Basic Income Poverty Aff - MSDI 2023
Basic Income Poverty Aff - MSDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
Basic Income – Poverty Line – Affirmative 1AC 1AC – Inherency Despite repeated success, there is no federal, nationwide basic income program but now is key Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/ If you just learned about guaranteed income in the past few years, chances are it was from the presidential campaign of Andrew Yang, who got a lot of attention for his proposal that the government offer $1,000 monthly payments to all Americans. But versions of this concept had been circulating for decades among academics and progressive activists. And as the country shut down in the early days of the pandemic, the conditions appeared ripe to try something new, something radical. Pilot programs launched in Los Angeles, in New Orleans, in Denver, but also in historically less progressive cities like Birmingham, Ala.; Columbia, S.C.; and Gainesville, Fla. In March 2020, even a vast majority of congressional Republicans backed a $2 trillion stimulus bill that included unconditional cash payments for tens of millions of Americans. Since then, the Mayors for a Guaranteed Income coalition, which grew out of SEED, has swelled to more than 90 members and three dozen programs; a $15 million donation from Twitter co-founder Jack Dorsey helped fund many of the pilots.Now, though, as the country emerges from the pandemic, the guaranteed income movement sits at a crossroads. The pilot programs have created scores of stories like Everett’s about how a small amount of money led to massive change in a recipient’s life. And a growing body of research based on the experiments shows that guaranteed income works — that it pulls people out of poverty, improves health outcomes, and makes it easier for people to find jobs and take care of their children. If empirical evidence ruled the world, guaranteed income would be available to every poor person in America, and many of those people would no longer be poor. 1AC Plan Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by providing a basic income for persons at or near the poverty level 1AC Solvency Basic Income works – overwhelming evidence shows they money is spent on solving basic needs and improving their overall situation Susan Harris “Demonstrating Economic Liberation: How Guaranteed Income Pilot Programs Point to Ne w Solutions to Poverty” 2023 https://www.lisc.org/our-resources/resource/demonstrating-economic-liberation-how-guaranteed-income-pilot-programs-point-new-solutions-poverty/ Despite critics’ fears that a no-strings-attached “handout” would encourage people to spend irresponsibly and avoid employment, research on the Stockton pilot shows that extra funds are typically spent on food, health care, paying down debt and household needs. Full-time employment among recipients actually increased, perhaps because people with a little extra cushion could spend more money looking for work, and when they got a job, were better able to successfully encounter challenges like a car breakdown. Advocates of guaranteed income point to positive effects not only on individual financial stability, but on health, economic stimulus, education, and crime and safety. As with Housing First policies that reduced overall homelessness dramatically over more restrictive – and expensive – program efforts, researchers are finding that unconditional assistance can be more effective for the individuals involved and a more efficient use of public sector dollars. Tailoring assistance programs to certain populations, as the cities described above are doing, allows policymakers to incorporate racial and gender equity considerations in their planning, directing the resources to those who need them most. In keeping with a focus on equity, many of these programs, like Magnolia Mother’s Trust, incorporate input and leadership from residents in their design. A new effort in Atlanta is following this path. LISC Atlanta is supporting the design and launch of the Georgia Resilience and Opportunity (GRO) Fund's In Her Hands initiative, which will serve approximately 650 women providing over $20,000 to individuals over two years, currently one of the largest guaranteed income amounts. The idea for the fund arose from resident input in a series of workshops about the best way to alleviate poverty. Its leaders are committed to incorporating continuous resident involvement, community-based research, and cooperative design as they launch in August 2022. The GRO Fund will focus on racial and gender justice, serving Black women in Atlanta’s Old Fourth Ward, the birthplace of Martin Luther King, Jr. It will provide women with, in his words, the solution to poverty: A guaranteed income. Policy making in the context of basic income key – government action required to right the wrong Megan Greenwell “Universal Basic Income Has Been Tested Repeatedly. It Works. Will America Ever Embrace It?” October 24, 2022 