Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 MNDI Kritik

K - Biopower - MNDI 2023 HPA

K - Biopower - MNDI 2023 HPA.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Biopower Kritik --- MNDI AHP
Special thank you to:
Anaya Brainch (New Trier)
Devin Brainch (New Trier))
Asher Meron (Harvard Westlake)
Michelle Sokovikova (Lane Tech)
Ruby Stoneking (Hudson High School)
Daria Teicher (Chapin Highschool)
Max Turetzky (Harvard Westlake)
Tejas Rajagopalan (University School)
Ismini Vasiloglou (Westminster)
If you have any questions, feel free to reach out to Joshua Harrington at joshharr@umich.edu. (I’d rehighlight this file before using)
Definitions
Definitions
Michel Foucault!
Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy – popular encyclopedia of philosophy [“Michel Foucault (1926-1987)” IV] https://iep.utm.edu/foucault/
Michel Foucault was a major figure in two successive waves of 20th century French thought–the structuralist wave of the 1960s and then the poststructuralist wave. By the premature end of his life, Foucault had some claim to be the most prominent living intellectual in France. Foucault’s work is transdisciplinary in nature, ranging across the concerns of the disciplines of history, sociology, psychology, and philosophy. At the first decade of the 21st century, Foucault is the author most frequently cited in the humanities in general. In the field of philosophy this is not so, despite philosophy being the primary discipline in which he was educated, and with which he ultimately identified. This relative neglect is because Foucault’s conception of philosophy, in which the study of truth is inseparable from the study of history, is thoroughly at odds with the prevailing conception of what philosophy is. Foucault’s work can generally be characterized as philosophically oriented historical research; towards the end of his life, Foucault insisted that all his work was part of a single project of historically investigating the production of truth. What Foucault did across his major works was to attempt to produce an historical account of the formation of ideas, including philosophical ideas. Such an attempt was neither a simple progressive view of the history, seeing it as inexorably leading to our present understanding, nor a thoroughgoing historicism that insists on understanding ideas only by the immanent standards of the time. Rather, Foucault continually sought for a way of understanding the ideas that shape our present not only in terms of the historical function these ideas played, but also by tracing the changes in their function through history.
Homo sacer definition.
Tagma, Halit Mustafa, 2009, prof. in the Political Science department at Arizona State University ("Homo sacer vs. homo soccer mom: Reading Agamben and Foucault in the war on terror.") Alternatives 34.4 (2009): 407-435. https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/pdf/10.1177/030437540903400403 Rs
At such a juncture, it is timely to reflect on a body of scholarship that contributed to a growing literature on Guántanamo Bay, the “war on terror,” and our more general understanding between sovereignty and political violence. This literature has offered various interpretations of the different forms of political violence that have come be known as indefinite detention, torture, and extraordinary rendition. In the growing body of popular and scholarly studies on the “war on terror,” the most interesting and popularized analogy used to identify the status of Guántanamo prisoners is the figure of homo sacer. Advanced by Giorgio Agamben, the concept of homo sacer refers to “a body that can be killed but not sacrificed.” In most studies of the “war on terror” this analogy is taken as obvious. For example, quoting a US senator, Slavoj Zizek underlines how the prisoners are regarded as expendable biological creatures: “The inmates at Guántanamo were those that were missed by the bombs.”3 Nevertheless, important questions can be raised with respect to this hasty connection between the concept of homo sacer and the prisioners in Guántanamo, and in this article I want to engage in a careful theoretical analysis of aspects of Guántanamo that problematize the association. Moreover, I want to suggest that while Agamben is trying to both correct and build upon Foucault’s understanding of biopower, his neglect of the details and nuances of Foucault’s work has lead him to betray important components of Foucault’s understanding of biopower.
Biopolitics.
