Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← Back to archive
2023 TDI Affirmative

Africom Aff Neg - TDI 2023

Africom Aff Neg - TDI 2023.docx

Download Word file
Indexed text preview
AFRICOM 1AC FINAL – TDI ’23
1AC
1AC – Imperialism
The United States ought to substantially reduce its military presence of the United States Africa Command in North Africa.
The contention is US imperialism.
The history of US military presence in North Africa is inseparable from its post-Cold War ascent as the primary global hegemon. Beginning with the Broader Middle East and North Africa Initiative providing the architecture of modern US neo-colonialism in the region, the War on Terror then established the pretense for military intervention in the region to secure American interests under explicitly false pretenses.
Now, AFRICOM’s presence actualizes the modern extension of American military terror across the North African region – strategic presence connects regional “counter-terror” efforts with imperialist looting and suppression of self-determination.
A-APRP ’21 [(All-African People’s Revolutionary Party, a permanent, independent, revolutionary, socialist, Pan-African Political Party based in Africa. Africa is the just homeland of African People all over the world. Our Party is an integral part of the Pan-African and World Socialist revolutionary movement. The A-APRP understands that “all people of African descent, whether they live in North or South America, the Caribbean, or in any other part of the world, are Africans and belong to the African Nation”.) “Say No To Africom!”, A-APRP, 12/01/2021. https://aaprp-intl.org/say-no-to-africom/] pfox TDI
In an arrogant assertion of their intention to own and militarily dominate the world, the United States of America has established eleven unified combatant commands across the globe, each with an “area of responsibility”. This “responsibility” represents the positioning of the U.S. to militarily protect its allies, to keep pressure on nations to maintain a relationship of subservience to the U.S., and to militarily ‘keep in check’ or attack nations that refuse to bow down to its demands. These demands force the incorporation of all nations into an economic and political system dominated by U.S. corporate imperialism, thus preventing any genuine self-determination.
Eritrea is the only country in Africa that is not a part of AFRICOM and continues steadfast resistance to U.S. military presence on our continent. Egypt is not in AFRICOM because it falls under the U.S. Central Command, or CENTCOM. The separating of Egypt from the rest of Africa in US military strategy is important because it connects Egypt to Israel under the umbrella of CENTCOM. This arrangement is designed to ensure U.S. Control of the Suez Canal and the strategic waterways of the Red and Mediterranean Seas. Egypt and Israel are two of the largest recipients of U.S. military and financial aid in the world.
AFRICOM’s stated mission is “anti-terrorism” and “promotion of democracy”, but AFRICOM’s true purpose is to thwart any attempts by African nations to achieve self-determination and emancipation from neo-colonialism. AFRICOM is one party of an international military machine designed to control humanity’s economic, social and political activities under the helm of US corporate and military power.
Thieves, Liars and Killers
The U.S. and its allies relentlessly seek to control the oil, coltan, bauxite and other vast mineral resources, fertile land, fresh water and labor power on the continent of Africa. This is achieved through the collaboration of several imperialist partners, including: Non-Government Organizations (NGOs) to manipulate labor, social and human resources. International finance institutions such as the IMF and World Bank control the economies through debt and dependency. Major corporate media distort and misinform the masses of the people. Multinational corporations maximize profits by extracting resources and processing them into commodities to be sold on the open market.
Government officials from capitalist nations and their client states set policy to ensure that capitalism makes profits. AFRICOM, with regional and national armed forces which they control, crush resistance to these sophisticated capitalist money making schemes. AFRICOM stands ready to serve imperialism by waging war, overthrowing legitimate governments, financing and supporting coups, or by militarily enforcing economic sanctions and blockades designed to destabilize nations, diminishing the nation’s ability to govern themselves and provide for their people.
Imperialism and all its international, national and local agencies are mighty enemies of Africa, African People and all humanity. They will be defeated, and the people will win. The people have always resisted oppression. We will continue to reject the militarization of our communities and the world. Anti-imperialist forces must stand together to smash capitalism and smash imperialism. The All-African People’s Revolutionary Party (A-APRP) uncompromisingly condemns imperialist militarization of Africa and the world. We recognize that only Pan-Africanism can empower African nations to stand-up against this imperialist menace, which is but a new, violent, grotesque form of colonialism, called neo-colonialism.
