Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 MNDI Disadvantage

AT Natural Gas DA - MNDI 2023 HPA

AT Natural Gas DA - MNDI 2023 HPA.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Affirmative Answers
2ac Natural Gas Production Decreasing
U.S. natural gas production falling now despite booming demand --- weak commodity prices
McCormick, 6-26-23 – US energy correspondent [Myles, 26 June 23, Financial Times, "US Shale Oil and Gas Producers Pull Back after Commodity Price Drop" www.ft.com/content/26bd3376-c4b4-4257-98e1-93b29706d2d8, Accessed on June 28 2023, NP] The prolific US shale oil and gas industry is decelerating in the face of weakening commodity prices, suggesting production growth will stall at a time of booming demand.
Evidence of stagnating activity is mounting. A survey by the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas posted a score of zero for business activity growth in the second quarter among some 150 oil and gas groups in its region — suggesting any expansion had hit a wall. It was the lowest score since 2020, when an oil price crash during the coronavirus pandemic forced operators to slash headcounts and idle drilling rigs.
On Friday, data showed that the number of drilling rigs deployed across the country had fallen for the eighth week in a row, according to Baker Hughes, an oilfield services company.
“Weak oil and gas prices” and “high costs” had “brought growth in oil and gas activity to a standstill in the second quarter”, said Michael Plante, senior research economist and adviser at the Dallas Fed. US natural gas prices have slid from more than $6 per million British thermal units a year ago to less than $3. Brent crude, the international oil price benchmark, sat at about $74 a barrel on Friday, down more than a third since this time last year.
With average producers needing an oil price of $66 a barrel to break even this year, according to HSBC, that is barely enough for many drillers to turn a profit.
American oil output is still rising, however, driven by the prolific Permian Basin of West Texas and New Mexico, and may even hit a record high later this year, according to the US Energy Information Administration.
But those volumes reflect drilling decisions taken months ago, when oil prices were higher. The fall in drilling activity since then suggests any spurt in output will be shortlived. Shale output requires ever more drilling just to hold output steady, with new production tending to come on line months after wells are fracked.
As the world guzzles increasing volumes of oil, any deterioration in US production growth is all alarming, given that the country has been the main source of added supply in recent years.
Among the issues weighing on the shale patch’s ability to grow are commodity prices, worker shortages, investors’ insistence on returns and growing fears that shale rocks, which made the US the most dynamic producer in the world, are becoming increasingly less productive.
Escalating costs for everything from well casing to pressure pumping equipment are also biting into profit margins. “Expenses for everything have increased dramatically, while . . . prices remain weak,” said one executive surveyed by the Dallas Fed. “It seems as if the break-even price for oil is in the mid-$70-per-barrel range at this point. I would drill if costs were not so high.” Some have pointed out that oil companies are able to produce more oil with fewer rigs. But EIA data has shown a sharp decline in new oil production per rig, as output from once prolific basins slides.
“You definitely have mature plays, like the Bakken and the Eagle Ford where it’s kind of run its course,” said Nathan Nemeth, an analyst at consultancy Wood Mackenzie, referring to basins in North Dakota and Texas. “They’re not really the growth engines anymore.”
US oil production, which soared by almost 2mn barrels a day at the height of the shale revolution between 2018 and 2019, is set to grow by just 200,000 b/d over the next 12 months — with practically all of that growth coming from the Permian, as other basins dwindle.
The number of oil and gas drilling rigs in the field last week fell for the eighth week in a row, sliding to 682, leaving the count down by more than 100 in the past six months.
That trend could reverse if oil prices rally in the latter part of this year, say analysts, but with the threat of recession looming over the global economy, that is far from a guaranteed outcome.
“We’re not certain of what to expect,” said one Dallas Fed survey respondent. “The highs were too high. The lows too low.”
2ac Non-Unique – Biden Hurting Oil & Gas
Biden’s policies are undercutting domestic oil and gas production
Eberhart, 23 --- CEO of Canary, LLC (Feb 24, 2023,09:41am ES, Dan, “Ukraine War Illustrates Importance Of American Energy Dominance,” https://www.forbes.com/sites/daneberhart/2023/02/24/ukraine-war-illustrates-importance-of-american-energy-dominance/?sh=2cfd961570a6, JMP))
It’s why the previous administration pursued an “energy dominance” agenda – to ensure Americans were insulated from shocks to the energy market and help address global supply crises when they arise.