Camarena 14
Carlos Gomez Camarena (Literature Department, Universidad Iberoamericana Ciudad de Mexico), 2014, “Biopolitics,” Encyclopedia of Critical Psychology, https://link.springer.com/referencework/10.1007/978-1-4614-5583-7 //MLT
Biopolitics is the attempt to explain the history of civilization through the laws of cellular life and the most elementary biology (Starobinski, 1960). It is for this reason that social Darwinism and sociobiology are only two aspects of a wider phenomenon, the mechanisms of which Foucault worked to expose. According to Foucault’s thought, biopolitics is a way of thinking about governmental practice through the categories of living beings constituted in a population (health, hygiene, birthrate, longevity, races). Biopolitics is a way of exercising power by multiplying the disciplines (demographics, statistics, and the analysis of wealth) and institutions (schools, headquarters, hospitals) that reorganize learning, education, and order in society. Roberto Esposito, (2008, p. 15) suggests that the structure of biopolitics is so intricate that the terms “life” and “politics” can be conjugated in two ways: a politics that governs life (biopower, politics over life) and a life that governs politics (biopolitics, the politics of life). Thus, while biopower exhibits a negative facet, biopolitics is the positive face of the relationship between power and life. Other authors such as (Bazzicalupo, 2010) prefer the terms biopower and affirmative biopolitics.
Necropolitics.
Verghese, 2021 [Namrata, writer and Phd candidate at Stanford, Mar 10 2021, Teen Vogue, “What is Necropolitics? The Political Calculation of Life and Death” https://www.teenvogue.com/story/what-is-necropolitics]
Necro comes from the Greek root nekros, meaning “corpse.” Necropolitics then translates to the “politics of death.” Philosopher Achille Mbembe describes necropolitics as “the capacity to define who matters and who does not, who is disposable and who is not.” In other words, necropolitics is a framework that illuminates how governments assign differential value to human life. The closer you are to dominant power, the more your life is worth. In the United States, if you’re a straight, white, able-bodied, cisgender, wealthy, Christian man, this is great news for you. But the further away you are from those axes of privilege, the less your life is worth under the logics of necropolitics — and the more precarious your existence becomes.
Even if you’ve never encountered the term necropolitics before, you probably already understand it as a gut instinct. Have you heard of “collateral damage”? It’s a phrase we often associate with U.S. bombings in the Middle East. It suggests that some people may have to die to achieve an abstract societal good. It is not a coincidence that the victims of these bombings are, by and large, not white, not wealthy, not Christian, and not American. “Collateral damage” justifies the killing of millions of Black and brown people. Our governments rationalize their deaths as the only means by which the rest of us can lead better lives. This, to me, is the heart of necropolitics: One person’s life comes at the expense of a more vulnerable person’s death. Or, in Mbembe’s words: “The calculus of life passes through the death of the Other.”
Disciplinary Power.
DEMİRBAŞ ‘19 ELİF DEMİRBAŞ, Bogazici University MS, Brandeis University PhD, University of Massachusetts, Lowell, 2019, https://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12622927/index.pdf ED
A counterpart of disciplinary power, bio-power emerged somewhat later, though these two types of power were undeniably linked in their formation. Foucault explains how sovereign power could no longer organize the modernizing Europe, with its demographic explosion and continuous industrialization in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries (Foucault, 2003, p. 249). “So much so that far too many things were escaping the old mechanism of the power of sovereignty, both at the top and at the bottom, both at the level of detail and at the mass level” (ibid, p. 249). First, disciplinary power emerged to take care of the details. By using surveillance and training, disciplinary power was applied on the individual body, so as to shape and mend the body to fit the appropriate norms of the disciplinary society. Hence, we see the formation of schools, hospitals, barracks, workshops, asylums and punitive institutions in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. These strategies formed what Foucault terms as the micro-physics of power, which is “a study of the forms and means of power focused on individuals and the details of their behavior and conduct” (Gordon, 2001, p. xxiv). For the mass level, however, a second type of power emerged, which is termed by Gordon as the “macro” physics of power (cited in Collier, 2009, p. 81), centered not on the individual body, “man-as-body,” but on the multiplicity of men, “man-as-species” (Foucault, 2003, p. 242). Perhaps the best way to explain what bio-power is to compare its working mechanisms with those of disciplinary power. The most striking difference 66 between two types of power is, as mentioned above, that while disciplinary power is applied on individual bodies, bio-power is applied on masses or populations. The former disciplines, trains and uses surveillance and other direct measurers in achieving its aims. The latter, however, regulates and coordinates. It does not use constant surveillance of individual bodies but uses more overall measures. Or, to put it more precisely, bio-power transforms disciplinary power’s mechanism of surveillance of individual bodies into statistical estimates of an entire population. While disciplinary power tries to optimize each individual’s capacities, bio-power tries to achieve or maintain an average level of optimal capacities in a population. Bio-power does not care about each individual conforming to the norm as disciplinary power does. Its aim is to achieve an overall level of compliance to the norm; because bio-power is not “centered on the body as machine” as disciplinary power is, it is “focused on the species body” (Foucault, 1978, p. 139).
