Neg - SSI Puerto Rico - Michigan Classic 2023 CGO
Neg - SSI Puerto Rico - Michigan Classic 2023 CGO.docx
Indexed text preview
NEG Case 1nc---expansion fails Social Security in Puerto Rico Increases Unemployment Romberg 12 (Raquel Romberg currently teaches at Tel Aviv University in Israel. She taught previously at Swarthmore College and Temple University and was a Mellon Scholar in the Institute for Global Stdies in Culture, Power and History at Johns Hopkins University. “The Moral Economy of Brujería under the Modern Colony: A Pirated Modernity,” Duke University Press, 4/2012, https://read.dukeupress.edu/books/book/1611/chapter-abstract/176767/The-Moral-Economy-of-Brujeri-a-under-the-Modern?redirectedFrom=fulltext) //sz The economic boom of the island between World War II and the 1970s was ‘‘showcased’’ internationally (especially in contrast to the involvement of the Soviet Union in Cuba) as an American success story of development. For example, Operation Bootstrap (‘‘industrialization by invitation’’) in the 1950s boosted labor-intensive industries and the infrastructure. In addition, the exemption from federal taxes granted to American companies on the island under the 936 Law in 1976 propelled massive foreign and federal investments for capital-intensive industries. According to the political scientist Ramón Grosfoguel and the sociologist Marietta Morrissey, the United States welfare system was extended to Puerto Rico as a social and political buffer for its various massive, postwar capitalist development programs. In addition to extending federal social insurance and public assistance, the minimum wages guaranteed in the United States were imposed on Puerto Rico. Although this improved the personal income of Puerto Ricans, it drove many companies away from the island, raising its levels of unemployment.∞π To prevent social unrest, the United States government extended its food stamp program to the island (used by approximately 60 percent of Puerto Rican families by the 1980s).∞∫ Most analysts conclude that these economic changes had repercussions that were not only economic and social but also political and cultural. Along with stimulating the growth of the manufacturing, financial, and service sectors and raising personal income and living standards, these measures contributed to the assimilation of and dependence on American consumerist and welfare values and practices, which eventually hindered the decolonization impetus on the island and constituted a unique boricua everyday practice marked by political and cultural ambiguity. 2nc---expansion fails The combination neoliberal socialist policies forwards consumption culture that leads to indebtedness Rotenberg 12 (Raquel Romberg currently teaches at Tel Aviv University in Israel. She taught previously at Swarthmore College and Temple University and was a Mellon Scholar in the Institute for Global Stdies in Culture, Power and History at Johns Hopkins University. “The Moral Economy of Brujería under the Modern Colony: A Pirated Modernity,” Duke University Press, 4/2012, https://read.dukeupress.edu/books/book/1611/chapter-abstract/176767/The-Moral-Economy-of-Brujeri-a-under-the-Modern?redirectedFrom=fulltext) //sz In addition to transforming Puerto Rico into a modern colony, the Americanization of the island reconstituted not just the previous roles and power basis of brujos but also the material desires of their clients. New sites for economic mobility that have been opened up by U.S. federal welfare agencies and U.S.-based businesses, together with the alluring powers of the modern colony—consumerism and fame, not persecution and isolation—now inform the practices of brujería.≤≠ According to the economist Jaime E. Benson-Arias, Puerto Rico’s norm of consumption after the Second World War has been shaped by its participation in mainland accumulation and regulation activities, which has been maintained even during periods of economic crisis. With the recent post-Fordist neoliberal social policies that lowered considerably the buying power of many Puerto Ricans, the norm of consumption on the island has been maintained through an increase in consumer indebtedness (just as it has on the mainland).≤∞ Indeed, the social scientist Laura Ortiz-Negrón’s investigation of consumer practices in Puerto Rico shows that shopping has become a primary social activity, confirming the adage that ‘‘going shopping is a national pastime in Puerto Rico.’’ This is so, Ortiz-Negrón argues, not just because of the sheer amount of shopping malls and mega-stores plastered on the small island, but also because these shopping malls are always full despite relatively low salaries, an unofficial unemployment rate of 30 percent, and the fact that 60 percent of the population receives federal nutritional assistance through the program known as pan (Programa de Asistencia Nutricional).