The Biden administration continues to treat the domestic oil and gas industry as the villain in recent events, accusing it of price-gouging, war profiteering, and, ironically, underinvesting in exploration and development of new supply despite federal policies that thwart domestic production at every turn. President Biden remains committed to a “Keep It in The Ground” strategy despite his rhetoric against high energy prices.
The approach of Biden and his Democratic coalition on Capitol Hill to leasing federal lands and waters, permitting new pipelines, general reform of the federal permitting system, or any initiative that encourages domestic production continues to frustrate U.S. energy security goals.
2ac Non-Unique – Renewables Now
Non-uq: Inflation reduction act expands to renewables
Isaacs-Thomas ’22 [Bella, 8/17/22, PBS, “What the Inflation Reduction Act does for green energy” https://www.pbs.org/newshour/science/what-the-inflation-reduction-act-does-for-green-energy, Accessed on 6/23/22, JR]
The legislation, signed Aug. 16 by President Joe Biden, does a lot of things, including tackling deficit reduction, health care access and prescription drug pricing, but addressing the energy industry and climate change is one of its most significant aims.
“This is very much climate legislation,” said Brian Murray, interim director of the Nicholas Institute for Energy, Environment & Sustainability at Duke University, who added the bill offers “a significant bump” in the nation’s projected ability to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions.
The goal of the bill is to put the country on a path to reduce greenhouse gasses by 40 percent below 2005 levels by 2030, Murray said – a meaningful increase compared to our current path, which is projected to reach a 25-percent reduction. (The U.S. has actually pledged to lower emissions by 50 to 52 percent under that same framework as part of the Paris Agreement, he noted.)
That’s an important breakthrough for every living thing on Earth, but there also are more mundane benefits, including for anyone who drives a car or pays utility bills and has felt fuel costs rise this year.
Every part of the economy has energy running through it — it literally “powers everything in our lives,” said Abigail Dillen, president of Earthjustice, a nonprofit that litigates environmental issues. But how we source that energy has a massive impact on the planet.
The use and production of energy, which includes fuels that power vehicles and buildings, makes up the largest contribution of greenhouse gas emissions across the globe, according to the EPA. In the U.S., the transportation, electric power and industry sectors each make up around 25 percent of national emissions, the agency says.
Building up the U.S. capacity to build renewable technology, like solar panels or electric vehicle components, and then ensuring people can use those things more easily by shoring up energy infrastructure is a key facet of the Inflation Reduction Act. Meanwhile, consumer-oriented provisions meant to make it more affordable for those with lower to middle incomes to access electric-powered options, from cars to heat pump systems and more.
2ac AT: Green New Deal Link
No link – Green New Deal revised and no longer calls for an end to fossil fuels
Colman, 2-4-19 [Zach Colman, February 4, POLITICO, "Green New Deal Won't Call for End to Fossil Fuels" www.politico.com/story/2019/02/04/green-new-deal-fossil-fuels-1142544, Accessed on June 23, NP]
The first effort by congressional climate advocates to define their “Green New Deal” will omit one of the most ambitious goals its supporters have demanded, sources told POLITICO on Monday: a firm date for ending oil, gas and coal development in the U.S.
The change is a compromise that may make the proposal more politically palatable for many of the Democrats’ presidential contenders in 2020, as well as for labor groups that compose a powerful portion of the party’s base. But it will disappoint many of the progressives who have rallied and staged sit-ins in the Capitol in recent months to demand swift action on climate change.
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) are expected to introduce a resolution outlining elements of the plan within days, which will include a goal for eliminating the U.S. carbon footprint by 2030, according to multiple sources.
The text includes an aim to “achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions for a fair and just transition for frontline communities and displaced workers,” among other high-level ambitions. It also opens the door to using still-unproven technology to eliminate carbon pollution from fossil fuel use — an avenue that many climate activists dismiss as an expensive dead end. But it does not explicitly call for eliminating fossil fuels themselves.
Ocasio-Cortez’s office said the plan’s goal is still to act quickly on climate change with a range of technologies, though allowing fossil fuels to persist is “not what we’re shooting for,” spokesperson Corbin Trent said.
