Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 Michigan Disadvantage

DA - Oil Supplement - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP

DA - Oil Supplement - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Oil
Rebounding---Uniqueness---2NC
Oil demand rebounded in early 2023, reaching new highs.
Perkins 23 [Robert Perkins; Robert is a journalist with over 20 years of experience covering finance, business, economics, and energy industry issues; 3-15-2023; "World oil demand to hit fresh highs in 2023 as China rebounds: IEA"; S&P Global; https://www.spglobal.com/commodityinsights/en/market-insights/latest-news/oil/031523-world-oil-demand-to-hit-fresh-highs-in-2023-as-china-rebounds-iea; Accessed 7-11-23; AO]
The International Energy Agency March 15 raised its estimate for global oil demand in 2023 by another 100,000 b/d as rebounding air traffic and pent-up Chinese demand push consumption to record highs. In its latest monthly oil market report, the Paris-based energy watchdog said it now sees global oil demand averaging 102.02 million b/d in 2023, 2 million b/d higher than in 2022. The gains will accelerate over the year, however, rising to 2.6 million b/d year on year in the fourth quarter, from just 710,000 b/d in the current quarter, the IEA estimates. "Global oil demand growth started 2023 with a whimper but is projected to end the year with a bang," the IEA said ".... Rebounding jet fuel use and a resurgent China will see an overall Q1-Q4 ramp-up of 3.2 million b/d, the largest relative in-year increase since 2010 with oil use surging to 103.2 million b/d in second-half 2023." The IEA said the global economic outlook has benefitted from China's economic momentum, with rebounding February Purchasing Managers' Index data and robust air traffic demand. Chinese mobility mostly stabilized after January's "remarkable bounce", the IEA said, adding that Chinese air traffic with domestic flights is now well above prepandemic levels. As a result, the IEA raised its estimate for Chinese jet/kerosene demand by 60,000 b/d. Globally, the IEA said its Q4 2023 forecast for jet/kerosene demand is now at 94% of Q4 2019 levels, representing a 7.5 million b/d year-on-year growth. "This assumes that by the end of 2023, the rebound in air travel will have largely run its course, with organic growth in non-OECD economies lifting overall passenger numbers further beyond 2019 levels," the IEA said. Market balance The report comes a day after OPEC kept its own 2023 global oil demand estimate largely unchanged at 101.90 million b/d, blaming weaknesses emerging in some western economies offsetting expected Chinese growth of 710,000 b/d. Under the IEA's outlook, the market balance looks set to flip into a supply deficit during the second half of the year as global oil demand rebounds with stock draws of over 1 million b/d. "Global demand is set to surge by 3.2 million b/d from Q1 2023 to Q4 2023, taking average growth for the year to 2 million b/d. Matching that increase would be a challenge even if Russia were able to maintain production at prewar levels." the IEA said. S&P Global Commodity Insights oil analysts expect to see global oil stock draws average 1.4 million b/d in H2 2023, putting pressing on prices as demand outstrips supply. The North Sea physical crude benchmark Dated Brent is expected to rise over the coming months to an average of $90/b in September before easing again in 2024, according to S&P Global analysts. Platts, part of S&P Global, assessed Dated Brent at an average of $82.49/b in February, down $0.29/b on the month. Supply growth Despite solid Asian demand growth, the IEA said that the oil markets have been in surplus for three straight quarters, helped by resilient Russian export volumes. Looking ahead, the IEA raised its supply growth estimate for the year by 300,000 b/d to 66.9 million b/d, with the increase led by the US, Brazil, Norway, Canada and Guyana. Global oil supply jumped 830,000 b/d in February, the IEA said, as the US and Canada rebounded strongly from winter storms and other outages. For the year, the IEA expects world oil production to grow 1.6 million b/d, with the US and Brazil dominating growth.
High-Prices---Uniqueness---2NC
Oil prices high and they’re on an upwards trend – Saudia Arabia and Russia key drivers
Stephanie Kelly, 7/3-2023, is a correspondent covering the U.S. crude market and member of the energy team since 2018 covering the oil and fuel markets "Oil prices up, hit nearly 3-month high as US inflation eases," Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/oil-prices-rise-early-trade-us-inflation-cools-2023-07-13/ // ecam
Oil prices rose over 1% on Thursday to their highest in nearly three months after U.S. inflation data suggested interest rates in the world's biggest economy were close to their peak.
