AT Minimum Wage CP - MNDI 2023 DMP
AT Minimum Wage CP - MNDI 2023 DMP.docx
Indexed text preview
Aff No Solvency No Solvency – Innovation/Growth Raising the Minimum wage fails: No behavioral response among firms and workers (will lead to unemployment) No innovation to offset higher costs (companies will shrink) Makridis 16 [Christos Makridis; February 5 2016; a Ph.D. Candidate in Macroeconomics and Public Finance at Stanford University; The New Republic; “Raising the Minimum Wage Won’t Reduce Inequality”; https://newrepublic.com/article/129286/raising-minimum-wage-wont-reduce-inequality; CP] Walmart is giving more than one million of its employees a raise later this month as part of a plan that will lift all but its newest hires to at least $10 an hour. The move, first announced last year, follows an aggressive campaign to get the largest private employer in the U.S. to lift worker wages and coincides with a nationwide push to raise federal and state minimum wages and a prolonged period of little growth in pay. While Walmart’s decision is at least in part a result of that pressure, it’s still the action of a private company to revamp its own wage policies, as opposed to the result of a government forcing it to lift worker pay. Proponents of requiring just that argue raising the minimum helps reduce inequality. Critics contend it can actually worsen it by driving up unemployment and weakening economy-wide labor market flexibility by raising the costs firms face. So what does the economic research say about the impact of minimum wages on income inequality and is there a better way to reduce it? Minimum wage fallacies. Many of the articles in the mainstream press promoting minimum wages are incompatible with basic economic principles. The first fallacy is that changes in the minimum wage do not affect the behavioral response among firms and individuals. The second fallacy is that higher wages will force companies to innovate in order to reduce costs. Both these arguments overlook some very basic, but informative, economic principles. The first overlooks the fact that wages are designed to compensate workers for productivity. When wages are distorted, they affect the profit-maximizing decisions that businesses make. The textbook prediction, which is generally supported in the data, is that higher minimum wages reduce employment since companies restrict the number of workers they will hire. These adverse effects are especially likely given the pace of technological change and automation. The second overlooks the fact that there are effective and ineffective ways to stimulate innovation among businesses. The idea that making hiring more costly will spur innovation is tantamount to requiring companies to reduce the size of their physical presence so they become more productive. While these types of distortions may prompt a small fraction of companies to innovate, misallocation more generally is a major factor behind cross-country differences in productivity. No Solvency - Inequality Alt cause to inequality – CP doesn’t solve Makridis 16 [Christos Makridis; February 5 2016; a Ph.D. Candidate in Macroeconomics and Public Finance at Stanford University; The New Republic; “Raising the Minimum Wage Won’t Reduce Inequality”; https://newrepublic.com/article/129286/raising-minimum-wage-wont-reduce-inequality; CP] Minimum wage and inequality Nonetheless, economists themselves have debated how minimum wages affect employer decisions for many years. In 1994, economists David Card and Alan Krueger were the first to provide some evidence that such effects may be small. But more recently, a consensus has generally emerged that changes to minimum wages have strong effects on jobs growth. How minimum wages affect inequality, however, remains controversial. Detecting it with standard statistical methods is very challenging because their full effects are constantly changing and require data on both individuals and companies. Back in 1999, Princeton economist David Lee used the Consumer Population Survey (CPS) from 1979 to 1989 to argue that the declining purchasing power of the minimum wage largely explains why inequality surged in the 1980s. Other new research, however, has put that conclusion in doubt. Perhaps the most conclusive reassessment comes from economists David Autor, Alan Manning, and Christopher Smith earlier this year. Using many more years of microdata from the CPS, as well as a different statistical approach, they found that the minimum wage explains at most 30 percent to 40 percent of the rise in wage inequality among the lowest earners. Since economists had thought that changes in the minimum wage could explain as much as 90 percent of the shift in inequality, these new estimates are important. How wages affect worker behavior While the extent is still uncertain, it’s clear that the minimum wage and other wage-setting forces such as tax rates and union bargaining power do in fact affect inequality and the labor market. My own ongoing research, which focuses on the link between such