“It’s had lots of different iterations. The goal is to be a zero-carbon economy in 10 years,” Trent told POLITICO when asked whether the resolution calls for banning fossil fuels. “The door is open for technology to solve this problem, sure.”
A U.S. economy that produces a net zero of greenhouse gas emissions would still pose a huge challenge, requiring changes well beyond what former President Barack Obama proposed in his climate regulations.
The soon-to-come legislation is the first concrete step by lawmakers to put language behind the Green New Deal, a largely still-undefined platform of environmental and social-justice goals that has quickly become part of the lexicon of the Democrats’ presidential hopefuls.
Ocasio-Cortez’s campaign platform had previously called for achieving “100% of national power generation from renewable sources” and “decarbonizing” other industries by 2030. The proposed legislative text doesn’t rule out such an ambitious goal, but it could ease the friction between two key elements of the Democratic base: labor groups that support oil, gas and coal projects and environmental groups that oppose them.
The phrasing could also leave more room for a slate of Democratic presidential hopefuls to craft a Green New Deal in their own terms in what is becoming a litmus test for the packed field of contenders. Several 2020 candidates, including Sens. Kirsten Gillibrand (D-N.Y.), Kamala Harris (D-Calif.), Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Cory Booker (D-N.J.), have endorsed the concept of a Green New Deal, but have not clearly outlined exactly what they mean.
2ac Renewable Natural Gas
Biomethane is a renewable source for natural gas that will solve climate change – it is not a fossil fuel
Underwood, 19 [April 25, 2019, Joanna; Joanna D. Underwood is founder of Energy Vision, whose mission is to analyze and promote ways to make a swift transition to pollution-free renewable energy sources and to the clean, petroleum-free transportation fuels of the future.; “A Green New Deal for Natural Gas, Why ultral-low-carbon biomethane, aka renewable natural gas, deserves more attention from policy makers” https://www.greenbiz.com/article/green-new-deal-natural-gas, LK]
The U.S. Senate voted against the Green New Deal, but its interlinked climate, job and social justice goals are still percolating. Among the issues supporters and opponents alike have flagged is what role the natural gas industry should play in advancing them.
Natural gas long has been considered a "bridge fuel" to renewables. During the Green New Deal debate, former Department of Energy leaders from both parties argued that natural gas is part of the clean energy future, because it burns cleaner than coal or oil, reduces coal use and smoothes out the variability of solar and wind generation.
But the Green New Deal proposed to phase out natural gas-fired electricity generation entirely by 2030. Natural gas opponents point out it is essentially methane — a greenhouse gas (GHG) 86 times more potent than carbon dioxide over 20 years — extracted in harmful ways and transported in pipelines that can leak. Besides, they argue, natural gas is no longer needed as a bridge fuel. Renewables prices are already low enough to transition from coal directly to solar, wind and other technologies, so why risk more methane emissions by continuing to expand the natural gas industry?
CARB found that when made from food waste or farm waste in anaerobic digesters, biomethane is actually net carbon-negative over its lifecycle.
But the reality is, the industry’s operations are already vast. There are 3 million miles of gas pipelines in the United States. Over 28,000 megawatts of new gas-fired generation capacity have been built here in the last two years, with 6,100 MW coming this year. That infrastructure will be with us for 40 years or more.
While natural gas operations are already locked in, their emissions need not be. Renewable natural gas, also known as biomethane, significantly could reduce the climate impacts of the natural gas industry we have now.
An ultra-low-carbon fuel using natural gas infrastructure
Biomethane is chemically virtually identical to fossil natural gas, and it burns even cleaner, but it is not a fossil fuel. It is a renewable fuel, superior in many ways to fossil gas. Producing it involves no fracking or drilling; it involves capturing methane biogases emitted by decomposing organic wastes, which otherwise would be released into the atmosphere and warm the climate.
Organic wastes are ubiquitous — found in landfills, on dairies and farm fields, at wastewater plants and so forth. To make biomethane, biogases from these wastes are captured and refined into a "pipeline-grade" product that can be transported in the same pipelines and used the same way as fossil natural gas — for power generation, home heating and cooking, or fueling vehicles.
