Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 SDI Negative

Medicare For All Neg - MSDI 2023

Medicare For All Neg - MSDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
MSDI Case Neg vs Medicare for All
A2 Health Advantage
A2 Access to Care
Medicare for All will reduce reimbursement rates for providers – calling into question the ability to continue to provide care.
Charles Blahous J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith 2018 The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System MERCATUS WORKING PAPER George Mason University. https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system
To offset the substantial cost increases created by stimulating additional consumer demand for and utilization of healthcare, the M4A bill would constrain expenditures by subjecting healthcare providers—including hospitals, physicians, and others—to Medicare payment rates.19 Under current law, Medicare reimburses healthcare providers at much lower rates than private health insurance does. In 2014, Medicare hospital payment rates were 62 percent of private insurance payment rates and are currently projected to decline to below 60 percent by the time M4A would be implemented, and to decline further afterward. Medicare physician payment rates were 75 percent of private insurance rates in 2016 and, per the terms of the Medicare Access and CHIP Reauthorization Act of 2015 (MACRA), are projected to decline sharply in relative terms in future years, also falling below 60 percent within the first full decade of M4A.20 The M4A Act as introduced specifies that provider payment amounts are to be consistent with those paid under current Medicare law.21 The adoption of Medicare payment rates would represent a substantial reduction in provider reimbursements for care provided to everyone now covered by private insurance (though it would also be a temporary increase in physician payments for those now covered by Medicaid, which currently pays physicians at lower rates than does Medicare).22 For example, in 2014, hospitals were reimbursed just 89 percent of their costs of treating Medicare patients and 90 percent of their costs of treating Medicaid patients— losses that were offset by hospitals collecting private insurance reimbursement rates equaling 144 percent of their costs.
Significant double bind – either reimbursement rates would have to go up – or access to care would plummet or maintaining reimbursement rates will massively increase the cost of the program.
Charles Blahous J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith 2018 The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System MERCATUS WORKING PAPER George Mason University. https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system
Furthermore, it is not precisely predictable how hospitals, physicians, and other healthcare providers would respond to a dramatic reduction in their reimbursements under M4A, well below their costs of care for all categories of patients combined. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) Office of the Actuary has projected that even upholding current-law reimbursement rates for treating Medicare beneficiaries alone would cause nearly half of all hospitals to have negative total facility margins by 2040.25 The same study found that by 2019, over 80 percent of hospitals will lose money treating Medicare patients—a situation M4A would extend, to a first approximation, to all US patients. Perhaps some facilities and physicians would be able to generate heretofore unachieved cost savings that would enable their continued functioning without significant disruptions. However, at least some undoubtedly would not, thereby reducing the supply of healthcare services at the same time M4A sharply increases healthcare demand. It is impossible to say precisely how much the confluence of these factors would reduce individuals’ timely access to healthcare services, but some such access problems almost certainly must arise. Anticipating these difficulties, some other studies have assumed that M4A payment rates must exceed current-law Medicare payment rates to avoid sending facilities into deficit on average or to avoid triggering unacceptable reductions in the provision and quality of healthcare services.26 These alternative payment rate assumptions substantially increase the total projected costs of M4A. Specifically, they would mean payment rates being set higher than they are under current Medicare law and lower than those now paid by private insurance. Even with a higher payment rate assumption, the UI team determined that “not all increased demand could be met because provider capacity would be insufficient.” This constraint is reflected in their final cost estimates.27
The plan causes immediate panic regardless of implementation details—health providers would panic and close
Daniel Summers 16, pediatrician in the greater Boston area., 2-19-2016, "I’m a Doctor. Here’s Why I Oppose the Single-Payer Revolution.," New Republic, https://newrepublic.com/article/130145/im-doctor-heres-oppose-single-payer-revolution
Compared to the lustrous ideals that inform the pursuit of a single-payer system, talking about profitability seems downright grungy. But businesses need to stay profitable in order to stay afloat, and medical practices are no different. Even not-for-profits need sufficient revenue to keep the doors open. Talking about substantially reducing payment to medical providers in one fell swoop, as though doctors and hospitals will say, “Alrighty then,” and carry on providing the exact same services without any appreciable change to patients strains credulity. For my practice, it would immediately put pressure on us to eliminate services we provide that do not generate any revenue. As it stands, every patient of ours who gets admitted to the hospital is seen by one of our providers, even if they’re not admitted to our service. We visit our patients in the hospital every day because we believe strongly that doing so keeps us informed about and involved in the management of our patients’ care, even if we’re not ultimately in charge of that care at any given time. It generates no income for the practice when we do this, and it’s hard to see how we could keep paying providers for this service when they could be in the office seeing patients instead. Further, every well-child exam at our practice is scheduled for a full 30 minutes, and for medically complex patients we dedicate an entire hour. Giving ample time to discuss each patient’s care thoroughly, answer all the parents’ questions, and offer guidance about important health and safety issues is a value we hold strongly. But the pressure to maximize patient volume could put that value in jeopardy. And despite pressure to see as many patients as possible, it’s still very likely that we would need to reduce payroll costs to stay in the black. Even if you factor in a reduction in our already-thin billing personnel (a prospect I don’t greet with any joy, as these are employees I care about), and even with the substantial haircut my partners and I would doubtless take to support our staff as much as possible, we’d have to pay our providers less. This may be a matter of blithe unconcern to advocates of Sanders’s plan, but it would almost certainly mean we’d have to make compromises in what we ask our providers to do. We’re currently open seven days a week. Even on major holidays, we make a provider available for urgent sick visits to the office. If you call our number outside regular office hours, at any time of the day, it’s one of our physicians or nurse practitioners who gets the page. It’s hard to see us maintaining that level of availability while simultaneously cutting the pay of people who show up on Sundays and take those two o’clock in the morning phone calls. Could we make all the changes necessary to make it worthwhile to stay in business? I hope so. It would be a grimmer place to work, to be sure, but we’d try to make it happen. However, I have no doubt many offices would see the writing on the wall. Some may try to sell to hospitals, which certainly won’t keep them open at a loss, and others will close outright. Who will assume care for the thousands of patients these closures would displace is not a question I see answered in Sanders’s plans. The government can provide insurance, but providing care directly is an even more ambitious change than Sanders is already proposing.
