Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 Michigan Evidence

Impacts - Renewables Bad - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP

Impacts - Renewables Bad - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Renewables
Turn---1NC
Green Energy innovation cause international conflict---US and Chinese tensions cause World War III.
Hal Brands 22, Writer for Bloomberg, 11/01/2022, “The Green-Energy Revolution Will Make the World More Dangerous,” https://www.aei.org/op-eds/the-green-energy-revolution-will-make-the-world-more-dangerous/, eb
Think a green transition will free America from high-stakes competition over energy supplies? Think again. Since the Industrial Revolution, changing patterns of energy consumption have propelled international conflict. Today, the world is entering a very messy period, in which rivalry over sources of renewable energy will steadily intensify, even as older clashes over oil and other hydrocarbons continue to play out.
Energy is the lifeblood of civilization: Since the early 1800s, access to coal, oil and other resources has driven economic prosperity and military power. The struggle over energy is, in many ways, the story of modern geopolitics.
In the 19th century, coal was king, so the great empires sought colonies and other territories with rich reserves; they clashed for control over oceanic coaling stations that were the infrastructure of overseas trade and global power projection. In the 20th century, oil displaced coal, and oil-producing regions, from the Middle East to the Caucasus to the Dutch East Indies, became key strategic prizes in two world wars and the Cold War that followed.
US President Joe Biden’s administration is now calling for a green revolution, in part because of accumulated fatigue from America’s role as guardian of the Persian Gulf. But don’t except the deeper pattern to change anytime soon.
For one thing, energy transitions don’t happen quickly or cleanly: Older models of power generation typically persist even as newer models emerge. The shocks caused by the Ukraine war remind us that global oil dependence isn’t going away anytime soon, and neither will the quest for influence in the regions that produce that vital resource.
If anything, the Middle East is becoming more contested, as China invests heavily in Saudi Arabia and other oil monarchies, seeks to build military bases, and develops a blue-water fleet necessary to ensure that Washington can’t simply starve Beijing of energy imports in a crisis. As much as the US wants out of the Middle East, its primary great-power challenger wants in.
Meanwhile, the clash over renewable energy resources is just getting started. Solar panels and wind turbines are built with aluminum, copper, silver, silicon and other materials. Cobalt, lithium and manganese are vital components of electric vehicle batteries. In a fragmenting international system, competition over the resources that will ultimately power the 21st-century economy could be just as vicious as the fights over oil in the 20th.
The world’s great powers will have a strong rooting interest in civil wars and political contests in resource-rich countries, just as the US has long deemed the political stability of Saudi Arabia to be vital to its security. Large states will seek to ensure, whether commercially or militarily, the security of their supply chains while perhaps developing the ability to fracture those of their rivals. It’s happening already.
China, which has long pursued loans-for-resources deals in developing countries, is investing heavily in production of methanol and other non-traditional fuels at home, while paying close attention to sources of renewable energy abroad. Beijing is seeking greater control over global lithium supplies, in part through investments in mining and production in Chile and other South American countries. China has also made a priority of accessing the Democratic Republic of Congo’s world-leading cobalt reserves. By one estimate, Chinese companies own or help fund 15 out of 19 cobalt mines in that country.
These acquisitions are part of what US officials have described as a larger, integrated strategy from Beijing that emphasizes securing the infrastructure — especially ports and railroads — that are needed to move resources to the sea and then to China. It also involves the military deployments and logistical facilities — some shrouded in mystery — needed to ensure that China can protect its investments and extend its global reach.
The US isn’t particularly well positioned for this challenge. Part of the problem, as President Donald Trump’s administration catalogued, is that America relies on China for many minerals deemed critical to US interests. Then there is the fact that Washington just hasn’t prioritized many of the key countries and regions.
South America and Africa loom large; Southeast Asian countries have lots of nickel. Beijing has consistently expanded its influence in these regions. American engagement has been far more episodic and reactive — in military, diplomatic and economic terms — because Washington has simply been focused on other things.
