Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 SDI Disadvantage

IRS DA - MSDI 2023

IRS DA - MSDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
IRS TRADEOFF DA
NOTES
The Disadvantage points out that the strategy necessitates the IRS to allocate significant resources to taxing high-net-worth individuals and businesses. The most challenging tax disputes often involve these entities as they are the most capable of avoiding taxes through both legal and illegal means, and can afford to retain a large team of accountants and tax lawyers to safeguard these avoidance techniques. The IRS is likely to face difficulty succeeding in these disputes, consuming massive person-power and resources, which could be more effectively used to achieve the agency's existing objectives.
1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Terror
IRS hiring 20,000, yet resources are stretched thin
Heckman, 23. (Jory Heckman, Reporter for Federal News Network, “IRS plans for 20,000 new hires by end of FY 2024 to replace aging workforce” Federal News Network. Web. 4-6-2023. Accessed 7-2-2023. https://federalnewsnetwork.com/hiring-retention/2023/04/irs-plans-for-30000-new-hires-by-end-of-fy-2024-to-replace-aging-workforce/#:~:text=Hiring%2FRetention-,IRS%20plans%20for%2020%2C000%20new%20hires%20by%20end,2024%20to%20replace%20aging%20workforce&text=The%20IRS%20is%20preparing%20to,experience%20and%20beef%20up%20enforcement. JBFunke)
The IRS is preparing to hire tens of thousands of new employees by the end of fiscal 2024, with many of those new hires going to improve taxpayer experience and beef up enforcement.The IRS outlined its hiring and workforce goals as part of the Strategic Operating Plan it released Thursday.More broadly, the plan describes how the IRS will spend nearly $80 billion in the Inflation Reduction Act, which is meant for the agency to rebuild its workforce and modernize its legacy IT over the next decade.The IRS plans to hire more than 10,000 employees before the end of this fiscal year, and nearly an additional 10,000 employees in fiscal 2024. Most of the hiring is focused on taxpayer services and enforcement.Newly confirmed IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel said the spending plan “is only the beginning of our work,” as the agency also looks at long-term ways to modernize its IT and shrink a growing tax gap between what taxpayers owe, and what the agency is able to collect.“For years, the agency has not had the resources to provide the service people deserve. Across all of our operations we’ve seen the impact. We’ve lost employees and seen our resources stretched thin with new mandates and an increasingly complex economy,” Werfel said. “The IRS looks forward to demonstrating how the actions under this plan will translate into real improvements for taxpayers.”
*****Insert Link Card Here*****
IRS modernization solves identity theft and fraud
GAO 23 (“IRS Needs to Complete Modernization Plans and Fully Address Cloud Computing Requirements,” http://www.gao.gov/assets/820/814634.pdf)//BB
The mission of IRS, a component agency within the Department of the Treasury, is to (1) provide America’s taxpayers top quality service by helping them understand and meet their tax responsibilities, and (2) enforce the law with integrity and fairness to all. While it relies extensively on IT to carry out this mission, IRS has reported that modernization is needed to improve its core tax administration systems, operations, and cybersecurity. IRS has also reported that modernization is critical to improving customer experience and providing the kind of service taxpayers have come to expect. For example, IRS has previously reported that modernization will help address business and technical challenges due to constraints with the Individual Master File (IMF) program it has been using since 1970.10 These challenges include the inability to get a real-time view of the taxpayer account, quickly respond to tax code changes, provide enhanced analytical capabilities, and provide additional taxpayer account information to more effectively combat fraud and identity theft.
