Impacts - Renewables Good - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP
Impacts - Renewables Good - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP.docx
Indexed text preview
AFF Renewables Good---Impact---2AC Renewables are now the most cost efficient and environmentally friendly source of energy McMeekin 23 – Researcher in Physics and in the Marie Skłodowska-Curie fellowship at the University of Oxford (David McMeekin, “The Inevitable Energy Transition,” St Edmund Hall University of Oxford, 3-10-2023, Available Online: https://www.seh.ox.ac.uk/blog/the-inevitable-energy-transition, Accessed: 7-19-2023)//DD- ILake-EN Solar energy is the most abundant energy resource on earth and available in every country. Transitioning towards renewable energies has previously been difficult due to the need for direct or indirect government subsidies to support initial adoption of emerging technologies. However, this is no longer the case, where unsubsidised utility-scale bids for wind and solar projects have come in at lower price ranges than gas or coal projects, which have long been regarded as the lowest Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE). According to the Lazard’s report, utility-scale renewables are now below coal generation prices, where unsubsidised wind prices ranged from 28 to 54 USD/MWh, while utility-scale solar ranged from 32 to 42 USD/MWh, compared to coal priced at 66 to 152 USD/MWh, and gas combined cycle at 44 to 68 USD/MWh. Enabling this cost-competitiveness has triggered an inevitable energy transition from fossil fuel-based technologies to renewables. This transition is no longer an environmentalist’s pipe dream, but rather a current reality, which now has been accelerated by the soaring energy cost caused by the current geopolitical conflict. A viable, abundant and now relatively cheap source of energy is solar power. To date, crystalline silicon-based (c-Si) photovoltaics have dominated the solar market. Although c-Si-based solar cells have been around for many decades, they have only been truly cost-effective in the most recent decade. In the late 1990s, universities, research institutes and industrial partners have developed crystalline silicon technology to reach a 25% power conversion efficiency milestone. From that point forward, the world record efficiency has only risen to 26.7%, as we are approaching a theoretical limit of 33.16% for a single-junction solar cell, known as the “Shockley–Queisser limit”. Hence, it is becoming increasingly difficult to improve the efficiency of the conventional crystalline silicon solar cell. Recent cost reductions in solar energy have mainly been achieved by advancements in manufacturing techniques and reaching economies of scale. As silicon-based solar cells efficiencies converge towards their maximum theoretical limit, price reductions will soon become increasingly difficult to achieve. However, multi-junction architectures can overcome the single-junction efficiency limit, by absorbing distinct portions of the solar spectrum using materials with different band gaps, leading to an increase in solar cell efficiency. These architectures allow for a reduction in photon thermalisation losses; a loss mechanism that occurs when a high energy photon partially converts its energy to heat instead of transferring it to an electron. Multi-junction solar cells are formed by mechanically stacking, on top of one another, two or more solar cells with different band gaps, allowing each junction to absorb different portions of the solar spectrum. A relatively small increase in performance, obtained by transitioning towards multi-junction architectures, could lead to significantly lower solar energy prices, since the other major costs such as land rights, installation, and inverters should remain constant. A generic ABX3 metal-halide perovskite unit cell forming a cubic structure A strong candidate for multi-junctions are metal-halide perovskite solar cells, which form in a generic ABX3 crystal structure, where the A-site is typically an organic or inorganic cation, the B-site is a divalent metal cation, and the X-site a halide anion. Although perovskites materials have been discovered since the 19th century, perovskite structures have only emerged for solar application in the last decade or so. Oxide-based perovskite crystal structures occur abundantly in nature, with approximately 38% of the earth’s volume forming in a perovskite crystal structure. However, here in the Clarendon Laboratories, we focus our efforts on researching and developing halide-based perovskites, which form crystal structures that are particularly good at absorbing light, while maintaining long charge-carrier lifetimes with the semiconductors. Furthermore, we can fabricate metal-halide perovskite solar cells with various band gaps by tuning their chemical composition. The band gap of a semiconductor represents the energy required to promote an electron from the valence band to the conduction band, thus creating a “free-electron” that can move freely within the crystal