But unlike fossil natural gas, biomethane is ultra-low-carbon. In fact, according to the California Air Resources Board, it is the lowest-carbon fuel available. CARB found that when made from food waste or farm waste in anaerobic digesters, biomethane is actually net carbon-negative over its lifecycle. That’s because making the fuel captures more greenhouse gases than vehicles emit when burning it — a big net gain for the climate.
Decarbonizing heavy transport
Transportation emits more greenhouse gases than any other sector of the U.S. economy. Heavy-duty vehicles use a quarter of all road fuel, and getting them off diesel is particularly important. But electrifying them is not yet a practical solution.
Only a few hundred electric buses and far fewer heavy trucks are in operation in the United States, and they have been plagued by service problems. Although their tailpipe emissions may be zero, their overall lifecycle emissions are only as good as the fuel generating the electricity to charge the batteries.
Biomethane, on the other hand, can cut lifecycle vehicle emissions up to 300 percent compared to diesel. It’s a practical way to decarbonize heavy transport here and now.
Estimating the impacts
The more biomethane flows through natural gas pipelines, and the more it gets used in existing gas-fired power plants or natural gas-powered buses and trucks, the more the overall climate footprint of the natural gas industry shrinks. Just how much depends on how much biomethane is produced, how soon anaerobic digesters are built, and how fast truck and bus fleets, utilities and companies adopt the fuel.
The U.S. organic waste stream is huge and growing (including 87 million tons a year of food and yard wastes alone). It’s a big enough resource to justify building 10,000 new digester facilities, which would create 30,000 to 50,000 full-time jobs plus 200,00 to 400,000 construction jobs.
While natural gas operations are already locked in, their emissions need not be.
Using existing processing technologies, we could generate enough biomethane fuel from our organic wastes to displace 10 percent of current U.S. fossil natural gas use or 25 percent of current on-road diesel fuel use.
If higher-tech ways of making the fuel from additional sources become commercial, such as thermal gasification or power-to-gas, those percentages could more than double. And as biomethane is often net carbon-negative, it would reduce emissions from the natural gas industry even more than the percentage of fossil fuel it displaces.
Companies leading the way
Biomethane’s potential to mitigate the natural gas industry’s negative climate impacts is too great to ignore. Gas companies are starting to recognize it, and some forward-thinking ones are investing in it.
For example, SoCalGas, the largest U.S. natural gas utility, plans to purchase biomethane from California dairies and other digester companies, and provide it to business and residential customers via its pipeline network. It aims to replace 20 percent of the fossil gas it sells today with biomethane by 2030.
California-based Clean Energy Fuels is leading the drive to scale up biomethane in the transport sector, which emits more greenhouse gases than any sector of the U.S. economy. The company’s roots go back to T. Boone Pickens’ championing natural gas as a transportation fuel in the 1990s. Today, it operates over 530 natural gas refueling stations across the country, enabling more bus and truck fleets to switch from diesel to natural gas.
The company also offers financing for new natural-gas-powered heavy-duty trucks equipped with ultra-low emission engines that can run on biomethane, so they cost the same as equivalent diesel trucks. Those engines slash lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions compared to diesel, including virtually eliminating nitrogen oxide pollution. NOx is a public health hazard as well as a climate super pollutant accounting for 6 percent of GHG emissions. Its health-damaging effects are worse in poorer communities that have higher heavy vehicle traffic, and more bus and truck depots.
Clean Energy was the first company to offer biomethane to commercial fleet customers in 2013 under the brand name Redeem. By 2018, most of the fuel the company delivered (53 percent) was Redeem. By 2025, it plans to zero out fossil gas altogether and sell only biomethane.
That’s a remarkable goal. Running exclusively on biomethane by 2025 would allow Clean Energy fleet customers to meet California’s net-zero carbon goal 20 years before the envisioned deadline at minimal incremental cost.
Biomethane is growing rapidly worldwide, with global capacity roughly tripling (PDF) over the last decade. The Danish company Nature Energy is working to phase out fossil gas and sell biomethane exclusively, just as Clean Energy is doing in the United States.
Nature Energy owns nine co-digestion projects in Denmark; it recently merged with Xergi, which has built more than 70 large-scale digester plants worldwide. Biomethane was 10 percent of the natural gas grid in Denmark in 2018 (spi

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.