CP - Degrowth - Michigan Classic 2023 JRY
CP - Degrowth - Michigan Classic 2023 JRY.docx
Indexed text preview
Notes Thanks to all those that helped! Aditya Gandhi, Aanya Ujjval, Aaron Luo, Aiden Gao, Daisy Chen, Danya Bayer, Darius Esmailzadeh, Devdan Jeffrey, Jeffery Bao, and Nate Roshan The file is separated into three parts and primarily useful against the “degrowth federal jobs” aff. All three variations of this argument agree with the aff that economic growth is ecologically unsustainable and a transition away from growth imperatives is necessary. However, the file questions the primacy of a federal job in creating a degrowth transition. Most degrowth literature (including the aff) supports a federal job guarantee because it is a necessary safety net to counter-act the negative externalities of a planned recession. The second plank attempts to resolve this by instead instituting a universal basic income, not only reducing the necessity of work, changing worker/labor relations, and disentangling federal jobs from growth-oriented economies; but also allowing alternative means of social configurations to flourish. The first variation of the argument (titled: Reverse Econ Pic) is exactly what you would expect. Michigan put out a litany of aff/neg cards that speak to the positive economic impacts of a federal job guarantee. In a world of degrowth these “positive” cards are in fact internal net benefits to the CP because any risk of the aff increasing economic growth is a reason why degrowth without a job guarantee is preferable. Similarly, negative cards that speak to the unproductive nature of a UBI becomes net benefits to the CP. These cards can be taken from all sorts of folders so have fun! The second variation of the argument (titled: Radical Degrowth K) differentiates between a vision of degrowth tied to socialism (the aff) and expanding degrowth beyond mere economic relations. Albeit the aff will certainly try to claim that their approach is the holistic approach of the alternative, two important difference exist: UBI vs. Job Guarantee and de/alienation. Standings, and by extension Barca, criticize how degrowth movements fail to consider systematic conditions that establish one’s identity in relation to work. A job guarantee only guarantees safety so long as the worker is willing to sacrifice their labor in exchange for a paycheck. Petersen et al. believe a UBI attached to degrowth is able to reconceptualize our understanding of work, expanding beyond JG system of alienation. Independently Standings is skeptical as to how JG will become implemented in governments causes people to perform manual meaningless task to be deemed worthy enough to stay out of poverty. The third variation gives negatives the ability to go for degrowth against Green New Deal affirmatives. 1NCs 1NC -- Reverse Econ PIC Without instituting a federal job guarantee (JG), the United States Federal Government should: Implement degrowth policies including a ban on the extraction of fossil fuels, an elimination of all economic growth, increase investments in green technology, and redistribution of resources globally. Implement a universal basic income (UBI) set according to the Giacomo evidence A UBI maintains social health despite the negative externalities of degrowth policies. Alisa, Giacomo D’, et al 2014. Alisa is a ecological economist and political ecologist, Kallis is a professor of ecological economics and political ecology at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology, Autonomous University of Barcelona, and Demaria is an Associate Professor in Ecological Economics and Political Ecology at the University of Barcelona, and a senior researcher at the Institute of Environmental Science and Technology (ICTA), Autonomous University of Barcelona Degrowth a Vocabulary for a New Era. Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 2014. (AG) To eliminate poverty, capitalist societies generally rely on growing the economic pie, not slicing it differently. If the pursuit of growth were given up, however, and a degrowth process of planned economic contraction were embraced, pov-erty would have to be confronted more directly. Among other things, this would require a restructuring of the property and tax systems for the purpose of redis-tributing wealth and ensuring everyone had ‘enough’ (Alexander 2011). The Basic Income and the Maximum Income are two policies that could help achieve these important egalitarian goals, without relying on growth. Although there is considerable variety in forms of Basic Income, the core idea is relatively straightforward. In its idealised and most radical form, every person living permanently in a nation would receive from the state a periodic (e.g. fort-nightly) payment, and this payment would be sufficient for an individual to live at a minimal though dignified standard of economic security. Advocates typically argue that a Basic Income payment should be guaranteed by the state, unconditional on the performance of any labour, and