K - Buddhist Economics - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP
K - Buddhist Economics - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP.docx
Indexed text preview
K – Buddhist Economics Alt—BLP Notes: This file is NOT the Buddhism k its about consumption focused economics, based off a buddhist mindset to be an alt to the capitalism critique. Consumption focused economics will solve some stuff, all of cap bad, but its distinct from the socialism alt. It’s a mindset shift as well as a group of material alternatives, grassroots movements that can transform economies at a small scale, cutting off global interdependence in order to ensure that the world isn’t able to collapse and to ensure that the system can be contained. Creds: Thanks to Sarah Lee for management and helping me understand the whole thing! Thanks to leo Federspiel for one of those perm cards Thanks to lucas plotkin for the Turn cards --Sahil Gupta 1NC—Capitalism Critique 1NC—Top Level (Insert link) Capitalist accumulation is unsustainable, causes extinction and planetary immiseration. Robinson, 23—Distinguished Professor of Sociology, Global and International Studies, and Latin American Studies at the University of California at Santa Barbara (William, “The Violent Crackup of the Post-WWII International Order: Notes on the Geopolitical Crisis and Global Capital,” Journal of World-Systems Research, Vol. 29, No. 1, dml) Some scholars have framed the crisis of global capitalism in terms of a declining U.S. hegemony and the rise of a Chinese competitor. But no new nation-state power can supply the political authority necessary to stabilize the now-inextricably integrated global economy. The crisis of hegemony in the international system takes place within this single, integrated global economy. No one state, no matter how powerful, can control the process of global accumulation. This disjuncture between a globalized economy and a nation-state-based system of political authority generates enormous geopolitical tensions. The end of Western domination of world capitalism is upon us as the center of gravity of the global economy shifts to China. But China will not become a new hegemon. Rather, we are moving towards political multipolarity at a time of acute crisis in global capitalism—prolonged economic turbulence and political decay. The breakdown of the political organization of world capitalism is not the cause but the consequence of contradictions internal to a globally integrated system of capital accumulation. Escalating geopolitical conflict is pushing us towards global conflagration. Wars provide enormous outlet for surplus accumulated capital. Historically they have pulled the capitalist system out of accumulation crisis while they serve to deflect attention from political tensions and problems of legitimacy. The most urgent task at this time is to prevent World War III. The more we understand the changing nature of this beast that is global capitalism, the better we are situated to work out strategies of resistance and transformation. The task before us is ever more urgent in the face of the threat of nuclear holocaust, the collapse of the biosphere, and ever more acute inequality, immiseration, and social disintegration around the world. The alt is to adopt a consumption focused mindset on economics—focusing on others instead of our own self interest stops the capitalist drive for accumulation and endless consumption. The endless consumption is intertwined with our lives—realizing this is enough to restructure our lives and the global economy. Brown 17, Clair Brown is an American economist who is Professor of Economics and Director of the Center for Work, Technology, and Society at the University of California, Berkeley. Brown is a past Director of the Institute of Industrial Relations at UC Berkeley. Clair has published research on many aspects of how economies function, including the standard of living, wage determination, inequality, sustainability, high-tech industries, and development engineering. Her books include American Standards of Living: 1919-1988 and Buddhist Economics: An enlightened approach to the dismal science (Bloomsbury Press, 2017) "How “Buddhist Economics” Can Make Us Happier – Lions Roar," Lions Roar, https://www.lionsroar.com/what-makes-people-happy/ , April 27, 2017 //$$G Economics affects how we live and how happy we are. Yet most people ignore economics, even though it has a powerful impact on our lives and our future. Take our two biggest worldwide challenges: global warming and income inequality. United Nations climate scientists warn that time is running out if we are to avoid destroying our planet and our way of life. Income inequality rivals that of the Gilded Age, with economists predicting that inequality will continue to grow, along with political turmoil. Both of these challenges are profoundly influenced by economics. Overcoming them will require a complete rethinking of our economic system, our lives, and what matters to us. We must learn to live