The US is trying to catch up, by seeking greater access to key resources in allied countries (such as Australian cobalt); stimulating domestic extraction and production; exploring cobalt-free batteries and other alternatives; and working with allies and private companies to provide developing countries with options other than relying on Chinese financing, investment and infrastructure deals. But many of these efforts are nascent at best, and the momentum appears to be on Beijing’s side.
The world’s new energy competition is heating up, not least in regions that the US has become accustomed to treating as strategic afterthoughts. If history is any guide, it won’t have that luxury for long.
Inequality---Turns Case---2NC
Renewables perpetuate inequality---forcing them to make the decision between Food and Energy.
PSU 19, Portland State University, 07/12/2019, “ Shifts to renewable energy can drive up energy poverty, study finds”, https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2019/07/190712151926.htm#:~:text=Shifts%20to%20renewable%20energy%20can%20drive%20up%20energy%20poverty%2C%20study%20finds,-Date%3A%20July%2012&text=Summary%3A,according%20to%20a%20new%20study, eb
Efforts to shift away from fossil fuels and replace oil and coal with renewable energy sources can help reduce carbon emissions but do so at the expense of increased inequality, according to a new Portland State University study.
Julius McGee, assistant professor of sociology in PSU's College of Liberal Arts and Sciences, and his co-author, Patrick Greiner, an assistant professor of sociology at Vanderbilt University, found in a study of 175 nations from 1990 to 2014 that renewable energy consumption reduces carbon emissions more effectively when it occurs in a context of increasing inequality. Conversely, it reduces emissions to a lesser degree when occurring in a context of decreasing inequality.
Their findings, published recently in the journal Energy Research & Social Science, support previous claims by researchers who argue that renewable energy consumption may be indirectly driving energy poverty. Energy poverty is when a household has no or inadequate access to energy services such as heating, cooling, lighting, and use of appliances due to a combination of factors: low income, increasing utility rates, and inefficient buildings and appliances.
McGee said that in nations like the United States where fossil fuel energy is substituted for renewable energy as a way to reduce carbon emissions, it comes at the cost of increased inequality. That's because the shift to renewable energy is done through incentives such as tax subsidies. This reduces energy costs for homeowners who can afford to install solar panels or energy-efficient appliances, but it also serves to drive up the prices of fossil fuel energy as utility companies seek to recapture losses. That means increased utility bills for the rest of the customers, and for many low-income families, increased financial pressure, which creates energy poverty.
"People who are just making ends meet and can barely afford their energy bills will make a choice between food and their energy," McGee said. "We don't think of energy as a human right when it actually is. The things that consume the most energy in your household -- heating, cooling, refrigeration -- are the things you absolutely need."
War---Impact---2NC
Renewables drive global conflict.
Ahern 23, MA in Philosophy from Memorial University of Newfoundland and environmental and outreach coordinator for numerous climate justice programs. (Andrew, 2-21-2023, “How Degrowth Can Help Reduce Global Conflict,” Science for the People, https://magazine.scienceforthepeople.org/online/how-degrowth-can-help-reduce-global-conflict/)
Let’s use the example of electric vehicles. The batteries in these vehicles rely on minerals like nickel, cobalt, and lithium, which, according to the World Bank, could drive demand up to 500 percent depending on the mineral, all else being equal.4 Indonesia, for instance, holds the world’s largest nickel reserves and environmental degradation is already underway in the pursuit of such a mineral. According to the Environmental Justice Atlas, “Fisheries are declining and health is deteriorating in Kawasi since the local nickel mining and smelting project started dumping waste in the sea.”5 Such local deterioration is explored in visual detail in the Yale Environment 360 film contest winner “From Dreams to Dust,” which shows how the pursuit of materials for green technologies result in polluted drinking water, barren landscapes, and threatened workers and communities.6 Since 2012, at least fourteen Indonesian environmental defenders have been killed.7 This extractive logic applies to other green technologies like solar panels and wind turbines as well, since renewables are still materially intensive (although less so than fossil fuels).8 While it is no doubt true that we need to get off fossil fuels, there are choices to be made about how much energy we use, where it comes from, and who is faced with the risks and benefits.