≤≤ Looking at the constitutive nature of consumption on Puerto Rican subjectivities, OrtizNegrón’s study reveals that consumer culture offers an escape from the utilitarian spaces of everyday life, that it signifies the participation in, not just the illusion of, equal access to goods and services, and that it allows for a nontraditional perception of commodities and social relations that stresses elements of desire and cultural capital.≤≥ Consumerism under the modern colony, she concludes in a way that pertains to my chapter here, needs not be assessed solely in terms of ‘‘the problem of consumption’’ or as a prevalent mode of criticism of American hegemony, cultural imperialism, and national identity.≤∂ Therefore, consumerism as a contemporary (some would add, postmodern) means of imagining and constructing self-images through the acquisition of commodities may be examined in relation to magic in general or the transformative potential of commodities (as in the spirit of matter, or ‘‘commodity Welfare SSI fetishism’’), and to brujería practices more specifically as one of the social arenas in which one’s ‘‘blessings’’ could be attested or tested. In framing the moral economy of brujería also within consumer capitalism, I also want to draw attention to the impact of consumerism on vernacular religious practices in Puerto Rico. Indeed, capitalist modes of consumption, not just production, could be considered as critical sites for the exploration of both the constitutive aspects of capitalist forms of domination and the potential agency of consumers as producers of meaning.≤∑ The distinction made by Daniel Miller between a priori and a posteriori differences in the kinds of rupture that the consumption of commodities might entail is useful here. By focusing on the a posteriori effects of consumer capitalism on brujería practices, I illuminate ‘‘the unprecedented diversity created by the differential consumption of what had once been thought to be global and homogenizing institutions.’’ Rather than solve theoretical conundrums, it provides a lens to observe how brujos and their clients ‘‘commonly live out these contradictions in local practice.’’≤∏ Since the late 1980s, the increasing transnational pool of ritual experts and commodities in Puerto Rico, together with a local multicultural identity politics, have also reshaped the moral economy of brujería with a more inclusive and positive attitude toward people and things African.≤π Taken together, these economic, political, and cultural changes have not only shaped Puerto Rico’s modernity in comparison to other Caribbean nations, but also, as I will show below, distinguishes the moral economy of brujería from other vernacular religions in the Caribbean. In the concluding discussion of this chapter, these ethnographic realities will be situated within and against a growing, compelling cross-cultural literature on the modernity of magic as a first step in tracing the unique genealogy of modernity that the moral economy of brujería (under a modern colony) exposes. olonization Random Congress Key Card I Found It is up to congress to act on the expansion of welfare to Puerto Rico [Mark Sherman, 11-9-2021, PBS NewsHour, "Court seems reluctant to rule for Puerto Rican resident excluded from U.S. welfare program,", https://www.pbs.org/newshour/nation/court-seems-reluctant-to-rule-for-puerto-rican-resident-excluded-from-u-s-welfare-program, Accessed 7-19-2023, LASA-LR] WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court appeared reluctant Tuesday to rule for a resident of Puerto Rico who claims it’s unconstitutional to be excluded from a welfare program that’s available in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. The justices acknowledged that the differential treatment of Puerto Ricans might be problematic, but several suggested that it is up to Congress, not the courts, to act. Justice Brett Kavanaugh said there are “compelling policy arguments” for including Puerto Rico in the Supplemental Security Income program, which provides benefits to older, disabled and blind Americans. But Kavanaugh said the court had to confront a provision of the Constitution that allows Congress to treat territories and states differently. The Caribbean island has been a U.S. territory since the Spanish American War in 1898. Puerto Rico SSI Fraud ️ Puerto Rico has historically been a hotspot for social security fraud, significantly hurting the U.S. welfare budget [Tad Dehaven, 8-15-2013, Cato Institute, "Social Security Disability Fraud in Puerto Rico,", https://www.cato.org/blog/social-security-disability-fraud-puerto-rico, Accessed 7-19-2023, LASA-LR] In 2011, the Wall Street Journal’s Daniel Paletta reported on the rapid growth in individuals applying for and receiving Social Security disability benefits. Paletta found that Puerto Rico had become a particularly easy place to obtain benefits. Officials with the Social Security Administration (SSA) absurdly claimed that nothing was amiss. It looks like the SSA is about to get some egg on its face. Yesterday, Paletta reported that federal investigators, including the FBI, raided doctors’ offices in Puerto Rico as part of a