in harmony with nature and with one another. As a professor of economics and a student of Buddhism, I have been grappling for some time with the troubling disconnect between free market economics and the issues of the real world. In an era marked by vast economic disparities and the threat of environmental collapse, with opulent living for a few, comfortable living for many, and deprivation with suffering for most, something is clearly wrong. What makes people happy? This question takes us to the heart of the difference between free market economics and Buddhist economics: our human nature. Free market economics is not guiding us toward living meaningful lives in a healthy world. According to Buddhist economics, human nature is generous and altruistic, even as it also cares about itself. Buddha taught that all people suffer from their own mental states, with feelings of discontent that come from desiring more and more. The Dalai Lama tells us that the feeling of not having enough and wanting more does not arise from the inherent desirability of the objects we are seeking but from our own mental illusions. Buddha taught us how to end suffering by changing our states of mind, which translates into finding happiness through living a meaningful life. Free-market economics holds that human nature is self-centered, and that people care only about themselves as they push ahead to maximize their incomes and fancy lifestyles. According to this approach, buying and consuming—shopping for new shoes or pl\aying a new video game—will make you happy. Forget that soon you will grow tired of the shoes, become disappointed with the game, and be off shopping again. In this endless cycle of desire, we are continuously left wanting more without ever finding lasting satisfaction. Free market economics is not guiding us toward living meaningful lives in a healthy world, nor is it offering solutions to our concerns about global wars, income equality, and environmental threats. Buddhist economics, in contrast, provides guidance for restructuring both our individual lives and the economy to create a better world. “Practice compassion to be happy” replaces “More is better.” “Everyone’s well-being is connected” replaces “Maximize your own position.” “The welfare of humans and nature is interdependent” replaces “Pollution is a social cost that the individual can ignore.” The term “Buddhist economics” was first coined by E. F. Schumacher in his 1973 book Small Is Beautiful: Economics as if People Mattered. Schumacher foresaw the problems that come about with excessive reliance on the growth of income, especially overwork and dwindling resources. He argued for a system that valued individual character development and human liberation over an attachment to material goods. In Schumacher’s view, the goal of Buddhist economics is “the maximum of well-being with the minimum of consumption.” We can reprogram our economic system to create, measure, and evaluate what we value. My approach expands on Schumacher’s notion of Buddhist economics to accommodate a world that couldn’t have been envisioned in 1973, and to advocate an approach to organizing the economy so that a meaningful life reflects our caring for one another and global sharing of the world’s resources in a sustainable system. The Buddha taught that true happiness does not come from the external world, not from fame or consumption or friends or power. True happiness comes from within ourselves as we surrender to the great unknown, develop love and compassion for everyone, and become aware of every precious moment of life. We are failing at both the personal and the national level, and we must wake up and take action. And we do not have to don sackcloth and stop living comfortable, interesting, and fulfilling lives to do so. We can reprogram our economic system to create, measure, and evaluate what we value, to develop well-performing economies that provide meaningful lives for everyone while protecting the planet. Buddhist economics can guide us along the way. Links These are just more specific links than the cap ones—tailored towards the alt a bit more but the other links still work—the capitalist mindset is still solved by Buddhism. Just a note: the ubi links and generic links aren’t great but most of the magnuson cards are fine. Strongest links are probably still in the cap file. Link—UBI—2NC A UBI built into the capitalist system is merely a band-aid towards our current problems—it entrenches the fascination with more money—only after a mindset shift towards consumption can we truly redistribute wealth Ng 20, Dr. Ernest C. H. Ng is adjunct assistant professor at the Centre of Buddhist Studies, University of Hong Kong, where he teaches undergraduate and postgraduate courses on Buddhism and economics. Dr. Ng is a fellow at the European SPES Institute and author of Introduction to Buddhist Economics. “A Buddhist Perspective: Is Universal Basic Income Genuinely Caring, Compassionate, and Wise?”, Berkely Center For Religion, Peace, and World