Topicality - MSDI 2023
Topicality - MSDI 2023.docx
Indexed text preview
MSDI – Topicality Resolution This is the resolution Dr. James Weaver, 2-28-2023, "Economic Inequality Selected as 2023-2024 National Policy Debate Topic," No Publication, https://www.nfhs.org/articles/economic-inequality-selected-as-2023-2024-national-policy-debate-topic/, accessed 6/24/23, mw Resolved: The United States federal government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by adopting a federal jobs guarantee, expanding Social Security, and/or providing a basic income. 1NC Fiscal Redistribution Only 3 types of redistribution – tax, programs, tilting econ outcomes – none of this is deficit spending Jeffrey A. Miron, 2011, “Rethinking Redistribution,” National Affairs, https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/rethinking-redistribution, accessed 6/15/23, mw Whether one agrees with it or not, this popular understanding of redistribution's purpose yields some useful criteria for assessing the degree to which our redistribution programs are actually succeeding. The aims of helping the poor and minimizing harm to everyone else, in other words, offer some specific ends against which our means of redistribution can be tested. By and large, those means take three forms. First, there are direct anti-poverty programs, like Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (what we commonly think of as welfare), food stamps, Medicaid, and the Earned Income Tax Credit. Second, there is progressive taxation, which transfers wealth from richer to poorer Americans across the income distribution. And third, there are policies that tilt economic outcomes in specific markets to benefit people with lower incomes (minimum-wage laws are a classic example). Violation – The aff isn’t fiscal redistribution policy Standards – Limits – Fiscal redistribution is the topic, they justify any aff that moves money around without being grounded in a specific mech Ground – they justify a race to the infinite margins, destroys clash since negative teams cant research everything that’s effectively redistribution Voters for fairness and education 2nc Fiscal redistribution policy only exists in three forms – anti-poverty programs, Progressive taxation, and tilting economic outcomes – the aff is (insert mech) which explodes limits through justifying any aff that redistributes through unlimited mechanisms forcing both aff and neg teams to the margins of the topic rather than engaging in the core dispute about how we should use fiscal policy to redistribute wealth –limits is the key internal link to all benefits of debate (Insert TVA) A2 We meet – A2 lbl – Substantially – UBI = 5 categories (Subsets) Affs must meet definitional features of a UBI Rebecca Hasdell, July 2020, “WHAT WE KNOW ABOUT UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME A CROSS-SYNTHESIS OF REVIEWS,” Stanford Basic Income Lab, https://basicincome.stanford.edu/uploads/Umbrella%20Review%20BI_final.pdf, accessed 6/12/23, mw A fully universal and unconditional basic income has never been implemented at scale. However, evidence from programs, policies and experiments that share features of a UBI can be used to approximate economic, social, health and other impacts. There are a growing number of contemporary literature reviews that report on the substantial evidence base of interventions that meet at least two or more features of a UBI. Since the 1990s, there has been a proliferation of cash transfers in low- and middle-income countries and increased attention to UBI in higherincome contexts. DEFINITIONAL FEATURES OF A UBI Universal: It is paid to every individual and not targeted to a specific population Unconditional: It involves no set conditions or sanctions and is given to those who are both employed and unemployed, voluntarily or not Cash payment: It is paid in cash, which allows recipients to convert their benefits however they choose Individual: It is paid on an individual basis (versus household-based) Periodic: It is a recurring payment rather than a one-off grant “Substantially" means 80 to 90%—government definitions prove. Curtin, 2003 (John T. Curtin, Judge, United States District Court for the Western District of New York, Gateway Equipment Corp. -vs- United States of America, United States District Court for the Western District of New York, lexis) The government cites Webster's Ninth New College Dictionary for the definitions of "limit" and "impairment" as suggesting "meanings equivalent to restriction and reduction, respectively." Item 30, p. 3, n.1. It posits that the word "substantially" suggests "an order of magnitude equivalent to 80% or 90%." Id. It concludes that "using those definitions, 'substantially limited' and 'substantially impaired' means that there must be an 80%-90% restriction and/ or reduction of use by virtue of the design of the CB-4000." Id. Violation: The aff is a tiny subset of UBI policy Limits – they justify infinite tiny social security affs under the category of UBI Ground – they justify a