In 2007, the Bush Administration said the following at the inception of the US Africa Command, or AFRICOM: it “will strengthen our security cooperation with Africa and create new opportunities to bolster the capabilities of our partners in Africa. Africa Command will enhance our efforts to bring peace and security to the people of Africa and promote our common goals of development, health, education, democracy and economic growth in Africa.” In 2011, the established ruler of Libya, Muammar Gaddafi, was accused of mobilizing “African mercenaries” to murder his citizens. This is why AFRICOM’s very first mission was the overthrow of the Libyan government, Gaddafi’s assassination, and the installation of a puppet regime to decimate the development of what was, at the time, the most prosperous state in North Africa. AFRICOM’s operations provide political cover for deploying US-backed insurgents and counter-intelligence, all of which have massively deteriorated regional stability and cost tens of thousands of African lives.
Akizwe ’22 [(Abayomi Akizwe, editor of Pan-African News Wire, an international electronic press service designed to foster intelligent discussion on the affairs of African people throughout the continent and the world.) “Imperialist Militarism and the African Crisis”, Toward Freedom, 10/09/2022. https://towardfreedom.org/story/archives/africa-archives/imperialist-militarism-and-the-african-crisis/] pfox TDI
After 14 years, the AFRICOM project which was announced in 2007 by the administration of President George W. Bush, Jr. and became operational in 2008, has been a disaster for the AU member-states whether they have participated or not with this entity. Initially, the African states rejected the stationing of the AFRICOM headquarters on the continent.
Later after a reframing of the AFRICOM mission by the Pentagon, where the purpose was to assist African states by strengthening military cooperation and therefore enhancing security, numerous governments allowed the escalation of the presence of U.S. forces. In the Horn of Africa, the French military base at Camp Lemonnier, became the major outpost for Pentagon troops on the continent.
According to the AFRICOM website: “In response to our expanding partnerships and interests in Africa, the United States established U.S. Africa Command in 2007. For the past 14 years, U.S. Africa Command has worked with African partners for a secure, stable and prosperous Africa. The creation of U.S. Africa Command has advanced this vision through a whole-of-government, partner-centric lens by building partner capacity, disrupting violent extremists, and responding to crises. Through consistent engagement, we strengthen our partnerships and assure our allies. Only together can we realize security goals vital for global interests and free trade. Allies and partners are critical in realizing our shared vision while enabling contingency operations, maintaining superiority over competitors, monitoring and disrupting violent extremist organizations, and protecting U.S. interests.” (https://www.africom.mil/about-the-command/history-of-us-africa-command)
However, in reality the security situation in Africa has worsened since the creation of AFRICOM and the deployment of thousands of U.S. troops on the continent. These military forces have constructed drone stations and makeshift bases while engaging in purported trainings of local military units along with engaging in what is described as counter-insurgency operations.
By 2011, AFRICOM was prepared for a large-scale military operation on the continent resulting in regime change and the destruction of population groups. In Libya, beginning in February of 2011, a rebel insurgency was trained and turned loose in the northern city of Benghazi with the aim of overthrowing the government of Col. Muammar Gaddafi.
After the defeat of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA)-sponsored rebels in several regions of Libya, the U.S. went to the United Nations Security Council where they engineered the passage of resolutions 1970 and 1973 as a cover for the blanket bombing of the oil-rich North African state, then the most prosperous of the AU member-states. On March 19, the bombing of Libya began by the U.S. Air Force accompanied by NATO and allied units.
The result of the war which lasted for nine months killed tens of thousands of Libyans, Africans from other states working in the country and guests from other geopolitical regions. With the installation of a puppet regime in Tripoli after the murder of Gaddafi in October 2011, the conditions in Libya only deteriorated further.