https://www.washingtonpost.com/magazine/2022/10/24/universal-basic-income/ In the United States, which has the world’s largest gross domestic product, the basic-income calculus is different than in places like Kenya, where a significant minority of people live on less than a dollar a day. But America has its own unique factors, like that inequality rate and a history of racist policies that have left a disproportionate number of people of color at the bottom of the income scale. Indeed, Tubbs and his counterparts frame basic income as something akin to reparations — a way to alleviate harm done to marginalized people by decades of biased and ineffective policy. The SEED recipients were struggling to survive because society had let them down, Tubbs argues, and the conventional methods of helping them were paternalistic and inadequate. In Baltimore, where more than 1 in 5 residents live below the federal poverty line, a new guaranteed-income pilot gives $1,000 a month to 200 recipients, all of them parents in high-crime neighborhoods. “We’re like the birthplace of racial redlining, right?” Scott says. “You’re not going to erase inequality, inequity that was caused by policy, without creating policy to do the opposite.” The notion of guaranteed income as a government-backed corrective for decades of racist policies has spread to dozens of cities, many led by young, Black mayors. Scott, 38, consults regularly with St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones, 50, whose city launched a guaranteed-income pilot in December 2021. St. Paul, Minn., Mayor Melvin Carter, 43, serves as co-chair of Mayors for a Guaranteed Income, and is a mentor to Tubbs, 32. According to Tubbs, guaranteed-income programs in Columbia, S.C.; Shreveport, La.; and Atlanta were the result of a Black mayors’ group text shortly after George Floyd’s murder in which he evangelized for King’s approach to solving urban poverty, before sending everyone a copy of “Where Do We Go From Here.” It’s no coincidence that these are the people plotting the future of guaranteed income in America, Scott argues. Many of them grew up in families that would have benefited from guaranteed-income programs. “We’re the first group of elected folks who actually lived through all of the s---,” he said, looking up from his phone for a rare moment during a 30-minute interview at Baltimore City Hall and drawing out the vowel sound in “lived.” “We lived through crack and heroin. We lived through zero tolerance. So all the stuff that folks are now talking about, we understand it in a way that no one else will.” 1AC Quality of Life Advantage Covid 19 and global economic conditions have reversed a decades old trend – poverty is on the increase and conditions are worsening for millions of people. Drastic action is needed. Nature “A decades-long decline in extreme poverty has gone into reverse — here’s how to fix things” June 28, 2023 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-023-02098-3 By 2030, says the World Bank, something like 574 million people will be living in extreme poverty. That is equivalent to the combined population of the European Union and Japan. The United Nations has a Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) to eradicate extreme poverty by 2030; this was always ambitious, even when policymakers and researchers set the SDGs in 2015. It is now unattainable. The past few years have bucked a positive trend. Back in 1990, almost two billion people were living under the extreme-poverty line, which the World Bank currently defines as an income of no more than US$2.15 a day at 2017 prices. By 2015, there were fewer than 700 million. Had that trend continued, extreme poverty would have been eliminated by, and possibly before, the SDG target. But the trend had started to slow by 2020, and the COVID‑19 pandemic reversed it, forcing an extra 75 million people below the extreme-poverty line. And the pandemic wasn’t the only factor. Soaring food and energy costs after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, ongoing conflicts and, increasingly, the effects of climate change have all played a part. Extreme poverty is starting to decline again, but it will take until 2024 to return to 2019 levels. A rethink in approach is clearly needed — and researchers can get involved. Guaranteed income solves historical racial inequities and allows access to transportation, education, healthcare, childcare and more. It is key to quality of life Kiara Alfonseca (ABC News) “Guaranteed income experiment for Black women aims to tackle racial wealth gap” January 12, 2022 https://abcnews.go.com/US/guaranteed-income-experiment-black-women-aims-tackle-racial/story?id=82073348 Guaranteed income programs like these have seen a resurgence in recent years amid attempts to address racial and economic equality and reduce poverty. The scope can be either targeted or universal. They have had successes, but some critics say these initiatives have to be multifaceted to work