Medicare for all disrupts the entire health care sector on a domestic and international level – crushing quality of care
Jonathan Yates, 7-28-2018, Jonathan Yates, a former University of Iowa adjunct professor, was general counsel for a publicly traded health care firm, and Assistant Washington Counsel for the Health Insurance Association (HIAA). "A single-payer system will cause the health care sector to implode", Des Moines Register, https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/opinion/columnists/iowa-view/2018/07/27/single-payer-system-cause-health-care-sector-implode/849329002/, 6-26-2023, //ms
In the early days of the American automobile industry, consumers could buy a Model T in any color they wanted, so long as it was black. Such will be the "service and selection" to be expected in the United States if a single-payer system, where the government pays for all medical treatment, is implemented for health care. A single-payer system will cause the health care sector to implode, with profound implications for Iowa, the United States and the world's economy. Health care is the largest component of the American economy, about one-sixth of gross domestic product. Forcing the health care system in the United States, the best in the history of the world, to be socialized will have profound implications. The government will immediately be put in a position of having higher expenses and less revenues. With health insurance companies gone, so will the tens of billions in tax dollars paid to local, state, and federal government from these entities. This will most certainly not be compensated for by reduced government spending. Rarely in history has a government program reduced spending, especially in health care. In addition to wrecking the government budget, a single-payer system would destroy the stock, bond and commercial real estate markets. Insurance firms are major investors in the financial markets. Taking away the insurance companies would eviscerate the financial markets. The same would happen with salaries for health care professionals such as doctors and nurses. Doctors in Canada, England and France make a fraction of those in America.. Opportunities in health care would be reduced, starting with the educational system. The United States has the finest system of higher education in the world. More than half of the top 100 universities in the world are in the United States. It is the same American dominance for medical device and other health care patents. International universities can't even begin to compete with the best in the United States in a holistic approach that encompasses undergraduate education, graduate schools, research facilities and athletics.. Foreign and business leaders from abroad come to the United States for medical care. Americans go overseas for cheap health care. Those who can afford it come to the USA for the best health care treatment. Which is preferable in medical services: the cheapest or the best? A lesson learned very quickly in life is that generally the best works out to be the least expensive, over the long term. It is because of the superiority of the American health care system that single-payer systems still exist around the world. Without the United States outperforming the rest of the world in research and development, their medical systems would collapse. Single-payer systems around the world can survive only because they benefit from what the health care industry in the USA produces. There is also no need for a single-payer system as the purported 40 million uninsured in the USA has never held up to research. About 11 million of those are illegal immigrants. Another quarter qualify but can't be bothered to fill out the paperwork. Then there are those who make easily enough to buy health insurance, but prefer to go without it and pay for their medical costs as they arise. Survey after survey reports that at any one time about 80-90% of Americans are insured, with the same amount being satisfied with their health care. Over the last decade, health care and social assistance employment in Iowa has soared from around 145,000 to about 185,000, according to the 11th edition of Iowa's Workforce and the Economy. Insurance and health care are also growing segments of the state's economy. This will be truncated with a single-payer system. A single-payer system in the United States will reduce the quality of health care for Americans and the quantity of opportunities available for all around the world.
