Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 TDI Affirmative

Persian Gulf Aff Neg - TDI 2023

Persian Gulf Aff Neg - TDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AFF---Persian Gulf
1AC
1AC — ADV — Regional Stability
Advantage one is REGIONAL STABILITY:
The US is bolstering its military presence in the Persian Gulf.
Fossum 23 – [Sam, B.A. in journalism from Johns Hopkins. “US Bolstering Defense Posture in the Persian Gulf after Iran Seized Two Merchant Ships in Recent Weeks | CNN Politics.” CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/12/politics/us-iran-persian-gulf/index.html. May 12, 2023] TDI
“Today, the Department of Defense will be making a series of moves to bolster our defensive posture in the Arabian (Persian) Gulf. US central command will provide additional details on those reinforcements in coming days,” he continued.
The decision by the US to take further security measures in and around the strategically critical Middle East waterway comes after two internationally flagged merchant vessels were seized by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Navy in recent weeks, according to the US Navy who added that Iran has interfered with or attacked 15 internationally flagged merchant ships over the past two years.
In the coming weeks, according to Kirby, the US will also be increasing its coordination and interoperability with the International Maritime Security Construct, which is a coalition of 11 nations formed two years ago to help reassure and protect merchant shipping in the area.
The Strait of Hormuz is vital to the global economy, serving as the only way to move oil from the Persian Gulf to the world’s oceans.
The US 5th fleet will increase the rotation of ships and aircraft patrolling the Strait of Hormuz and further increase security collaboration with partners and allies, according to a US Navy statement.
“Iran’s unwarranted, irresponsible and unlawful seizure and harassment of merchant vessels must stop,” Vice Admiral Brad Cooper, who oversees US Naval forces in the region, said in the statement, adding the US is “committed to protecting navigational rights in these critical waters.”
And against the backdrop of all this, the US and Iran have repeatedly had tense interactions at sea the last several years over a fraught relationship that has only continued to deteriorate. The US has sharply condemned Iran’s crackdown on widespread protests against its governing regime and its morality police, while Iran’s Supreme Leader has blamed the US for the unrest. Washington has also criticized and sanctioned Iran for providing armed drones to Russia which Russian forces have used in Ukraine.
This isn’t the first time this year the US military has bolstered its presence in the region. Back in March, the US strengthened its military forces in the Middle East following a series of attacks on US troops in Syria attributed to Iranian-affiliated militias, according to the Pentagon.
As part of that, the US ordered a carrier strike group to remain in the region to support US forces in Central Command, which covers the Middle East, and a squadron of A-10 attack aircraft to the region.
The US also responded with precision air strikes on facilities associated with Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps.
There are roughly 900 US troops in Syria as part of the ongoing mission to defeat ISIS.
On-the-ground presence fuels regional instability, not military leadership.
Wasser 21 – [Becca, fellow in the defense program at the Center for a New American Security. “Drawing down the U.S. Military Responsibly.” Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, https://carnegieendowment.org/2021/05/18/drawing-down-u.s.-military-responsibly-pub-84527, May 18, 2021] TDI
THE CASE AGAINST U.S. BASES
From a strategic standpoint, U.S. presence in the Middle East is not directly linked to core U.S. interests. Critics argue that continued U.S. presence contributes to, if not fuels, the ongoing instability in the Middle East, often driving U.S. operations. Such arguments cite diminishing U.S. reliance on oil and gas originating in the Middle East and the emergence of regional terrorist organizations intent on attacking U.S. troops specifically to force a military withdrawal.
Operationally, continued U.S. military presence in the Middle East comes directly at the expense of U.S. forces in other, more critical regions. At the same time, critics argue that continued U.S. presence contributes to the inability or unwillingness of regional states to develop their own military capabilities. They also highlight the growing risks to U.S. forces as the capabilities of regional adversaries like Iran advance and claim that forward presence is no longer required thanks to new technological advancements in warfare.
The supporting evidence bears out these arguments. U.S. troops have been attacked by terrorist organizations, notably the Khobar Towers bombing in 1996 and the more recent rocket attacks by Iranian-backed groups in Iraq. The U.S. military presence has also added to the security of Middle Eastern autocracies, which has emboldened these authoritarian regimes to crackdown on their citizens—for example, in Bahrain after the February 14, 2011, uprisings.