and address the nuances of poverty. Others claim it will stop people from working (though the claim has been debunked) or be too expensive to maintain. As a community advocate and member of the Old Fourth Ward Economic Security Task Force, Lockhart said many of her neighbors continue to experience similar hardships, despite working day and night in an effort to escape poverty. "Everybody's on this hamster wheel," Lockhart said. "They're working two or three jobs … they're working low wage jobs, but they're still in poverty." Black residents in Atlanta are more four times as likely to be living under the federal poverty line than their white neighbors, with 46% of Black households earning below $25,000 a year, according to recent research by the Old Fourth Ward Economic Security Task Force. Some 38% of Black women and 26% of Black men in the city are living in poverty, compared to 8% of white women and 5% of white men in the same city, the task force reports. "We're working, we're tired, we're stressed," Lockhart said. "With an extra $850 a month, people will be able to enjoy the sunlight and will be able to spend more time with their babies." Hope Wollensack, the executive director of the Georgia Resilience & Opportunity Fund, said the program is just the tip of the iceberg in terms of what is needed to address inequality. "It'll take a multifaceted approach -- and probably many different policies -- to even begin to address the racial wealth gap," she said. "But we do know that stabilizing one's income can be a powerful tool not only to improve one's material circumstances in the short term and to improve quality of life and opportunities but also to enable individuals across the board to plan for the long term." The program, called "In Her Hands," was shaped by discussions and surveys from community members that examined the causes of economic insecurity and wealth disparities in the city. The project, run by the Georgia Resilience & Opportunity Fund, is an initiative from the Atlanta City Council, as well as the nonprofit cash assistance service GiveDirectly. It will begin rolling out in the Old Fourth Ward, the childhood neighborhood of civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr., who was a fierce advocate for universal basic income as a way of addressing racial wealth inequities. "We have economic insecurity that is pervasive and it's the result of decades of policies, if not more, that have made it harder for the majority of Americans to get ahead," Wollensack said. The ability to access quality education, transportation and higher-paying jobs, the burden of childcare or predatory debt -- factors like these, Wollensack said, are also more likely to burden communities of color. Poverty and food insecurity can impact a community's physical and mental health, and is considered one "of the most serious and costly health problems," according to the Food Research & Action Center, a national nonprofit research organization working to eradicate poverty. Poverty is pervasive and has not improved – only major material changes can affect it Matthew Desmond 4-3-2023. ( Matthew Desmond. "Why Poverty Persists in America." No Publication. Web. 4-3-2023. accessed 7-1-2023. < https://www.nytimes.com/2023/03/09/magazine/poverty-by-america-matthew-desmond.html >. Phops) In the past 50 years, scientists have mapped the entire human genome and eradicated smallpox. Here in the United States, infant-mortality rates and deaths from heart disease have fallen by roughly 70 percent, and the average American has gained almost a decade of life. Climate change was recognized as an existential threat. The internet was invented. On the problem of poverty, though, there has been no real improvement — just a long stasis. As estimated by the federal government’s poverty line, 12.6 percent of the U.S. population was poor in 1970; two decades later, it was 13.5 percent; in 2010, it was 15.1 percent; and in 2019, it was 10.5 percent. To graph the share of Americans living in poverty over the past half-century amounts to drawing a line that resembles gently rolling hills. The line curves slightly up, then slightly down, then back up again over the years, staying steady through Democratic and Republican administrations, rising in recessions and falling in boom years. What accounts for this lack of progress? It cannot be chalked up to how the poor are counted: Different measures spit out the same embarrassing result. When the government began reporting the Supplemental Poverty Measure in 2011, designed to overcome many of the flaws of the Official Poverty Measure, including not accounting for regional differences in costs of living and government benefits, the United States officially gained three million more poor people. Possible reductions in poverty from counting aid like food stamps and tax benefits were more than offset by recognizing how low-income people were burdened by rising housing and health care costs. The American poor have access