Neg - Gendered UBI - MNDI 2023 HPA
Neg - Gendered UBI - MNDI 2023 HPA.docx
Indexed text preview
Gendered UBI Neg 1NC - Gender Advantage Resps 1. No solvency – a UBI is Insufficient to overcome societal gender roles and structures. Belgium empirically proves. Koslowski and Duvander, 2018 - prof of Social and Political Science, Univ of Edinburgh and prof of Sociology, Stockholm University [Alison and Ann-Zofie, Working Paper 2018:05 “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?” https://www.su.se/polopoly_fs/1.406392.1539614783!/menu/standard/file/WP_2018_05.pdf Acc 1/28/23 TA] Basic income seeks to support our ambitions, without dictating what these should be. It makes the assumption that the power differential would be sufficiently shifted by the individualised payment to women for them to negotiate different domestic arrangements, and that norms would be flexible enough to accommodate a greater—and less gendered—range of ‘life options’. The experience of the Belgium time credit scheme does not bode well in this regard. The time credit scheme allowed people a limited amount of paid time away from work, for any purpose. It was a seemingly gender-neutral scheme. However, it has seen extremely gendered use in practice. Mothers (but not fathers) in Belgium have overwhelmingly used their time credit account to care for children, in effect as an extension of parenting leave (Deven & Merla, 2019). Perhaps another example is the completely gender-neutral parental leave in Sweden: despite there being individual parallel rights for two parents, gendered practice endures, with women using the lion’s share of leave. These experiences suggest that for a basic income to have an impact on the gendered practices of parenting, further thought would have to be given to how to achieve that specific goal. Gender equality is not a primary aim of a basic income, but it is a hoped for secondary consequence. Parental leave scholarship suggests that gender equality is most efficiently a consequence when it is an explicit policy aim, but that, as described above, even then it might fail to materialise. Perhaps considering the distinction between gender equality and gender equity is helpful here. Gender equity is the value-laden concept that stems from the socially constructed expectations of female and male behaviour, which is based both on gender stratification and gender roles (Fraser, 1994). Gender equity is thus based on the experience of fairness and whose values are valuable, whereas gender equality would be easier defined by quantitative measures of gendered division of time and rewards of paid and unpaid work. Fraser (1994) would say that gender equality depends on female behaviour becoming the norm. Basic income has the potential to change the meaning of gender equity, either reversing back towards traditional gendered expectations, or alternatively liberating us from such stratifications and norms that limit our behaviour. There are many factors in hypothesising is such outcomes, but it seems clear that a basic income set at too low a payment rate would reverse development by necessity. Firestone (1970, p. 1) observed that: Sex class is so deep as to be invisible…the reaction of the common man, woman, and child—That? Why you can’t change that!....This gut reaction, the assumption about changing a fundamental biological condition, is an honest one….That so profound a change cannot be easily fit into traditional categories of thought, e.g., “political,” is not because these categories do not apply but because they are not big enough: radical feminism bursts through them. 8 As with other big political movements, the basic income project does not appear to be ‘big enough’, remaining relatively conservative and essentialist with regard to its understanding of gender equalities. Perhaps it is precisely because a basic income would be such a revolutionary expansion of freedom, that this core unchallenged gender binary worldview is all the more disappointing. An independent source of income is a good start on the road to freedom, but, it is not a sufficient condition to challenge the persistent norms and prevailing gendered structures. To the extent that gender is based on norms and structures, which have to be challenged, basic income, as a gender-neutral idea that hides gender, could be argued to be a necessary condition, but not a sufficient condition to see female behaviour becoming the norm, thus leading us towards gender equality (Fraser, 1994). 2. Turn – Labor Withdrawal undermines emancipation – empirically proven – in a well established welfare state, it would decrease women’s employment Kangas et al, 2023- a Research Director at the Department of Social Research at the University of Turku in Finland [Olli, with Minna Ylikännö "Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 20, no. 3, ProQuest, https://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/basic-income-status-women-established-gender/docview/2774904198/se-2, doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20031733. EO] In the alternate strand of the literature, UBI is seen more negatively (for example, [13,14,15]). For this position, it is feared that UBI forms a strong incentive for women to stay at home, locked in their traditional caring positions. Empirical results from the negative income tax experiments conducted in the U.S. and Canada (Mincome) in the 1970s and the 1980s displayed diminishing female labour market participation: wives and single mothers reduced their labour supply, corresponding to three weeks of full-time employment [29,30,31,32]. When given the possibility, women, especially those in lower socioeconomic groups, opted out of unpleasant jobs and chose to spend more time with their children. Thus, the income transfer introduced in the experiments decreased the female labour supply. This finding is, to some extent, corroborated by a Swedish study on the labour market behaviour of lottery winners who reduced their working time as well as those of their spouses [33]. More detailed analyses from the U.S. experiment suggested that the reduction in labour supply was strongest among mothers with small children who were a part of the experiment, given that the opportunity to stay at home with their babies was not possible under the existing social security schemes [29,30]. The Canadian Mincome experiment displayed fewer substitutional effects [29], which is explained by the