Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 Michigan Kritik

AT Buddhist Economics K - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP

AT Buddhist Economics K - Michigan Classic 2023 BLP.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Aff
Note: link turns are really strong, could probably win on em unless the neg has answers.
Indicts
Buddhist Economics Wrong—2AC
Their portrayal of capitalism and their alternative is bad—they sever from true Buddhist teachings and their view of economics only reinforces capitalism. State action is possible to ensure a true change of the economy—complete and utter rejection of capitalism as an essential issue makes it worse and diverts attention away from true ways to solve.
Nelson 18, Julie Nelson currently conducts research on feminism and economics, with special interests in methodology and in implications for social and environmental policies. She has also published in the areas of ethics, the teaching of economics, and the empirical analysis of household and individual behavior. She has served as a Research Economist at the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, an Assistant and Associate Professor of Economics at the University of California-Davis, an Associate Professor of Economics at Brandeis University, a Visiting Associate Professor at Harvard University, a Fellow at the Center for the Study of Values in Public Life at Harvard Divinity School, and as the Visiting Sowell Professor of Economics at Bates College. “A Skeptical (and Buddhist) Take on “New Economy” Approaches*”, December 18, 2018, $$G
Before I get into the “skeptical” part of my argument, let me first outline a few points on which I enthusiastically agree with the views expressed by John Tomer (2017), Clair Brown (2017), and Joel Magnuson (2008). First, we are in deep trouble. Climate change and other forms of environmental degradation are real; injustices are widespread and persistent; human misery is rife. Second, many of these problems can, in fact, be traced to economic phenomena. These include fossilfuel-based industrialization, a narrow focus on material satisfactions and GDP growth, and policies that allow the few to get rich at the expense of the many. Third, Buddhism has something important to offer. This is particularly true in regard to its warnings about the “three poisons” of greed, anger, and ignorance.
But here is where I differ: These authors (along with other notable Buddhist writers such as David Loy (2015) and the Ven. Bhikku Bodhi (2015)) locate the root of these problems in various principles, such as greed and competition, which they believe are part of the inherent nature of our present economic system. Often this system is labeled simply as “capitalism.” They then advocate for dismantling the present system and replacing it with a “new economy” that would be governed by diametrically opposite principles. In the “new economy,” altruism and cooperation would, presumably, rule. I do not find this dualism helpful.
I will argue that, first, such a “new economy” view takes mainstream economics teachings about how firms and markets work far too seriously. Secondly, I will suggest that the “new economy” approach runs counter to basic Buddhist teachings about the real sources of delusion and suffering. Finally, I will posit that turning our efforts towards a better world would actually be strengthened by not getting caught up in notions of essential principles and ideal societies.
1. Don’t Believe Economists
What I was taught, in college and grad school in economics, was consistent with how “new economy” thinkers characterize the “old economy.” That is, I was taught that people in our current economy are driven by self-interest. Firms are 2 entities whose essence is to maximize profits. Individuals maximize satisfaction from consumption. Markets are arms-length and impersonal “mechanisms.”
But perhaps what drew me further into the study of economics was the same thing that later drew me to Zen: A tendency to entertain doubt, and try to look afresh at the world with a “don’t know mind.” And so I became curious about how economists figured out that self-interest, competition profit-maximization and so on were the fundamental laws and principles underlying economic activity. Economists don’t generally like to talk about where our assumptions come from. So my explorations took me into many areas, from the history of economic thought to the history and philosophy of science to contemporary corporate law. And what I discovered is that economists made this stuff up. Really.
Economists, for example, invented the belief that corporations maximize profits. The common belief that profit-maximization is mandated by law is simply factually erroneous. Really. Nor do shareholders regularly force corporate executives to act in their interests, by bringing lawsuits against them, as is sometimes asserted. Nor, in many cases, does intense market competition, in goods markets or capital markets, force companies to pursue every last dollar of profits. Large parts of the economy are dominated by relatively few firms. The idea that firms are always running after the last dollar of profits was also not derived from observation of actual businesses. Some corporations are more oriented towards innovation, or expansion, or maximizing CEO compensation. Others focus on preserving a tradition, serving a community, or providing a beneficial, quality product. Still others are rather a mess and don’t seem to effectively pursue any goal at all (Nelson, 2011, Nelson, 2018).