to cheap, mass-produced goods, as every American does. But that doesn’t mean they can access what matters most. Any fair assessment of poverty must confront the breathtaking march of material progress. But the fact that standards of living have risen across the board doesn’t mean that poverty itself has fallen. Forty years ago, only the rich could afford cellphones. But cellphones have become more affordable over the past few decades, and now most Americans have one, including many poor people. This has led observers like Ron Haskins and Isabel Sawhill, senior fellows at the Brookings Institution, to assert that “access to certain consumer goods,” like TVs, microwave ovens and cellphones, shows that “the poor are not quite so poor after all.” No, it doesn’t. You can’t eat a cellphone. A cellphone doesn’t grant you stable housing, affordable medical and dental care or adequate child care. In fact, as things like cellphones have become cheaper, the cost of the most necessary of life’s necessities, like health care and rent, has increased. From 2000 to 2022 in the average American city, the cost of fuel and utilities increased by 115 percent. The American poor, living as they do in the center of global capitalism, have access to cheap, mass-produced goods, as every American does. But that doesn’t mean they can access what matters most. As Michael Harrington put it 60 years ago: “It is much easier in the United States to be decently dressed than it is to be decently housed, fed or doctored.” Poverty is the deadliest form of structural violence – it is equivalent to an ongoing nuclear war. Gilligan, 96’ [James, Former Director of Mental Health for the Massachusetts Prison System, Violence, p.] // JW In other words, every fifteen years, on the average, as many people die because of relative poverty as would be killed in a nuclear that caused 232 million deaths; and every single year, two to three times as many people die from poverty throughout the world as were killed by the Nazi genocide of the Jews over a six-year period. This is, in effect, the equivalent of an ongoing, unenending, in fact accelerating, thermonuclear war, or genocide, perpetuated on the weak and poor ever year of every decade, throughout the world. It is important to make a distinction here. Poverty and economic growth are not the same thing. The plan is key to true, long-term poverty reduction. Hanna, Rema, and Benjamin A. Olken. 2018. "Universal Basic Incomes versus Targeted Transfers: Anti-Poverty Programs in Developing Countries." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 32 (4): 201-26. DOI: 10.1257/jep.32.4.201 Of the 17 Sustainable Development Goals articulated by the United Nations, number one is the elimination of extreme poverty by 2030. While future economic growth should continue to reduce poverty, it will not solve the problem by itself; thus, there is a potentially important role for national-level transfer programs that assist poor families in developing countries. Such programs are often run by developing country governments. Many countries have implemented transfer programs that seek to target beneficiaries: that is, to identify who is poor and then to restrict transfers to those individuals. Some people have begun to advocate for "universal basic income" programs, which dispense with trying to identify the poor and instead provide transfers to everyone. We begin by considering the universal basic income as part of the solution to an optimal income-taxation problem, focusing on the case of developing countries, where there is limited income data and inclusion in the formal tax system is low. We examine how the targeting of transfer programs is conducted in these settings, and provide empirical evidence on the tradeoffs involved between universal basic income and targeted transfer schemes using data from Indonesia and Peru—two countries that run nationwide transfer programs that are targeted to the poor. We conclude by linking our findings back to the broader policy debate on what tools should be preferred for redistribution, as well as the practical challenges of administering them in developing countries. Independently, guaranteed income necessary for better health outcomes – key to quality of life Kiara Alfonseca (ABC News) “Where guaranteed income programs are growing in the US” June 21, 2023 https://abcnews.go.com/US/guaranteed-income-programs-growing-nationwide-popping/story?id=100243617#:~:text=Recipients%20have%20said%20the%20money,and%20mental%20health%20in%20participants Guaranteed income experiments are popping up or expanding around the country, offering no-strings-attached temporary cash payments to low-income residents. Some governmental programs limit what recipients can or cannot pay for with their assistance. Guaranteed income programs select certain groups impacted by income inequality -- such as the impoverished or the formerly incarcerated -- and gives them mont
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.