universal. Within a fully developed Basic Income system, some advocates argue that other state transfers could be abolished – such as unemployment benefits, family allow-ances, pensions, etc. – since the Basic Income grant would be sufficient to provide everyone with a decent, though minimal, subsistence. Existing ‘social welfare’ has proven unable to eliminate poverty, even in the richest nations, so the powerful moral attraction of a Basic Income lies in how directly it confronts poverty. It is a policy based on the idea that the distribution of an economy’s wealth must begin by ensuring that everyone has ‘enough’ to live with dignity. The Basic Income could also include non-monetary benefits, such as free health care, or direct provi-sion of food, clothes, and accommodation to those in need. The feasibility of a Basic Income System is typically questioned on two main grounds (Fitzpatrick 1999). The first objection is that making the Basic Income unconditional on the performance of any labour would give rise to a society of ‘free-loaders’ and ultimately lead to economic collapse. This objection, however, arises out of a debatable conception of human beings. While it may be the case that the ‘free-loader’ problem would exist to some extent, a case can be made that human beings, by and large, are social creatures, who find being engaged in their community’s work more meaningful and fulfilling than being isolated, idle, and parasitic on their community. Furthermore, even if there were a minority that chose not to contribute productively in any way, this could well be a tolerable social burden – more tolerable, one might argue, than the levels of poverty that exist today. Alternatively, the Basic Income could mandate some form of social contribution, even if that contribution were outside the ‘formal economy’. The second objection typically levelled at the Basic Income concerns its finan-cial feasibility, a pragmatic issue that is obviously of great importance. However, this is arguably more a matter of political commitment than a financing challenge, especially since the state has the power to issue money for worthwhile or neces-sary purposes. To ease the burden on the public purse and soften the transition, one policy option is to begin the Basic Income payments at some very low level and increase them gradually over time to a level of dignified subsistence. Another option would be to establish a Negative Income Tax system, which differs from a Basic Income in that it provides a tax-credit to people, not universally, but only to those with incomes below the subsistence level. This would provide low-income earners with a guaranteed minimum income but via an alternative route. Over time, the Negative Income Tax system could evolve into a Basic Income system. The social benefits of a successful Basic Income system would be profound and far-reaching. Beyond eliminating poverty and economic insecurity, its institution would also strengthen the bargaining position of employees, since it would give people a property right that was independent of their paid employment, and thus more power to demand decent working conditions. It would also mean that peo-ple did not have to accept alienating, exploitative, or degrading jobs just to survive; nor would there be any real pressure to sacrifice social and political autonomy in order to achieve economic security. Furthermore, a Basic Income would also effectively acknowledge the worth of unpaid work and other forms of social con-tribution, thereby extending economic citizenship beyond participants in the tra-ditional labour market or ‘formal economy’ (see care, the New Economy).For these reasons, among others, a Basic Income would produce far more democratic and egalitarian societies than any capitalist society ever could, which is why it receives support from many advocates of degrowth. As well as a Basic Income – or income ‘floor’ – some degrowth advocates also insist that there should be an income ‘ceiling’ – that is, an upper limit to the size of any individual’s income. This is sometimes called a ‘maximum income,’ and like the Basic Income it could be achieved in various ways. For example, a tax rate could increase progressively as the taxable income increases, culminating in a 100 per cent tax on all income over a specified level. This would avoid the creation of a stratified society of Basic Income recipients, on the one hand, and super-rich, on the other. Such a policy also finds support in the voluminous evidence showing that great inequalities of wealth are socially corrosive and that more equal societies do better on a whole host of social and economic indicators (Pickett and Wilkinson 2010). The ‘maximum income’ idea finds further justifica-tion in the sociological research indicating that once basic material needs are met, further increases in income contribute little if anything to subjective wellbeing or happiness (Alexander 2012). What this research suggests is that high incomes are essentially wasted so far