lattice. This process occurs after a photon with enough energy gets absorbed by the perovskite material. Using specific materials or dopants, these free-electrons can then be extracted at their respective electrodes to create photogenerated current and voltage. The ability to tune their band gap makes metal-halide perovskite solar cells a perfect candidate for multi-junction solar cells. Perovskite-silicon tandems and/or all-perovskite multi-junction solar cells, may certainly be the next technological advancement in the photovoltaic roadmap, however, their long-term stability has yet to match conventional silicon-based technology. Hence, in the photovoltaic and optoelectronic group, located in Oxford’s Condensed Matter Physics (CMP) department, we are constantly trying to find new perovskite materials, architectures, or deposition techniques that improve the overall stability of these solar cells to make them commercially viable. As the cost of photovoltaic energy has plummeted, countries now have the option to lessen their dependence on fossil fuels, along with the countries that control these resources. Energy self-sufficiency has become a major policy concern since the start of the Russo-Ukrainian conflict. The energy policy change from non-renewable fossil-fuel based sources towards low carbon emission-based renewables is inevitable considering the economic advantages renewables now have to offer. Hence, in my opinion, along with the emergence of cheaper energy storage, it is not a question of “if”, but rather a question of “when” the world will change to a combination of renewable energy sources. However, citizens, politicians and scientists can significantly accelerate this change to mitigate the impact of climate change. Renewables are a green alternative to fossil fuels Lotzof 23 – Journalist for the The Natural History Museum of London (Kerry Lotzof, “Renewable energy and its importance for tackling climate change,” The Natural History Museum of London, Date Published Found Using Wayback Machine, Available Online: https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/renewable-energy.html, Accessed: 7-11-2023)//ILake- EN Replacing fossil fuel-reliant power stations with renewable energy sources, such as wind and solar, is a vital part of stabilising climate change and achieving net zero carbon emissions. Professor Magda Titirici, Chair in Sustainable Energy Materials at Imperial College London, offers an introduction to renewable energy and the future of clean, green power in the UK. What is renewable energy? Renewable energy comes from sources that replenish naturally and continually within a human lifetime. Renewable energy is often called sustainable energy. Major sources of renewable energy include solar, wind, hydroelectric, tidal, geothermal and biomass energy, which is derived from burning plant or animal matter and waste. Switching our reliance on fossil fuels to renewable energy sources that produce lower or no greenhouse gas emissions is critically important in tackling the climate crisis. Clean, green or renewable - what's the difference? Clean energy doesn't produce any pollution once installed. Nor does green energy, which comes from natural sources such as the Sun and is produced without any major negative impacts on the environment. Renewable energy refers to sources that are constantly replenished. While there is often overlap between these definitions and most renewable energy sources can also be considered clean and green, it's not always the case. Nuclear energy doesn't release greenhouse gases into the atmosphere, so some people consider it to be clean - providing the radioactive waste is stored safely and doesn't escape into the environment. But the uranium energy source used in nuclear power plants isn't renewable. A coal power plant emitting smoke, steam and carbon dioxide. Fossil fuels such as coal are non-renewable resources. Burning fossil fuels contributes to climate change by releasing greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. What's the difference between renewable and non-renewable energy? Non-renewable energy comes from natural resources such as coal, oil and natural gas that take billions of years to form, which is why we call them fossil fuels. They are present in finite amounts and will run out, as we are using them far more quickly than they form. When will fossil fuels run out? Research based on 2015 data predicts that coal stocks will last well into the next century, but oil and natural gas reserves (stocks that we know we can extract from) will run out in the late 2060s. However, scientific models suggest that if we are to limit global warming to 2°C - the target agreed at COP26 is 1.5°C - over 80% of coal, 50% of gas and 30% of oil reserves will need to be left untouched anyway. When we extract fossil fuels from deep within the planet and burn them, we can generate electricity quite efficiently. But the process releases a lot of carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere, which contributes to the greenhouse effect, global