race to the infinite margins, destroys education and clash since negative teams cant research all permutations of UBI’s Voters for fairness, and education 2NC o/v There are 5 features of a universal basic income – Universality, unconditional, cash payments, individual, and periodic – substantial affs must meet 4 of the five categories and the 1ac doesn’t meet (insert violated parts). They justify transforming the UBI category into infinite subsections of social services which explodes any hope for limits – that’s the key internal link to all the benefits of debate all of our offense is multiplied by aff conditionality – they gets to shed parts of the aff that don’t meet the 2acs vision of the round to get out of links they conceded the Curtin warrant about limits – only interps that are “by virtue of design” limited meet our standards, which means you can’t weigh the affs self-serving we-meet TVA – meet 4 of the five categories in Hasdell to meet both definitions – (make ur own combination) (or read a card) A2 We meet – A2 lbl – UBI – poverty target = guarantee income Poverty ubi is guaranteed income Leah Hamilton, et al. 2021, “Does Frequency or Amount Matter? Testing the Perceptions of Four Universal Basic Income Proposals,” SOCIAL POLICY INSTITUTE RESEARCH, https://openscholarship.wustl.edu/spi_research/45/, accessed 6/16/23, mw Economic volatility since the 2008 Great Recession and more recently, the COVID-19 pandemic has brought renewed public interest to an old idea: universal basic income (UBI). Andrew Yang, a technology entrepreneur who ran for the Democratic Party’s nomination for presidential candidate in 2020, is credited with raising awareness of UBI as a current policy option, proposing that all Americans receive $1,000 monthly. Several cities and some states have recently proposed or enacted basic income pilots. Most modern UBI proposals include three conditions: the payment should be distributed directly to individuals (rather than households), should not be means-tested, and hold no mandatory conditions (i.e. workforce or educational participation) to receive the payment (Johnson & Roberto, 2020). Put simply, UBI is “a periodic cash payment unconditionally delivered to all on an individual basis, without means-test or work requirement” (Basic Income Earth Network, 2020). However, basic income programs currently being piloted in cities such as Stockton, CA and St. Paul, MN are sometimes referred to as “guaranteed income” rather than basic income because they are means-tested to target low-income households. Whether universal or means-tested, basic income programs have no requirements for how the money is spent. That is, they may be conditional on income or not (universal), yet are unrestricted concerning benefit usage. Violation – the aff is guaranteed income, not a UBI Limits – they justify infinite affs that target transfers to any of nearly infinite groups Ground – targeted transfers functionally thumps out of all neg ground by massively reducing the scope that the lit base assumes, makes every neg round hyper generic while affs get even more specific Voters for fairness and education 2NC o/v Targeted UBI’s are definitionally guaranteed income – the aff doesn’t meet the mandatory condition and means-tested sections of our Hamilton ev which is the only clear Brightline on what is and is not UBI policy – that explodes limits by justifying all other forms of means-tested income plus placing infinite conditions on transfers which shifts the goalposts of the res away from fiscal policy towards deciphering who the aff targets – limits are the key internal link to all the benefits of debate (Insert TVA) A2 We meet – A2 lbl – FJG This one may not be a winner, but it will give you tons of links for other stuff There are tons of conditions a job guarantee must meet – have fun with this wm! U.S. Congress, 9-10-2019, " Text: S.2457 — 116th Congress (2019-2020)," Congress.gov, https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/senate-bill/2457/text?s=1&r=1&q=%7B%22search%22%3A%5B%22Federal+Jobs+Guarantee+Development+Act%22%5D%7D, accessed 5/25/23, mw SEC. 2. JOB GUARANTEE PILOT PROGRAM. (a) Definitions.—In this section: (1) ELIGIBLE ENTITY.—The term “eligible entity” means an entity that— (A) is a political subdivision of a State, Tribal entity, or a combination of contiguous political subdivisions or Tribal entities; (B) has an unemployment rate that is not less than 150 percent of the national unemployment rate, as determined by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (except in the case of Tribal entities which may submit their own employment data where no such Federal data is available for such entities) based on the most recent data available at the time the Secretary solicits applications for grants under this section; and (C) submits an application in accordance with subsection (d). (2) JOB GUARANTEE PROGRAM.—The term “job guarantee program” means a program that meets the requirements of subsection (c). (3) RURAL AREA.