Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 Michigan Counterplan

CP - Advantage CPs - Michigan Classic 2023 CGO

CP - Advantage CPs - Michigan Classic 2023 CGO.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
Acknowledgements
Thank you to Annabelle Durbin, Anjana Murthy, Aralyn Connolly, Caroline Garland, Danica Diva, Jensen Stanzi, Marianne Griffith, Nikoo Tahmasebi, Payten LaPoint, Saad Khan, and Sophia Kaye for their work on this file.
Adv CPs
Agriculture
1NC --- Agriculture --- Vertical Farming CP
The United States federal government should subsidize and accelerate the adoption of Aeegrivoltaics Practices and Vertical Farming.
Vertical Farming provides long term resilience for the ag sector.
Sai Sproothi Swamy 23. Staff Editor for the Vermont Journal of Law and is an IEE Research associate in environmental and business studies with a degree from the University of Waterloo. “How Can Vertical Farming Solve the Issue of Global Population Increase and Food Scarcity?” Vermont Journal of Environmental Law , https://vjel.vermontlaw.edu/how-can-vertical-farming-solve-the-issue-of-global-population-increase-and-food-scarcity#:~:text=According%20to%20the%20United%20Nations,places%20pressure%20on%20agricultural%20land., May 2, 2023,. //KOO
According to the United Nations, the human population will reach 8.5 billion by 2030 and 9.7 billion by 2050. Most of the population increase will occur in developing countries. The drastic increase in population threatens global food security and places pressure on agricultural land. The United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization (UNFAO) estimates that food production must increase by 70 percent before 2050. The increase in food production will lead to resource scarcity and volatility. Conventional agriculture requires the consumption of 70 percent global water supply, and half of the world’s population will experience water scarcity by 2030. Current agriculture practices result in 40 percent of crops wasted, which signals that they are unsustainable to meet food demands for the expected population growth in 2030 and 2050. Furthermore, agricultural production has also been impacted by the drastic natural disasters from climate change, which has made agriculture production unreliable, volatile, and vulnerable to crop pests.
Vertical farming is one solution to food scarcity and prevents the volatility in agricultural production caused by climate change. Vertical farming is an agricultural practice that involves producing large quantities of crops in multistory buildings using controlled environmental conditions and nutrients to allow for fast crop growth and planned production. Vertical farming has become popular in recent years. Many countries, such as the United States, Japan, China, Netherlands, Dubai, United Kingdom, and France, have implemented successful vertical farm systems
Vertical farming has proven to be advantageous. One advantage is that vertical farming systems can operate in cities, allowing for local crop growth. Growing crops locally reduces waste and the energy used to produce and provide food to consumers. In addition, vertically stacked farms are more sustainable, requiring less land and water when compared to conventional farming. For example, vertical farms can yield 10 to 20 times more per acre when compared to conventional farming. Further, vertical farming increases efficiency since it allows crop production year-round. While seasonal changes and geographical locations limit when conventional farmers can grow crops, vertical farming has no such limitations. Growing crops in an indoor, controlled environment also eliminates the need for toxic pesticides or weather resilience, increasing the production of organic produce. Ultimately, vertical farming systems can replace and reduce the risks associated with conventional farming. For example, risks that crops produced by conventional farming are an increase in pests, the spread of diseases, and contamination.
While vertical farming has its advantages, there are also disadvantages. A disadvantage of vertical farming is the cost of construction, specifically the energy and heating costs associated with operating the farm itself. Crop growth in a vertical farming system requires artificial light sources, thus requiring a lot of energy which becomes costly. Along with artificial lighting, vertical farms also require proper ventilation, heating, and air conditioning systems to control humidity which are all expensive. In addition, vertical farming requires dependency on technology, which increases cost and the risk of spoilage from power outages in places like California.
However, ensuring backup generators are available in case a power outage occurs can mitigate this issue. While both vertical and conventional farms are no match for natural disasters like earthquakes, conventional farmers are more vulnerable to natural disasters. This is because natural disasters result in the loss of harvest or livestock and the destruction of agricultural infrastructure and irrigation systems. In comparison, crops and the infrastructure required to produce crops in vertical farms have a layer of foundation that protects them from natural disasters or any outside factor. Furthermore, vertical farming could lead to conventional farmers losing their jobs along the process.