Fraud funds terror operations
Tierney 18, George & Mary Hylton Professor of International Relations; Director Global Research Institute (GRI) (Michael, “#TerroristFinancing: An Examination of Terrorism Financing via the Internet,” International Journal of Cyber Warfare and Terrorism, vol. 8, no. 1, 01/2018, pp. 1–11)
2. TERRORIST FINANCING AND THE INTERNET As mentioned, terrorists’ use of the internet has become a major concern for security officials across the world in recent years. Like many other users, terrorists have found that the internet is an invaluable tool to share information quickly, in order to disseminate ideas and link up with likeminded individuals (Jacobson, 2010; Okolie-Osemene & Okoh, 2015). In this manner, terrorists use the internet for a variety of purposes, including recruitment, propaganda, and financing. As scholars have also noted, the internet is an attractive option for extremists due to the security and anonymity it provides (Jacobson, 2010). Yet while there have been a growing number of studies completed on the ways in which terrorist organizations use the internet to recruit and indoctrinate others, there has been relatively little focus on the methods by which terrorists finance themselves through online activities. Some researchers have attempted to fill gaps in this area by broadly studying internet aspects of terrorism financing. However, research on this particular aspect of terrorism financing still appears to be lacking, with little focus on new methods of terrorist financing via the internet or a marrying of strategies to combat online financing trends available to practitioners in the field. For instance, Sean Paul Ashley (2012) assessed the mobile banking phenomenon, which is prevalent in regions such as the Middle East and Africa, and provides extremists with the ability to easily connect to the internet and remit funds around the world. The decentralization of this kind of banking, due to the fact that brick-and-mortar facilities are not needed to conduct transactions, has allowed terrorist financiersto more efficiently move funds while avoiding detection from authorities. Other researchers,such as MichaelJacobson (2010), have studied the ways in which terrorists engage in cyber-crime to raise and move funds. For example, Jacobson (2010) found that online credit card fraud was a fairly major source of terrorist financing. By stealing a victim’s private credit information, terrorists are able to co-opt needed funds and provide support to themselves or their counterparts. Yet as James Okolie-Osemene and Rosemary Ifeanyi Okoh (2015) note, the internet is mostly used to augment and assist activities which occur in the physical world. In this way, it would appear that the internet is far more useful as a means to move funds globally in support of terrorism, rather than simply as a method to raise funds.
Nuclear war---cash is key
Hayes 18, Executive Director of the Nautilus Institute for Security and Sustainability, Ph.D. in Energy and Resources from the University of California-Berkeley, Professor of International Relations at RMIT University (Dr. Peter J., “Non-State Terrorism and Inadvertent Nuclear War”, NAPSNet Special Reports, 1/18/2018, https://nautilus.org/napsnet/napsnet-special-reports/non-state-terrorism-and-inadvertent-nuclear-war/)
The critical issue is how a nuclear terrorist attack may “catalyze” inter-state nuclear war, especially the NC3 systems that inform and partly determine how leaders respond to nuclear threat. Current conditions in Northeast Asia suggest that multiple precursory conditions for nuclear terrorism already exist or exist in nascent form. In Japan, for example, low-level, individual, terroristic violence with nuclear materials, against nuclear facilities, is real. In all countries of the region, the risk of diversion of nuclear material is real, although the risk is likely higher due to volume and laxity of security in some countries of the region than in others. In all countries, the risk of an insider “sleeper” threat is real in security and nuclear agencies, and such insiders already operated in actual terrorist organizations. Insider corruption is also observable in nuclear fuel cycle agencies in all countries of the region. The threat of extortion to induce insider cooperation is also real in all countries. The possibility of a cult attempting to build and buy nuclear weapons is real and has already occurred in the region.[15] Cyber-terrorism against nuclear reactors is real and such attacks have already taken place in South Korea (although it remains difficult to attribute the source of the attacks with certainty). The stand-off ballistic and drone threat to nuclear weapons and fuel cycle facilities is real in the region, including from non-state actors, some of whom have already adopted and used such technology almost instantly from when it becomes accessible (for example, drones).