fact that the family leave systems in Canada are better than those in the U.S. Thus, the context of social policy matters. There have been attempts to bridge the gap between the two opposing lines of argument. While UBI, when generous enough, provides women with the opportunity to choose between family and work, it simultaneously reshapes patriarchal gender norms around paid work and unpaid care, especially as no person is relegated to being a masculinised ‘breadwinner’ or feminised ‘caretaker’ to attain income security. Combined with the provision of affordable quality care services, UBI could potentially facilitate a more equitable distribution of care between genders [5,6,10,34,35,36]. In most cases, the motivation to introduce UBI is related to perceived problems and shortcomings in existing welfare systems: holes in the safety net, poverty, overly low take-up rates, and stigma attached to means-tested programs. Furthermore, it is argued that social insurance-based transfer schemes typical for most welfare states disproportionally benefit males with longer working careers and higher incomes compared to women with care duties at home and longer absences from the labour market. While social insurance-based social security schemes provide inferior benefits to those who do not participate in full-time formal employment, UBI would treat everyone equally, regardless of participation in the labour market or length of working career [34,35,36,37]. However, there is an obvious weakness in this argumentation. The further the equality of women and men has progressed in the labour market, the weaker this motivation for basic income. This applies first of all to gender-equal welfare states. Thus, our main hypothesis is that in a well-established welfare state, UBI would not be a strong policy measure for female emancipation. 3. Turn - Statistical discrimination – if even Some women leave the labor market, employers will respond by reducing women’s wages because Statistically, it is more likely for all women. Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1515/auk-2001-0108 AC] 2.9 Spill-Over Effects on All Women Due to Statistical Discrimination A last second order effect is an expected increase of statistical discrimination against women. Statistical discrimination is a form of indirect discrimination based on the fact that a person belongs to a group that has certain characteristics. These characteristics are used as proxies for the average productivity of that group. Women on average get one or two children and take maternity leave. They also work less hours on the labour market than men, and bear more responsibility for the household and the care of the children and the elderly. They have more career interruptions and are more absent from the workplace. For all these reasons, it is assumed by many employers that women are on average less productive than men. Furthermore, it is rational for an employer to think of an individual woman that she will share these characteristics of her group, as he has no information on her future commitments. Hence, an employer discriminates a woman (by not hiring her or giving her a lower wage) because the employer has no exact information on her productivity and therefore his perception of the average productivity of all women will count. A woman who does not want children, or wants to make a career or has a husband who takes half of the household responsibilities, will still bear the consequences of the fact that other women are more 'child and household oriented'-which is perceived as a good indicator for lower productivity. This implies that if a basic income is introduced, and a group of women decreases her labour supply, it will also be expected from other women that they will be less labour market attached. Hence, a basic income will probably worsen the statistical discrimination against women. 4. Alternative Causality - Over-policing hurts women of color, driving them into debt Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” https://rooseveltinstitute.org/publications/exploring-guaranteed-income-through-a-racial-and-gender-justice-lens/#:~:text=In%20%E2%80%9C%20Exploring%20Guaranteed%20Income%20Through%20a%20Racial,that%20is%20capable%20of%20redefining%20these%20wealth%20divides. June 2019. Accessed 23 June 2023 EO] Ferguson was representative of the systemic racism prevalent in many other municipalities: Over-policing of communities of color has led to disproportionate rates of stops and arrests of people of color, forcing these communities to pay exorbitant fines and fees and extracting their wealth—and in many cases driving them into debt (Bingham et al. 2016). Additionally, even if women are not the ones being arrested and/or fined, they are the ones primarily paying the fine, fee, or bail money for their sons, grandsons, brothers, partners, uncles, and other family members (deVuono-powell et al. 2015). 63 percent of court-related costs were paid for by family members outside of the system, and 80 percent of these family members were women. Further, close to 90 percent of costs for phone calls and visits to an CREATIVE COMMONS COPYRIGHT 2019 | ROOSEVELTINSTITUTE.ORG 8 incarcerated person are incurred by women (deVuono-powell et al. 2015). This creates an additional financial burden to the layers of economic insecurity women of color already experience from race and gender discrimination in the labor market. These practices and the crusade towards mass incarceration and criminalization of nonviolent crimes effectively strip wealth from Black and brown women and communities. In many cases, these realities prevent people of color from building wealth at all. It is clear that any policy discussion about a guaranteed income must both address the historic barriers placed on women and people of color to build wealth and eliminate current wealthextraction policies that are reinforced by current governmental policies. Putting money into people’s pockets through government interventions won’t mean anything if that money is taken by the government with the other hand. 5. Turn – False Gender Neutrality - A UBI will not challenge gender norms because it is only gender neutral on its face – when it is implemented, it reinforces existing patriarchal institutional norms Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1111/1467-923X.12844. AC] Conclusions Women are increasingly integrated within the waged labour market, but