Brent crude futures rose $1.25, or 1.6%, to settle at $81.36 per barrel. The session peak was $81.57, the highest since April 25.
U.S. West Texas Intermediate crude futures rose $1.14, or 1.5%, to $76.89. The session high was $77.13, the strongest since April 26.
Data on Wednesday showed U.S. consumer prices rose modestly in June and registered their smallest annual increase in more than two years as inflation continued to subside.
The data caused the U.S. dollar index (.DXY) to drop to the lowest since April 2022, which helped to boost oil prices, said John Kilduff, partner at Again Capital LLC in New York.
A weaker dollar makes crude cheaper for holders of other currencies.
"We've had very low inflation numbers today," said Phil Flynn, an analyst at Price Futures Group. Fears that the Federal Reserve was going to raise interest rates had posed a headwind to oil, he said.
Markets expect just one more rate rise. Higher rates can slow economic growth and reduce oil demand.
Oil prices have rallied by over 11% in two weeks, primarily in response to supply cuts from top producers Saudi Arabia and Russia, said Craig Erlam, senior market analyst at OANDA.
The futures contract structure of the global benchmark Brent indicates the market is tightening and that OPEC could be succeeding in its mission to support the market.
The premium of a front-month Brent contract to a six-month February 2024 contract rose to $2.64 a barrel on Wednesday. At the end of June, the front-month contract was at a discount to the six-month contract.
A report by the International Energy Agency (IEA) on Thursday predicted oil demand would hit a record high this year, though broader economic headwinds and interest rate hikes meant the increase would be slightly less than previously anticipated.
An OPEC report also published on Thursday maintained an upbeat world oil demand outlook despite economic weakness. It raised its growth forecast for 2023 and predicted only a slight slowdown in 2024, with China and India expected to keep driving the expansion in fuel use.
Oil prices high – and they’re here to stay
Charmaine Jacob, 7-27-2023, is a digital news associate based out of CNBC’s Singapore office. “Oil markets will face ‘serious problems’ as demand from China and India ramps up, IEF secretary general says,” CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2023/07/22/oil-markets-to-face-serious-problems-as-demand-rises-ief.html //ecam
Oil prices are set to rise in the second half of the year as supply struggles to meet demand, according to the Secretary General of the International Energy Forum.
Oil demand bounced back to pre-Covid levels quickly, “but supply is having a tougher time in catching up,” said Joseph McMonigle, secretary general of the International Energy Forum, adding that the only factor moderating prices right now is the fear of a looming recession.
“So, for the second half of this year, we’re going to have serious problems with supply keeping up, and as a result, you’re going to see prices respond to that,” McMonigle told CNBC on the sidelines of a meeting of energy ministers from the group of the 20 leading industrial economies (G20) in Goa, India, on Saturday.
McMonigle attributes the push in oil prices to increasing demand from China — the world’s largest importer of crude oil — and India.
“India and China combined will make up 2 million barrels a day of demand pick-up in the second half of this year,” the Secretary General said.
China and India's oil demand will rise by 2 million barrels per day in the second half of 2023: IEFWATCH NOW
China and India oil demand to rise by 2 million barrels a day in H2 2023: IEF
Asked if oil prices could once again spike to $100 a barrel, he noted that prices are already at $80 per barrel and could potentially go higher from here.
“We’re going to see much more steep decreases in inventory, which will be a signal to the market that demand is definitely picking up. So you’re going to see prices respond to that,” McMonigle said.
Russia Oil---Uniqueness---2NC
Russia oil industry is rebounding- but it could easily fall back into decline.
Ilas et al. 23 – Andrei Ilas, Guest Writer; Petras Katinas, Energy Analyst; Isaac Levi, Energy Analyst; Jan Lietava, Data Analyst; Lauri Myllyvirta, Lead Analyst; Meri Pukarinen, Europe-Russia policy officer (Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air, “Russia’s oil revenue rebounds in March–April as price cap enforcement and review are failing – Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air,” Available Online: https://energyandcleanair.org/publication/russias-oil-revenue-rebounds-in-march-april-as-price-cap-enforcement-and-review-are-failing/, Accessed: 7-12-2023)//DD- ILake-EN
Russia’s oil revenues have rebounded in March–April from levels reached in January–February 2023, rising to the highest level since November, even as the G7 leaders stated at the conclusion of the Hiroshima Summit that the price cap is working. The latest analysis from the Centre for Research in Energy and Clean Air (CREA) shows that the price cap policy had a good start after it came into force in December 2022. However, it has since lost traction, integrity and credibility as the members of the Price Cap Coalition failed to revise price levels and enforce the policy.