And let me mention a few additional mythical creations. A “free market” has never existed, and could never exist. Markets are totally entwined with government and other forms of social regulation. “Imperatives to grow” are also largely a fiction, whether we are talking about individual firms or larger economies. The degree of “consumerist” values displayed in capitalist societies is not something inherent, but rather is historically and culturally variable. Cooperation and trust, not just “selfinterest and competition,” are rife in, and essential to, our economic system. If you 3 can’t cooperate with your suppliers or coworkers, how could you ever create anything? Unethical cooperation is, alas, also a feature of economic life. Failure to study the high levels of pernicious cooperation between, for example, financial institutions and financial regulators is a sign that we economists have blinded ourselves, not that we are “rigorous” and “scientific” (Nelson, 1996, Nelson, 2018).
Do why did economists invent these so-called “principles”? Economists have long wanted to be more like high-status physicists, than like lower-status sociologists. The dogma of “profit maximization” allows us to analyze “the firm” as though it were an autonomous entity that finds the highest point on its mathematical profit function. This is much easier than dealing with corporations as complex social organizations involving many different people working together and interacting with political, social, and physical environments. Growth models, standard utility functions, and ideas of arms-length competition similarly simplify the world to an unrecognizable abstraction, all for the sake of mathematical tractability.
These fanciful theories have had such staying power, I believe, for at least two reasons. One is political, in that they provide an intellectual cover story that greedy people can use to excuse their greed, saying this is “just the way the system works.” But there’s another reason—a gendered reason—as well. What economists chose to notice in economic activity were elements of competition, self-interest, autonomy, rationality, precision, and mechanism. What was ignored? All the equally present elements of cooperation, other-interest, connection, emotion, complexity, and sociality. Notice that that the former have an aura of masculinity and toughness about them, while the latter seem more soft, more feminine. In a sexist culture, they are easily dismissed as of lesser importance (Nelson, 1992).
So, to recap my first point, I think the “new economy” approach, that prescribes replacing the current economy (characterized by bad principles) by a new economy (characterized by good principles), has gotten its facts wrong. It has made a category error, or fallen into the “fallacy of misplaced concreteness,” taking abstract ideas invented by economists and confusing them with how the world actually works. Furthermore, repetition of these myths tends to turn these beliefs 4 into a self-fulfilling prophecy. When Buddhist social activists claim that greedy, opportunistic behavior is the norm in capitalist systems, they actually reinforce those values. Such a fatalistic belief in “essences” tells us that we can’t do anything much that is good in the system we’re in, here and now.
2. Buddhism Isn’t Just About Giving Up Greed for Material Goods
Certainly, looking into how greed for material riches actually fails to give us true satisfaction is one important aspect of Buddhist practice. But this barely scratches the surface of Buddhist teachings. We can also suffer from the other two “poisons,” that is, anger and ignorance--or, as some translations have put the latter, “delusive certainty.” In addition, Buddhist philosophy presents a deeply relational understanding of how our universe works, that upends our usual preconceptions. It talks about existence having “three marks.” These are anatta, the fact that all phenomena lack any essential nature; dukkha, ever-present suffering; and anicca, the inescapability of impermanence and change.
I’m afraid I see contradictions all over the place between the “new economy” approach and these basic teachings. The belief that capitalism has an “essential nature” denies anatta, the fact that nothing has an essential nature, and the belief itself is a form of delusive certainty. The lust after a totally different form of economy and society is a form of greed: Fundamentally, greed or grasping is telling the universe, “You can’t be as you are; you have to be the way I want you to be.” (Forgoing this view does not, however, mean just turning a blind eye to suffering, as I will explain below.) Envisioning a more perfect, just, infinitely peaceful and infinitely sustainable society--a society that has a good “essential nature”-- denies all three of anatta, dukka, and anicaa (Nelson, 2016).
