stone v. City of Arcola, 181 Ill. App. 3d 513, 526 (Ill. App. Ct. 1989) (acknowledging that a project is “substantially complete” at a given date where “it could be used for the purpose for which it was intended on that date”). See also Sorenson v. Dager, 601 N.W.2d 564, 570 (Neb. Ct. App. 1999) (*fix this parenthetical); Evans & Assocs. v. Dyer, 246 Ill. App. 3d 231, 239 (Ill. App. Ct. 1993) (“Substantial performance . . . . means performance in all the essential elements necessary to the accomplishment of the purpose of the contract. ‘Substantial’ means in substance; in the main; essential, including material or essential parts.”)..
c. And to always be “in the main”
Words and Phrases ‘2 (Volume 40A, p. 469)
Ill.App.2 Dist. 1923 “Substantial” means in substance, in the main, essential, including material or essential parts.
d. One more for “without material qualification”
Black’s Law ‘91 (Dictionary, p. 1024)
Substantially - means essentially; without material qualification.
2nc – JG = Wholistic
Extend Bhandari ’19 – a jobs guarantee is universal and includes multiple jobs and isn’t specific. In fact, it requires local discretion in choosing what kind of jobs are needed, not top-down mandates. Programs must include jobs like jobs in infrastructure repair, ecological restoration, caregiving, and community development
The term guarantee means it’s a right that can’t be qualified with a specific skill-set or industry – it’s an unconditional offer of a job.
L. Randall Wray 20, professor of Economics at Bard College and Senior Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, “Job Guarantee,” The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, Palgrave Macmillan UK, 2020, pp. 1–9 Springer Link, doi:10.1057/978-1-349-95121-5_3080-1
‘Job Guarantee’ (JG) has become the favoured term applied to a variety of approaches that seek to ensure what can be described as true full employment. While often used as a synonym for ‘Employer of Last Resort’ (ELR), these terms evoke quite different framing. Employer of Last Resort implies that there is an entity that stands by to provide jobs to those who otherwise have failed to secure them. The term Job Guarantee implies a right to a job, although it does not indicate how that right will be secured. However, if we are to include the right to a job as similar to other recognized rights (right to life, right to free speech, right to vote, right to marriage), this would seem to imply that it is government that is to provide the guarantee. Many proponents of the JG do emphasize the human rights angle, interpreting the UN Charter on Human Rights as explicitly guaranteeing the right to access to a job (See Harvey 1989, 1993, 1999; Burgess and Mitchell 1998). Unfortunately, each term carries a negative connotation: ‘last resort’ can be seen as derogatory—the potential workers cannot find anything better; ‘guarantee’ implies that potential workers must be employed no matter what. Together, these associations fuel suspicion that work done is of low quality and otherwise without merit. There have been some efforts to rebrand the proposal as Public Service Employment (PSE) to emphasize the positive potential of such jobs (Wray 1999).
2nc – No Infrastructure
Extend the Tcherneva ev from the 1nc – even if specification is allowed, their infrastructure focus is uniquely untopical because it violates the universal nature of a jobs guarantee. Not everyone is skilled enough for infrastructure and not every community needs the projects.
And, Jobs guarantee is distinct from an infrastructure rebuild.
PHILIP HARVEY in 2021
Professor of law and economics at Rutgers Law School.; Infrastructure Investment vs. Job Guarantee; National Jobs For All Network; https://njfac.org/index.php/2021/09/05/infrastructure-investment-vs-job-guarantee/
What is the difference between job guarantee and infrastructure investment? And to what extent would infrastructure investment and a J.G. program serve the aims of the other? The goals of a job guarantee (J.G.) and the infrastructure spending legislation like the American Jobs Plan (AJP) proposed by the Biden Administration or the bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (H.R.) currently under debate in the U.S. Congress are different. -> The purpose of J.G. legislation is to close the economy’s job gap through direct job creation and to administer the job creation program to ensure all job seekers access to proper employment providing fair and adequate wages along with safe and healthful working conditions. -> The purpose of infrastructure investment legislation is to develop and maintain society’s physical and social infrastructure, usually by contracting with private business firms, to perform the work and often stimulate economic growth and create jobs.
If the aff includes infrastructure spending, then they’re extra topical, which is an independent voting issue for unpredictable ground and de-justifying the resolution.
AFF ANSWERS
Substantially = Not All
‘Substantially’ means greatly, NOT entirely.
Burke ’12 [Christopher; April 27; United States Magistrate Judge; Westlaw, “Virgin Atl. Airways Ltd. v. Delta Airlines, Inc.,” No. CIV.A. 11-61-LPS-CJB, WL 1636147]
The Court agrees, and finds that such a result would be at odds with the established law. See, e.g., Circle R, Inc. v. Trail King Indus., Inc., 21 F. App'x 894, 898 (Fed.Cir.2001) (reversing a district court decision that construed the phrase “substantially flat” to mean “entirely flat”); York Prods., Inc. v. Cent. Tractor Farm & Family Ctr., 99 F.3d 1568, 1572–73 (Fed.Cir.1996) (construing “substantially the entire height” as “nearly the entire height”). The adverb “substantially” is typically defined to mean “to a great or significant extent,” or “for the most part; essentially.”4 The adjective “flat” is typically defined to mean “smooth and even; without marked lumps to indentations” or “having a broad level surface.”5 These ordinary definitions are generally consistent with the patent specification discussed at length above, which depicts and describes seat-to-bed systems with constituent surfaces that are close to, though not entirely, flat. (See ′861 patent, col. 9–10; col. 13 (describing multiple embodiments with “substantially flat” passenger-bearing surfaces that are composed of “substantially coplanar[ ] and contiguous” surfaces)6 As such, although the patent specification and claims lead to the inescapable conclusion that the claimed “substantially flat bed” must consist of surfaces that are flat to a great extent, those surfaces need not be precisely so. (See, e.g., id., col. 33:12–17; 36:32–33; 43:7–8; 46:54–56).