Our key findings include:
Russia’s oil export revenue rebounded in March–April from levels reached in January–February 2023, rising to the highest level since November. Export earnings fell substantially in the first months since the EU’s crude oil import ban took effect in early December.
The rebound was driven by an increase in export prices, enabled by the failure of the U.S., EU and other price cap coalition countries to lower the level of the caps, contrary to the policy, and due to failures in enforcing the crude oil price cap.
Reported prices for Urals crude rose above the price cap in April, but European-owned and insured tankers continued to lift Russian oil, indicating that enforcement is not working. It has been apparent for months that enforcement of the price cap doesn’t work in the Pacific trade from Russia’s Far Eastern ports to China.
The price cap coalition holds every advantage, as Russia continues to rely on European-owned and insured tankers for most of its oil exports. The share of tankers covered by the price cap in crude oil shipments out of Russia stayed around 54% in April. For oil products & chemicals, the coverage of the price cap coalition is above 60% which shows the strong leverage the policy has if price levels are lowered and enforced properly to reduce Russia’s export earnings.
Russia has made an estimated EUR 58 bln in export revenue on seaborne oil since the EU import bans and the price caps entered into force, with the majority of this oil carried on European-insured or owned tankers. Russian revenues could have been slashed by EUR 22 bln (37%) by setting the price cap for crude oil at USD 30 per barrel and revising the caps for oil products accordingly.
Unless the price cap coalition takes action, changes to Russia’s oil taxation structure will force the price of Russian crude oil closer to international benchmarks, leading to further recovery of Russia’s oil revenue, which would damage the impact and credibility of the sanctions.
AT: Price Cap Thumper---Uniqueness---2NC
Price cap doesn’t work and many countries rely on Russian oil- but plan ruins it
Surran 23 – Editor for energy, utilities, and natural resources, BA at Duke University, MBA from Rollins College (Carl Surran, “Russian crude oil tops $60 price cap for first time in test of Western sanctions,” Seeking Alpha, 7-15-2023, Available Online: https://seekingalpha.com/news/3987854-russian-crude-oil-tops-60-g-7-price-cap-for-first-time-in-test-of-western-sanctions, Accessed: 7-23-2023)//ILake- EN
Russian Urals crude oil prices exceeded the G-7 oil price cap this week for the first time, with oil prices across the board rising as Saudi production cuts begin to take hold while demand moves higher.
Prices for Urals crude hit $62.22/bbl for oil ports in the Baltic Sea, and $63.22/bbl for supplies sent from the Black Sea, according to Argus - higher than the $60 cap for Russian crude imposed in December.
The tighter markets could ease the economic strain on Russia that Western countries had sought through the oil price cap, and perhaps prompt them to lower the cap.
The West has not needed to enforce its rule because Russian crude had been trading below $60/bbl since the price cap was introduced, but with prices now rising, the ability of Western authorities to enforce the cap is unclear.
Despite rising oil prices, buyers such as India seem unlikely to turn away from Russian oil, which supplied 46% of India's crude imports in May.
Instead, Russia could enlarge its fleet of illegal "shadow tankers" to ship oil outside the reach of the cap; estimates of its size vary widely, ranging from as high as 600 ships to as low as 100.
Rosenberg and Nostrand flows neg- reinforces our impact that TOTAL Russian oil collapse causes WORLDWIDE econ decline- We re-highlight in salmon
Rosenberg and Nostrand 23 – Elizabeth Rosenberg, Assistant Secretary for Terrorist Financing and Financial Crimes, Eric Van Nostrand, Acting Assistant Secretary for Economic Policy (U.S. Department of the Treasury, “The Price Cap on Russian Oil: A Progress Report,” 5-18-2023, Available Online: https://home.treasury.gov/news/featured-stories/the-price-cap-on-russian-oil-a-progress-report, Accessed: 7-12-2023)// DD- ILake-EN
A year ago at the G7 Summit in Elmau, the leaders agreed to pursue a policy to cap the price of Russian oil to prevent Russia from continuing to earn a wartime premium. The price cap policy is a novel tool of economic statecraft designed to achieve two seemingly contradictory goals: restricting Russia’s oil revenues while maintaining the supply of Russian oil. Meeting these goals would make it harder for Russia to fund its brutal war in Ukraine while keeping energy costs down for consumers and businesses around the world. Nearly six months after implementation, the price cap is achieving both goals. We will continue to monitor dynamics in the global oil market going forward and adjust as necessary in support of these goals.