Since 2011, the situation inside the country has not stabilized. The Libyan counter-revolution was the first major combat operation of AFRICOM. The administration of President Barack Obama and his Secretary of State Hillary Clinton championed the war as a victory for “democracy.” In reality, the instability within Libya spread throughout other neighboring states in North and West Africa.
AFRICOM’s intervention into Libya reveals a crucial truth – the modern architecture of racial governance cannot be disentangled from the framing of “humanitarian” values that drive interventions as neutral, apolitical goods. American imperialism on the African continent requires a redefining of African realities as requiring Western intervention to resolve crises, positing a false choice between domestic collapse or colonial brutality, with AFRICOM representing a key piece of the puzzle.
Wai ’14 [(Zubaru Wai, Department of Political Science, Lakehead University, Thunder Bay, Canada.) “The empire's new clothes: Africa, liberal interventionism and contemporary world order”, Review of African Political Economy, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1080/03056244.2014.928278] pfox TDI
Although he appeared to have repaired relations with the West in the post-9/11 environment, Western suspicion of Gaddafi lingered: he was still too ‘dangerous’ and unpredictable to be trusted. For example, his vocal stance against the United States’ Africa Command (AFRICOM), the latest military front for projecting the power of the United States on the continent, made especially that state very uncomfortable, and confirmed to US officials that Gaddafi had not given up his old ways. Gaddafi's influence on the continent appeared to have, in part, put the future of the project in jeopardy, at least temporarily. As journalist Dan Glazebrook rightly notes in The Guardian:
Gaddafi ended his political life as a dedicated pan-Africanist and, whatever one thought of the man, it is clear that his vision for Africa was very different from that of the subordinate supplier of cheap labour and raw materials that Africom was created to maintain. He was not only the driving force behind the creation of the African Union in 2002, but had also served as its elected head, and made Libya its biggest financial donor. To the dismay of some of his African colleagues, he used his time as leader to push for a ‘United States of Africa,’ with a single currency, single army and single passport. More concretely, Gaddafi's Libya had an estimated $150bn worth of investment in Africa – often in social infrastructure and development projects, and this largesse bought him many friends, particularly in the smaller nations. As long as Gaddafi retained this level of influence in Africa, Africom was going to founder. (Glazebrook Citation2012)
Indeed, when AFRICOM was established by the Bush administration in 2007, it was headquartered in Stuttgart, Germany, in part because no African state would openly accept hosting its bases. However, AFRICOM's plans have greatly advanced since the murder of Gaddafi and the overthrow of his regime. What is more, post-Gaddafi Libya was the first state on the continent to openly express interest in hosting AFRICOM's headquarters. In getting rid of Gaddafi, AFRICOM had succeeded in eliminating its most vocal critic and, perhaps, most formidable opponent on the continent. Libya became AFRICOM's first major intervention, as it were, and has proved to be a significant moment for that organisation and its drive to recolonise the continent, and impose an American peace on it. Going after Gaddafi was significant for another reason: it gave AFRICOM the perfect opportunity to test its operational capability by engaging in its first major military operation on the continent, which, ‘coincidentally’, was targeted at its biggest opponent.