[16] Two other broad risk factors are also present in the region. The social and political conditions for extreme ethnic and xenophobic nationalism are emerging in China, Korea, Japan, and Russia. Although there has been no risk of attack on or loss of control over nuclear weapons since their removal from Japan in 1972 and from South Korea in 1991, this risk continues to exist in North Korea, China, and Russia, and to the extent that they are deployed on aircraft and ships of these and other nuclear weapons states (including submarines) deployed in the region’s high seas, also outside their territorial borders. The most conducive circumstance for catalysis to occur due to a nuclear terrorist attack might involve the following nexi of timing and conditions: Low-level, tactical, or random individual terrorist attacks for whatever reasons, even assassination of national leaders, up to and including dirty radiological bomb attacks, that overlap with inter-state crisis dynamics in ways that affect state decisions to threaten with or to use nuclear weapons. This might be undertaken by an opportunist nuclear terrorist entity in search of rapid and high political impact. Attacks on major national or international events in each country to maximize terror and to de-legitimate national leaders and whole governments. In Japan, for example, more than ten heads of state and senior ministerial international meetings are held each year. For the strategic nuclear terrorist, patiently acquiring higher level nuclear threat capabilities for such attacks and then staging them to maximum effect could accrue strategic gains. Attacks or threatened attacks, including deception and disguised attacks, will have maximum leverage when nuclear-armed states are near or on the brink of war or during a national crisis (such as Fukushima), when intelligence agencies, national leaders, facility operators, surveillance and policing agencies, and first responders are already maximally committed and over-extended. At this point, we note an important caveat to the original concept of catalytic nuclear war as it might pertain to nuclear terrorist threats or attacks. Although an attack might be disguised so that it is attributed to a nuclear-armed state, or a ruse might be undertaken to threaten such attacks by deception, in reality a catalytic strike by a nuclear weapons state in conditions of mutual vulnerability to nuclear retaliation for such a strike from other nuclear armed states would be highly irrational. Accordingly, the effect of nuclear terrorism involving a nuclear detonation or major radiological release may not of itself be catalytic of nuclear war—at least not intentionally–because it will not lead directly to the destruction of a targeted nuclear-armed state. Rather, it may be catalytic of non-nuclear war between states, especially if the non-state actor turns out to be aligned with or sponsored by a state (in many Japanese minds, the natural candidate for the perpetrator of such an attack is the pro-North Korean General Association of Korean Residents, often called Chosen Soren, which represents many of the otherwise stateless Koreans who were born and live in Japan) and a further sequence of coincident events is necessary to drive escalation to the point of nuclear first use by a state. Also, the catalyst—the non-state actor–is almost assured of discovery and destruction either during the attack itself (if it takes the form of a nuclear suicide attack then self-immolation is assured) or as a result of a search-and-destroy campaign from the targeted state (unless the targeted government is annihilated by the initial terrorist nuclear attack). It follows that the effects of a non-state nuclear attack may be characterized better as a trigger effect, bringing about a cascade of nuclear use decisions within NC3 systems that shift each state increasingly away from nuclear non-use and increasingly towards nuclear use by releasing negative controls and enhancing positive controls in multiple action-reaction escalation spirals (depending on how many nuclear armed states are party to an inter-state conflict that is already underway at the time of the non-state nuclear attack); and/or by inducing concatenating nuclear attacks across geographically proximate nuclear weapons forces of states already caught in the crossfire of nuclear threat or attacks of their own making before a nuclear terrorist attack.[17]
1NC---IRS Tradeoff Disad --- Democracy
IRS hiring 20,000, yet resources are stretched thin
Heckman, 23. (Jory Heckman, Reporter for Federal News Network, “IRS plans for 20,000 new hires by end of FY 2024 to replace aging workforce” Federal News Network. Web. 4-6-2023. Accessed 7-2-2023. https://federalnewsnetwork.com/hiring-retention/2023/04/irs-plans-for-30000-new-hires-by-end-of-fy-2024-to-replace-aging-workforce/#:~:text=Hiring%2FRetention-,IRS%20plans%20for%2020%2C000%20new%20hires%20by%20end,2024%20to%20replace%20aging%20workforce&text=The%20IRS%20is%20preparing%20to,experience%20and%20beef%20up%20enforcement. JBFunke)
The IRS is preparing to hire tens of thousands of new employees by the end of fiscal 2024, with many of those new hires going to improve taxpayer experience and beef up enforcement.The IRS outlined its hiring and workforce goals as part of the Strategic Operating Plan it released Thursday.More broadly, the plan describes how the IRS will spend nearly $80 billion in the Inflation Reduction Act, which is meant for the agency to rebuild its workforce and modernize its legacy IT over the next decade.The IRS plans to hire more than 10,000 employees before the end of this fiscal year, and nearly an additional 10,000 employees in fiscal 2024. Most of the hiring is focused on taxpayer services and enforcement.Newly confirmed IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel said the spending plan “is only the beginning of our work,” as the agency also looks at long-term ways to modernize its IT and shrink a growing tax gap between what taxpayers owe, and what the agency is able to collect.“For years, the agency has not had the resources to provide the service people deserve. Across all of our operations we’ve seen the impact. We’ve lost employees and seen our resources stretched thin with new mandates and an increasingly complex economy,” Werfel said. “The IRS looks forward to demonstrating how the actions under this plan will translate into real improvements for taxpayers.”