wage-setting mechanisms and company behavior, suggests labor-market distortions like raising the minimum wage can have other negative effects on workers, businesses and inequality beyond the overall impact on employment. The first adverse effect concerns how much people work. If, for example, worker wages rise due to a government mandate, the employer may reduce the number of hours staff work, leading to lower paychecks even after the raise. That’s part of the reason why we’ve seen companies like McDonald’s increasingly try to automate tasks that were once held by people. In addition, my research suggests one of the major ways people acquire new skills is by spending more time at work. Thus policies that lead to fewer hours could lower employees’ ability to improve their long-run earnings potential. The second is an indirect effect on the way businesses invest in workers and design compensation and organizational policies. When companies are forced to pay higher wages, they may offset the cost by reducing how much they invest in workers. There is evidence that minimum wage laws have this effect. This can result in weaker compensation contracts (e.g., purely salary-based), which provide employees with fewer incentives to accumulate skills. As a result, workers paid fixed wages suffer greater long-run earnings volatility than those receiving performance-based pay. Put simply, if a recession comes and an individual loses his or her job, having more skills makes it easier to find a new position and return to the previous income level. Minimal impact on inequality Even setting aside all the plausible economic arguments against the minimum wage, under the best case scenario, what does it really achieve? If the average full-time employee works 1,700 hours per year, then moving from $7.25 an hour to $9 an hour produces only about $2,975 in additional annual earnings. While some may argue that something is better than nothing, this would be at best a marginal solution to inequality. Taking a look at the most recent 2015 Current Population Survey data and restrict the sample to full-time earners with over $10,000 earnings per year, Americans at the 90th income percentile (they earn more than 90 percent of their compatriots, or $80,000 a year) make 5.6 times as much, on average, as those at the 10th percentile ($14,200). Increasing the minimum wage to $9 an hour would put the ratio around 4.65. In other words, even in the best of worlds—where the minimum wage has no unintended side effects—it appears to only marginally reduce inequality. First, companies are welcome to raise wages at any time they want. And letting them do so may be more effective at reducing inequality than when they’re forced to because it avoids the adverse consequences such as reducing hours. Businesses are well aware of their marginal costs and benefits—how much it costs to produce an additional unit of output versus the incremental gain. When governments set uniform wage regulations, they require all companies—each with their own and distinct marginal costs and benefits—to abide by the same rules. In contrast, when companies decide to change their own pay practices—as Walmart is doingthey do so in a more efficient way. Alternatives to raising the minimum wage. Where does this leave us in trying to reduce inequality? Second, as Stanford economist John Cochrane has remarked, instead of addressing the short-term problem of low wages, governments and companies can address the more structural problem: a lack of skills. Companies and local governments can provide training programs and support for additional education, such as through community colleges, in order to equip workers with additional skills that translate into meaningful value for their companies. Investing in worker skills can lead to increased employee productivity and creativity, which in turn translates into sustained higher wages. And these benefits have broad spillover effects throughout the labor market and make sustainable gains in narrowing the gap between the richest and the poorest. While the economic effects of minimum wage laws are very complex and a subject of scrutiny within the economics community, there are much better ways to deal with systematic challenges in the labor market. Getting more people to work, reducing the barriers for businesses to hire and encouraging the accumulation of new skills are all strategies for promoting sustainable long-term growth in wages. A2 Politics Links to Politics – Dems favor, but Republicans are against Davis and Hartig, ’19 – Leslie Davis is an intern at Pew Research Center and Hannah Hartig is a research associate at Pew Research Center (“Two-thirds of Americans favor raising federal minimum wage to $15 an hour,” Pew Research Center, 7/30/19, https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2019/07/30/two-thirds-of-americans-favor-raising-federal-minimum-wage-to-15-an-hour/)//CTP By a wide margin, Americans say they favor raising the federal minimum wage to $15 an hour. But there is a deep partisan