The presence of U.S. forces and the unspoken U.S. security commitment has also meant that many regional countries have not invested heavily in building up their militaries. Some partners, like Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates, have used their nascent capabilities in ways that work against U.S. interests.
Furthermore, the growing capabilities of regional adversaries has placed U.S. military installations at risk. Iran, especially, poses a risk to the survivability of U.S. forces and could impede U.S. military operations, as Tehran builds up its missile capabilities, employs new technologies like unmanned aerial vehicles, and proliferates its capabilities to proxy forces. Moreover, while advancements in U.S. military capabilities enable remote operations, they are unlikely and unable to replace forward-based operations in the Middle East—either in the case of an Iran contingency or to respond to terrorist threats.
The depth and breadth of US military presence motivates Iran’s naval expansion.
Bagheri Dolatabadi & Kamrava 22 – [Ali, Department of Political Science, Yasouj University; Mehran, School of Foreign Service, Georgetown University Qatar "Iran’s changing naval strategy in the Persian Gulf: motives and features." British Journal of Middle Eastern Studies, https://doi.org/10.1080/13530194.2022.2105815, July 27, 2022] TDI
Iran’s motives for developing naval capabilities
While the Arab states of the Persian Gulf are dependent on the United States for their security needs, Iran feels a sense of security independence in its immediate region. This security independence rests on Iran’s assumption of conventional military superiority vis-à-vis Arab neighbours.6 When it comes to naval forces, Iran does indeed have by far the largest navy of all the littoral states of the Persian Gulf.7 Iranian naval force, in fact, has undergone a steady expansion in size and hardware in recent years.
This expansion, meant to augment Iran’s naval capabilities, and the evolving strategic postures that have been adopted, is the result of several considerations, the most important of which include heightened tensions—and occasional military confrontation —with the United State (including the shooting down of a US drone in 2019); assumptions about the vulnerability of the Bushehr nuclear power plant and the oil facilities located in the southern Iran; expansive US military presence in and around the Persian Gulf and the Arabian Peninsula and the strategic importance to Iran of the Strait of Hormuz and the Persian Gulf. In the mid-2010s, approximately 93% of Iranian exports and 13% of the country’s imports passed through the Strait of Hormuz.
Critically, much of Iran’s efforts at developing its naval capabilities in the Persian Gulf have been driven by the depth and breadth of the US military presence there and also by the naval strategies adopted by America’s regional allies. The history and depth of the US military presence in the Persian Gulf has been well documented.9 This presence has been significantly expanded since the early 1990s, resulting in the semi-permanent presence of US naval warships as well as permanent bases across the Persian Gulf. According to a study by the Rand Corporation, ‘Because the United States does not anticipate large-scale land-warfare with Iran, much less with China, maritime war-fighting capabilities, such as for sea-based strike, are considered key’.
This has not gone unnoticed in Tehran. Iranian military officials consider the country’s southern borders as the only area where the United States can enter and deploy troops on Iranian soil.11 This is borne out by historical experience. In World War II, Allied forces entered Iran through the country’s southern ports, and in both the First and Second Persian Gulf Wars, the US also sent troops to Iraq through the waterway. Iranian strategists were particularly alarmed when the United States not only invaded Iraq in 2003 but also proceeded to overthrow Saddam Hussein.12 They therefore believe that ‘one of the most dangerous ways to threaten the interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran is by sea’.13 This has resulted in a concerted campaign to enhance the country’s naval power and to deny potential invaders any access to Iranian territory from the sea. As one IRGCN commander put it, ‘it is our obligation to challenge American military superiority in the Persian Gulf’ in order to protect the country.14 As far back as 1985, in fact, Iran devised a comprehensive military strategy for the protection of its maritime borders in both the Caspian Sea and the Persian Gulf. As part of this strategy, the Islamic Republic of Iran Navy (IRIN) was given the responsibility for the Caspian Sea and the waters east of the Hormuz Strait, and the newly established Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps Navy (IRGCN) was placed in charge of ensuring the security of the Persian Gulf.
A strong IRGC increases maritime disputes and harassment operations along the Strait of Hormuz.