widening probe into disability fraud on the island. A doctor’s opinion that an individual is suffering from a disability is naturally quite helpful in convincing examiners and judges that benefits are warranted. Investigators are apparently looking into whether Puerto Rican doctors are being paid to document that applicants are disabled. From the article: In 2006, just 36% of initial applicants in Puerto Rico were awarded benefits. In December 2010, the award rate had jumped to 69%. By 2010, nine of the top 10 U.S. ZIP Codes for workers receiving disability benefits were on the island. At the time, SSA officials said the high number of recipients and the high award rate was due to the island’s weak economy and a lack of adequate health care for workers. The program is overseen by the Social Security Administration in Baltimore, but each state and territory is responsible for performing an initial screening to determine eligibility. Social Security officials said in 2011 that Puerto Rico had rigorous standards and a virtually nonexistent error rate. The characteristics of Puerto Rico’s beneficiaries differed from other areas. In addition to the large clusters in certain zip codes, federal data showed that 33.3% of Puerto Rican beneficiaries qualified because of “mood disorders,” a rate that is at least 10 percentage points higher than any U.S. state. Disability examiners and federal judges say mental disorders are harder to measure and often rely on medical opinions issued by doctors to make a determination. Overwhelming Taxation Extending social security would burden the Puerto Rican economy with new significant forms of taxation [Kelsey Reichmann, 7-19-2023, Courthouse News Service, "Puerto Ricans seeking federal disability benefits strike out at Supreme Court,", https://www.courthousenews.com/puerto-ricans-seeking-federal-disability-benefits-strike-out-at-supreme-court/, Accessed 7-19-2023, LASA-LR] The court traced Vaello Madero’s position to far-reaching consequences, like forcing Congress to extend many federal benefits programs to residents of territories like it does for states. “If this Court were to require identical treatment on the benefits side, residents of the States could presumably insist that federal taxes be imposed on residents of Puerto Rico and other Territories in the same way that those taxes are imposed on residents of the States,” Kavanaugh wrote (emphasis in original(. “Doing that, however, would inflict significant new financial burdens on residents of Puerto Rico, with serious implications for the Puerto Rican people and the Puerto Rican economy. The Constitution does not require that extreme outcome.” Dependency The Plan increases Puerto Rican dependency on the U.S., further destroying their autonomy Colón-Morera and Cordero-Nieves 22 [José Javier Colón-Morera, Department of Political Sciences, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; Yolanda Cordero-Nieves, Graduate School of Public Administration, CEMGAP, University of Puerto Rico, Río Piedras Campus, San Juan, Puerto Rico; “Puerto Rico: Intergovernmental Relations, Territoriality, and the Political Question”; Public Organization Review; November 30, 2022; https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11115-022-00690-1#auth-Jos__Javier-Col_n_Morera-LASA LR] Fiscal policies precede government action. In that sense, fiscal powers are considered "keystones of autonomy" (Agranof, 2004). Moreover, decisions regarding what gets funded or not are at the core of political control and autonomy (Krane & Wright, 2000). For that reason, most intergovernmental conflicts arise from the need to control public funds through fiscal policy decisions. Puerto Rico, however, is more dependent on federal funds than ever. Federal funds increased consistently from $2,680 billion (27% of the General Fund) in 2000 to $5,617 billion (35%) in 2017. Then, after Hurricane María federal funds increased considerably more reaching $13,437 billion (56%) in 2020 (Economic Report to the Governor, 2006, 2014, 2020). We argue that instead of improving the financial model to create a healthier economy and more employment, the U.S. Government has focused on increasing federal funds, leading to more dependency and less capacity to promote local policies. The U.S. Government granted Puerto Rico the fiscal autonomy to generate revenues and determine its allocation.6 Excluding the Island from Federal taxation was a decision taken in the aftermath of the 1898 Treaty of Paris. At the time, and still today, the Puerto Rican economy was too weak to absorb the impact of the Federal taxation system. This exclusion allowed subsidiaries of American companies an exemption from taxation for all income derived from their operations in the U.S. territories to stimulate job creation through, for example, Sect. 936 of the Federal tax code.7 This exemption made Puerto Rico more attractive to manufacturing and pharmaceutical companies. However, by 1995 the U.S. Congress had doubts about its benefits, and the Puerto