divide in views of this proposed policy – a version of which recently passed the Democratic-controlled House of Representatives, though it is unlikely to be taken up by the GOP-controlled Senate. Two-thirds of Americans (67%) support raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, including 41% who say they strongly favor such an increase, according to a Pew Research Center survey conducted this spring. [chart omitted] Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents are largely united in backing a $15 an hour federal minimum wage: 86% favor this, including nearly six-in-ten (59%) who say they strongly support it. Republican opinion on this issue is more divided, but a majority of Republicans and Republican leaners – 57% – oppose raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, including nearly three-in-ten (29%) who say they are strongly against it. A2 Debt NB N/U – Debt increasing Debt increasing now – highest since WWII and will increase Klein and Obstfeld 6/12/23 [Michael Klein and Maurice Obstfeld; 6-12-2023; FLETCHER SCHOOL OF LAW AND DIPLOMACY, TUFTS UNIVERSITY. Professor of International Economic Affairs; UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, BERKELEY. Class of 1958 Professor of Economics; Econofact | Key facts and incisive analysis to the national debate on economic and social policies., "Why is the U.S. Debt Expected to Keep Growing?", https://econofact.org/why-is-the-u-s-debt-expected-to-keep-growing]BG The United States Federal debt is the subject of ongoing concern and, during negotiations over lifting the debt ceiling, a source of political friction. Current debt levels are higher than at any time since the end of World War II. The Federal government debt in the hands of the public was 96.9 percent of Gross Domestic Product at the end of 2022, somewhat lower than it was at the end of 2021, but well above the 79.2 percent of GDP at the end of 2019, before the pandemic. Other economies similarly have seen spikes in public debt relative to GDP since the beginning of 2020, when the worldwide COVID pandemic led to rising public-sector deficits and slower economic growth. Despite the high-stakes negotiations around the debt ceiling, the U.S. Federal debt relative to GDP is projected to continue growing over the next decade. What factors account for this projection and why does it matter? The CBO estimates that the U.S. Treasury will pay 3.9 percent interest on average on its 10-year borrowing in 2023 and 4.5 percent on its 3-month borrowing. These interest rates are up from 3 percent and 2 percent, respectively, in 2022. The Facts: There are two main costs of a higher public debt. First, the government must pay additional interest on its debt, which may require it to raise taxes or cut expenditure programs. Second, if the economy’s saving flows into government debt, less is available to finance accumulation of possibly more productive capital assets, such as machinery, factories, and intellectual property. The level of publicly held debt as a fraction of GDP is a key ratio because the costs of any debt level are less important when the economy is larger. For a given level of debt, costs become less important as the economy grows because growth raises both the tax base and the flow of private saving. Conversely, a rising ratio of debt to GDP could signal lower economic growth. Historically, excessive debt-GDP ratios have sometimes led to financial crises in which governments may default on their debts, either through changes in repayment terms or through unexpected inflation. The government publishes statistics on its total gross debt and the portion that is publicly held. While the former is used in determining whether the government has exceeded its debt ceiling, and is often cited by the public (for example, in the U.S. Debt Clock), this includes money the government owes itself. The publicly held Federal debt is, therefore, the more relevant measure. (The figure presents data on gross debt and publicly held debt from 1940 to 2022.) The U.S. national debt is projected to exceed 100 percent of GDP in the next year or two. The rate at which the debt grows relative to GDP depends partly on fiscal policies, inflation, and real GDP growth. Nominal GDP is the denominator in the debt-GDP ratio, so when it goes up, either through real growth or inflation, the ratio of government debt (measured in dollars) to GDP falls. But GDP growth also influences the debt-GDP ratio through its effect on the government’s deficit. A government issues additional debt when its net revenue does not fully cover its outlays and the interest it owes on existing debt, creating a deficit. When the economy suffers a downturn, government borrowing normally rises owing to reduced tax revenue, higher automatic outlays on social safety net programs like unemployment insurance, as well as new discretionary spending and tax measures to support the economy. In turn, higher deficits make government debt rise more quickly. Then, as the economy recovers, deficits