—The term “rural area” means an area that is located outside of an urban area. (4) TRIBAL ENTITY.—The term “Tribal entity” means an Indian tribe or tribal organization as such terms are defined in section 4 of the Indian Self-Determination Act (25 U.S.C. 5304). (5) URBAN AREA.—The term “urban area” means an urbanized area (a region of 50,000 or more residents) and an urbanized cluster (and area encompassing between 2,500 and 50,000 residents), according to the Census Bureau’s urban-rural classification in the 2010 census. (6) SECRETARY.—The term “Secretary ” means the Secretary of Labor. (7) WIOA DEFINITIONS.—The terms “adult education and literacy activities”, “career planning”, “individual with a barrier to employment”, “in-demand industry sector or occupation”, “local board”, “recognized postsecondary credential”, “State board”, “supportive services”, and “workplace learning advisor” have the meanings given such terms in section 3 of the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (29 U.S.C. 3102). (b) Establishment.— (1) IN GENERAL.—The Secretary shall establish a pilot program to provide competitive grants to eligible entities to establish programs to ensure that any individual within the area served by the entity who applies for a job through the program will be provided with employment as provided for in this section. (2) TERMINATION.—Federal funding for a job guarantee program established under a grant under this section shall terminate on the earlier of— (A) the end of the 3-year period beginning on the date of the grant; or (B) the date of any revocation of the grantee as an eligible entity. (c) Job Guarantee Programs.—A job guarantee program meets the requirements of this subsection if the jobs provided under such program— (1) are available to all individuals who— (A) are 18 years of age or older; and (B) reside in the area served under the program at the time the area became an eligible entity; except that participants in the program may be disciplined, released, or suspended from further participation in jobs under this program if they are found to be negligent, or generally disruptive to the workplace involved under procedures established by the Secretary that provide for an opportunity for a review of such determinations; (2) are, with respect to individual participants, included as part of an established bargaining unit and covered by any applicable collective bargaining agreement in effect if similarly situated employees are part of such unit and represented by an exclusive bargaining representative; (3) are available for the duration of the pilot program; (4) provide a wage of not less than the greater of— (A) the hourly wage provided for under the provisions of S. 150 (116th Congress), if enacted, or the hourly wage otherwise required to be paid to employees in area to be served under the pilot program, whichever is greater; (B) the prevailing wage in the area involved for a similar job as required by chapter 67 of title 41, United States Code, and other related laws; or (C) the applicable wage under an applicable collective bargaining agreement as provided for under paragraph (2); (5) provide for coverage of the worker under a health insurance program that is comparable to that offered to Federal employees under the Federal Employee Health Benefits Program; and (6) provide at a minimum— (A) paid family leave consistent with the provisions of S. 463 (116th Congress) and applicable State law; and (B) paid sick leave consistent with the provision of S. 840 (116th Congress) and applicable State law. (d) Other Uses.—Funds may be used to provide workers in a job guarantee program with— (1) supportive services, which can include transportation, child care, dependent care, housing, and needs-related payments, that are necessary to enable an individual to participate in activities authorized under this Act; (2) access to a workplace learning advisor to support the education, skill development, job training, career panning, and credentials required to progress toward career goals of such employees in order to meet employer requirements related to job openings and career advancements that support economic self-sufficiency; (3) adult education and literacy activities, including those provided by public libraries; (4) activities that assist justice involved individuals, formerly incarcerated individuals, and individuals with criminal records in reentering the workforce; and (5) financial literacy activities including those described in section 129(b)(2)(D) of the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act. (e) Applications.