warming and biodiversity loss. Magda explains, 'Fossil fuels brought with them immense technological progress but using them releases CO2 into the atmosphere, which acts like a blanket, trapping heat that would otherwise escape into space and causing global warming.' Did you know? The energy sector is responsible for almost three-quarters of the emissions that have caused global temperatures to warm by 1.1°C since pre-industrial times. If we continue to use fossil fuels, the effect will only worsen. Magda adds, 'If we want to live on this planet much longer than 2050 and keep temperature levels below the 1.5°C of warming agreed to by governments around the world, we need to make some radical changes right now. We need to move to technologies that will give us the same level and comfort of living but drastically cut our emissions and carbon footprint.' Renewables are capable of replacing fossil fuels and will create more jobs Tierney and Bird 20 [Susan Tierney Vice Chair, WRI Global Board of Directors, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group, Inc, and Lori Bird Director, US Energy Program and Polsky Chair for Renewable Energy 5-12-2020, "Setting the Record Straight About Renewable Energy," World Resources Institute, https://www.wri.org/insights/setting-record-straight-about-renewable-energy | czx] 1. Renewables replace fossil fuel energy on the grid. In the U.S. and in virtually every region, when electricity supplied by wind or solar energy is available, it displaces energy produced by natural gas or coal-fired generators. The type of energy displaced by renewables depends on the hour of the day and the mix of generation on the grid at that time. Countless studies have found that because output from wind and solar replaces fossil generation, renewables also reduce CO2 emissions. For example, an NREL study found that generating 35% of electricity using wind and solar in the western U.S. would reduce CO2 emissions by 25-45%. Solar and wind farms have dominated new power plant builds in the U.S. in recent years, while fossil fuel plants—particularly coal-fired plants—continue to be retired at record pace. In 2019, wind (9.1GW) and solar (5.3GW) represented 62% of all new generating capacity, compared to 8.3GW of natural gas, while 14GW of coal-fired capacity was retired. The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) has also projected that most new electric generation added in the U.S. in 2020 could come from wind and solar, with new natural gas plants projected to represent less than a quarter of new generating capacity. Certainly, some of these installations may be delayed by the COVID-19 pandemic. While natural gas builds exceeded those of renewables in 2018, reversing the earlier trend of renewables leading, there were 12.9GW of coal-fired capacity and 4.6GW of gas-fired capacity retired in that same year, according to EIA. 2. Clean energy has created millions of jobs – and can create more. At the start of 2020, the clean energy sector employed about 3.4 million workers in the U.S., with much of the workforce concentrated in the energy efficiency industry. In 2019, clean energy jobs outnumbered jobs in the fossil fuel sector 3 to 1; across 42 states and the District of Columbia, the clean energy workforce was larger than that of the fossil fuel industry. The quality of these jobs is also important. According to research by the Brookings Institute, clean energy workers earn higher and more equitable wages when compared to workers nationally, with mean hourly wages exceeding the national average by 8 to 19%. Clean energy jobs are only expected to continue growing — notwithstanding the hit to the sector as a result of COVID-19. Through 2028, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics forecasts that the two fastest-growing jobs in the United States will be solar installers (projected to grow by 105%) and wind technicians (projected to grow by 96%). Under the International Renewable Energy Agency’s “Transforming Energy Scenario,” the number of renewable energy jobs worldwide could more than triple, reaching 42 million jobs by 2050, while energy-efficiency jobs would grow six-fold, employing over 21 million more people. By contrast, the fossil fuel industry is expected to lose over 6 million jobs over the same time period, even without the impact of the virus. Renewables have minimal impacts on the environment Tierney and Bird 20 [Susan Tierney Vice Chair, WRI Global Board of Directors, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group, Inc, and Lori Bird Director, US Energy Program and Polsky Chair for Renewable Energy 5-12-2020, "Setting the Record Straight About Renewable Energy," World Resources Institute, https://www.wri.org/insights/setting-record-straight-about-renewable-energy | czx] Wind and solar plants can be built with minimal environmental impacts, and often with co-benefits. All power plants, including renewables, result in some environmental impacts during siting, development and operation. Over the past two decades, siting practices for U.S. wind projects