While vertical farming has advantages and disadvantages, it is a promising solution to addressing the drastic increase in global population. Before expanding the use of vertical farming, further research or technological advancement is required to help reduce the high operating costs associated with vertical farming.
Agrivoltaics solves for energy efficiency
Chris Malloy 21, Malloy is a writer from the Northeast now based in the Southwest. For stories, he has gone foraging in the southern Rockies and Sonoran Desert, trailed a quest to brew ale overnight in a forest, roamed a feral mountain orchard with cider-making scientists, and gone hunting with Apaches. He covers mostly food, culture, agriculture, the environment, and innovation. “Why combining farms and solar panels could transform how we produce both food and energy”, The Counter, 3-30-21, https://thecounter.org/agrivoltaics-farmland-solar-panels-clean-energy-crops/.//KOO
Agrivoltaics help to solve that spatial dilemma. They allow a given area to harvest the sun not only once, but twice — as fuel for crops and as a source of renewable energy. But space-saving isn’t all that has sparked the interest of researchers and advocates across the world, from the U.S. to Western Europe and Japan. Another kind of symbiosis can occur, with surprising benefits we are only just beginning to understand—an untapped synergy that may have the potential to transform the way we produce both food and energy.
For Barron-Gafford, the idea emerged organically from a challenge in his work. In 2012, he was looking for ways to quantify the temperature of large solar arrays, trying to determine how they might contribute to an urban heat island effect, or the phenomenon of cities being warmer than the surrounding countryside. He noticed that heat collected beneath the solar array, making the panels less efficient. Maybe, he thought, growing plants under the panels would cool them. Plants, after all, “exhale” water through a process called transpiration, losing water through their pores as they intake carbon dioxide for photosynthesis.
Indeed, Barron-Gafford’s agrivoltaic garden proved to produce a cooler microclimate under panels than conventional solar farms, something other studies have echoed with findings from their own plots. Intrigued, he went on to research the phenomenon in more detail. In his 2019 study of jalapenos, cherry tomatoes, and chiltepines (a desert chile native to the U.S.), Barron-Gafford found that agrivoltaic panels produced 3 percent more energy during the May-through-June growing season and 1 percent more overall.
But the benefits weren’t only on the energy-efficiency side. His simple system—just solar panels lofted above plants—also helped the crops, which needed far less water to grow. This was due to cool shade under the solar panels. “If you spilled your water bottle in the shade versus out in the sun, where’s it going to stay wet longer? In the shade,” he said. “So we’re just using these oh duh principles to try to make a more sustainable food system.”
But the shade also conferred another significant benefit, one that may prove tantalizing for farmers focused on yield: It caused Barron-Gafford’s plants to grow differently.
Some plants thrive in partial sun, especially in semiarid regions where farms may be growing non-native crops unadapted to water scarcity, like the Southwest. That makes solar panels an ideal growing partner. The shade they provide keeps moisture in the ground longer, which keeps plants from stressing out, Barron-Gafford explained; instead of burning through their energy reserves early, crops can keep photosynthesizing at a more even, measured rate throughout the day.
In some species, that leads to markedly increased production, Barron-Gafford found: The presence of plants ups solar energy production, and solar panels returned the favor for two of the three plants he studied. Tomato production doubled, with 65 percent more water efficiency. Chiltepin production tripled. Jalapeno production was static, yet with water efficiency 157 percent greater — a win in a region embroiled in historic drought.
While those numbers represent astonishing productivity gains, similar results may not be possible in every region or with every crop, said Jordan Macknick, lead energy-water-land analyst for NREL. Macknick has studied agrivoltaics with NREL since 2010, working to understand “what grows under solar panels where and why.” Today, he analyzes data from 25 sites, including the plot at Biosphere 2, together forming “a network of projects that are designed to explore the tradeoff between solar energy development and agriculture.”