—An eligible entity seeking a grant under this section shall submit an application to the Secretary at such time, in such manner, and containing such information as the Secretary may require. Such application shall include— (1) a description of the geographic area and population that the entity intends to serve under the job guarantee program established under the grant, including the area unemployment rate, underemployment rate, unemployment rate for individuals with disabilities, poverty rate, housing vacancy rate, crime rate, household income, home-ownership rate, labor force participation rate, and educational attainment; (2) to extent practicable, a description of the jobs that will be offered under the job guarantee program, including— (A) a description of supports provided to individuals with disabilities and accommodations required under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. 12101 et seq.); and (B) a description of supports and procedures to ensure job access and opportunities for individuals with criminal records, including information on physical and programmatic accessibility, in accordance with section 188 of the Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act, if applicable, and the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, for individuals with disabilities; (3) the need in the area for jobs to be performed, including for jobs designated as a high-skill, high-wage or in-demand industry sector or occupation by the Secretary, State board, or local board; (4) a description of State, local, or philanthropic funding, including through coordination and in-kind or non-financial support, if any, that will be provided to assist in carrying out the job guarantee program; (5) an assurance that the eligible entity will establish— (A) a public internet website, in conjunction with the Secretary, to post all available jobs under the job guarantee program; and (B) a process for individuals to apply for such jobs; (6) a comprehensive plan to describe how the funding under the program will leverage existing or anticipated local, State, and Federal funding; (7) an assurance that necessary administrative data systems and information technology infrastructure are available, or will be available, to provide for full participation in the evaluation under subsection (k); (8) a description of how the eligible entity will comply with the requirements described in subsection (c)(6); (9) an assurance that the entity will enter into an allocation agreement with the Secretary under subsection (j)(2)(A); and (10) an assurance that energy and infrastructure jobs provided under the program will not exacerbate the impacts of climate change. (f) Selection.—The Secretary, after reviewing applications from eligible entities, shall award grants under this section to not more than 15 such eligible entities. In awarding such grants, the Secretary shall consider diversity in geographic location, urban-rural composition, and political entity, including the representation of Tribal entities. Violation – The aff doesn’t meet (take your pick, choose based on other offense) Standards – Limits – they justify creating job guarantees with little to none of the technical requirements that facilitate the structure created by the 1ac function – destroys core topic education Ground – creates a race to the margins of the topic where affs find anything that could create jobs and create a government program for it which forces negs towards hypergenerics Voters for fairness and education 2NC there are so many intricate facets that are critical to the way that an FJG would function – funding and creation of programs across the country, providing various forms of paid leave, creating adult education programs, building a website and application process and that doesn’t even touch on each program proving the jobs they create don’t exacerbate climate change – the core of FJG affs should be the balancing act that creating them entails – the aff skips that massive section of the literature base which cuts out the negs greatest chance to clash with the aff This is a double bind – either you meet our interp and have to (do x thing that you are linking – ideally a category of thing – ie funding for the program, or types of jobs), or you don’t meet. (Insert TVA) A2 WM – A2 lbl – Topic Terms Federal Jobs Guarantee Core objective of FJG is guaranteeing a basic human right to work, its permanent and targeted – federally funded, locally run Pavlina R. Tcherneva, April 2018, “The Job Guarantee: Design, Jobs, and Implementation,” Levy Economics Institute, https://www.levyinstitute.org/pubs/wp_902.pdf, accessed 5/25/23, mw II. OBJECTIVES OF THE JOB GUARANTEE Core Policy Objective of the Job Guarantee To provide decent jobs at decent pay on demand to all individuals of legal working age who want to work, irrespective of labor market status, race, sex, color, or creed. Additional Objectives To guarantee a basic human right, as outlined in the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights and Franklin D. Roosevelt’s call for an Economic Bill of Rights. To institute a public option for work, i.e., an employment safety net. To create job opportunities in close proximity to the unemployed. To create suitable work opportunities for people of varied skill levels. To serve the public purpose. To establish an effective minimum wage for the economy as a whole. To operate as an “empl
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.