Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 SDI Affirmative

Green New Deal Aff - MSDI 2023

Green New Deal Aff - MSDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
MSDI --- Green New Deal Aff
1AC --- MSDI
1AC --- Plan
The United States federal government should substantially increase fiscal redistribution in the United States by adopting and implementing a Green New Deal.
1AC ---Warming Advantage
The world is dying. Humanity is at a crossroads, we either fix the problem now or are doomed to destruction.
Fiona Harvey 5-17-2023. (Fiona Harvey Environment editor, . "World likely to breach 1.5C climate threshold by 2027, scientists warn." Guardian. Web. accessed 6-7-2023 < https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2023/may/17/global-heating-climate-crisis-record-temperatures-wmo-research >.)MSUCB
The world is almost certain to experience new record temperatures in the next five years, and temperatures are likely to rise by more than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, scientists have warned. The breaching of the crucial 1.5C threshold, which scientists have warned could have dire consequences, should be only temporary, according to research from the World Meteorological Organisation (WMO). However, it would represent a marked acceleration of human impacts on the global climate system, and send the world into “uncharted territory”, the UN agency warned. Countries have pledged, under the 2015 Paris climate agreement, to try to hold global temperatures to no higher than 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, after scientific advice that heating beyond that level would unleash a cascade of increasingly catastrophic and potentially irreversible impacts. Prof Petteri Taalas, the secretary general of the WMO, said: “This report does not mean that we will permanently exceed the 1.5C specified in the Paris agreement, which refers to long-term warming over many years. However, WMO is sounding the alarm that we will breach the 1.5C level on a temporary basis with increasing frequency.” Global average surface temperatures have never before breached the 1.5C threshold. The highest average in previous years was 1.28C above pre-industrial levels. The report, published on Wednesday, found there was a 66% likelihood of exceeding the 1.5C threshold in at least one year between 2023 and 2027. New record temperatures have been set in many areas around the world in the heatwaves of the past year, but those highs may only be the beginning, according to the report, as climate breakdown and the impact of a developing El Niño weather system combine to create heatwaves across the globe. El Niño is part of an oscillating weather system that develops in the Pacific. For the past three years, the world has been in the opposing phase, known as La Niña, which has had a dampening effect on temperature increases around the world. As La Niña ends and a new El Niño develops, there is a 98% likelihood that at least one of the next five years will be the hottest on record, the scientists found. Taalas warned of the effects. “A warming El Niño is expected to develop in the coming months and this will combine with human-induced climate change to push global temperatures into uncharted territory. This will have far-reaching repercussions for health, food security, water management and the environment,” he said. “We need to be prepared.” The Arctic is heating much faster than the rest of the world, and this appears to be having an impact on global weather systems, including the jet stream, which has disrupted weather across the northern hemisphere in recent years. There is likely to be less rainfall this year in the Amazon, Central America, Australia and Indonesia, the report found. This is particularly bad news for the Amazon, where scientists have grown increasingly concerned that a vicious cycle of heating and deforestation could tip the region from rainforest into savannah-like conditions. Over the next five years, there is likely to be above-average rainfall in northern Europe, Alaska and northern Siberia, and the Sahel, according to the report. For each year from 2023 to 2027, the global near-surface temperature is predicted to be between 1.1C and 1.8C above the pre-industrial average, taken from the years 1850 to 1900. The world has warmed considerably in recent years. In 2015, when the Paris agreement was signed, requiring countries to hold global temperature increases to no more than 2C above pre-industrial levels while “pursuing efforts” to hold them to 1.5C, it was forecast that the chance of temporarily exceeding the 1.5C threshold within the following five years was zero. This November, governments will meet for the Cop28 UN climate summit, where they will assess progress towards meeting the goals of the Paris agreement. Known as the “global stocktake”, this assessment is likely to show that the world is far off track to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by the 43% this decade that is required to have a good chance of limiting temperature rises to 1.5C.