It’s clear that what works in Arizona might not work in the Pacific Northwest, and what works in New England might not work in the South. “One of the challenges is many things in agrivoltaics are very site specific,” Macknick said. “You have to try very hard to be able to extrapolate results from one region to another region.” His research partners take a consistent approach to enable comparison.
“You have to try very hard to be able to extrapolate results from one region to another region.”
Agrivoltaics projects across the world already demonstrate some of this inherent variability. In Minnesota, solar panels shading the cattle of a rotational grazing pasture have successfully lowered animal heat stress while powering a milking parlor. In Belgium, an agrivoltaic potato field showed cooler microclimates below panels and less evaporation, as well as larger leaves with “adapted light harvesting capability.” But in other locations, the results are more mixed. In Massachusetts, numerous cranberry bog farmers have adopted agrivoltaics, hoping that solar energy will provide an additional source of revenue and offset plummeting prices—though some worry that the crop won’t respond as well to shade, the Associate Press reports. In Italy, spinach yields decreased in one study. Still, its researchers observed more efficient photosynthesis and greater protein production. They calculated that the financial value of the agrivoltaic spinach remained greater, given the solar energy production.
Generally, research suggests that agrivoltaics might benefit, at the very least, a small fraction of global farmland. But agrivoltaics won’t need to work everywhere to become a transformative idea. Writing in the journal Scientific Reports, scientists from Oregon State University found that if a mere 1 percent of global cropland gained solar panels, “global energy demand would be offset by solar production.”
Think about that for a second: turning just 1 percent of cropland agrivoltaic—a method that can also increase harvests in many environments—could more than satisfy the world’s energy demand, generating BTUs by the hundred quadrillion.
2NC --- Agriculture --- Vertical Farming CP
Empirically proven to have a higher yield using less land and resources.
Emiliano Bellini 23, Emiliano joined pv magazine in March 2017. He has been reporting on solar and renewable energy since 2009. Emiliano is responsible for the daily news coverage on pv-magazine.com with a particular focus on European market. Emiliano also covers new technology, R&D, installations and company financial reporting. In its previous experience as a journalist, Emiliano has written about EdTech and new language technologies. “Agrivoltaics for vertical farming”, June 8th, 2023, PV Magazine, https://www.pv-magazine.com/2023/06/08/agrivoltaics-for-vertical-farming/#:~:text=An%20Italian%20research%20group%20has,use%20while%20increasing%20agricultural%20yield.//KOO
Scientists at the Polytechnic University of Marche in Italy have proposed to combine vertical farming with solar power generation from PV greenhouses in an effort to increase land utilization.
They defined solar greenhouses as “closed agrivoltaics (CA),” which would be a form of agrivoltaic project in which power generation and food production are implemented in a protected environment.
“All common horticultural crops grow with none or limited yield losses when the percentage of the projection of the PV panels on the roof to the greenhouse area (PV cover ratio) is under 20%,” the researchers specified. “We propose an alternative approach to increase the agricultural sustainability of the CA with the experimental integration of the vertical farm (VF) technology, characterized by yields, light and resource use efficiency consistently higher than conventional greenhouses.”
They also emphasized that vertical farming utilizes use light-emitting diodes (LED) to achieve high photosynthetic use efficiency and year-round production in the plants, noting that PV is a perfect solution to reduce the impact of the LEDs' high energy consumption on project viability.
The Italian group sought to assess, in particular, the land productivity, the PV area, and the electricity required by an experimental VFCA system with a cover ratio of 100%. “The yield was quantified on green and red baby-leaf lettuce varieties, adopting four lighting treatments, expressed as Daily Light Integral (DLI) and compared to a control CA,” it explained.
They tested this approach on an experimental 40.48 kW VFCA located in the municipality of Villaperuccio, Sardinia, Italy. The system is operating since 2012 and is selling power to the grid at a feed-in tariff of €0.39 ($0.41) kWh. The shelves used for vertical farming each have a height of 40 cm and eight LED dimmable lamps that each have a nominal power of 22 W.
Popular content
The greenhouse hosts four varieties of baby-leaf lettuce grown under four different lighting treatments.