Difference between coverage and access
Michael D. Tanner April 5, 2017. Cato Institute senior fellow, Michael Tanner heads research into a variety of domestic policies with a particular emphasis on poverty and social welfare policy, health care reform, and Social Security. “Hard Truths about Health Care” https://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/hard-truths-about-health-care
Republicans have vowed to go back to the drawing board to draft a new Obamacare repeal-and-replacement bill. Meanwhile President Trump is threatening to work with Democrats to come up with a health-care plan — or maybe to simply let Obamacare crash and burn. But whoever eventually comes up with a replacement for the Affordable Care Act should keep a few hard truths in mind. 1. Health care is neither a right nor a privilege; it’s a commodity. Worse, it’s a finite commodity. There are only so many doctors, so many hospitals, and so much money, and there are limits to how much these things can be expanded. That’s why no health-care system, outside Bernie Sanders’s fantasies, provides unlimited care to everyone. Every health-care system in the world rations care in some way, either through bureaucratic fiat (Scandinavia, the U.K.), waiting lists (Canada), or price (that’s us). One can argue about which of these rationing mechanisms is fairest or most efficient, but let’s not pretend that it won’t occur. Republicans would be well advised to stop trying to win a popularity contest and simply do what’s right. 2. Coverage is not access. Democrats like to pretend that giving everyone a piece of paper called insurance guarantees them access to the care they need. It’s sort of like magic. Say the right words, and poof, medical care appears. But in the real world it doesn’t work that way. For example, take Medicaid, which is responsible for more than half the increase in coverage under Obamacare. Nearly a third of primary-care physicians won’t accept Medicaid patients. And when doctors do see Medicaid patients, they tend to be slower in granting appointments. Moreover, for the working poor, seeing doctors during normal office hours can be problematic. Perhaps that’s why Medicaid patients continue to use emergency rooms for routine care at a disproportionate rate. Numerous studies show that health outcomes for Medicaid patients are little better than those for the uninsured. In fact, some studies show patients faring worse under Medicaid than if they had no insurance at all. Similarly, if Obamacare forced your insurance carrier to cut back its provider network, your shiny new coverage may no longer include the physician of your choice. And the incentive structure of Obamacare, notably its pre-existing-condition rules, encourage insurers to drop coverage for top doctors and hospital centers of excellence.
Decreases quality of care and increases wait times – Canada and Great Britain prove
Sally Pipes Jan 30 2023 I cover health policy as President of the Pacific Research Institute Canadian Leaders Finally Waking Up To The Horrors Of Single-Payer Health Care https://www.forbes.com/sites/sallypipes/2023/01/30/canadian-leaders-finally-waking-up-to-the-horrors-of-single-payer-health-care/?sh=4b69e6be5d1a
But that system already exists in Canada. Canadians routinely leave the country to seek medical care that their public system can't or won't provide in a timely fashion. Canadians spent $690 million on health care in other countries in 2017 alone, a recent study found. Many of those people are rich, famous, and powerful people who have the means to escape. In 2010, former Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams flew to the United States for heart surgery. "This was my heart, my choice and my health," Williams said. "I did not sign away my right to get the best possible health care for myself when I entered politics." Canadian singer Michael Bublé decamped from Vancouver to Los Angeles in 2016 when his young son was diagnosed with liver cancer. His son received treatment, including chemotherapy, at the Children's Hospital of Los Angeles. Bublé credits doctors at the hospital with saving his son's life. Thankfully, his son's cancer remains in remission today. Millions of Canadians don't have the resources to flee to the United States for top-notch care. The story is similar in Great Britain's government-dominated system. Just this year, British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak caused a scandal after revealing that he had received private care while publicly singing the praises of the United Kingdom's socialized National Health Service. Fortunately, to paraphrase Thomas Jefferson, it seems that all eyes are opened, or opening, to the false promise of single-payer health care. Hopefully Americans will look at the human tragedies unfolding in Canada and Great Britain—and make clear to progressive lawmakers that they have no interest in Medicare for All here.
Plan causes rationing
Medicare for All would drastically increase health care demand and utilization
Charles Blahous J. Fish and Lillian F. Smith 2018 The Costs of a National Single-Payer Healthcare System MERCATUS WORKING PAPER George Mason University. https://www.mercatus.org/research/working-papers/costs-national-single-payer-healthcare-system
M4A would increase healthcare demand and utilization in at least three important ways. First, the plan would provide health insurance coverage to all Americans who are currently uninsured, greatly increasing their utilization of healthcare services.11 Coverage of the currently uninsured is estimated to increase their health service costs by roughly 89 percent. 12 Second, the plan would expand the range of services covered by existing insurance, explicitly covering dental, vision, and hearing care for all participants.13 This, too, would increase utilization of such services in addition to shifting their financing from private to public spending, especially for those now reliant on traditional Medicare. Currently, only 12 percent of all personal healthcare expenses in the United States are paid out of pocket, while 22 percent are paid by Medicare. By contrast, 40 percent of national dental care expenses are paid out of pocket, while the national share financed by traditional Medicare rounds to 0 percent. 14 This indicates that the addition of dental, vision, and hearing benefits will substantially increase total projected health service utilization and costs.15 Finally, the plan’s requirement that “no cost-sharing, including deductibles, coinsurance, copayments, or similar charges, be imposed on an individual” would also significantly increase healthcare utilization. 16 As a general rule, the greater the percentage of an individual’s healthcare that is paid by insurance (i.e., the insurance’s actuarial value, or AV), the more healthcare services an individual tends to buy. There is an extensive literature devoted to estimating how much individuals increase their use of healthcare as the AV of their insurance increases—which, in the case of M4A, would be to an AV of essentially 100 percent. 17 Providing this first-dollar coverage is estimated to induce 11 percent additional demand for those current

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.