Russian exports have continued to flow, contributing to global oil market stability. Even as global oil prices have remained stable, the price of Russian oil has fallen significantly—driving down the Kremlin’s revenue. Immediately after the invasion, Russia received windfall profits on an oil price spike created by its war in Ukraine. But today, the price cap policy is taking that windfall off the table, which allows for low- and middle- income countries to purchase oil while at the same time making it increasingly challenging for Russia to finance its aggression.
In this post, we review how the price cap policy works and how it is accomplishing these twin goals.
HOW THE PRICE CAP WORKS
Following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine last February, the G7 committed to phasing out its reliance on Russian energy. We each took steps over time to ban the import of Russian products, notably oil. When the EU joined the US, UK, Canada, and others in banning imports of oil and petroleum products from Russia, they took steps to also prohibit services in support of the shipment of such fuel. Many analysts predicted that this total maritime services ban could have led to skyrocketing global oil prices. Investors widely recognized that oil prices could have surged to upwards of $150 per barrel, exacerbating global inflationary pressures. To mitigate these consequences, the G7 and Australia aligned with the EU to ban services related to the movement of Russian oil and petroleum products unless they were purchased below a price cap. Given the leading role the G7 plays in such services – from insurance to shipping to finance – this restriction has worked to limit Russia’s ability to profit from its war while promoting stability in global energy markets.
The price cap policy works by allowing companies based in Coalition countries to continue providing maritime services for the transport of Russian oil only if that oil is sold at or below the price cap level. Companies based in Coalition countries have historically accounted for around 90 percent of the market for relevant maritime insurance products and reinsurance. Traders, brokers, and importers depend on these services to trade, and vessel owners rely on insurance to protect their ships. Moreover, almost all ports and major canals require ships to carry protection and indemnity (P&I) insurance. If Russian exporters or importers of Russian oil want access to the Coalition-countries’ service providers, Russia must sell the oil at or below the price cap level. At the same time, the price cap affords greater leverage to purchasers operating without these services. These purchasers can use the price cap to negotiate better prices and pay less for Russian oil.
The price cap policy incentivizes the continued sale of oil and petroleum products on to the market at a steep discount from Russia’s wartime premium. In December 2022, the Coalition set the price cap on Russian crude oil at $60 per barrel. Immediately following its illegal invasion, Russia was earning over $100 per barrel on its oil sales, with world spot prices rising higher than $140 per barrel in the spring of 2022.According to data from the International Energy Agency (IEA), since the Russian oil price cap has been put in place, the average price of Russian Urals crude oil has been below $60 per barrel on a monthly basis.
Despite the complexity of the issue and the speed at which the Coalition needed to work, every Coalition country successfully implemented new coordinated laws and regulations. In addition, in February, the Coalition built on its success with the Russian crude oil cap by imposing a $100 per barrel price cap on Russian petroleum products, such as diesel, that trade at a premium to crude and a $45 per barrel price cap on Russian petroleum products, such as fuel oils, that trade at a discount to crude. Extensive consultations with shippers, traders, insurers, financers, and other market participants ensured that the price cap policy works within the contours of the global oil trade and that industry was able to implement smoothly at the outset, avoiding disruption to global energy markets.
The price cap policy benefits low- and middle- income countries. To be clear, Coalition members have prohibited almost all seaborne oil imports from Russia and are not themselves benefiting directly from Russian sales at the capped prices. Instead, the direct beneficiaries are mostly emerging market and lower income countries that import oil from Russia. Even for countries who are not using Coalition services, the price cap creates leverage to demand lower prices from Russia. These nations receive drastically lower prices than they did in the first few months after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. The policy has thus lessened the negative global spillovers from Russia’s war and has been financially helpful for a number of vulnerable countries.
ECONOMIC IMPACT
Following the implementation of the price cap policy, Russia’s oil revenues have fallen substantially compared to both pre-war levels and the elevated level at the onset of the war. According to the

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.