Through their analysis, the academics found that the VFCA system is able to provide a 13% higher agricultural yield compared to a conventional CA system, with CO2 emissions dropping by over 12%.
pv magazine print edition
In the June issue of pv magazine, due out tomorrow, we turn the spotlight onto European solar with a comprehensive review of the state of the PV industry across the region’s key markets and a look at the legislation which aims to drive a solar rooftop boom. We also examine the difficulty of establishing a solar panel recycling industry in Australia, where industry backbiting isn’t helping matters.
“The case study quantified the high land consumption of this reconversion, with a CA area from 5.4 to 13.9 times higher than the VF area to achieve the energy self-sufficiency and avoid the related CO2 emissions, meaning that only 7–18% of the CA area can be reconverted to vertical farming,” they highlighted.
Their findings were presented in the study “Increasing the agricultural sustainability of closed agrivoltaic systems with the integration of vertical farming: A case study on baby-leaf lettuce,” published in Applied Energy. “This study contributed to identify the main design features to reconvert the existing and underutilized CAs into sustainable and efficient mixed agrosystems,” the researchers concluded.
AI
1NC --- AI --- UN CP
The United States federal government should:
---develop a treaty with the United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization that ensures humanist global regulations on artificial intelligence.
Collaborating with the UN solves---international regulation is key.
Timofey Dovbush 22 et al. (Timofey N. Dovbush---St. Petersburg Institute of ARSUJ, RLA of Ministry of Justice of the Russian Federation, St. Petersburg, Russian Federation, 2022, accessed 7/19/2023, Challenges and Solutions in the Digital Economy and Finance, “International Legal and Economic Aspects of Regulation of Digital Technologies and Artificial Intelligence.” https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-14410-3_4)SAADK
Despite the problems discussed above, the countries of the European Union are trying to approve provisions on liability for harm caused by artificial intelligence at the level of national legislation.
For example, Article 7 of the German Road Traffic Act (StVG) provides for the liability of the owner of a motor vehicle even if the vehicle is equipped with artificial intelligence systems (Bundesamt für Justiz, 2021).
Thus, when a traffic accident occurs without the fault of the driver due to the shortcomings of the artificial vehicle control system, the owner of the vehicle remains directly responsible for the requirements of the victims.
There is a similar legal norm in France in Decree No. 2018–211 of March 28, 2018, on experiments with automated vehicles on public roads. We believe that the artificial intelligence regulation at the level of regional state associations is unproductive since it is necessary to develop and implement global standards.
Realizing the importance of developing common approaches in this area, the Second Conference on Artificial Intelligence was held in September 2021 with the participation of representatives of the OECD, the World Bank, and a number of other international organizations. During this event the need for comprehensive regulation of artificial intelligence at the global level was stated (Globalpolicy, 2021).
As part of meeting the need for global regulation of artificial intelligence, under the UNESCO auspices recommendations on the problems of artificial intelligence that should become one of the first international legal documents on the ethical aspects of artificial intelligence are being developed.
UNESCO notes that in the field of artificial intelligence it is necessary to focus on building a “knowledge society” and achieving sustainable development goals (SDGs) (UNESCO, 2019).
Moreover, UNESCO recommends approaching artificial intelligence in terms of ensuring human rights, openness, accessibility, participation of all interested groups (UNESCO, 2019). In addition to these principles, UNESCO notes the need to develop ethical principles, as well as the need to respect gender and social minorities equality, to pay special attention to overcoming the “digital divide”, especially in relation to African countries.
The great importance attached by UNESCO to the issues of artificial intelligence can be seen from the activities that have been carried out on this issue:
the UNESCO global conference “Principles of Artificial Intelligence: Towards a Humanistic Approach” in March 2019 that states that artificial intelligence systems should not replace human intelligence.
the UNESCO International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Education in Beijing (UNESCO, 2019) that published the final Beijing Consensus (UNESCO, 2019).
XV World Conference on Intellectual Capital “Artificial intelligence and the next generation of competences: how digital and artificial intelligence will impact jobs and competences profiles?”
By the end of 2021, the UNESCO General Conference is expected to approve the developed and agreed ethical princ

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.