as wellbeing is concerned, making a maximum income an extremely important means of avoiding wasteful consumption and creating more egalitarian societies. The tax procured from the maximum income could be used to fund a basic income. The FJG would increase economic growth by wage increases, productivity imperatives, and competition with the private market. Paul et al 17, Mark Paul is an assistant professor of economics at New College of Florida and a fellow at the Roosevelt Institute, William Darity Jr is the Samuel DuBois Cook professor of public policy, African and African-American Studies, and economics; and the director of the Samuel DuBois Cook Center on Social Equity at Duke University, Darrick Hamilton is associate professor of economics and urban policy at the Milano School of International Affairs, Management and Urban Policy and the Department of Economics, New School for Social Research., 2-4-2017, "Why We Need a Federal Job Guarantee," Jacobin, https://jacobin.com/2017/02/federal-job-guarantee-universal-basic-income-investment-jobs-unemployment/ (AG) Conventional wisdom holds that people dislike work. Introductory economics classes will explain the disutility of labor, which is a direct trade-off with leisure. Granted, employment isn’t always fun, and many forms of employment are dangerous and exploitative. But the UBI misses the way in which employment structurally empowers workers at the point of production and has by its own merits positive dimensions. This touches on a heated debate on the Left. But for now, there is no doubt that people want jobs, but they want good jobs that provide flexibility and opportunity. They want to contribute, to have a purpose, to participate in the economy and, most importantly, in society. Nevertheless, the private sector continues to leave millions without work, even during supposed “strong” economic times. The workplace is social, a place where we spend a great deal of our time interacting with others. In addition to the stress associated with limited resources, the loneliness that plagues many unemployed workers can exacerbate mental health problems. Employment — especially employment that provides added social benefits like communal coffee breaks — adds to workers’ well-being and productivity. A federal job guarantee can provide workers with socially beneficial employment — providing the dignity of a job to all that seek it. The FJG would also act as a de facto wage floor — private employers will have to offer wages and benefits at least as enticing as the federal government to attract workers. There has been extensive public support for recent increases in the minimum wage, such as the Fight for $15 campaign, demonstrating that most Americans believe workers deserve a living wage. Fighting for a higher minimum wage is an important step to ensure that workers are compensated a living wage rather than a poverty wage, yet let us not forget that the effective minimum wage in this country without a UBI or a job guarantee is $0. This must change. Finally, some argue that a “skills mismatch” explains why some workers remain unemployed. While we reject that narrative, a well-designed FJG will nevertheless include a training element to build workers’ skills and a jobs ladder to create upward mobility in the workplace. All of these elements will build an inclusive economy that provides good jobs for all. The UBI, in contrast, could subsidize bad jobs — allowing low minimum wages and lack of benefits to persist. 4. Federal jobs could provide socially useful goods and services. During the Great Depression, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) and Civilian Conservation Corps (CCC) were public employment programs designed to put Americans back to work after the national unemployment rate reached 25 percent. These programs, implemented under the Roosevelt administration, provided socially beneficial goods and services that benefited all Americans. Some of our national parks — Zion, Glacier, and Shenandoah — received substantial work contributions from employees of the federal jobs programs. The Blue Ridge Parkway was a federally funded and staffed infrastructure program. A new federal job guarantee could undertake similarly bold and much-needed public-works projects. The American Society of Civil Engineers gave the United States a D+ in infrastructure and prices necessary repairs at $3.6 trillion. This lack of investment has lowered employment rates, cost businesses sales, and reduced incomes for American families. Make no mistake, these are government choices. They could choose instead to hire unemployed workers to repair bridges, maintain roadways, and update power grids. Likewise, Bill McKibben just called for us to “declare war” against climate change. With climate change being perhaps the largest threat to our well-being, bold action is needed. The job guarantee program would create the capacity to do just that. Professor Robert Pollin of the Political Economy Research Institute calls for scaling