Hossein al-Shahrani 21 – [Saad, Ph.D. in economics at Washington State University, fellow professor of economics at Princess Nourah bint Abdulrahman University, and vice chairman of the board of directors of the Saudi Economic Association “IRANIAN MARITIME ORIENTATIONS: OBJECTIVES, CHALLENGES, AND SCOPE OF INFLUENCE” Journal for Iranian Studies, https://rasanah-iiis.org/english/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2022/03/IRANIAN-MARITIME-ORIENTATIONS-OBJECTIVES-CHALLENGES-AND-SCOPE-OF-INFLUENCE.pdf, October 2021] TDI
3.4 Placing Pressure on US Military Presence in the Region
Iranian boats harassing US military vessels passing through the Arabian Gulf has increased recently. Nearly 30 harassment operations were recorded against vessels passing through the Strait of Hormuz by Iranian missile boats in 2016. The harassments continued through 2017(41) as well as in 2018, 2019 and 2020. Definitely, the United States closely follows the growth of Iran’s naval capabilities. The US Office of Naval Intelligence (ONI) issued a report, forecasting that by the time the arms embargo is lifted in 2020, Iran’s naval forces will significantly boost their fleet after Tehran is allowed to purchase new naval vessels.
Iranian military leaders have continued to threaten US bases and interests in the Arabian Gulf region.(43) US reports indicated that Iran has deployed a range of anti-ship missiles in the region overlooking the Strait of Hormuz.(44) Iranian boats also harassed US warships in the Arabian Gulf. Iran threatened to target US commercial ships in the Arabian Gulf and the Sea of Oman, in case any Iranian oil tankers faced US attacks in the Caribbean.
In the same context, the IRGC established a new mockup jet carrier off Iran’s southern coast to carry out potential drills using live ammunition. This decoy plane carrier was previously used in February 2015 during a military drill dubbed “The Great Prophet IX.” This operation indicates that the IRGC was preparing to sink a mockup carrier — similar to the one it carried out in 2015.
The maritime dispute between Iran and its foes, especially the United States, escalated after the latter seized Iranian oil tankers that were bound for Venezuela, and confiscated what was aboard the vessels. The UK also seized the Iranian oil tanker Grace 1 in July 2019 at the Strait of Gibraltar. Moreover, Israel targeted a number of Iranian oil tankers in 2021 in the Mediterranean on their way to Syria. US national security agencies followed in June 2021 the movements of two Iranian vessels — the Iranian modern frigate Sahand and the former oil tanker Makran which has been turned into a floating base. Iranian authorities said that the latter will reassert Iran’s presence in the Atlantic Ocean and at the international level.(45)
Conflicting leadership interests ensure minor conflicts around the Strait of Hormuz escalate quickly.
Damayanti et al. 22 – [Angel, associate professor in the Department of International Relations, Universitas Kristen Indonesia (UKI), Jakarta. She obtained her Doctoral degree from University Sains Malaysia in 2017, Alexander Texas Meresin; student research assistant at the Center for Security and Foreign Affairs Studies, Universitas Kristen Indonesia (UKI), Jakarta. He obtained his bachelor’s degree in international relations from UKI in 2021, and Bryan Libertho Karyoprawiro; junior researcher at the Center for Security and Foreign Affairs Studies, Universitas Kristen Indonesia (UKI), Jakarta. He obtained his bachelor’s degree in international relations from UKI in 2021. “United States-Iran Shared Interest and the Stability of the Strait of Hormuz.” Global Strategis https://doi.org/10.20473/jgs.16.2.2022.357-378, February 16, 2022] TDI
The tension between the United States (US) and Iran has yet to improve. It started with negative perceptions of the two after the Iranian Revolution in 1979. The US-Iran relationship continued to deteriorate during the Gulf War between Iraq and Iran throughout 1980 and the imposition of an embargo by the US on Iran during the Bill Clinton administration (Raharjo 2012). The worsening of US-Iran relations peaked after the US, under Donald Trump’s administration, left the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) that deals with Iran’s nuclear program. The US-Iran conflict flared up in mid-2019 when the US blamed Iran for attacking merchant ships and oil tankers around the Strait of Hormuz (Reed 2019). On the other hand, Iran was irate since the US included the Iran Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) in the list of international terrorist groups. The tension was further worsened by the killing of top General Qasem Soleimani of the IRCG in early 2020 (Congressional Research Service 2020).