Footnote 4 begins:
See http://oxforddictionaries.com/definition/substantially; http://www.wordreference.com/definition/substantially; see also http:// www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/substantially (“being largely but not wholly that which is specified”). Cf. Circle R, 21 F. App'x at 898 (citing similar definitions for “substantially”); York Prods., 99 F.3d at 1572–73 (same).
‘Substantially’ does not mean wholly.
Zoss ’98 [Paul; November 16; Magistrate Judge on the United States District Court for the Northern District of Iowa; Lexis, “Bailey v. United States,” 39 F. Supp. 2d 1132, 1138]
To do this, the court will need a working definition of the terms "substantial" and "substantially." Courts have given these terms widely different meanings, depending on the context. See Victor v. Nebraska, 511 U.S. 1, 19, 114 S. Ct. 1239, 1250, 127 L. Ed. 2d 583 (1994) ("substantial" means either "not seeming or imaginary" or "that specified to a large degree" in the context of a reasonable doubt instruction, citing Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1981)); Kluener v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 154 F.3d 630, 637 (6th Cir. 1998) ("substantial" means something less than a preponderance, but more than a mere reasonable basis, citing 26 C.F.R. P1.6662-4(d)(3) (1997)); Id., at 639 ("substantial" means "considerable" or "ample"); Canyon Air Tour Coalition v. Federal Aviation Administration, 332 U.S. App. D.C. 133, 154 F.3d 455, 474 (D.C. Cir. 1998) ("substantial" may well be defined as meaning "more than half," "being that specified to a large degree or in the main," "not seeming or imaginary," "considerable in amount"); York Products, Inc. v. Central Tractor Farm & Family Center, 99 F.3d 1568, 1572-73 (Fed. Cir. 1996) ("substantially" means "considerable in . . . extent," citing American Heritage Dictionary Second College Edition 1213 (2d ed. 1982) or "largely but not wholly that which is specified," citing Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 1176 (9th ed. 1983)); Koch v. United States, 47 F.3d 1015, 1021 (10th Cir. 1995) ("substantially" means "justified in substance or in the main -- that is, justified to a degree that could satisfy a reasonable person." (citations omitted)); Laitram Machinery, Inc. v. Carnitech, 884 F. Supp. 1074, 1085 (E.D.La. 1995) (definition of "substantially" in a patent case is a jury question); C.E. Equipment Co., Inc. v. United States, 17 Cl. Ct. 293, 299 (1989) ("substantially" means "less than totally"); Darlington v. Studebaker-Packard Corporation, 191 F. Supp. 438, 439 (N.D. Ind 1961) ("The word 'substantially' is a relative term and should be interpreted in accordance with context of claim in which it is used."). At trial, the court will expect the parties to propose appropriate definitions for these terms for the court to use in deciding this case.
Substantial = Large
“Substantial” means considerable or to a large degree --- this common meaning is preferable because the word is not a term of art
Arkush 2 (David, JD Candidate – Harvard University, “Preserving "Catalyst" Attorneys' Fees Under the Freedom of Information Act in the Wake of Buckhannon Board and Care Home v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources”, Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review, Winter, 37 Harv. C.R.-C.L. L. Rev. 131)
Plaintiffs should argue that the term "substantially prevail" is not a term of art because if considered a term of art, resort to Black's 7th produces a definition of "prevail" that could be interpreted adversely to plaintiffs. 99 It is commonly accepted that words that are not legal terms of art should be accorded their ordinary, not their legal, meaning, 100 and ordinary-usage dictionaries provide FOIA fee claimants with helpful arguments. The Supreme Court has already found favorable, temporally relevant definitions of the word "substantially" in ordinary dictionaries: "Substantially" suggests "considerable" or "specified to a large degree." See Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1976) (defining "substantially" as "in a substantial manner" and "substantial" as "considerable in amount, value, or worth" and "being that specified to a large degree or in the main"); see also 17 Oxford English Dictionary 66-67 (2d ed. 1989) ("substantial": "relating to or proceeding from the essence of a thing; essential"; "of ample or considerable amount, quantity or dimensions"). 101
Substantial = Materially
Substantially means real, not imaginary
Wollman ’93 (Circuit Judge, US Court of Appeals – 8th Circuit, Kansas City Power & Light Company, a Missouri corporation, Appellee, v. Ford Motor Credit Company, a Delaware corporation; McDonnell Douglas Finance Corporation, a Delaware corporation; HEI Investment Corp., a Hawaii corporation, Appellants, 995 F.2d 1422; 1993 U.S. App. LEXIS 13755, L/N)
Instruction No. 10 was not given in isolation, however. The district court's instructions also contained a definition of "substantial." Instruction No. 11 defined "substantial" as meaning "true, real or likely to materialize" and as not meaning "imaginary or unlikely to materialize." This instruction properly limited the potential bases for the jury's decision, which is the essential function of jury instructions. When combined with the contract and the verdict-directing instructions, [*1432] which tracked the operative language of the contract, Instruction No. 11 required the jury to find that KCPL had determined a real risk, not some imaginary hypothetical risk premised solely on a reduction in the DRD. Because the contract provided only one means of creating a risk of making an indemnity payment--a demand notice from an Investor--the jury's discretion was properly channelled into deciding whether KCPL had sufficiently studied and honestly considered th
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.