The Green New Deal is critical to resolving climate change. The transformative approach of linking wealth concentration and inequalities to the project of emissions reductions is fundamental to the success of decarbonization efforts. All carbon-centric policies alone will fail. The plan is the only option.
Green & Healy, 2022 Fergus Green1, * and Noel Healy2 1Department of Political Science, University College London, London, UK 2Geography and Sustainability Department, Salem State University, Salem, MA, USA How inequality fuels climate change: The climate case for a Green New Deal https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oneear.2022.05.005 https://www.cell.com/one-earth/pdf/S2590-3322(22)00220-2.pdf
Policy proposals for mitigating climate change have predominantly emerged from a carbon-centric policy paradigm: a reductionist approach that focuses on reducing greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs). Amid growing concerns about the normative credentials and political viability of this agenda, proponents of more radically transformative approaches have begun to coalesce around a Green New Deal (GND) policy paradigm.1–4 For GND proponents, excessive GHGs are densely intertwined with socioeconomic inequalities—such as income and wealth inequality, poverty, extreme wealth concentration, unequal political influence, and social hierarchies based on race and gender— which must be tackled simultaneously if deep decarbonization is to succeed. In Box 1, below, we contrast more fully the key features of the carbon-centric and GND policy paradigms. In the US, where the GND agenda is most politically advanced, GND proposals have provoked predictable resistance from conservative elites and carbon-intensive capital interests.12,13 More interestingly, they have attracted criticism from advocates of decarbonization who endorse the carbon-centric paradigm (see Table S1). Essentially, these criticisms reflect a view that socioeconomic inequalities are not significant drivers of climate change and that tackling them together would be unjustified and/or politically counterproductive. The following quote from distinguished climate scientist Michael Mann, writing in Nature, is illustrative: ‘‘Saddling a climate movement with a laundry list of other worthy social programmes risks alienating needed supporters (say, independents and moderate conservatives) who are apprehensive about a broader agenda of progressive social change.’’1 Here, we aim to provide a systematic response to critiques of this kind. We show that socioeconomic inequalities causally contribute to climate change. We then argue that a more systemic approach to climate mitigation, exemplified by the GND policy paradigm, better addresses these inequality-related drivers and is more likely to be politically effective than carboncentric policy alone. We synthesize the theory and evidence linking climate change to socioeconomic inequalities. The numerous channels through which climate change exacerbates socioeconomic inequalities are well established and widely understood in the climate policy community,15 so we do not discuss these here. Less well known, and therefore the focus of our synthesis, are the channels through which causation flows in the opposite direction: from existing socioeconomic inequalities to climate change. We use ‘‘socioeconomic inequalities’’ as an umbrella term, intending that it be understood to encompass both interpersonal inequalities per se and absolute forms of disadvantage (e.g., financial insecurity) and advantage (e.g., extreme wealth). However, when analyzing causal mechanisms linking socioeconomic inequalities to climate change, we identify the particular explanatory variable relevant to each.We identify 10 such mechanisms, which we discuss under five themes: consumption patterns, production decisions, the obstruction of climate change mitigation policies by elites, households’ fears about the economic and social effects of climate mitigation policies, and the erosion of the social bonds that underpin collective political action—in short, consumption, production, obstruction, trepidation, and non-cooperation. This evidence suggests that integrating certain carbon-centric policies into a wider program of social, economic, and democratic reforms would achieve decarbonization more effectively than carbon-centric policies alone. In the second half of the paper, we draw on this evidence to evaluate the case for GNDs as a means of climate action. We argue first that GNDs make for good policy. On the basis of our review of 29 GND-style proposals from around the world in 2019–2021, we show that common policy components of GNDs do indeed tackle the mechanisms by which inequalities fuel climate change, making them more effective than carbon-centric policies alone. We then argue that GNDs make for good politics: the political strategy associated with GNDs is likely to be more effective than the political strategies associated with carbon-centric policies.
Green New Deal pushes national cohesion on transformative environmental change to sustain the future of the planet.