Rican pro-statehood government supported its elimination since it was a policy not available to the states (González García, 2017; Maldonado, 2021). It was argued that the number of jobs created by the 936 Section companies was not enough to justify the loss in tax revenue (Hexner & Jenkins, 2016). Therefore, in 2006 it was eliminated. Section 936 was the last significant effort made by the U.S. Government to favor its territories’ economic development (Caraballo-Cueto, 2021). Ks Set Col Links The assumption of Puerto Ricans as U.S. citizens and deserving of their benefits further entrenches them as U.S. colonial subjects, disregarding their own self-determination in favor of assimilation. Font-Guzmán 17 (Jacqueline N. Font-Guzmán is professor of law and conflict studies and director of the Negotiation and Conflict Resolution Program in the Department of Interdisciplinary Studies at Creighton University Graduate School, “Puerto Ricans are hardly U.S. citizens. They are colonial subjects.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/puerto-ricans-are-hardly-us-citizens-they-are-colonial-subjects/2017/12/13/c0f1c700-de9f-11e7-89e8-edec16379010_story.html)//英生 Hurricanes do more than destroy homes, daily routines, power lines, agriculture, communication systems and levees. Hurricanes unveil unequal power dynamics, crush souls and create narratives, such as: "Puerto Ricans are American citizens." This is dangerous and arrogant. It is dangerous because it is incomplete. It is arrogant because it presupposes that the solution to Puerto Ricans' colonial predicament is U.S. citizenship. As a Puerto Rican, I find this story disturbing. It deprives us of our self-determination, and it assumes that the master knows what is best for the slave. The question is not why Puerto Ricans are not treated as U.S. citizens. The question should be whether Puerto Ricans want to be U.S. citizens. It is true that Puerto Ricans have U.S. citizenship due to a series of congressional statutes. But it is also true that these statutes were enacted without consulting Puerto Ricans. Puerto Rico became a U.S. colony in 1898, when the United States purchased the island and its people as war booty from Spain as part of the Treaty of Paris. Before the United States invaded, Puerto Ricans had Spanish citizenship. The queen of Spain had signed the Autonomic Charter of 1897, granting Puerto Ricans representation (voice and vote) in the courts of Spain. Ironically, Puerto Ricans enjoyed greater political participation under the monarchy of Spain than under the United States. Soon after, in 1900, Congress passed the Foraker Act, implementing a military government in Puerto Rico. Sen. Joseph Foraker (R-Ohio) proposed Puerto Rican citizenship for Puerto Ricans because Congress did not want to give Puerto Ricans even the illusion of having the same rights as those on the mainland. Eventually, Congress did give Puerto Ricans official citizenship under the Jones-Shafroth Act of 1917. But to this day, Puerto Ricans continue to be subjects of the United States without a right to vote for the president, without voting representation in Congress and without equal treatment compared with citizens born or naturalized in the United States. The Supreme Court has yet to decide whether the statutory citizenship that Puerto Ricans possess is equivalent to U.S. citizenship — including guarantees of equal protection laid out in the 14th Amendment. One solution to the separate-and-not-equal nature of Puerto Rican citizenship might be for Puerto Ricans to be granted the full rights enjoyed by other U.S. citizens. This answer to the Puerto Rican citizenship conundrum, however, passes over the essential step of Puerto Rican self-determination. The fact that a minority of Puerto Ricans favor independence does not mean that a minority of Puerto Ricans favor self-determination. Puerto Ricans have a right to decide who they are before they decide whether they wish to be U.S. citizens. The prevailing story that Puerto Ricans are U.S. citizens and should be treated like citizens on the mainland presupposes that Puerto Ricans have already decided their political future — or worse, that Puerto Ricans have no say in the matter. This story line promotes Puerto Ricans' perpetual colonial status. Puerto Ricans never asked to be colonized, never asked to be denied their Puerto Rican citizenship and never asked to have U.S. citizenship imposed upon them. Puerto Ricans suffering the devastation of Hurricane Maria are not fellow American citizens; they are colonial subjects of the United States. The United States has an obligation to provide aid to Puerto Ricans because over the past 100 years, it has chosen to keep Puerto Rico as a colony, not because Puerto Ricans have U.S. citizenship. The stories we share matter. Stories can set boundaries or create possibilities. I do not have much hope that Congress will change its story of oppression. I do hope that Hurricane Maria has dis
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.