And, try as we might to resist it, the “new economy” model tempts us towards the poison of anger, and the deep delusion of “us versus them” thinking. It’s all too easy to see ExxonMobil as motivated by greed, and our own anger as righteous. If we tend to see the people “inside the system”—and especially “corporate elites”—as no more than weak, deluded, role-playing robots, we deny them their humanity. And if we think that “they” are uniquely motivated by greed, and we are not, we deny our own humanity. Greed for money is only greed’s least subtle form.
Buddhist teaching tells us that suffering and impermanence are fundamental marks of existence. Recognizing these marks doesn’t at all mean that we sit on our hands and don’t do anything. But I think we want to look twice at a plan that is built around imagining an existence without them.
3. Do Use Buddhist Insights to Work for a Better World
So, while our hearts yearn to make things better, I think we need to be very careful about how we go about acting on this, and keep our actions well-informed by Buddhist insights. I’m afraid that keeping our eyes on that imagined “new economy,” created by “us, the good folks,” can cause us to overlook what we can do, and urgently need to do, here and now.
Releasing the beliefs about the “essence” of capitalism allows us to recognize that the economy that we are in is emergent and ever-changing—just like everything else. We can realize that there are and have been, in fact, many different capitalisms, across space and time. While we may, quite rightly, engage in boycotts and movements for legislation to shape the behavior of corporations, we can also recognize that when change happens it is likely because we’ve had allies on the inside of those corporations all along.
I believe we also need to let go of any naïve faith that some other institution, structure, or system will be inherently free of greed. No human organization— business, government, non-profit, local enterprise, community, family, or, alas, even a Buddhist sangha—has an essential “nature” that makes it automatically serve good ends. The current US federal government is more involved in plundering the public than serving it. You like nonprofits? The National Rifle Association is one. The new media every day carry stories of domestic violence. Sanghas are far from immune to scandals over money and sex. The three poisons are everywhere.
Yet while we do not need to swap our “old economy,” wholesale, for a diametrically opposed “new economy,” this doesn’t mean that we don’t need “systemic” and “structural” changes. These are badly needed at a number of 6 different levels. Within nations, communities, businesses, and other organization are systems and structures that shape the flows of information, the values, the decisions, and the patterns of activity. As individuals, we need to act from where we are to help shape the specific institutions that we can influence. With our dedicated work, we might make progress in the direction of justice and sustainability.
Conclusion
Economies, markets, and corporations, like human individuals, or like any other institutions, have no essential nature. They arise contingently, historically, and in deep interdependence. I believe that this recognition opens many possibilities for wise, compassionate, pragmatic, and deeply engaged action, in the messy and painful world here-and-now.
Turn—Money Good—2AC
Money does buy happiness—its scientifically proven and our perception is the only thing that actually does that—alleviating poverty is proven to have the highest increase in happiness
Suliman 23, Adela Suliman is a breaking-news reporter in The Washington Post's London hub, covering news as it unfolds in the United States and around the globe during overnight and early morning hours in Washington. Previously, she has worked for NBC News, Al Jazeera English, Reuters and the Thomson Reuters Foundation and The Associated Press. She is a graduate of the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS), University of London, with a degree in Law, and Columbia’s Graduate School of Journalism. “Can money buy happiness? Scientists say it can.”, Washington Post, March 8, 2023, https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2023/03/08/money-wealth-happiness-study/ ,$$G
It’s a question that philosophers, economists and social scientists have grappled with for decades: Can money buy happiness?
For most people in the United States, the answer is, seemingly, yes.
Two prominent researchers, Daniel Kahneman and Matthew Killingsworth, came to this conclusion in a joint study published this month in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, overturning the dominant thinking that people are generally happier as they earn more, with their joy leveling out when their income hits $75,000.