Sophie Carter A Green New Deal Makes Economic And Environmental Sense April 25, 2021 Updated April 25, 2021 at 6:33 pm https://www.bcheights.com/2021/04/25/a-green-new-deal-makes-economic-and-environmental-sense/
Last Tuesday, U.S. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York and Massachusetts’ own U.S. Senator Ed Markey took the ambitious steps to formally reintroduce their signature bill, the Green New Deal. With new Democratic control of both houses of Congress and the White House, it appears as though the most sweeping piece of climate legislation in history may have another chance at being passed. If so, it will transform the national economic and environmental landscape. It is well past time for the Democratic Party to uniformly rally around the Green New Deal and work to change the course of climate injustice in America.
As it stands today, climate change is undoubtedly one of the most pressing issues facing the world. There are concerning signs surrounding the prospects for maintaining an inhabitable world—storms and major weather events are worsening, the sea level is rising, and humans have already warmed the globe by about one degree Celsius. It is also important to note that the effects of the climate and environmental crises are not uniformly felt across all social groups. Declining air and water quality is far more likely to impact racial minorities, especially those who live in urban areas. In the United States, one out of every six Black children suffer from asthma due to poor air quality, and they are five times more likely than white children to contract lead poisoning because they live in close proximity to toxic waste. On a more global scale, the majority of those who will be displaced by rising sea levels, unstable weather events, and plummeting food supplies will be those who live in developing nations, mostly in the global south. It is evident that this situation is fundamentally unfair and unsustainable. The question is, what can we do about this moral and environmental crisis?
The Green New Deal is a piece of public policy that is carefully crafted to address the interrelated crises of environmental degradation and social inequality. Scientists agree that in order to achieve a best-case scenario surrounding the changing climate, the world needs to achieve carbon neutrality by the year 2050. The Green New Deal aims to push the U.S. to take on a leading role in working toward this goal by implementing a 10-year plan that includes investing in the move to 100 percent renewable energy and sustainable infrastructure. All of these goals would be achieved through creating high-paying, green jobs in order to reduce economic inequality and retrain those who work in the dying fossil fuel industry. Although the bill would function as a non-binding resolution, its passage would signal national cohesion on climate-friendly initiatives that are already being implemented at state and local levels.
Our future will require a total reversal of direction and now is our last chance to get it right. The direction of the Green New Deal is what is necessary to avert a total climate breakdown.
Ann Pettifor 2020 The Case for the Green New Deal. google books.
For humanity to survive on a liveable planet there is an urgency to what we must, and can, do. We are facing extinction. The earth’s complex life support systems of atmosphere, oceans, land surface and life forms are at the point of breakdown, according to the world’s top scientists. As George Monbiot has warned, ‘only one of the many life support systems on which we depend—soils, aquifers, rainfall, ice, the pattern of wind and currents, pollinators, biological abundance and diversity—need fail for everything to slide. The UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) issued a clear and trenchant call for action in 2018. We need to cut annual global emissions by half in the next twelve years and hit net zero carbon by the middle of the century. According to Jason Hickel in Foreign Policy magazine, it would be difficult to overstate how dramatic this trajectory is. It requires nothing less than a total and rapid reversal of our present direction as a civilization. The challenge is staggering in its scale, and the stakes are even more so. As the co-chair of an IPCC working group put it, ‘the next few years are probably the most important in our history’. After decades of delay, this is our last chance to get it right. For the UK and US, as well as other OECD countries, averting climate breakdown means cutting CO2 emissions by 80 percent by 2030 and reaching a zero carbon economy by 2040. This will allow OECD emission cuts to be equitably shared with non-OECD countries’ emission cuts (as in the 1992 UN Convention on Climate Change’s ‘common but differentiated responsibilities’ (CBDR), in which OECD nations have to cut first and hardest).