Affairs, https://berkleycenter.georgetown.edu/responses/a-buddhist-perspective-is-universal-basic-income-genuinely-caring-compassionate-and-wise#:~:text=The%20Buddha%20taught%20that%20those,greed%2C%20hatred%2C%20or%20delusion. ,$$G Universal basic income (UBI), as a universal and unconditional periodic cash payment directly to individuals, has recently become a topic of interest among politicians, scholars, and religious leaders. It aims to serve as a neatly designed policy tool to address widening income disparities. Even though further studies are required, some existing evidence supports that UBI-style programs alleviate poverty, improve health and education outcomes, and do not hinder labor market participation. These programs have drawn more interest and debate during the COVID-19 pandemic, as they are temporarily accepted to serve as band-aid and short-term responses to the unprecedented economic dislocation. The pandemic may push the circumstances to extremes: Even some self-righteous defenders of the free market are willing to concede that if rescue packages are required to bail out failing corporations, many others may need help too! When people are restricted from working to protect public health, not because they are not motivated, previous concerns over moral hazards may also seem unwarranted. The pandemic may also force us to rethink what humans really “need” instead of “want” to be happy. Necessary medicine to maintain good health, proper food and nutrition, safe shelter, and sufficient protective clothing are the four basic human needs in Buddhist teachings. In one instance, the Buddha waited for a poor peasant to be properly rested and fed before commencing his teachings. Those without these four basic needs would be considered to be in poverty. Nonetheless, Buddhist notions of wealth are not only material. The Buddha does not deny material wealth like silver and gold, but these forms of wealth can be taken away (by fire, water, kings, thieves, and displeasing heirs). They are also unreliable because they can deepen our greed, hatred, and delusion. Instead, the Buddha taught about the cultivations of wealth in terms of moral virtues, namely (1) faith; (2) virtuous behavior; (3) learning; (4) generosity; (5) wisdom; (6) moral shame; and (7) moral dread (Anguttara Nikaya [AN] 7.6 and AN 7.7). These seven kinds of wealth are truly worthy because they cannot be taken away, and they lead to the cessation of suffering. The Buddha taught that those without moral temperaments are truly indebted and poor (AN 6.45). Accordingly, a significant insight from Buddhist teachings to UBI is to properly align its objectives. UBI should aim at supporting human basic needs but not greed, hatred, or delusion. It is supposed to provide the foundation to develop human capacity and moral cultivation. The cash distribution should not be a panacea, and definitely not a band-aid, but perhaps a sustainable and flexible way to kick-start human potential and inspiration without taking away the incentive to work, save, invest, and learn. Another distinctive Buddhist perspective on UBI is that work should be meaningful by itself. According to Buddhist teachings, work should not be considered merely as a means to satisfy our endless desires. It is an integral part of life, and a skill- and character-building process. Work, if conducted in accordance with the Buddhist concept of right livelihood, is a real life practice of sustainable happiness. As Michael Sandel argues, market power could corrupt and coerce people to make involuntary or immoral choices. UBI should empower people with the basic necessity to freely choose morally sound and inspiring work. The Buddha taught that “whatever occupation he makes his living—whether by farming or trading or cattle tending or archery or as a king's man or by any other craft,” he is accomplished in initiative when he is skillful and diligent (AN 8.54). The Buddha guides a layperson to acquire wealth worthy of praise and enjoyment by “energetic striving, strength of his arms, sweat of his brow, righteous wealth righteously gained…” (AN 4.61). According to the “Kutadanta Sutta” (Digha Nikaya [DN] 5) and “Cakkavatti-Sihanada Sutta” (DN 26), the Buddha further explains not only that material and moral developments are intertwined, but that individual and societal well-being are also inseparable. He advises leaders to conserve resources and allocate them to society in the form of tangible support such as capital, seeds, and equipment to engage in economic activities conducive to well-being (DN 5). The society could only be prosperous and harmonious when individuals afford to excel in their own businesses. While contemporary society focuses on transfers through taxes and government programs, Buddhist teachings would encourage those with wealth and privilege to generously offer opportunities and support for people to earn what they need diligently and intelligently with respect. Genuine care and generosity in Buddhist teachings demand a deep understanding