*****Insert Link Card Here*****
The IRS is K2 equitable taxes – an integral part of democracy
Yellen, 22 (9-15-2022, Secretary Of Treasury, U.S. Department of the Treasury, Remarks by Secretary of the Treasury Janet L. Yellen at the IRS facility in New Carrollton, Maryland, 7-2-2023, https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/jy0952) //shelbor
Good morning, everyone. It’s great to be at the IRS today with so many remarkable colleagues. I would first like to acknowledge the IRS leaders who are here with us today. Thank you, also, to Commissioner Rettig, who is in Memphis today celebrating the 50th anniversary of the IRS facility there. I’m grateful for his hard work and leadership. I just finished a tour of the technology facilities at the New Carrollton Federal Building. These facilities are a model for the IT modernization that has long been needed at the IRS. Today, I want to spend some time discussing how the new IRS funding in the Inflation Reduction Act will make these types of investments possible – as well as its impact on the American economy. But first, I want to begin by speaking about the IRS itself. As our nation’s revenue collection agency, the IRS is a foundation of our government and society. The IRS collects 96% of the revenue that funds the federal government – supporting our priorities from national security to infrastructure to social security.[1] It also is one of the very few parts of the federal government that touches nearly every American household. IRS employees are known for their extraordinary dedication to public service. They have always served with distinction. But over the past couple of years, the employees of the IRS have been called to step up – even further – to serve the American people. While the country sheltered in place, many of you made sure the business of government continued. You worked long hours to deliver relief to American households. This includes three rounds of Economic Impact Payments and the monthly Child Tax Credit.[2] The work that you did ensured families got through a once-in-a-century event. And, in the case of the expanded Child Tax Credit, your work is said to had cut child poverty in half. You managed to deliver on these historic new programs while simultaneously fulfilling your tax administration responsibilities. But during the pandemic, even filing season was far from routine. For instance, on one day last year – March 15 – the IRS received 8.6 million phone calls.[3] This is over 20 percent of the phone calls that the IRS received in the entire year of 2019. Many of you are now working very hard to return the pandemic backlog of unprocessed returns to normal, healthy levels by the end of the year. You dealt with the unprecedented demand and uncertainty that came with being the nation’s tax administrator over the past two years. And you did it while the pandemic was surely disrupting your personal lives and you were called to juggle more responsibilities at home. I’ve heard so many stories of IRS employees who went above and beyond. During the start of the pandemic, from Andover to New Carrollton, your teams mounted an all-hands-on-deck effort to keep the IRS operational. For some facilities, this meant an extensive clean-up effort and provision of PPE to keep employees safe. For others, it meant sending hundreds of laptop bundles, including cables, power cords, and headsets, to enable employees to work remotely. I’ve also heard that one of your colleagues – a U.S. air force veteran – has long donated his time to provide free tax preparation services to his community. But during the pandemic, he went even further. He spent his Economic Impact Payments on additional laptops to build out the tax assistance site – so that more people could get help. And these stories are just the beginning. Just last month, here in New Carrollton, I heard that a team of your software developers completed the conversion of more than 200,000 lines of Assembly Language Code to Java. This is widely recognized as one of the most complex modernization efforts in all of government. And your team completed it more than a month ahead of schedule. I know many of you have worked weekends and traveled across the country to provide tax filing assistance to thousands of taxpayers. These are people who would otherwise not have had any help. So thank you. I want you to know how much I appreciate the work that you do. And I want you to hear from me: that especially amid the recent rise in deeply unfair and dangerous misinformation and threats, there is nothing more important to me than for you to be able to safely carry out your critical

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.