Its feasible – broad public sector mobilization can achieve a rapid and just transition
Aronoff, et.al., 2019 A Planet to Win: Why We Need a Green New Deal Kate Aronoff, Alyssa Battisoni, Daniel Aldana Cohen, and Thea Riofrancos 2019 google books
For the United States to get to net zero emissions in its power sector by the mid-2030s, the country needs to build out new clean energy at least ten times faster than in recent years. Along with public investments in ecosystem restoration, green infrastructure, and conservation work, these measures would require an enormous amount of labor—and thus create millions of high-quality green jobs. There’s simply no precedent for the private sector mobilizing that broadly and quickly. With state support, green capitalists have developed cheap and effective clean energy technologies. But while solar companies can gradually outcompete coal, they can’t legislate coal out of existence or transform the electricity grid and broader energy system.
Under a radical Green New Deal, the public sector would direct investment and coordinate production, much as it did during World War II. Can government bureaucracies handle such complex work? They could seventy-five years ago working with legal pads and chalkboards. In the 1940s, improvised public agencies, the army, and government subsidized businesses ramped up the production of killing machinery with unbelievable speed. The public backed industry built the world’s largest factory in under a year near Ypsilanti, Michigan; it went on to produce a B-24 bomber every hour. Overnight, car seat factories switched to parachute production and Cadillac assembly lines started churning out tanks. We wish we had a different analogy for that scale of public action than World War II. But the point remains: we can build—and push—a public sector capable of stewarding a rapid and just transition. Its often forgotten, moreover, that state capacity was built up in the decade prior by the New Deal. Neoliberals have spent four decades chipping away at these administrative capacities, weakening regulations and many federal agencies to empower big business. Rebuilding and reinvigorating public institutions is one of the most important tasks we face today.
Climate change is a non-linear, existential risk.
Kemp et al. 22, *Luke Kemp, Centre for the Study of Existential Risk, University of Cambridge; *Chi Xu, School of Life Sciences, Nanjing University; *Joanna Depledge, Cambridge Centre for Environment, Energy and Natural Resource Governance, University of Cambridge; *Timothy Lenton, Global Systems Institute, University of Exeter; (August 1st, 2022, “Climate Endgame: Exploring catastrophic climate change scenarios”, https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2108146119#sec-3)
Worst-Case Climate Change
Despite 30 y of efforts and some progress under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) anthropogenic greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions continue to increase. Even without considering worst-case climate responses, the current trajectory puts the world on track for a temperature rise between 2.1 °C and 3.9 °C by 2100 (11). If all 2030 nationally determined contributions are fully implemented, warming of 2.4 °C (1.9 °C to 3.0 °C) is expected by 2100. Meeting all long-term pledges and targets could reduce this to 2.1 °C (1.7 °C to 2.6 °C) (12). Even these optimistic assumptions lead to dangerous Earth system trajectories. Temperatures of more than 2 °C above preindustrial values have not been sustained on Earth’s surface since before the Pleistocene Epoch (or more than 2.6 million years ago) (13).
Even if anthropogenic GHG emissions start to decline soon, this does not rule out high future GHG concentrations or extreme climate change, particularly beyond 2100. There are feedbacks in the carbon cycle and potential tipping points that could generate high GHG concentrations (14) that are often missing from models. Examples include Arctic permafrost thawing that releases methane and CO2 (15), carbon loss due to intense droughts and fires in the Amazon (16), and the apparent slowing of dampening feedbacks such as natural carbon sink capacity (17, 18). These are likely to not be proportional to warming, as is sometimes assumed. Instead, abrupt and/or irreversible changes may be triggered at a temperature threshold. Such changes are evident in Earth’s geological record, and their impacts cascaded across the coupled climate–ecological–social system (19). Particularly worrying is a “tipping cascade” in which multiple tipping elements interact in such a way that tipping one threshold increases the likelihood of tipping another (20). Temperature rise is crucially dependent on the overall dynamics of the Earth system, not just the anthropogenic emissions trajectory.
The potential for tipping points and higher concentrations despite lower anthropogenic emissions is evident in existing models. Variability among the latest Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6) climate models results in overlap in different scenarios. For example, the top (75th) quartile outcome of the “middle-of-the-road” scenario 

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.