have become more sophisticated and effective at minimizing impacts. As a result, wind projects have fewer impacts than other types of projects, falling near the bottom on lists of developments that can have negative effects on the environment and wildlife, according to the U.S. Department of Energy. What’s more, these projects often provide co-benefits. Wind farms sited in rural areas benefit farmers and ranchers by providing annual revenues from $4,000 and $8,000 per turbine, while allowing landowners to continue to use the sites for agriculture or grazing. Additionally, wind farm owners pay county property taxes that support schools, recreation centers and other county activities. Solar siting practices require environmental investigations to identify and minimize negative impacts. Plans can be developed that provide additional benefits such as protecting wildlife, improving soil health and water retention, nurturing native vegetation, or incorporating pollinator-friendly plants. Additional benefits can include lease income to farmers and county or city tax revenues. Payments to landowners vary widely across the U.S. and can range from $300-1,000 per acre. And operating these plants, of course, requires no fuel-delivery infrastructure like gas pipelines, propane trucks, coal barges and railroads, all of which produce their own negative environmental impacts. Renewable energy is cheap Tierney and Bird 20 [Susan Tierney Vice Chair, WRI Global Board of Directors, Senior Advisor, Analysis Group, Inc, and Lori Bird Director, US Energy Program and Polsky Chair for Renewable Energy 5-12-2020, "Setting the Record Straight About Renewable Energy," World Resources Institute, https://www.wri.org/insights/setting-record-straight-about-renewable-energy | czx] Solar and wind now provide the cheapest power for 67% of the world. The costs associated with solar and wind have fallen dramatically in recent years. According to BNEF, the cost of energy globally for onshore wind and utility-scale solar is now $44 and $50/MWh (on a levelized basis), compared to $100 and $300/MWh only a decade ago. In the U.S., the levelized cost of energy (LCOE) associated with onshore wind ($24-46/MWh) and utility-scale solar ($31-111/MWh) is now less than that of almost all gas-fired power production. Battery storage, which is crucial to address the variability of wind and solar power, has seen the swiftest global price drop among all technologies, from nearly $600/MWh in 2015 to about $150/MWh in the first half of 2020. This precipitous drop in the cost of utility-scale solar and onshore wind has made them the cheapest sources of power in two-thirds of the world. Today, solar projects in Chile, the Middle East and China, or wind projects in Brazil, the U.S. and India, are approaching figures lower than $30/MWh, lower than the costs of building and producing power from plants that use coal or even the cheapest gas. By 2030, upcoming innovations are likely to reduce costs even further. Although wind and solar cannot produce energy every hour of the day, the energy they generate can be managed on the grid. Wind farms produce electricity when it’s windy and solar farms produce power when there’s sun, leading to variability in the supply of energy. However, this can be — and is being — managed by utilities and grid operators through operational practices, forecasting, responsive loads and infrastructure such as storage and transmission. Electricity grids are designed to address variability in customers’ electricity demand, maintain continuous balance between generation and demand and maintain reserves for any type of outage on the system (e.g., power plant failure), so they are already designed to manage variability. However, grids need to be modified to be more flexible over time, to integrate larger amounts of wind and solar and address the additional variability that comes with heavier reliance on renewables. Increased investments in storage and transmission, as well as market reforms, can help. Around the world, grid operators are managing larger amounts of wind and solar every year. In 2018, operators in California, the Southwest, and Texas used wind and solar for nearly 20% or more of their energy on an annual average basis, and in excess of 50-60% on an hourly basis. In Europe, several countries have managed even higher hourly penetrations of wind and solar, including Denmark (139%), Germany (89%) and Ireland (88%). Battery storage is economically viable to address the variability of wind and solar and can help reduce emissions. While most energy storage currently comes from pumped hydro storage facilities, the use of battery energy storage is growing rapidly, because of its increasingly cost competitiveness. Lithium-ion energy storage systems have seen dramatic price declines — as much as 85% between 2010 and 2018. Batteries are efficient carriers of energy, with round-trip efficiencies of 85-90%. If they are charged by renewable energy sources, they have no added GHG emissions. Batt
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.