We are already seeing these conflicts play out in real time all over the world, and while still at the earliest stage of the energy transition—if we can even call it that. According to Global Witness, an international nongovernmental organization that tracks the deaths of environmental defenders, the rise in murders among people defending their local land or natural resources has risen almost every year for the last two decades, with the largest source of conflict typically in the mineral sector.9 It is no coincidence that at the same time environmental protection is most needed, environmental conflict has reached its highest point yet. To add insult to injury, the US military is well aware of the importance of these minerals. In the words of the US Department of Defense, “Strategic and critical materials are vital to our national defense and economic prosperity, enabling the United States to develop and sustain emerging technologies. They also improve our warfighting capability, support family-sustaining jobs, and strengthen our alliances and partnerships.”10 In no uncertain terms the US military sees access to these “strategic and critical minerals” as vital to sustain economic growth and the United States’ dominance on the world stage. Unfortunately, without drastic changes in energy demand, this trend will only continue.
AND two more causes of war:
1. Scarcities
Renewable energy will cause a security crisis over land and resources.
Tom Johansmeyer 22, Tom Johansmeyer is head of PCS, a Verisk business, which estimates the industry-wide insured losses from disaster events around the world, 11/01/2022, “HOW RENEWABLE ENERGY COULD SET THE STAGE FOR FUTURE RESOURCE CONFLICT,” https://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/how-renewable-energy-could-set-stage-future-resource-conflict, eb
The push for renewable energy sources through 2035 and 2050 makes the need for wind and other forms of renewable power obvious. Unfortunately, you can’t just pop up a wind turbine or lay out some solar panels. Geography matters. Renewable energy requires favorable conditions, creating a linkage between energy security and physical locations that could result in future military threats. Taking action to prevent wars over renewable resources starts with experience, which is in short supply. However, the conflict in Ukraine offers some early insights, even if there is a slight a mismatch of circumstances.
Location, Location, Location
There’s no doubt that renewable energy will shape the global energy mix over the coming decades. We won’t be able to achieve IPCC emissions reduction targets without a mix of renewable sources. A wide range of factors could impede progress, from the economic security of extractive resources exporters to a shortage of high-quality green investment alternatives to entrenched large fossil fuel companies. However, those are likely more manageable than what could be the most significant barrier: Geography. Wind and solar require specific characteristics, as do geothermal and hydro. The connection between certain regions and favorable renewable energy characteristic entails a natural scarcity of renewable energy production, simply because some locations better than others.
The relative scarcity of regions favorable to renewable energy production could cause some to become contested, in much the same way that fossil fuel producing regions have been. Wind power illustrates the issues associated with geography that shrink the amount of viable wind power production location and creates scarcity, which could ultimately lead to shortages and thus conflict. Wind requires space – a lot of it, with a 200-megawatt facility potentially occupying 13 square miles. Sheer space isn’t enough, though. Wind farms need a lot of space in the right place. They need to be close to sources of demand, reasonably unobtrusive for trade and aesthetic purposes, and in jurisdictions familiar enough with the technology. Further, wind farms require conditions that make sense, to include target average wind speeds enabled by “nonforested, ice-free, nonurban areas.”
Plenty of locations around the world meet the criteria necessary for wind power generation suitability, but they remain reasonably scarce – with similar situations for other renewable energy sources. It’s not inconceivable, therefore, that access to optimal renewable energy areas could become an international security issue, particularly for countries that see renewable energy as a contributor to energy independence, rather than just as a way to manage climate risk, as Ukraine and Taiwan do. The need to protect land favorable to renewable energy production takes the notion of energy security into the realm of military security, as well. Such areas could be exposed to threats from adversaries seeking either to destabilize through disruption of energy production or simply take control of renewable energy capabilities.