Despite the conflict and different political views, the two countries have common interests in the Strait of Hormuz. The strait is the only access for the Middle East countries to develop their sea-based trading. Thus, the channel becomes essential for the economies of the Middle East region, especially for oil and gas exports, and for countries that depend on energy imports, mainly the US and its allies in the Asia Pacific (Slade 2019). Thus, the US, Iran, and other countries have common interests in ensuring the security and stability of the sea-based trading routes in the Strait of Hormuz. Regrettably, the US and Iran are both interested in dominating the leadership in the strait to ensure the security of the Strait of Hormuz and ships passing through the channel (Gilsinan 2019).
Collaboration and conflict may emerge from the US and Iran’s shared interests. Both the US and Iran desire influential positions in the region due to their strategic interests in the Strait of Hormuz. However, if conflictual relations exaggerate their common interest, a crisis around the Strait of Hormuz most likely occurs. This crisis is latent to disasters as any conflict around the strait will cause an increased risk for tankers operating in these waters. If left unchecked, this conflict will also lead to a more severe security crisis on a larger scale.
The importance of the Strait of Hormuz makes even a minor conflict can become a significant security threat in a short time (Slade 2019). Various reactions from the US and Iran – to show their dominance – have contributed to the crisis and the deteriorating security situation. Therefore, this article explains how the US-Iran conflict impacts the security and stability of the Strait of Hormuz. This article will be divided into several sections, including the concept of conflict of interest and maritime security, an explanation of the conflict of interest in the Strait of Hormuz, the US and Iran conflicts, and the impact of these conflicts on security and stability in the Strait of Hormuz.
Methods to Assess the Impact of the US-Iran Conflictual Relations on the Hormuz Strait’s Stability
In this article, the authors use a qualitative research method with a case study approach to form a conclusion on this issue. With a case study approach, this research intensively focuses on one particular object that becomes the research case. Case study data can be obtained from all involved parties and collected from various primary and secondary sources. Furthermore, these research methods can produce descriptive data in the form of written or spoken words from people and observable behavior, which carefully describes the characteristics of a symptom or problem under study and reveal how it happened (Moleong 2007; Mudjiyanto 2018).
Researchers used primary data from interviews with Nostalgiawan Wahyudi, a researcher at the Center for Political Research, Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI), focusing on Islamic politics and the Middle East. The researchers also collected secondary data from various sources through a literature study related to the research topic. The researchers then validated the data and research results through triangulation before analyzing the data to make conclusions. Triangulation was done to compare the truth of any information obtained from different sources (Bachri 2010). Thus, the data’s basis or truth and validity are very concerning. Therefore, the data obtained by researchers related to the US-Iran conflict and the security of the Strait of Hormuz were validated from different sources based on primary and secondary data findings.
Miscalculation causes an open war in the Middle East and jeopardizes global trade.
Damayanti et al. 22 – Angel, associate professor in the Department of International Relations, Universitas Kristen Indonesia (UKI), Jakarta. She obtained her Doctoral degree from University Sains Malaysia in 2017, Alexander Texas Meresin; student research assistant at the Center for Security and Foreign Affairs Studies, Universitas Kristen Indonesia (UKI), Jakarta. He obtained his bachelor’s degree in international relations from UKI in 2021, and Bryan Libertho Karyoprawiro; junior researcher at the Center for Security and Foreign Affairs Studies, Universitas Kristen Indonesia (UKI), Jakarta. He obtained his bachelor’s degree in international relations from UKI in 2021. “United States-Iran Shared Interest and the Stability of the Strait of Hormuz.” Global Strategis https://doi.org/10.20473/jgs.16.2.2022.357-378. February 16, 2022] TDI
The escalation of tension in the Strait of Hormuz poses a security threat to Iran, the US, and countries in the region. The long-term increase in the US deployments of naval, missile defense, intelligence, and asset surveillance in the area prompted Iran to do the same to counter the US. The hope of a peaceful resolution to this crisis is far-fetched because neither side is willing to concede. However, for this crisis to be resolved in a non-violent manner, both parties must reach an agreement and mutual understanding (Slade 2019). If the escalation of tensions in the region continues, a miscalculated move by either side can create an open w

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.