of the interdependent relationship between the givers and the takers, the haves and have-nots—the wealth, fame, and well-being of the billionaires are not possible without the contributions of their customers, shareholders, employees, and everyone in the community. Contributions to UBI can therefore be considered as contributions from those who benefited most from the socioeconomic system to re-invest more in the common goods. In Buddhist teachings, wealth is only of benefit if it is put to good use. That means that as much as billionaires deserve their great successes, they should also be grateful of common goods, such as social stability, skilled employees, infrastructure, and so forth. Buddhist teachings would encourage a more primary level of income distribution by allowing all stakeholders of a corporation and a community to share the fruits of success. These teachings invite us to think deeply about income disparity and the dualism of wealth and poverty. As Thich Nhat Hanh explains, “the affluent society and the deprived society inter-are. The wealth of one society is made of the poverty of the other.” Buddhist teachings would inspire a UBI which is not a demeaning subsidy program but a genuinely caring, compassionate, and wise contribution to the common good. Like other common goods such as infrastructure, education, public hygiene, and law and order, UBI could be funded by the fruits of the social capital itself. Just like the clean air and fresh water we should all fairly enjoy, UBI could serve as an important common good which we could all prudently utilize as necessary. Everyone in the community could draw into the social capital with no questions asked and without any stigma. With the right intention, UBI should contribute to human flourishing leading to sustainable happiness. It may allow people to be truly free to explore their full potential both materially and spiritually. Link—Generic—2NC Wealth redistribution entrenches the fascination with money and material consumption—limiting ourselves by only realizing basic needs solves Loy 01, David Robert Loy is an American scholar, author and authorized teacher in the Sanbo Zen lineage of Japanese Zen Buddhism. ResearchGate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232884890_Buddhism_and_poverty, March 2001 //$$G By redefining these moral qualities as “noble wealth,” Buddhism draws attention to the fact that the single-minded pursuit of material wealth will not make human beings happy or even rich. A world in which envy (issa) and miserliness (macchariya) predominate cannot be considered one in which poverty has been eliminated. This follows from the second noble truth of the Buddha: the cause of dukkha is tanha “craving”. When human beings gain an intense acquisitive drive for some object, that object becomes a cause of suffering. Such objects are compared to the flame of a torch carried against the wind, or to a burning pit of embers: they involve much anxiety but very little satisfaction — an obvious truth repressed by immediately turning our attention to another craved object. For Buddhism such a proliferation of wants is the basic cause of unnecessary ill-being. This implies that poverty can never be overcome by proliferating more and more desires which are to be satisfied by consuming more and more goods and services. In some places this may result in the elimination of material poverty for many or most, yet at the cost of promoting a different kind of poverty that is even more harmful. In short, there is a fundamental and inescapable poverty “built into” a consumer society. For that reason, development projects which seek to end poverty by “developing” a society into an economy focused on consumption are grasping the snake by the wrong end. From a Buddhist point of view we should not be surprised that such efforts in social engineering end up creating more problems than they solve. This is not a criticism of wealth itself: as in the Bible, not money but love of money is the source of evil. However, wealth must be acquired by righteous means, through one’s own efforts without using immoral or exploitative methods. Economic activity involving injury to human or nonhuman life, or undermining the moral ideals of a society, however beneficial that may be according to purely economic criteria, is unacceptable from a Buddhist perspective. Is this image of our human nature and its potential too idealistic? I don’t think so: in fact, this approach reflects better than economic theory the attitudes of most societies not already conditioned by advertising into believing that happiness is something you purchase. According to my favorite definition, by the Vietnamese teacher Thich Nhat Hanh, Buddhism is “a clever way to enjoy your life.” Confusing the quality of one’s life with a quantitative “standard of living” is, in contrast, a stupid way. Many of the Third World peoples we have been so eager to “develop” seem to be more aware of the differenc
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.