1NC
1NC --- Shell
The 1AC extends the power of the necropolitical war machine to surveil and manage the activities of citizens. The apocalypse is coming now, but the plans proliferation of scenarios makes bare life inevitable.
Stümer and Loest 22 [Jenny Stümer, researcher for Centre for Apocalyptic and Post-Apocalyptic Studies, Felicitas Loest, managing director of the Centre for Apocalyptic Studies and Post-Apocalyptic Studies, 2022, Editorial Apocalyptica, “The Apocalyptic World, Why Begin with The End of the World”, https://doi.org/10.17885/heiup.apoc.2022.1.24602, JMH]
As we move forward with Apocalyptica’s first issue, the world is looking dire: Anthropogenic climate change is accelerating, the petrochemical experiment is in full force, resources are depleting, species are vanishing, climate refugees are met with increasingly militarized borders, forests are burning, oceans are dying, we all have plastics in our blood and the COVID-19 pandemic still holds a strong grip on the world. Meanwhile Vladimir Putin has raised the stakes of nuclear threat once more as millions are fleeing a war-torn Ukraine. In Yemen Children are starving. Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos are colonizing space. The Far right is on the rise around the globe and disaster capitalism is feeding off the poor. People are tearing each other apart on social media. Oil spills, earthquakes, hurricanes and school shootings are common news events. Homelessness is endemic. The necropolitical war machine is tearing through the Middle East. Algorithmic governance has put us under constant surveillance. Scientists have glued their hands in protest to the UK Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy while Don’t Look Up is the second most watched film on Netflix. Kentanji Brown Jackson is being badgered at her confirmation hearing and the Dakota Access Pipeline is still transporting toxic crude oil to the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe reservation. Slow violence has gained traction; the Hyperobject is disintegrating We are faced with a plethora of catastrophes; a cataclysm of apocalyptic scenarios all of which propose the unravelling of a destructive way of inhabiting the Earth, or an anti-relational refusal of the (common) world, while constantly doubling down on the gendered, raced, colonial, and environmental violence that have impelled these devastating patterns in the first place. The simultaneity of apocalyptic upheaval, in other words, provokes a peculiar convergence of premonitions, experiences, and time lines, where one end is haunted by an /other, giving rise to new challenges that demand our questioning of what it meant, means, and will mean to live through the end times. Following Karan Barad, it is obvious that these different apocalypses do not merely exist side by side but that they can live “inside” each other (2018, 57), uprooting the past and throwing us back to the future as the present slips away. In other words, there are many endings and many worlds, but it is through the philosophical trope of the pluralist apocalypse that we can come to approach the interconnectedness and intersectionality of these various (up)endings. Nagasaki and Hiroshima, the colonial assault on the Americas, Africa, and Australasia, two World Wars, slave ships, famines, genocides, invasions, dispossessions, storms, floods, diseases, and the coming bee extinction; these earth /world-shattering events can (and should) not be equated, of course, but they interlace and blend in ways the apocalypse as a figure of thought can make tangible and therefore, thinkable. In this sense, apocalypse as an intellectual project reminds us that death and catastrophe cannot be simply relegated to what Malcom Ferdinand describes as “off-world spaces, far removed from European Centers” (2021, 65) — if not for lack of trying — and that the disasters of past and present are neither neutral nor natural but subject to political and cultural forces that we can and must interrogate. At the Käte Hamburger Centre for Apocalyptic and Post-apocalyptic Studies (CAPAS) we work with the premise that the apocalypse provides a way into thinking through these complex and urgent entanglements. We propose that apocalypses are productive, that they are more than theological abstractions and that the world(s) they are upending are not a given. We assume that apocalypses have happened and that they prompt us to question how we make sense of /in a disaster-ridden world. Optimistically speaking, apocalypses are transformative: They are about the creation of novel and emancipatory collective imaginaries that undo pervasive conceptions of the world and trouble established ontological and epistemological promises of the ways we may inhabit this planet. As