This threshold was initially posited by Kahneman, a Nobel Prize-winning economist and psychologist, in a 2010 study that concluded that “emotional well-being [also] rises with log income, but there is no further progress beyond an annual income of $75,000.”
But in 2021, Killingsworth, a happiness researcher and senior fellow at the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School, found that happiness does not plateau after $75,000, and that “experienced well-being” can continue to rise with income well beyond $200,000.
Kahneman and Killingsworth said their latest study was an “adversarial collaboration” where they pitted their theories against each other with the help of an arbiter. The latest research adjusted for inflation, they said.
In their study, Kahneman and Killingsworth surveyed 33,391 adults aged between 18 and 65 who live in the United States, are employed and report a household income of least $10,000 a year. The authors said they lacked substantial data for those earning over $500,000.
To measure their happiness, participants were asked to report on their feelings at random intervals in the day via a smartphone app developed by Killingsworth called Track Your Happiness. Killingsworth said in an email that the data came from “repeatedly pinging people at randomly-timed moments during daily life, and asking about their happiness at that moment in real-time.” Specifically, they were asked “How do you feel right now?” on a scale ranging from “very bad” to “very good,” he said.
The study reached two big conclusions: First, that “happiness continues to rise with income even in the high range of incomes” for the majority of people, showing that for many of us, on average having more money can make us increasingly happier.
But the study also found that there was an “unhappy minority,” about 20 percent of participants, “whose unhappiness diminishes with rising income up to a threshold, then shows no further progress.”
These people tend to experience negative “miseries” that typically cannot be alleviated by earning more money; the report cites examples such as heartbreak, bereavement or clinical depression. For them, their “suffering” may diminish as their income rises to about $100,000 but “very little beyond that,” the study said.
“In the simplest terms, this suggests that for most people larger incomes are associated with greater happiness,” Killingsworth said in a statement about the study.
“The exception is people who are financially well-off but unhappy. For instance, if you’re rich and miserable, more money won’t help. For everyone else, more money was associated with higher happiness to somewhat varying degrees.”
(Image Omitted)
The study acknowledges that happiness or emotional well-being is a changing daily scale for many people and that “happy people are not all equally happy” but argues that there are “degrees of happiness” and often a “ceiling” for happiness.
The study also found that money can affect happiness differently, depending on income. Among lower earners, “unhappy people gain more from increased income than happier people do,” it said. “In other words, the bottom of the happiness distribution rises much faster than the top in that range of incomes.”
In his statement, Killingsowrth made clear that money isn’t everything — “just one of the many determinants of happiness.” He added: “Money is not the secret to happiness, but it can probably help a bit.”
The study also made its way to social media Wednesday, with one Twitter user joking: “Anyone who says money doesn’t buy happiness just doesn’t know where to go for shopping.”
Another teased: “Money won’t make you happy, but it’s nicer to cry in a Ferrari.”
Turn—Non-Violence—2AC
Violence is subject to change which means a definition or path of action of non-violence is impossible
Peter Gelderloos 15, Peter Gelderloos is an American anarchist activist and writer. “The Failure of Nonviolence” Chapter 1 https://web.stanford.edu/group/peacejustice/Gelderloos-Failure-of-Nonviolence.pdf Stanford LPlot
Perhaps the most important argument against nonviolence is that violence as a concept is ambiguous to the point of being incoherent. It is a concept that is prone to manipulation, and its definition is in the hands of the media and the government, so that those who base their struggle on trying to avoid it will forever be taking cues and following the lead of those in power.
Put simply, violence does not exist. It is not a thing. It is a category, a human construct in which we choose to place a wide array of actions, phenomena, situations, and so forth. “Violence” is whatever the person speaking at the moment decides to describe as violent. Usually, this means things they do not like. As a result, the use of the category “violence” tends towards hypocrisy. If it is done to me, it is violent. If it is done by me or for my benefit, it is justified, acceptable, or even invisible.
In the last ten years, I have organized o

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.