The truism that wars are fought over oil may not be broad enough. A successful energy transition could mean that wars will be fought over wind and other renewable natural resources, as long as there is a strong geographical connection. And while we aren’t seeing wars fought for wind yet, the impact of conflict on renewable energy has found early precedent. The conflict in Ukraine was not driven by strategic considerations related to geography suitable for wind and other forms of renewable energy, but it has found the part of the country with most of its wind and renewable energy capabilities.
Security Includes Recovery
Most of Ukraine’s wind power assets are located from Odesa to Luhansk and are directly exposed to the conflict. In fact, 90% of Ukraine’s wind farms sit along that stretch. Damage has already begun, with at least two turbines from different owners destroyed and more affected. The insurance tab alone for wind farms in Ukraine could exceed $800 million, a number that still could go higher. Solar power plant economic and insured losses have yet to be revealed but are expected to be significant. Although the circumstances of damage do not align perfectly with the notion of renewable resource conflict sketched out above, the current conflict in Ukraine can offer important lessons for future renewable energy security.
Foremost is the importance of post-conflict recovery and reconstruction of renewable energy assets, which may be as important as traditional defense considerations. While you wouldn’t want to leave such infrastructure exposed, no defense is perfect, and plans for rapid and cost-effective recovery are crucial, especially for facilities that may be owned by private companies based in other jurisdictions. Several factors have arisen from the impact of the conflict on renewable energy so far.
Renewable energy may be natural, but the components used to harness it are not. Energy independence is only as resilient as the sourcing of components and raw materials necessary for the likes of solar panels and wind turbine, such as cobalt, nickel, and other minerals. While the affected nation may not need to source them directly, the necessary raw materials need to be available to the manufacturer of renewable energy equipment, which could be complicated in cases where an aggressor nation is also rich in relevant resources.
In addition to raw materials, demand for renewable energy equipment could frustrate the recovery and reconstruction process. Recent supply chain challenges for renewable energy equipment resulting from the pandemic are worth noting, but they have also occurred during a period of increased demand. Wind power installations are growing rapidly, as are renewables in general. Repair demand has to compete with new installation demand, which could elongate the time needed for recovery, increasing attendant post-conflict security risks – including political, economic, and societal concerns. Developing a renewable energy mix that includes faster and less expensive restoration of service can reduce that risk, as evidenced by the possibility of having solar facilities installed in western Ukraine by the end of the year.
Finally, the importance of predictable capital flows can’t be overstated. Recovery is fueled by cash, and conflict aftermath can involve plenty of competing interests. A quick scan of the Kyiv School of Economics assessment of the implications of the conflict so far provides an indication of the potential cost. The process of post-conflict remediation is further frustrated by the fact foreign aid tends to be negotiated during and after a conflict – i.e., during a period of peak need. Securing resources can be a volatile process, with distribution compounding that volatility. The fact that the wind farms in Ukraine are insured offers an additional lesson for renewable energy security. Pre-negotiated terms should result in higher-velocity capital with increased certainty of use. The wind farms have greater predictability of capital flow because of their insurance, which should factor into future considerations of the economic aspects of renewable energy security.
2. International Law
Renewables causes international conflicts and crushes I law.
Madison Freemam 18, Madison Freeman is a research associate for energy and U.S. foreign policy at the Council on Foreign Relations and an energy and environment fellow with Young Professionals in Foreign Policy, Morgan Bazilian, Morgan Bazilian is the executive director of the Payne Institute and a professor of public policy at Colorado School of Mines. He is also a non-resident fellow at the Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy and a non-resident senior associate with the Energy and National Security Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, 10/8/2018, "How Renewable Energy Could Fuel Future Conflicts," https://gjia.georgetown.edu/2018/10/08/renewable-energy-fuel-future-conflicts/, eb
Renewable energy technologies promise to help our world

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.