they remain at the same time the primary caregivers of society, at a time where state support for care is being withdrawn. Thus, the double burden many women juggle with—namely between productive and reproductive work—is not only reinforced within the market, but also legitimised by patriarchal norms that become institutionalised through state policies. The UBI alone will not be able to resolve this situation. UBI, because it would still be embedded in pre‐existing patriarchal and institutional norms, is gender neutral ex‐ante but not ex‐post. It is not gender neutral, because it implies undesired consequences for women if it is unable to challenge and readdress their pre‐existing position of disadvantage in society. The response of some Marxist feminists has been to see the basic income and the recognition of women's paid and unpaid work as intrinsically interdependent. Paid and unpaid work is subject to shaped by public and private institutions regulated by the state which, if reformed, can generate transformative change in the way we deal with care, work and welfare as a whole. Workers' organisations, the welfare system and labour legislation need to work to overcome the structural shortfalls of single‐wage households and develop more heterogeneous and fluid mechanisms of social protection and public goods that can dissolve existing patriarchal social norms, redistribute unpaid work duties to men (through, for example, shared parental leave), and tackle the regulatory obstacles faced within non‐heteronormative households. Governments have the tools to regulate and deconstruct social relations with targeted policies and create the necessary institutions to reflect the social heterogeneity we live in. Hence, policy makers should develop policy solutions that have the potential to be transformative for women's material and social disparities in the short and long term. Inequality in reproductive work does not always explain the inequalities occurring in the formal labour market or in the political sphere. Those separate dimensions reinforce the need to redefine what work is and transform the welfare state built around it. Unfortunately, neither UBI nor any form of cash transfer would help this difficult process. 6. Turn – Work Home Binary - A UBI won’t emancipate women because it reproduces the social relations arranged around a work/home dichotomy, which reinforces the patriarchy Lombardozzi, 2020 - Senior Lecturer in Economics at The Open University, UK [Lorena. “Gender Inequality, Social Reproduction and the Universal Basic Income.” Political Quarterly, vol. 91, no. 2, Apr. EBSCOhost, https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.1111/1467-923X.12844. AC] The gender case against UBI: a social reproduction approach Social reproduction is 'the domain where lives are sustained and reproduced', in other words how workers and households—but also capitalists, as well as all kinds of institutions of religion, state and culture—subsist and survive through the relations of production of which they are part.[11] The social reproduction framework underscores that much of the work responsible for reproducing these forms and relations relies on the exploitation of women in the home and elsewhere—in the care home, the school, the hospital and the crèche. As Tithi Bhattacharya writes, '[t]he most historically enduring site for the reproduction of labour power is of course the kin‐based unit we call the family'. But, she continues, labour power 'is not simply replenished at home, nor is it always reproduced generationally.' '[O]ther social relationships and institutions are comprised by the circuit of social reproduction' including care, health services, education, leisure, pensions, benefits.[12] Contemporary conditions in many rich advanced economies have led some to identify a 'crisis of care' synonymous with a crisis in the aforementioned forms of social reproduction.[13] This depends, as mentioned above, on the changing relations between women and labour and on the shift in state support in society. By focussing on the sphere of reproductive work and the gendered division of labour that circumscribes it, a social reproduction approach creates a challenge for the prescription of the UBI, highlighting how the latter situates work exclusively within the dynamic of buying and selling labour power, rather than the specific social conditions that make it both possible and necessary to begin with.[14] Yet, whilst Marxist feminists taking a social reproduction standpoint have been central in popularising the call for a UBI—for example, around the 'Wages for Housework' campaigns—others have been more circumspect. Weeks notes that the 'demand for a UBI does not directly address either the unequal gendered division of household‐based reproductive labour or its privatization', even 'serv[ing] simply to offer more support for the traditional hetero‐patriarchal family's gender division of productive and reproductive labour, with more men participating in waged work and more women working in the home'.[15] 7. Turn – Privatization - A basic income increases systemic gender discrimination by causing a shift to privatization of caregiving, which reinforces domestic violence Gheaus, 2008 – political philosopher at the Université Catholique de Lille [Anca, Dec, An International Journal of Basic Income Research Vol. 3, Issue 3 “Basic Income, Gender Justice and the Costs of Gender‐Symmetrical Lifestyles” http://www.bepress.com/bis/vol3/iss3/art8 Acc 5/18/23 TA] 3. The Increased Privatization of Care If a BI will lead, as some critics fear, to a serious shortage of labour supply in the caring professions, care might become increasingly (re)privatized. Given current cultural norms, it is likely that women will be expected to shoulder the burden of private care, especially if they will indeed gradually be more excluded from the market. The privatization of care and the confinement of more women to domesticity fare badly for gender justice for a number of reasons. Economically, women will lose skills and social capital, making their re‐entry in the market increasingly difficult – ultimately, many will have no substantive exit right from domesticity. Socially and culturally, the privatization of care may lead to the perpetuation of domestic violence and gender stereotypes. Psychologically, all blame for bad care will (continue to) g
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.