But perhaps the greatest significance of the NATO action in Libya is that it allowed the US (and its allies) to deal with anxieties that the Arab Spring was causing for Western, especially US, hegemony in the Arab world. It was Libya, and going after Gaddafi, that made it possible for the West to partially negotiate what appeared as a crisis of hegemony in the Arab world. While anxieties about a region slipping out of its control have always dominated Western, especially US, policy, this uneasiness acquired a new sense of urgency when popular mass agitation for democracy began to threaten client regimes (such as in Egypt, Bahrain, Yemen, Jordan etc.) dependent on especially US patronage. Libya, however, was different: its leader, Muammar Gaddafi, was not exactly a Western client. While his longevity (having ruled Libya for over four decades) and authoritarian style of governing had won him many enemies, unlike Ben Ali and Hosni Mubarak he could be targeted without threatening Western power in North Africa and the Middle East, where US-supported client regimes were struggling to hold on to power in the face of popular uprisings. If anything, going after him would allow the West to turn the tide, regain the initiative and gain control over a fluid situation which had arisen since stone-throwing youths took on the Tunisian state and won, and mass protests forced Egypt's Hosni Mubarak out of power. Supporting an uprising against a ‘dictator’ who was not exactly a Western client would achieve the long-term goal of regime change in Libya while presenting the West as champions of democracy and human rights in the region. Indeed, Libya presented an opportunity and became the moment that made it possible for the West to ‘credibly’ impose themselves on processes that had initially appeared beyond their control and position themselves, yet again, as defenders of human rights and democracy. Thus, that which had started as a counter-hegemonic moment of mass agitation for democratisation of social life in the region, and thus tended to threaten the hegemonic order of Western domination and the client regimes dependent on Western patronage, ended up becoming a moment for hegemonic articulation reinforcing that very order it was aimed at negating. The NATO military action in Libya was a significant event. However, it was neither new nor was it an accident. It was only perhaps the most visible and high-profile of the now increasing Western military interventionism on the continent. Incarnating the spirit of an imperial globalism that normalises warfare as the primary instrument for pursuing ethical and political agendas, it conforms to a now familiar pattern of the heightened militarisation of world politics, and advances the processes of rendering warfare banal, globalising violent interventions and normalising the processes of displacing violence to the South, especially Africa. It temporalises a state of emergency and state of exception (Agamben Citation2005), while conflating the political and moral registers of contemporary world politics by which concerns over ‘human rights’ and ‘humanitarian’ disasters are mobilised as alibis for pursuing parochial national interests and imperialistic vocations (Fassin and Pandolfi Citation2010). Operating through a violent totalitarian logic and its militaristic logics through which global relations are regulated, this oppressive imperial globalism and its regimes of violence that authorised the intervention in Libya have turned Africa into a major constitutive site for the production of its modalities, the enacting of its colonial fantasies and the furthering of its imperial vocations. Indeed, coinciding with the NATO campaign in Libya was a contemporaneous French military action in Côte d'Ivoire that would remove the sitting president, Laurent Gbagbo, from power following disputed presidential elections. The controversies over the results of the 2010 presidential elections provided the pretext for France to pursue its agenda of regime change in Côte d'Ivoire, taking sides in a civil war and militarising an electoral dispute that was rooted in real and imagined political contestations over the state of Côte d'Ivoire by multiple competing claimants. At the heart are questions about citizenship and membership of the Ivorian political community (Ivoirité); that is, who qualifies as Ivorian and therefore has rights to participate in politics in that state and who does not. This struggle itself results in part from the structural legacies of colonialism, the failures of the postcolonial state to create viable structures that unite its multiple constituent populations, and the realities of French neocolonial machinations that have since independence cast a suffocating shadow over its former colonies in the region. Indeed, this complex political and socio-historical reality was lost in the brazenly simplistic and problematic representations that fashioned a banal and all-too-familiar discourse about a typical power-hungry African ‘strongman’ refusing to relinquish power after losing an election, and thus subverting the democratic will of the people who have rejected him at the polls. Again, as in Libya, the protection of human rights and promotion of democracy provided a pretext for defining a violent interventionist impulse, orchestrated principally by France, in altruistic and humanitarian terms. This interventionist pattern would repeat itself in Mali, where France led a military intervention ostensibly to rid that country of Al-Qaeda-linked Islamists who had seized control of the north of the country. As in Libya and Côte d'Ivoire, its legitimating frame was partially mobilising the moral registers of rescuing Mali from violent and irrational Islamists driven by hatred for modern civilisation and harkening to primordial instincts of murderous villainy, as demonstrated by the wanton killing of innocent civilians and the pillaging of the library in Timbuktu housing valuable ancient and medieval manuscripts. While the Malian crisis, like that of Côte d'Ivoire, is rooted in the structural legacies of colonialism and the inability of the postcolonial state to manage conflicts around social identity and the everyday banality of existence in a state with limited resources claimed by multiple competing social groups, it also is both a bl

Preview shortened. Download the file for the full document.