tend to fall, reducing the pace of increase in government debt. For example, the Federal budget deficit tripled from $983.6 billion (4.6 percent of GDP) in 2019 to $3,129 billion in 2020 (14.9 percent of GDP) during the sharp COVID recession, according to data from the non-partisan Tax Policy Center. As the economy recovered, the deficit fell to $2,775 billion in 2021 (12.4 percent of GDP). These deficits have added to the Federal debt and the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) forecasts debt held by the public to grow even more over the coming years, to 100.4 percent of GDP in 2024 and 108.9 percent of GDP five years after that (see Table 1, in the 10-year Budget Projections report for May 2023). N/U – Fed spending increasing Federal spending increasing now – Medicaid, welfare, health tax credits, school food programs, and interest Edwards 23 [Chris; March 23; Former senior economist on the congressional Joint Economic Committee, a manager with PricewaterhouseCoopers, and economist with the Tax Foundation; “Federal Spending Up 40 Percent Since 2019,“https://www.cato.org/blog/federal-spending-40-2019#:~:text=Federal%20spending%20jumped%20from%20%244.45,percent%20increase%20in%20four%20years.] Federal spending jumped from $4.45 trillion in 2019 to $6.21 trillion in 2023, according to the Congressional Budget Office. That is a 40 percent increase in four years. The pandemic supercharged the federal budget, and spending and deficits are expected to continue rising unless policymakers pursue major reforms. What is all the new spending since 2019? The answer is surprising, as shown in the two tables below. The main drivers of the recent increases have not been the largest three programs—Social Security, Medicare, and defense—but rather rapid growth in numerous other programs. Table 1 shows CBO spending for 2019 and baseline estimates for 2023. The largest increases have been nondefense discretionary, Medicaid, veterans, food stamps, health tax credits, welfare, school food programs, and interest. All data in both tables are fiscal year outlays. Turn – Progressive tax Reversing tax cuts for wealthy key to solving debt crisis – other factors are temporary Kogan, ’23 -- Senior Director, Federal Budget Policy (Bobby, “Tax Cuts Are Primarily Responsible for the Increasing Debt Ratio,” 3/27/23, https://www.americanprogress.org/article/tax-cuts-are-primarily-responsible-for-the-increasing-debt-ratio/)//CTP Conclusion A series of massive, permanent tax cuts have created large federal budget primary shortfalls and continue to exert upward pressure on the debt ratio. In other words, the current fiscal gap—the growing debt as a percentage of the economy—stems from legislation that cut taxes, disproportionately for the very rich. While it is true that the Great Recession and legislation to fight it, along with the costs of responding to the health and economic effects of COVID-19, pushed the level of debt higher, these costs were temporary and did not change the trajectory of the debt ratio. If Congress wants to decrease deficits, it should look first toward reversing tax cuts that largely benefited the wealthy, which were responsible for the United States’ current fiscal outlook. No IL – No defense cuts Congress won’t cut the defense budget – China threat, lessons from 2013, and Ukraine focus Guyer, ‘23 -- Senior Foreign Policy Writer (Jonathan, “Republicans didn’t really want to cut the military budget after all,” Vox, 1/15/23, https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2023/1/15/23553637/kevin-mccarthy-congress-freedom-military-budget-cut-ukraine)//CTP Three reasons the budget won’t change The hawkish consensus around the threat of China is a primary reason that cuts to the military budget are highly improbable. Andrew Lautz, a policy director at the National Taxpayers Union, says that, even without compromising US national security, big cuts are possible on outdated military programs. But he is pessimistic that those would happen in the near future and pointed out how quickly Republican leaders, even some of the holdouts that McCarthy negotiated with, are starting to dispute the notion that defense cuts have ever been on the table. And so-called Reagan Republicans want to see a bigger budget to counter China. “The solution is always more spending,” Lautz told me. “I don’t think we will, anytime in the next two years, see meaningful cuts to the defense budget happening through the appropriations process.” A second reason for the unlikelihood of significant defense budget cuts is the mess that unfolded in 2013, when debt ceiling negotiations led to the complex wrangling of a congressional super-committee and a sequestration process that caused mandated, across-the-board defense budget cuts that the military and lawmakers of both parties hated. No one wants to repeat what happened with knock-on effects of the Budget Control Act of 2011. “Congress has to be a critical partner in resourcing the military an
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.