up the transition to a green economy, which would create millions of new jobs along the way. He and his colleagues estimate what a Green New Deal would look like, and find that a transition to a green economy would amount to an estimated $200 billion in investment annually, resulting in a drop in “US emission by 40 percent within 20 years, while creating a net increase of 2.7 million jobs.” In part, this is due to the labor-intensive nature of energy efficiency and other “green” investments. Additional services, when combined with a FJG, would save average American households thousands, if not tens of thousands, a year. According to the Economic Policy Institute, for example, tuition-free and universal child care and education — staffed by FJG workers — would trim an average of $22,631 annually from families’ budgets in expensive places such as DC while saving households in places like Arkansas a more modest $5,995 on average. To be sure, a UBI would free up time to volunteer, to care for sick relatives, or to start small businesses. Additionally, the UBI would finally provide greater financial freedom to those that choose to stay at home and engage in care work — disproportionately provided by women. However, the FJG has the ability to provide high quality services, such as child care and elder care, that would greatly reduce the care burden, providing more choice while building on the current social safety net. 5. It’ll stabilize the economy. A FJG would bring us much closer to actual full employment, not the neoclassical full employment that subjectively allows for some optimal frictional unemployment. Most contemporary economists rely on the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) to calculate this less-than-full full employment artificial statistic which functions as a disciplinary tool of the bourgeoisie, but this, according to Roger Farmer is “an idea past its sell-by date.” By full employment, we mean simply that everyone seeking a job gets one. We’d wager that if you asked the average American what full employment means to them, they’d give you a similar answer — a job for all. Indeed, a plurality of Americans will also tell you they support a FJG. The UBI would likely still leave a substantial segment of the population in poverty. As Belgian philosopher Philippe Van Parijs, one of the most prominent UBI advocates, acknowledged, even a large payment through the UBI won’t necessarily secure a comfortable living for all citizens. How about those without jobs, or those who earn below subsistence wages? Of course, a UBI coupled with a non-poverty wage option and strong unionization could seriously combat poverty. The UBI would eliminate the effective minimum wage of $0 currently offered in the United States, though it would fail to provide adequate employment for all that demanded it — a crucial shortfall of such a program. A FJG is a sounder mechanism to combat structural inequalities, for instance through closing the persistent unemployment gap experienced by stigmatized groups who face continued discrimination. (Note, since 1972 unemployment has average double digits for black workers and has never fallen below 7 percent — a level that is only reached during times of economic crisis — for white workers). Further, the FJG will have a strong macroeconomic stabilization effect. During economic downturns, it would expand and hire more people; it would then shrink during economic boom periods as people move from public to better-paying private employment. Pavlina R. Tcherneva, a leading voice on the FJG’s macroeconomic effects, argues that policies like the UBI have no counter-cyclical features. Thus, when the economy takes a downturn — say as it did in 2007 — basic incomes provide no automatic stabilizers to right the sinking ship. This is good for the economy as a whole. Rather than expanding the unemployment insurance rolls during economic busts, the FJG would put folks to work and moderate the business cycle. Federal workers’ paychecks will increase demand, which will increase economic growth. Many economists agree that today’s secular stagnation — insufficient demand — is contributing to continued “lackluster” growth after the Great Recession. Only modest upticks in growth for the foreseeable future will come if we continue the status quo. Finally, as a less costly program a FJG might be easier for a future left government to enact. Some estimate that basic income could easily cost more than $3 trillion each year, while others say it will only come to $2.7 trillion. The FJG, on the other hand, will cost orders of magnitude less. Even if we conservatively guess that fifteen million unemployed workers need jobs, funding the FJG would take about $750 billion. We want to build an inclusive economy. The FJG will build an economy that serves the working class more efficiently and effectively than the UBI. The benefits will be immediately and broadly distributed. The FJG will directly tar
Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.