NK Jemisin puts it, “the end of the world is happening as we speak. The question becomes whether it’s the kind of world that needs to go.” (Jemisin 2018, 477). In this vein, we want to broaden the notion of the apocalypse beyond ideas of disaster projected onto a future that ideally requires no change from us. Instead, apocalypses and post-apocalypses invoke a possibility of constructive upheaval, revolutionary energy, and radical difference. Jemisin’s provocative evocation of what John Drabinski, with reference to Aimé Césaire might call “the apocalyptic word” reminds us that “out of the end of the world, beginning is possible” (572) and that the end of history has not actually happened. As Oxana Timofeeva puts it, “the end of the world is a permanent reality. History doesn’t have an end” (2014). Rather, “the end of the end of history” (Timofeeva 2014) can free us to reshape our world(s), in so far as its inscribed futurelessness marks a “starting point for thought” (2020, 4) in Jessica Hurley’s words. The end thus produces “a place for struggle and resistance and somehow, impossibly, for hope” (Hurley 2020, 4). In this sense, living and thinking with apocalypses changes the horizon of how we orient the present and deal with the environmental and human consequences of Western chronopolitics. As Drabinski has further explained, “without apocalypse, there is always and only the despair of the past dragged into a melancholic present and future” (2016, 567). Our approach to the end of the world then is respectful to the destructions of past, present, and future, but, at the same time, it is defiantly enthusiastic, refusing the apocalypse as a bad object per se. Instead, we utilize the end as an opening, as Césaire would insist: Apocalypse, in this sense, unlocks new ways of thinking and being in and with the world. In line with these bearings, we treat the apocalypses as end and beginning. Apocalypse as a mode of thinking, writing and working together teaches us about the limits and potentialities of ‘world’, ‘worlds’, and ‘worlding’; raising questions about what it means to think with, against and beyond the end today. What movements, politics, ideas, geographies, sensibilities, stories, and images might be considered (post)apocalyptic or invoke debates and feelings about the end of the /a world? How do apocalypses entangle temporalities of past, present, and future? How do crisis and catastrophe shape human and non-human actors and their interconnections? And, how does the apocalypse as an idea help us to address escalating global as well as local challenges in ways that may articulate the promise of more just political futures and fuller relationships with each other and the world? Apocalyptica makes room for exploring these questions, utilizing the apocalypse as a point of uncovering and connection. Of course, etymologically the word apocalypse refers to a revelation; it marks an unveiling or disclosure, elucidating something that is hidden or less obvious. At the same time (and perhaps more commonly) we tend to think of apocalypses as catastrophic events that are shocking, crushing, and overthrow the status quo. We hope that this journal can be a venue for both of these nuances: presenting, discovering and illuminating novel approaches and ideas about the end of the world that in some sense mark a form of obliteration, a shattering of established worlds and ways of being and thinking. This includes a commitment to our transdisciplinary mission — an effort to encourage the possibility of open-access dialogue between different fields as well as with and between diverse epistemologies and cosmologies, toppling the boundaries that keep us apart. The apocalypse as an academic venture requires the exploration of a variety of theoretical and methodological consideration as it invites a broad range of experiential and experimental case studies. We maintain that where apocalypses and their envisioned aftermaths produce a series of practical, intellectual, and creative opportunities that engage with the possibility of plural worlds, embodied futurities, or non-linear temporalities, they can reflect on the cultural or lived experiences, haunting sensibilities, and productive fantasies that employ the un /making of worlds. If, as Jacques Derrida puts it in his musings on the apocalyptic tone in philosophy, “disclosure not only opens to vision or contemplation, not only affords seeing but also affords hearing/ understanding,” (1984, 5) then we need to explore each other’s way of relating to the world (or refusing it) in order to fully appreciate and endorse the emancipatory potentials of apocalyptic thinking and writing
The 1AC is an instance of liberal governmentality 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.